Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by ac29 on Sunday November 11, 2018 @11:41AM
(#18427193)
This particular article doesn't claim the new Macs can't boot Linux, only that you cannot boot Linux (or anything aside from macOS and Windows) with secure boot on, because you can't load your own trusted keys. Pretty much all other hardware in the price range allows you to load your own keys, and thus securely boot anything you want.
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by amaccuish on Sunday November 11, 2018 @12:39PM
(#18427498)
> This particular article doesn't claim the new Macs can't boot Linux
Yes it does. And it references the also incorrect phoronix article as evidence. It provides Chromebooks as an example with a hardware switch; the new T2 has an equivalent software switch. But the article ignores this and reads as if it's not possible to run Linux at all.
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by pocket on Sunday November 11, 2018 @10:41AM
(#18426865)
Pretty sure you can choose to disable the secure boot options… from only the latest, to ones that were at one point trusted (old OSes), to no restrictions - https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208330
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by bentona on Sunday November 11, 2018 @10:40AM
(#18426859)
I love the quality of apple hardware. I love knowing that the software was built for the hardware (or vice-versa, whatever). I do not enjoy configuring operating systems & desktop environments - I want to solve problems in the app I'm developing, not my development environment.
I have been delaying upgrading my MBP and iPhone, however, because I'm scared. I'm scared that the headphone-jack-removal, touchbar, locked-down-bootloader philosophy will continue, and I'll have to buy a thinkpad. I want to keep being an apple fanboy, but they're making it difficult.
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by asutekku on Sunday November 11, 2018 @10:37AM
(#18426834)
I mean the reason to buy Apple is the Software and hardware combination. Why would you install Linux on a Mac when pretty much every other cheaper laptop is more suitable for that?
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by pdkl95 on Sunday November 11, 2018 @10:54AM
(#18426952)
The laptop is their property; they don't need to justify how they want to use their own property.
Locking down the bootloader against the laptop owner's wishes is an attempt to de facto usurp the owner's basic property rights. Apple is not the owner of he laptop; they have no right to mandate how their product is used after the first sale.
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by gsich on Sunday November 11, 2018 @11:00AM
(#18426985)
After you bought it, it's your property. People tend to forget this. People are also allowed to install macOS on standard PC hardware, despite Apple crying "not allowed".
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by tarboreus on Sunday November 11, 2018 @10:39AM
(#18426854)
I was issued a Mac Air by my employer. OSX feels like an operating system for children. If this was in effect then, I would have just put the computer on the shelf as the toy it is.
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by scarface74 on Sunday November 11, 2018 @04:42PM
(#18428787)
Not needing to pay the licensing fees for vmware, parallells
So you’re okay with paying at least $800 for the cheapest Mac that Apple sells, but my development Mac would at least be $1100 - $2000, but you don’t want to spend $79 on Parallel Fusion?
Re:Apple's new bootloader won't let you install GNU/Linux
by claudius on Sunday November 11, 2018 @01:50PM
(#18427854)
Well, none? To install GCC, Homebrew wanted me to install XCode first. That’s when I gave up because nothing was installed there by default except for an outdated Bash.
This has been duped many times. And wrong. There is an option to entirely disable secure boot.
See this for accurate info: https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2018/11/apple-t2-chip-cant-boot-...
Dupes:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18383250
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18396925
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18383512
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18423560
Yes it does. And it references the also incorrect phoronix article as evidence. It provides Chromebooks as an example with a hardware switch; the new T2 has an equivalent software switch. But the article ignores this and reads as if it's not possible to run Linux at all.
EDIT: It was copy pasted wrong, here it is: https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2018/11/apple-t2-chip-cant-boot-...
I have been delaying upgrading my MBP and iPhone, however, because I'm scared. I'm scared that the headphone-jack-removal, touchbar, locked-down-bootloader philosophy will continue, and I'll have to buy a thinkpad. I want to keep being an apple fanboy, but they're making it difficult.
Locking down the bootloader against the laptop owner's wishes is an attempt to de facto usurp the owner's basic property rights. Apple is not the owner of he laptop; they have no right to mandate how their product is used after the first sale.
Apple is forced to keep things as stable as possible since new OsX drivers are their problem.
You could also test every OS on the same hardware, which is the only use we had for OsX after setup tasks.
Fortunately, per above fact checker, disabling secure boot allows Linux installs.
I hope that someone works with Apple to sign some Linux distro(s), recognized by secure boot.
I deeply appreciate Apple's efforts to locking down their gear. But would still like the option of installing known good Linux, xBSD, Haiku, etc.
* run containers natively
* customize / swap out the window manager/display manager
* run kvm virtual machines
* desktop fractional scaling
Not needing to pay the licensing fees for vmware, parallells
Not needing to use a buggier hypervisor/manager such as virtualbox
Leverage qemu and all of it's benefits at full speed, such as emulating ARM devices
So you’re okay with paying at least $800 for the cheapest Mac that Apple sells, but my development Mac would at least be $1100 - $2000, but you don’t want to spend $79 on Parallel Fusion?
There is also the integrated Hypervisor.framework that seems to be gaining traction and I fully welcome that! But it's still not kvm: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/hypervisor
https://wiki.qemu.org/Hosts/Mac
Admittedly I stopped looking into it and just shelfed the laptop until requesting a saner one.
But more to the point. Even if you didn’t know about that option you gave up because you didn’t want to sign up for a free account?
Let's hope there is enough community pushback to force Apple into making user modifications to trusted keys possible.
So this is apparently false, you can disable secure boot.
Still don't like apple though. :D
Source: https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2018/11/apple-t2-chip-cant-boot-...