News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by tjoff on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:16AM (#18533853)
Sure they do. 3D TVs and bent TVs are two glaring examples of something people never wanted. The only way companies could uphold that view was by ensuring that no manufacturer had sensible alternatives - effectively forcing people that wanted a TV to buy it. And then pretending that the sales were proof that people wanted it.

It is the exact same with the majority of subscription services.

For a company I get that it is easier. But easier for an individual?

I walk twice around the earth before even considering a subscription service. It cannot be simpler than pay once and you are done for life. The reason as to why so few companies offer both is because it then becomes apparent how bad the subscription value is.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by Nition on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:43PM (#18536190)
Agreed, and I'd add high-end smartphones with <5" screens, and non-"smart" TVs with decent picture quality as things that people still want but are forced into alternatives.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by softawre on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:09PM (#18537280)
<5"? How small do you want?

For me the 5" screen of the regular Pixel (2) is perfect.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by Nition on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:25PM (#18537410)
Personally I like the size of the iPhone SE, which has a 4" screen. I've talked to people and seen a lot of discussion on it so I know I'm not the only one.

The screen could be a bit larger if there was less bezel though: An iPhone SE size phone in the iPhone X style could have a 5" screen without getting any larger. That would be perfect.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by steelframe on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:24PM (#18538138)
The Sony Xperia Z5 Compact got the screen size just about perfect for me at 4.6". If someone could build a phone with a Pixel 2 camera, a Z5C screen, the thickness of a V35 ThinQ, compatibility with Project Fi, and an audio jack, that would be my sweet spot.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by Nition on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:30PM (#18538181)
Unfortunately the new Xperia XZ2 Compact is almost the same size as the original Xperia X, with the way phones keep getting larger.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by Illniyar on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:17AM (#18534362)
err... are you implying that there are no alternatives in the market to 3D TVs and bent TVs? As far as I know 3D TVs have basically gone out of market[1] because no one bought them. It is actually the exact opposite of what you suggested - they could not start a trend, even thought they tried to force it on people, because there was no demand for it.

[1]-https://www.cnet.com/news/shambling-corpse-of-3d-tv-finally-...

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by setr on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:58PM (#18535343)
For about 5 years, any tv you found in an electronic store was 3D, and I have yet to find a single person who claims to like them.

Today, every tv is a Smart TV, and yet again, I haven’t found anyone who thought they weren’t awful

In cars theres the same issue with GPS systems: even luxury cars have awful interfaces. Presumably tesla’s is decent (never tried), but otherwise the only interface I’ve encountered yet that met the minimum requirement of a sensible response time (let alone everything else) is a luxury jeep. Mercedes, priuses, bmws, etc are all horrendous.

In phones, the aux ports and phablets

On the web, heavy js

In games, complex 3D graphics (this is very slowly changing, as indie devs begin to realize games existed between 1980 and 2000)

This type of event, where the producers collectively decide what the consumers want, and only produce it, and miss the mark by a mile, definetely exist (these are just things I’m irrated by recently), though I assume incompetence and babdwaggoning over any kind of real thinking going into this. (They didn’t try to force a trend, they just all thought it was the trend, due to whatever terrible research they all do; hell, I’d bet there was one or two marketing firms that were the root cause of most of these messes)

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by Illniyar on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:12PM (#18536390)
If I recall correctly 3D TVs has always had minuscule sales volume compared to regular TVs. Even in it's "height" there were far more regular TVs sold then 3D ones.

If 3D TVs were able to garner any premium over regular TVs, the electronics companies would have continued selling them. It was, and probably still is, a net loss.

Smart TVs are a convenience that is actually in demand, mostly because it does not add a markup to price - why buy a non smart TV when you can buy a smart one at the same price.

The majority of iPhone users probably use bluetooth headphones.

Phablets are so much in demand, that apple had practically no choice but to build one.

Heavy js and web is a completely different story because you aren't the customer for website with heavy js, and the advertisers, who are the customers of these websites, have a great demand for more javascript.

AAA titles are dominating the market. Indie sales are a minuscule fraction of the game industry market. Why? because there is insane demand for AAA titles, and for that matter for massive multiplayer games - LoL, Fortnite, PUBG etc...

Just because you don't like it, or for that matter the entire of HN don't like it, doesn't mean there is no demand for it.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by setr on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:03PM (#18536775)
>If 3D TVs were able to garner any premium over regular TVs, the electronics companies would have continued selling them. It was, and probably still is, a net loss

Sure; the issue is that due to supplier convergence, the only option in a modern tv. If they weren’t so obviously harmful to sales, we’d still have them around, because it’d be impossible to differentiate between negative vs positive impact, simply because nothing else was available to even buy (in that trust/price/quality/brand range)

>The majority of iPhone users probably use bluetooth headphones.

Before or after it was their only choice? Like cars, the presence or lack of an aux port is irrelevant compared to the rest of the purchase. It doesn’t imply one way or the other whether anyone actually prefers it, when the change is bundled with so much more.

>AAA titles are dominating the market

AAA titles are always dominating the market. My point is that there is no way to differentiate between a AAA game being successful because of, despite or irresThe majority of iPhone users probably use bluetooth headphones.pective of its graphical complexity, because consumers simply cannot buy a AAA title that did not spend half its budget on 3D graphics.

This is only changing because a few indie games/smaller titles have seen extreme success despite “weak” graphics (minecraft, fortnite, LoL). Even kickstarter games appealing to older genres (eg The recent CRPGs trend) probably put an outsized emphasis on graphics, despite targetting players of 90s work.

My opinion is that games can get very far with very limited graphics, but looking at the general market its impossible to actually make the case because there’s very few examples where its even been tried. The best you can really do is turn to modern indie, or point out that some older games are still heavily played (WoW, starcraft, quake, etc)

If the whole market suddenly shifts in a particular direction, there’s no chance for competition to rule out an idea as being a bad one.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by ghaff on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:15PM (#18535494)
>I have yet to find a single person who claims to like them

I like 3D well enough at least for the occasional novelty and film that uses it well, e.g. Gravity. There is just about zero content available however. My impression when I bought my TV was that there were certainly non-3D options available. But I got a pre-Christmas deal and I paid about the same as for an equivalent TV that didn't have 3D.

It's the same with Smart TVs. It doesn't really add to the cost of the TV. I just never use the features.

I guess the latest trend is whatever resolution that's an additional increment beyond the limits of human vision. Or maybe OLED.

I do understand that the TV manufacturers are really desperate to drive TV upgrade cycles. The good news is that the new features are mostly harmless if you need a new TV anyway.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by OkGoDoIt on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:35PM (#18536140)
And the better news is that if you don’t actually care about these silly new features you can get amazingly great TVs for next to nothing. I saw a 46 inch 4K LED smart TV at Costco for around $300. It didn’t have HDR (the current trendy hotness in the top of the line TVs), so I guess it’s considered substandard, but holy crap that’s a great deal.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by abakker on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:52PM (#18538927)
I have one of the Visio ones. Yes, good screen, but never let one of those things on your WiFi. Jeez.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by mvid on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:37PM (#18536154)
Just because it doesn’t increase the cost of the base model doesn’t mean it doesn’t increase the price, just that you don’t have the option of not paying for it.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by a_t48 on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:43PM (#18535729)
I genuinely love my Smart TV. Its nice having the TV know about every input option, and not having to fool around d with multiple remotes.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by setr on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:18PM (#18536010)
The actual feature (having netflix, amazon, hulu, etc natively available) is fine; the problem is that its slow, unreliable, prints useless errors, and no matter how much you spend, the interface is always a janky horrible experience. There are also other nuisances like forcing the framerate up to 60fps by frame interprolation, causing everything in 24fps (most content) to look awful, and in certain implementations, jitter.

Some of the things I noted have perfectly valid ideas, but just ..pathetic.. implementations (smart tvs, gps), and others are preferences that get forced onto you (aux port, web heavy-js, game graphics)

But the key is the suppliers collectively decided that this is exactly what the consumers want, and the only option left otherwise is to turn back to 1990 or look to the chinese knockoffs. The ability to signal to the market that this isn’t whats wanted is lost... except by entirely avoiding all recent technological advances.

And the truly strange thing is that there are few, if any, offering the same object but with improved interfaces (with cars it makes sense, the rest of the vehicle is more important; but tvs? video games? What the hell? These should be much easier to find variations on.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by TylerE on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:14PM (#18536407)
> There are also other nuisances like forcing the framerate up to 60fps by frame interprolation, causing everything in 24fps (most content) to look awful, and in certain implementations, jitter.

THat's just a shitty TV. My now almost 5 year old Smart TV handles 24hz just fine... the panel is actually running at 120 so 24 is an even multiple.

Personally, I really like my smart TV and use many apps for stream non-mainstream sports, and the like.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by setr on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:45PM (#18536643)
As far as I can tell, its an intentional modification (makes the show look "better"), and I only usually see it on the more expensive, newer home TVs. Whats your TV model/brand?
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by TylerE on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:02PM (#18537239)
What you’re talking about is one of those brain-damaged “motion enhancement” things. Just turn it off in the options.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by alehul on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:51AM (#18534651)
Seconding this.

The markets aren't spectacularly and miraculously efficient, but they're efficient enough that products without demand will not last, with the exception of industry-wide collusion to remove the consumer-preferred option from the market. Game theory says the existence of a wanted-but-not-provided product probably won't last, however. And regardless of continuous cooperation of the participating suppliers, there can always be a new entrant.

Anecdotal on the TV point, but I recently purchased a new TV... no bend, no 3D (didn't even see that as an option), no hassle. :)

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by tjoff on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:11PM (#18534856)
No? I'm saying that there were no alternatives during the hype.

They didn't try to start a trend. They tried to make something up to warrant a new purchase.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by wesd on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:12PM (#18535955)
>I walk twice around the earth before even considering a subscription service.

I can't imagine going back not having music subscription service. I don't have to make a decision which album to buy anymore and I don't have to worry about my kids pirating music.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by asdff on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:16PM (#18536867)
That's because the music subscription service was designed from the ground up to be exactly unlike the previous music business model; in fact the spotify model boils down to legal napster.

The problem is when something really has no reason to not be a one time purchase, like companies on instagram charging me $15 a month to send me three new pairs of socks twice a quarter, or maybe they mail me a wooden box once a month with some woodsy smelling beard oil, a leather flask, and a small axe.

Software is moving this way too; but I'm still in the camp that would shell out $25 for a program as is that would still work on my machine decades later even if the company folds or puts out another version, than pay $2 a month for something that might not work at all or fundamentally change its functionality in a year.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by fossuser on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:33PM (#18536996)
I've actually moved to preferring subscription software for things like 1Password (which moved from purchase to subscription).

Software is a moving target where everything else is changing around it - OS, hardware, web infrastructure, etc. and having devs continuing development on a tool I'm using is useful. The subscription model in this case accurately reflects the reality and is better than randomly having to pay $45 on occasion to upgrade to a version that still works.

I'd also argue that Spotify is better than legal Napster with its streaming and music playlist curation. Spotify may be the best software application I use on a regular basis.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by tjoff on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:07PM (#18536808)
That I agree. I've payed for spotify for nine years. But that's reasonable because it is streaming the music. As is netflix et al. Though I have yet to see a media subscription service with decent software. It would be much better if they could provide a decent API that people could integrate it. But that doesn't fit well with the lock-in, and lock-in is apparently the only thing worth doing.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by saiya-jin on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:37AM (#18534036)
Bent TV probably no since they are mostly viewed with other people, but ultra wide bent monitors are super nice, especially for gaming. I go this way instead of VR which seems to take time to 'get there' (also HW requirements are easier to pay for).
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by corndoge on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:10AM (#18534292)
VR is already here and better than you might expect
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by giobox on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:13PM (#18538057)
I’d strongly argue the opposite. Even Palmer Lucky himself is finally starting to swear off the VR coolaid a little.

“A lot of people insist on price, but if the VR available today were as good as The Matrix, price wouldn’t be the issue. It’s going to be a combination of better software and better hardware. Right now free isn’t cheap enough for most people.”

I still regard the Rift/Vive as the poorest technology investments I’ve ever made, but if others want to spend thousands of dollars on low res, low frame rate (no, 90-120 FPS is not good enough to adequately trick the human mind) motion sickness generators, have at it.

The install base is, and will remain, far too small to support serious investment in AAA software/games for many years yet I suspect. People love to argue the minute practical differences between the Rift and the Vive, but I’d argue who cares about either when there is so little software worth anyone’s time available.

> https://www.wired.com/story/wired25-peter-thiel-palmer-lucke...

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by TomMarius on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:53AM (#18534670)
Is there something I missed? I wouldn't call Vive "here".
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by softawre on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:15PM (#18537326)
Odyssey+ is on sale for 300$ and is a darn good headset.

It's WAY better than most people imagine, even if it isn't "there" enough to be mainstream, yet.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by corndoge on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:10PM (#18534843)
I think Vive is pretty good and Rift is even better (I own both). What are your gripes with it?
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by fossuser on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:36PM (#18537014)
Is the Rift better now?

I had them both before the Rift had its non-xbox controllers. The Rift let in light through the nose, had no room scale (needed to be in a chair), and just generally seemed like a worse experience.

Did things change or are there other reasons you like it? Are the controllers just that much better?

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by giobox on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:23PM (#18538128)
Room scale support came to the Rift via addition of a third camera to your setup. It’s not quite as good as the Vive’s tracking but the difference is pretty small now, small enough that it largely doesn’t matter.

The tracked hand controllers the Rift now has are arguably a little better than the more basic “baton” style controllers on the Vive, although I believe HTC do have a “Knuckle” controller on the way that adds more advanced hand tracking.

The Rift is also significantly lighter and less sweaty on the head, its built in headphones are good enough you can avoid the additional weight of decent headphones, something the Vive pretty much requires.

I do strongly think both systems are _way_ too early for anyone other than insane early adopter types. Given this, I think the Rift makes most sense for no other reason than it’s the cheapest. Both of them will make many people sick even after relatively short play sessions. Neither of them are “good” in my opinion, merely the best it seems the market has managed so far.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by 83457 on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:32PM (#18538195)
Certainly. The touch controllers and room scale makes it completely different.
Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by ghaff on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:37AM (#18534034)
>It cannot be simpler than pay once and you are done for life.

Although that's rarely the case. At some point, your OS upgrade--which you probably have to do for security reasons--breaks your five year old program. Or the program doesn't handle some new format or peripheral, etc.

I don't really disagree with your basic point. I dislike money leaks. For online services of various types, I mostly have no choice but I at least want to minimize them with on-prem software--especially for things I only use every now and then.

Re:The greatest sales deck I've ever seen (2016) by manigandham on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:59PM (#18539218)
Those companies that sell things people don't want will go out of business.

Good luck only selling 3D TVs when the next company will just sell normal TVs for less and actually make money.