News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by Synaesthesia on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:06AM (#18439443)
The entire history of Europe is one of constant, vicious and brutal wars. Yes they exported it overseas but IMO WW1 is a continuation of a tradition of continental violence, not colonial violence that came home.

One could argue rather the colonial violence is an export of the European history of war, as Chomsky does in "Year 501"

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by baud147258 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:36AM (#18440463)
> The entire history of Europe is one of constant, vicious and brutal wars.

By that measure, the rest of the world is the same, with vicious and brutal wars everywhere since the dawn of civilization.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by weberc2 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:41AM (#18441252)
Except that Europe in general kept better written records than much of the rest of the world, so we’re more familiar with its violence.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by cm2187 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:15AM (#18441542)
Agree. A good example is the Mongol empire, which I wasn't familiar with at all (it is barely covered by any european school history book). Dan Carlin made an interesting series of podcasts on the topic [1]. The Mongols barely left any written trace but wiped out entires cities and regions [2].

[1] https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-43-wrath-... https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-44-wrath-... https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-45-wrath-... https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-46-wrath-... https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-47-wrath-...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_under_the_Mongol_E...

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by qubax on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:55AM (#18441887)
Dan Carlin is not a historian, he is an entertainer. His podcasts are entertaining fiction, not history.

> The Mongols barely left any written trace but wiped out entires cities and regions [2].

They left tons of written traces - in muscovy russia, in yuan china, in mughal persia, etc. You can't maintain such a large empire consisting of many civilizations without records. Most of it disappeared over the years as the empire broke apart and different empires formed.

Much of the history of the mongol empire is twisted propaganda, like all history. But it's especially so for the mongol empire due to shifting change of nationalistic, ethnic and racial landscape.

Here in the west, the mongol empire is caricatured and hated for racial reasons. In other parts of the world, the mongol empire is admired. In most of the world, it's a bit of both.

Also, most old empires, including the chinese, romans, greeks, indians, mesopotamians, egyptians, etc left very few records relatively speaking.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by barrow-rider on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:16AM (#18442072)
Europe didn't have any of the large, stable empires like a lot of the rest of the world, i.e. China's various empires, Sassanid Persia, Mughal India, etc.

That's not to say that violence didn't happen, things didn't fall apart -- they sure did -- but compared to Europe they had 200-300 year stretches of relative peace.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by iguy on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:07PM (#18444905)
I think China might be the outlier here, not Europe. (Thinking of the last 1000 years, say.) India was very fragmented -- the Mughals achieved great extent and then great longevity, but not both at the same time.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by nabla9 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:23AM (#18442136)
After Mongols were gone, Europeans were simply the best at organizing large scale, multi-year wars. Big war is all about logistics. Troops need to be fed constantly.

By the rate of death per 100,000 people Thirty Year's War was as violent as the two world wars. source: https://slides.ourworldindata.org/war-and-violence/#/6

Thirty Year's War was basically Europeans being religious nuts and solving the issue by fighting until exhaustion. The original reason for the continuous war was long forgotten when everyone was done. In the end Europeans just agreed to hate each others religion and just fight the normal amount.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by pasabagi on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:00AM (#18439649)
The years before the first world war had seen no serious, bloody conflicts since the Napoleonic wars. Most of the techniques and technologies used so destructively in WW1 were tested first in the colonies.

More fundamentally, the basic driver of tensions before the first world war was the german desire for colonies, or rather, export markets to allow their continued economic growth.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by freddie_mercury on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:34AM (#18439765)
650,000 casualties in the Franco-Prussian War. The November Uprising 100,000 casualties. Russo-Turkish War 200,000 casualties. Crimean War 800,000 casualties.

I guess I don't know what counts as a serious, bloody conflict.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by pasabagi on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:08AM (#18440629)
I think the thing is, the Franco-Prussian war was a limited war with limited goals. The reason why the Napoleonic war stands out as the last war of significance is it was an unlimited war, which reformed europe after it.

I don't think casualty counts are particularly good metrics here - rather, the metric should be the degree to which the civilian population is brought into the war, as victims, soldiers, or workers. In that sense, the colonies had been experiencing 'total' wars in the sense that, europeans rarely distinguished between civilian and enemy forces when putting down insurrection, and rarely had qualms about mass conscription in various forms. Consequently, the casualty numbers and social destruction of the first world war, while extremely unusual for europe, would have been far less unusual in east Africa, or India.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by fork1 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:42AM (#18440834)
Germany started WW1 with the ambition to make it a limited war, with limited goals. Quickly subduing France, and breaking Russia. Most people on either side thought it was going to be a short war. It evolved differently though.

As for the second part, take the Franco-Prussian war then, and it's consequences for France, it was massive. Besides the war that went quite badly, a massive uprising happened in Paris (the Commune), under siege from both Germans and Loyalists forces. Starvation was rampant, civilian impact massive, and the final death toll quite important.

The 19th century in Europe was characterized by nationalisms, unifications of countries in blood, and liberation of a few (Greece or Serbia for ex.), again in blood.

I think you're disregarding history, in the name of your argument.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by lucozade on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:50AM (#18440882)
In your estimation what wars, in 19C India and East Africa, are comparable to the Western Front in terms of "serious, bloody conflicts"?
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by pjc50 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:51AM (#18441321)
The eight million dead in the Belgian Congo?
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by jaimebuelta on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:14AM (#18440667)
Franco-Prussian War happened in 1870, 45 years earlier than WWI.

There was a surprising period of peace in Europe in the late XIX century where for 40 years there was relative peace. That probably work towards the specifics of WWI (war involving almost everyone in Europe, in a very short timespan, with no clear objective for anyone)

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by freddie_mercury on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:45AM (#18441272)
1912-1913: Balkan Wars: 500,000 casualties

I'm not really seeing peace. I mean, the First Balkan War ended only 13 months before the outbreak of WW1.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by jcranmer on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:15AM (#18441546)
The Seven Years' War killed a million people. Napoleonic Wars 5 million. The Balkan Wars 150,000 (note I'm counting deaths, not casualties). Crimean War 400,000 and the Franco-Prussian War perhaps 200,000.

World War I itself saw the deaths of over 10 million people. The Russian Civil War half that and World War II quadruple that. These numbers are not 10x anything seen since the Napoleonic Wars, they are 100x.

The experience of the long 19th century was that wars would be short, decisive, localized in scope, and fairly bloodless. The Balkan Wars and the wars of Italian and German unification were not exceptions to this rule. The American Civil War and Boer Wars were exceptions, but discounted because they weren't European wars. The Crimean War was a partial exception (it was long and indecisive, but still fairly localized and fairly bloodless for the ambitions of the powers involved). The leaders were wholly unprepared for the long, bloody stalemate that would characterize World War I, or the incessant civil wars and wars of ideology that would characterize the wars between World War I and World War II.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by barrow-rider on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:31AM (#18442222)
> The American Civil War and Boer Wars were exceptions, but discounted because they weren't European wars

Russo-Japanese War as well. More recent than the US Civil War and gave some early examples as to what WWI would look like, but generally considered to be irrelevant since it wasn't a European War and was generally localized to the far, far east.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by iguy on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:57PM (#18444838)
Indeed, discounting the American civil war seems to be the crucial step for making the 19th C look safe. While obviously not physically in Europe, it was the closest fore-taste of what determined modern states could do to each other.

But contrary to TFA's claims, colonial wars were also "short, decisive, localized", maybe all 10 times smaller again (unless my googling fails me).

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by freddie_mercury on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:10PM (#18447156)
> The experience of the long 19th century was that wars would be short, decisive, localized in scope, and fairly bloodless.

At the risk of writing a 1,000 word reply...for the past 2 decades there's been a growing body of academic research using archival documents from military archives (captured by the Soviet Union after WW2 and unknown to scholars until the 1990s), that politicians and generals didn't actually believe in the "short-war illusion" and they were actually fully prepared for the long, bloody stalemate that happened.

Christopher Clark's The Sleepwalkers is a popular book containing much of this new research.

Some examples from this kind of research:

Prussian General & Chancellor von Caprivi warned that war against France alone would be "tenacious and protracted."

Field Marshal von der Goltz publicly warned that "future wars would be long drawn-out affairs involving nations and not just cabinets."

In 1890 the architect of the Franco-Prussian War warned parliament that caution the nation that the next European conflict would most likely be a "Seven or Thirty Years' War."

The quartermaster-general of the German army warned "We cannot expect quick, decisive victories." The war of the future instead would feature "a tedious and bloody crawling forward step-by-step," that is, "siege-style" warfare.

Field Marshall von Haenseler also warned that one could not simply "carry off the armed forces of a great power [France] like a cat in a sack."

The German General Chief of Staff believed the coming war "will be a peoples' war, one which would not be concluded by a single decisive battle," but which would deteriorate into a "long and protracted struggle." The future war could not be terminated until "the peoples' energy had been entirely broken"; even if victorious, the German people would emerge from such a struggle "exhausted in the extreme."

The German Imperial Navy office wrote "It is not possible to discern why the war should last only nine months.... In order to avoid arriving at deceptive perceptions, one should, on the basis of available information, base planning on a war of perhaps 1 1/2 years."

The Prussian Statistics Office (who had to figure out how to feed the nation during the coming war) calculated a scenario for "a war of 2 or even 2 1/2 to 3 years."

In 1912 Field Marshall Ludendorff wrote any war would be "a long-drawn out campaign with numerous difficult, long-lasting battles, before we can defeat [even] one of our adversaries."

The General Staff's Third Section (Intelligence) continued to speak of the war of the future in terms of a "peoples' war," of a "protracted struggle," and of a "long-lasting campaign."

German Major Haushofer (the future "father" of geopolitics) believed the coming war would last "at least 3 years".

Falkenhayn told his old regiment the coming war would last "at least one-and-one-half years."

German Chancellor Hollweg believed that any action against Serbia "can lead to a world war".

According to this line of research, the short-term war illusion still existed but in a different (worse) guise. The generals and politicans knew (or strongly believed) the coming war would be anything but short, decisive, localised, and bloodless. But they couldn't see any alternative.

They realised that there was no viable alternative to a desperate HOPE of a short war, short of admitting that war itself was no longer feasible.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:38AM (#18439781)
What about the Franco-Prussian War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-Prussian_War from 1870-1871.

Between France and Germany, over 3 million soldiers were deployed and 44,000 Germans and 138,000 French soldiers died.

There was also the Crimean War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimean_War from 1853-1856, in which all sides mobilized over a million soldiers and suffered 750,000 losses and casualties (including deaths from disease).

Finally, although not in Europe, the American Civil War of 1861-1865 was a foretaste of what industrialize warfare looked like with artillery, trenches, railroads and telegraphs, as well as the deliberate destruction of civilian infrastructure as a way to destroy the enemies' ability to continue to wage a war.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by wcarey on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:28AM (#18439734)
Would the quarter million casualties of the Franco-Prussian war push it into the category of "serious, bloody" conflict?
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by fork1 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:37AM (#18439776)
There was plenty of important conflicts in Europe between WW1 and the Napoleonic wars, not on the same scale, but it was hardly peaceful. Europe was undergoing major structural changes with the advent of nationalisms.

And the causes of war are a lot more complicated than just Germany looking for export markets and colonies. It might be one of many causes (or rather consequences of other factors), but it's hardly the basic driver.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by thrower123 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:36AM (#18440801)
Indeed, just in the decade or so before the guns of august, there were a whole series of wars throughout the Balkans, as the Ottoman Empire started to unravel, that primed the tinderbox and led to the events of Sarajevo. Given a few more years, it's almost inevitable that nationalist movements would have fractured and busted apart the Austro-Hungarians and their uneasy multicultural coalition, given the frightening incompetence of most of their leadership.

The reunification of Italy always seems to get swept under the rug as well.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by gdfasfklshg4 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:25AM (#18439724)
Do you count the American Civil War as a colonial war?
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by icebraining on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:24AM (#18440415)
I don't think that happened in Europe.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by muro on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:14AM (#18441048)
There were also the 3 italian wars of independence.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by danmaz74 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:50AM (#18439606)
Tbh, having a state of very frequent wars wasn't an exclusive to Europe.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by ur-whale on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:32AM (#18439751)
wasn't => isn't
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by cm2187 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:56AM (#18441363)
I'd add that there was nothing in nature specific to ww1. These mass, all-in, full conscription wars have happened all over the XIX since the Napoleonic wars. What was new was the exponential improvement in technology that had devastating effects, which ww2 surpassed with an order of magnitude (burning an entire country to the ground rather than a few battlefields).

The gradual increase in horror and devastation between the great european wars has really been a story of technological advances more than anything else.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by Spooky23 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:23AM (#18441605)
The difference was the the theatre of war wasn't the battlefield, but the entire economy in general. Germany lost WW1 because they ran out of money first, while the allied powers could have kept the meat grinder churning for another 2-3 years with US intervention.

With industrialization, the results on the battlefield didn't really have much to do with the outcome of the conflict. Direct conflict between major powers from circa-1860 onward was about destroying the enemy's economy and political system or destroying the enemy utterly. The pursuit of decisive military victory was defeated time and time again, with the exception of the atomic bomb, and even that is arguable.

Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by cm2187 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:45AM (#18441796)
I don't know if that was specific to ww1. Finance, supplies and ability to hold a siege has always been key to wars.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by asianthrowaway on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:07AM (#18439670)
The entire history of mankind is one of constant, vicious and brutal wars.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by sbhn on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:15AM (#18440379)
Very good point, the amplification of the importance of WW1 is essential for the families that still profit from war and division today.
Re:Colonial violence came home in the First World War by baud147258 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:38AM (#18440474)
> the importance of WW1

Realising the importance of WW1 and its impact is important so that such a war does not happen again.