Honestly, I don't think my site looks as good as Butterick's, but I'm not a designer and I didn't spend much time on it. Also, my implementation is 1,000x more efficient.
1. I picked Baskerville because it's slightly more convincing than other fonts: https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/08/hear-all-ye...
I see you have gripe with designers but you have to understand few things
1. There is as many bad designers as there is bad programmers. Lot of the companies hire quite unexperienced designers because it sort of works out. Don't forget designers get lot less money then programmers so it might also mean that the quality people are programmers by now.
2. Designing graphics is mostly about putting yourself into someone elses shoes. Nobody else in company has to like the design, important is that your clients do and for that you can gather data. Often you would be suprised what people actually like.
3. I have read this https://geoff.greer.fm/2018/04/02/conserve-vectical-pixels/ and it seems like you want to have very functional approach to design. But you have to realize that function in visual communication is not straightforward. Its not about cramming most of data on page. Empty space is extremely functional element. It might not be so important for you but for most people it is. It establishes hiearchy and helps to rest your eyes. 95% time you are not designing Bloomberg Terminal but some interface people will see for the first time or maybe just from time to time. Things might seem to you super obvious because you spent so many hours with them but thats just not what most of the people get. And i am not even talking about their experiences with the computer itself.
Well, actually ... yes you do (Proxima Nova). Some of it is even thin!
That said, I'll probably fix those fonts soon. Thanks for pointing that out.
But Gnome's Cantarell for Linux and Segoe on Windows are both very ugly. Dalton Maags Ubuntu font OTOH is quite nice, kinda surprised it's not in the native stack..
The difference in experience between platforms is so great with the native stack that it indicates carelessness for users of platforms that aren't Apple or Google based.
The first thing I'd do in an untouched Gnome or in Windows is replace those fonts, and I'm surely not the only one. "Bahnschrift" is actually a nice replacement for Segoe on Windows, from MS.
Not everybody with a sense for style is techy enough to change it, or even in a position to do so. E.g. people who are stuck with Windows for work and aren't allowed to mess with the system.
If you use JS and design sites you could check out Typography.js, you can include webfonts through NPM. Performance is better than fetching them from a CDN.
I did change my terminal to use Hack, however.
> There's also the issue that while the site may look pretty, it requires downloading 5 megabytes of CSS.
3.4MB, and all but 5KB are web fonts which will be cached across the entire site. And while that's heavy for a normal site, it's probably not all that heavy for site specifically about typography. The extra fonts are included because they're used for interactive examples and comparisons, and downloading fonts is cheaper than downloading images.
Web browsers on limited connections are now smart enough to avoid downloading web fonts (on mobile Firefox, there's just a checkbox in settings you can click to turn them off universally). I honestly can't think of a single case where me checking that box has ever broken a webpage. Opera Mini (which is popular in the parts of the world people are most often referring to when they talk about limited connections) disables web fonts as well, so no harm to those users.
Given that there is a readily available, easy to use, safe, user-controlled solution to your problem, I do not see why forcing everyone to use system fonts helps anyone. If you have a problem with the defaults, go to Firefox/Google and tell them to check the box by default.
> Don't ship web fonts except for icons.
My feeling is that on the web we give control to the user, not the developer. And as mentioned above, you can not trust that your icon fonts will be downloaded, so you should not use fonts for icons. It is almost universally better to use SVG for icons. Your icon font is going to be a wrapper around SVG glyphs anyway, so skip the middleman and ship the glyphs directly -- you can still bundle them into a single SVG if you're worried about multiple network requests.
> At every job I've had, designers who talked about typography created more problems than they solved.
Having read the book, none (or at least very few) of the issues you're talking about apply here. The default fonts are heavy and have high contrast (with the exception of footnotes, fair point). They render well on Linux and Windows. They're large and display well on small screens. The book actually goes into detail about a number of your issues, talking about why bad color and unreadable "brand" fonts are a problem. The biggest valid criticism I see here is that links aren't underlined, which... yeah, there are probably better ways to do that, but underlined links do genuinely interrupt reading flow. I view that criticism as a matter of opinion.
It's a hack that was necessary at one point, but has been largely displaced, like table layouts or image-based drop-shadows. SVG is just better nowadays[0]. You can even use the same pseudo-element tricks to insert them purely in CSS, which is yet another accessibility win.
Could you elaborate? macOS doesn't typically do TrueType or CFF hinting. Kerning should be identical for modern rasterizers on all platforms nowadays.
If we left typography up to developers then we’d have the web equivalent of Linux - “good enough”.
Typography has a place in design. What you see with grey thin fonts is amateur work by designers who follow trends. To generalize this observation to the whole of design is not fair.
Nitpicking, but in this context I can't help myself: they're not ALL CAPS but sᴍᴀʟʟ ᴄᴀᴩs instead :)
There's also the issue that while the site may look pretty, it requires downloading 5 megabytes of CSS.
At every job I've had, designers who talked about typography created more problems than they solved. They picked fonts that were less readable but more unique, "To emphasize our brand." They chose web fonts that hurt page load times and had kerning and hinting issues on platforms besides macOS. They chose thin font weights and gray text colors because those looked nice when viewed indoors on retina displays with young eyes.
Almost every site could be improved by doing less with fonts, not more. For long form text, use a popular serif font. For user interfaces, use the system font stack.[1] Don't ship web fonts except for icons. Most importantly: Use high contrast and normal font weights. Thin gray fonts are extremely hard to read if you're outdoors or using an older/cheaper screen.
1. https://bitsofco.de/the-new-system-font-stack/