News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by impendia on Thursday November 22, 2018 @06:17AM (#18509316)
Working mathematician here --

1. Langlands is indeed a great mathematician, whose work has been enormously influential.

2. Most of us aren't all that eccentric. He wrote his paper in Russian, a language which he (presumably) does not natively speak, apparently just for the heck of it? That's just weird.

Most of the mathematicians I know, including the most influential ones, are relatively normal people. And they want as many people to read their work as possible, and don't throw up artificial roadblocks. (Most working mathematicians cannot read or write Russian.)

3. There is not that big of a conflict between pure and applied mathematicians. (Except when they're competing for money, or trying to decide whom to hire in their departments.)

The most common attitude among pure mathematicians is: we work on mathematical questions for their own sake, and don't think too much about applications to the "real world" -- but we are happy if it is brought to our attention that such applications exist.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by huhtenberg on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:54AM (#18509687)
Presumably that's the paper in Russian - https://publications.ias.edu/sites/default/files/iztvestiya_...

It's understandable, but with lots of grammatical, spelling and stylistic mistakes. Basically it reads like something Google Translate would produce.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by schoen on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:04PM (#18511836)
He has a discussion at the very end (on the last two pages) about his decision to write in Russian, in which he acknowledges that he may not have done very well. Google Translate's version of the final paragraph:

> This article is a consequence of two pushes, first of all, an attempt to understand the nature of the geometric theory, to form a clear idea about the difference between it and the arithmetic theory and their similarity. Here I think I was successful, although I do not argue a little. Secondly, I wanted to significantly improve my knowledge of Russian. Here I had only limited success. For me, Russian is on a completely different level than the two foreign languages ​​with which I am familiar, French and German. As I noted above, Russian is much more difficult than I appreciated, even more than Turkish, another language in which I have a limited but hard-to-work ability. Therefore, my efforts and the efforts of friends and acquaintances who encouraged me as I wrote this article had limited success. I am still pleased that, despite my age, I do not regret either the time or the effort that I have given her.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by aquadrop on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:34AM (#18509599)
According to Wikipedia: " Langlands likes to learn foreign languages, both for better understanding of foreign publications on his topic and just as a hobby. He speaks French, Turkish, German and Russian".

I'd say it's not _that_ weird, if he likes foreign languages, to combine both his passions and write one paper in Russian :) Also considering there are actually a lot of mathematicians who can read and write Russian.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by impendia on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:52AM (#18509679)
A half-remembered, and possibly apocryphal, story which another mathematician once told me:

Langlands was once invited to lecture in France, and he chose to give his talk in French. Evidently his accent was not all that good, and the audience found it a bit painful.

Jean-Pierre Serre, one of the leading mathematicians of the 20th century, and a Frenchman, was attending the lecture that day. He interrupted to ask a question, in English.

Declining to take the hint, Langlands answered in French and carried on with his lecture.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by thanatropism on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:15AM (#18509790)
Frenchmen are legendarily intolerant of badly-spoken French. This was a recurring theme in my couple of years as a student at Alliance Française - when in France (most people hoped to go to college or grad school there) if you're not solid don't even try.

In Brazil people will be glad you're trying and try to speak slowly in return.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by ColinWright on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:09PM (#18511140)
This is completely at odds with my experience of speaking French in France, both in major cities and small villages. My spoken French is appalling, and yet I've encountered nothing but good will from the French, happy to encourage me, and to work together to figure out what I'm trying to say.

Obviously YMMV, but your assertions are contrary to my experience.

Edit: Down-voted. Thanks for the reality check.

2nd edit: Up-voted, perhaps to compensate. Thank you to whoever did that.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by cmyr on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:30PM (#18511260)
There's sort of an uncanny valley sort of situation, in my experience (as an anglophone canadian with the french of a 3-4 year old): If you're clearly a foreign visitor, and you're speaking bad french, it's often appreciated and maybe found slightly charming. But once you get to the point where your french is reasonably good, but you have an obvious accent, then (some) people (might, sometimes) be more inclined to be a bit snooty about it.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by jnbiche on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:30PM (#18511614)
Precisely. If you try a few tourist phrases, or very basic French, it will be mildly appreciated. But if you speak fluent French with a bit of an accent, particularly in the big cities, you'll frequently be met with arrogance and attempts to switch to English, even if your French is far better than your interlocutor's.

That said, in small towns and villages, this doesn't happen as much. Seems to mainly be a phenomenon in Paris and other large cities.

Also, in Quebec this is never an issue. As long as you speak fluently, Quebecois are happy to speak with you in French.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by huhtenberg on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:33AM (#18509883)
Speaking bad French to French people helps them to suddenly remember that they also speak English.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by hprotagonist on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:28AM (#18510148)
German has a similar effect, too.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by celticninja on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:33AM (#18509887)
Yeah, this is my experience too. You should always attempt to use the language of where you are except in France. They would rather you spoke English than butchered their language. I usually keep it to please and thank you in french as a result. Although I did once use my high school french to ask where the swimming pool was once and had a bit of trouble deciphering the response I got (in french). So swimming pools and libraries and please and thank you :)
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by Koshkin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:20AM (#18510107)
I think problem is, English accent is probably the worst. This is because pronunciation-wise there hardly are other two languages as different as English and French. (The French return the favor, obviously - their accent sounds just as terrible.)
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by celticninja on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:24PM (#18511953)
Accent is such a non issue, in the UK the accent can be very different even 30 miles from one another, so let alone someone speaking it with a French, German or Spanish accent. It's still English and 99% of the time you can understand it. I assume the same is true of other languages too.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by Koshkin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:34PM (#18512370)
> Accent is such a non issue

But for the French it apparently is (and understandably so).

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by celticninja on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:31AM (#18516023)
I meant that you can still understand the speaker, and if so it is courteous to answer. Refusing to understand because you don't like the accent is hardly courteous.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by kenbellows on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:51PM (#18513822)
Which is ironic, given that English developed as basically French + German (or some old versions of those languages).
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by enriquto on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:47PM (#18511741)
> Frenchmen are legendarily intolerant of badly-spoken French.

It may have changed now. I have been living in Paris for several years, speaking strongly accented french (but mostly understandable), and I have had no tolerance problems so far, except the occasional person who prefers to speak in english to me.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by soperj on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:25PM (#18511235)
I'm fluent in French. Quebecois French. In France they're just rude about it, even when they speak terrible english. I would absolutely do the same thing.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by thanatropism on Thursday November 22, 2018 @06:38AM (#18509383)
In the library here they have a book called "Russian for Mathematicians".
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by Double_a_92 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @06:45AM (#18509412)
Maybe if you need to look up some soviet era literature?
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by thanatropism on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:34AM (#18509891)
The weird thing is that while modern-style mathematics with lots of display maths is supposedly to be less dependent on subtleties of text (as opposed to the arguments of old-style topology books like Munkres, which use display equations a lot less and pack a lot of oomph into dense paragraphs with inlined symbols). But mathematical terminology actually changes a lot -- it's enough to open a page in Wikipedia and switch languages to see.

A "field" in the algebraic sense (the real numbers are a "complete ordered field") in portuguese is corpo, but vector fields are campos. And both in Portuguese and French, manifolds and algebraic varieties are the same word (variedades/varietés).

Maybe if one starts graphing these separations and collisions across many languages some structure emerges -- obviously no one mixes up algebraic fields with physics fields, but the manifold/variety collision hints at some historical commonality that matters for expressive power at the level of a Grothendieck trying to say something sweeping about the entire landscape of mathematics.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by Koshkin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:26AM (#18510139)
To be fair, a ‘campo’ is also a ‘corpo’ that is commutative.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by metalsteady on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:44PM (#18511721)
Can you elaborate? Vector spaces and fields differ in how they define multiplication. In the former, we multiply vectors with scalars while in the latter we multiply two scalars.

Also, vector fields are functions from points to vectors whereas field is an algebraic structure.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by Koshkin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:04PM (#18512189)
What I meant was, in some languages 'corpo' is a more general notion of the (algebraic) field, the non-commutative version of which is known in English literature as the "skew field."
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by metalsteady on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:19PM (#18512262)
If I understand you correctly, you are saying vector fields and skew fields are the same object. But that's not true, though. The former is a function, the latter is a structure.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by Koshkin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:30PM (#18512343)
In other words: 'campo' = (commutative) field, 'corpo' = field (possibly skew); 'campo vectorial' is something else, of course.
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by thanatropism on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:04PM (#18511835)
I'm not entirely sure what he meant, but the flow maps of vector fields are semigroups. If irreversible, they're groups. And a field is like a group and a ring over the same set, right?
Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by metalsteady on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:50PM (#18512115)
A group is a set with a single operation defined on it that abides by certain axioms. A field is a set with two operations defined on it. But the field operations must abide by more axioms than a group operation. While vector spaces and fields are very similar (two operations, similar number of axioms), vector spaces are defined over fields (for example, an element cv is defined where v is a vector and c is a scalar) while fields are not defined over anything -- they are just a structure with two operations and a number of axioms (there's no element cv in a field, but it does have an element c_1 * c_2 where c_i is a scalar).

That said, vector field is a different object. It's a function. Likely named so by physics people while the structures like group/ring/field/etc were named by math folk.

I have no idea what flow maps of vector fields are, but if you give me their definition, it'd be trivial to check if they form a semigroup under a certain operation: we'll just check it for associativity.

To get a hang of this stuff I recommend the following books:

Book of Proof by Richard Hammack (tools of the trade)

Linear Algebra by Kuldeep Singh (rigorous tutorial: combines the rigor of a textbook and the ease of use of tutorial)

Abstract Algebra by the Dos Reis (rigorous tutorial)

Real Analysis by Lara Alcock (this books makes the rigorous definition of sequences trivial)

Real Analysis by Jay Cummings (contains much more info than the one above and is very similar in spirit)

Real Analysis by Rafi Grinberg (takes you from reals to Euclidean Spaces and Metric Spaces)

After that you ccan start reading intro level mathematical physics books to get an easy intro to differential geometry, manifolds and analysis in abstract spaces. Once you get an intuitive hang of this stuff, you can come back to the more brutal pure math setting.

Here, I like Modern Math Physics by Peter Szekeres. It's gentle and more about geometry and less about analysis.

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by thanatropism on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:50AM (#18515688)
Flow maps: take for example an autonomous ODE

    x'(t) = f(x(t))
f(.) describes a vector field, right? A flow map is a function w_t(u) = x(t) that solves the ODE with x(0) = u, for fixed t. If f(.) is invertible, then each flow map is a group in the very same way rotations of a Rubik cube are a group. If not, it's a semigroup, which is a group without an invertibility. The former describes systems that you can track back in time and calculate initial conditions only from looking at the present state.

My dissertation was actually about numerically integrating symplectic vector fields; I spent a lot of time hunching over Arnold's "Mathematical methods of classical mechanics".

Re:Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never... by thanatropism on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:19AM (#18510447)
An observation that illustrates my point.