I'm obviously simplifying. Luxury apartments downtown are different to the sort of monstrosities you see in suburbs.
Moving from a family home in a suburb into the city =/= moving from a family home into a block of flats on the same street. The latter is what I am calling a 'strict downgrade'.
I think the misunderstanding comes from making a comparison that I obviously haven't attempted to, and that no reasonable person would (basically, a strawman).
I can't see how a suburban apartment can be as nice as a suburban house unless you're making a cost argument.
Yes, perhaps an apartment at price X is better than a house at price X. (Perhaps at price X a house doesn't even exist).
The point is that someone who already owns a decent home doesn't have to make that decision, and that describes huge swathes of the city. The financial decision is for newcomers who are attempting to push these people out (or push them in to inferior conditions).
If you have a 4 bedroom semi in Zone 4 London then I cannot see an equivalent apartment. It doesn't even make sense to me. No apartment block on the same street could be nicer.
Only if you compared it with, say, some skyscraper in the City does it make sense to even talk about it, and that's a complete lifestyle change.
If you can sell a house, move to an apartment and net X00,000 $ that’s very attractive. So price difference are really part of the equation.
Also, people might prefer a detached home for ~30 years when having kids, but their is a constant stream of people exiting that life stage. How and where to downsize is a real question people deal with daily.
In the UK (and most of Europe) the suburban apartment is most akin to a concrete box.
Americans have their land of course. I have my own equivalent garden. The difference is scarcity. I can travel a continent and still buy a garden relatively cheap. The UK? Not so much.
I'm not sure about this "barely green" thing. Haven't been to Oxford, but I've visited Cambridge, and the gardens there are magnificently green.
Sounds like the most insignificant of concerns.
>A community of people who presumably are in your socioeconomic class will be living with you. These are folks you can interact with and depending on your stage in life you may potentially do business with, befriend, start children’s play groups with, or even date/marry.
A community of people that rarely interact the way neighbors in nearby homes do.
>There will tend to be more options for healthy foods
Assuming these people regularly eat outside, which automatically lowers the health factor of their food compared to home cooked.
Cities have more options for groceries and grocery delivery.
I've never seen apartment residents socialize more than suburban neighbors anywhere I lived or visited.
I don't have numbers, but the isolation of apartment living in cities is a common trope in movies and literature, and a constant complaint of people moving to cities or going away from them.
In the end, the closed door few common areas of apartment buildings (not talking about expensive condos with shared pools and stuff), means people see each other and interact less than some neighbors in a rural/suburban neighborhood.
> Sounds like the most insignificant of concerns.
If you're away from home any significant portion of the time, this can be really useful. An Amazon Prime membership, for instance, becomes less useful if 1) you don't know that you're going to be home at a certain time every single day and 2) your packages are likely to disappear if you don't collect them in a timely manner.
The mid-rise courtyard+playground styles I see in central and northern Europe today, on the other hand, are pretty much ideal for family life. Just enough density to support a walkable daily life with lots of serendipitous social encounters, eyes on the street, a view on the kids playing with enough proximity to intervene if something goes wrong, and the opportunity for first-floor private garden space and aesthetic personalization throughout.
Not only that they used those projects as a way to punish independent political adversaries in the city government. Everyone who originally conceived of the programs tried to build mixed density communities spread throughout the city that were only partially social housing, but racism & power politics prevented that.
Then the city doubled down & didn’t provide services appropriate for the number of people now densely packed in one place.
The book “Blueprint for Disaster” outlines the history of this very well.
Societywide, that's a huge bug, not a feature, but suburbs have the same problem, and cities mitigate it by having all classes cllose together in public.
24/7 doorman means someone to sign for packages.
A community of people who presumably are in your socioeconomic class will be living with you. These are folks you can interact with and depending on your stage in life you may potentially do business with, befriend, start children’s play groups with, or even date/marry.
Big communities tend to have nice amenities that you’d only find in a country club all inclusive.
Maintenance of the high rise unit is often included in the fees or rent.
These communities tend to get better access to interconnect technologies like fiber.
There will tend to be more options for healthy foods, increased opportunities for walkable restaurants and other forms of entertainment as the population density of the area increases.
And more...
Basically, my preference 10/10 times would be to live in a high density tall building over a single family home in a neighborhood.