Hey, it looks like TerraPower at least has some people who share your pet theory [1].
[1] https://www.worldscientific.com/doi/abs/10.1142/978981314899...
Honestly, I think for the LWRs in the US, it's more of a financing and risk problem than anything. As I understand it, the two South Carolina LWRs failed mainly because the fracking boom created a glut in natural gas prices. Now no one is willing to make any bets on energy prices 20-years out [2]. Note that I'm not sure if these were Gen-II.
At least from a cost standpoint, building LWRs the way we used to is akin to Space Shuttle launches: Awesome idea 30 years ago, but they match the finance risk profiles of energy markets today.
Re: construction. Funny enough, there's actually a industry-wide skilled construction squeeze in the US right now [1]. After the '07 crash the number of new workers going into construction dropped precipitously. Now when we need skilled project managers there isn't enough to fill demand.
[1] https://www.usnews.com/news/the-report/articles/2018-06-15/t...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/31/climate/nuclear-power-pro...
wat? They most assuredly generate electric power. It's just that the bleed steam the sub needs for electric power is trivial compared to the motive power sent to the main reduction gear. They carry diesel generators for emergency use only.
I believe France’s boomers and the next gen SSBN the US is designing both have electric drive.
Isn’t this a bit of a “if you can dodge a wrench, you can dodge a ball” question though? Electricity generation and direct steam propulsion both drive turbines, the principal of shipboard operation is well proven.
The bigger issue in my mind is that the nuclear powered ships spend a tremendous amount of time in port ( at least compared to the downtime of a land based power station) and then often just sail around bad weather rather than get hammered by it.
All nuclear reactors generate steam. That steam then drives a turbine which generates the electricity.
The difference in the Ford class is that the steam turbine is bigger, powering most of the ship’s systems via an electrical bus rather than by piping steam around the ship. This approach reduces complexity and maintenance costs.
The steam is used to run generators and provide electricity, as well as run engines that drive screws (propellers are on airplanes).
Naval reactors are smaller than civilian reactors, but are far more efficient and use different fuel.
And "evacuate and sink" isn't an option in a multi billion dollar strategic asset.
The Soviet Alfa-class used molten lead-bismuth coolant. (Which was run through a separate steam generator to generate steam, granted).
Though there's no principal reason why steam has to be the working fluid. Supercritical CO2, for instance, has many attractive properties.
> Naval reactors are smaller than civilian reactors, but are far more efficient
Hmm, define "efficient"? Efficient as in conversion of heat to mechanical power? Or use of uranium fuel? Or what?
Says that the reactor also powers other systems. And sometimes the motor is electric.
Makes sense. Why would you build a nuclear reactor and then only use the steam to power the motor?
https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-compu...
https://gizmodo.com/russias-floating-nuclear-power-plant-has...
http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/05/27/russias-nav...
https://de.rbth.com/wissen-und-technik/79917-russische-atom-...
If Germany invested that amount of money into Russia, you can bet that it was urgent.
Hopefully Russia has shown more care dealing with their Nuclear power plants...
https://www.dw.com/de/russland-entsorgung-von-atom-u-booten-...
http://www.faz.net/aktuell/politik/lager-fuer-alte-atom-u-bo...
All in all the West (!!!) provided many more billions for the safety of those approximately 120-180 (!) nuclear-powered submarines.
https://www.zeit.de/2013/07/Russisches-Polarmeer-Atom-U-Boot...
Pictures:
https://www.bmwi.de/Redaktion/DE/Downloads/A/abruestung-atom...
Russia also has submarines buried at the ground in the arctic sea. Like the K-27 in the early 80s.
https://www.maritime-executive.com/editorials/russia-updates...
Sunken objects:
> 17,000 containers of radioactive waste; 19 ships containing radioactive waste; 14 nuclear reactors, including five that still contain spent nuclear fuel; the K-27 nuclear submarine with its two reactors loaded with nuclear fuel and 735 other pieces of radioactively contaminated heavy machinery.
The nonradioactive steam handling, turbines and electrical generators should be quite similar to what's used in conventional coal/natural gas plants.
And as dangerous.
[1] https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/struggling-nucl...
The US does a poor job of recycling due to the fact that it listened to the environmentalists and anti-terrorist groups in the 70s. Jimmy Carter was told that recycling was bad for the environment (won't someone think of the children if the train overturns), was not cost effective, and would lead to nuclear proliferation due to terrorists dropping from the sky and stealing the train to Mexico [2].
Now we can recycle, and we can reuse the fuel to breed new fuel sources. If we did this 30 years ago, even just the first half of the last clause, we would not be looking down the barrel of climate change.
1 - https://www.zdnet.com/article/what-france-plans-to-do-with-i...
2 - https://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2014/10/01/why-doesnt-...
* Edit a typo thing of the children -> think of the children.
> proliferation due to terrorists dropping from the sky
This is exactly what I mean by a cavalier attitude towards these problems. It is dismissive, uses manipulative phrasing like the president "was told" that removes his agency, paints environmentalists as all powerful agents of manipulation, etc.
France is not a perfect example. Fukushima demonstrated the kind of disaster that can happen despite best efforts and good operating records, and there is much debate in France about the risks of relying on nuclear going forward.[1]
Which is all a shame given how much better modern designs are.
Of course, it's far better for health and the environment if we can replace them with solar and batteries. But perspective on the dangers of nuclear compared to fossil fuels is important.
They mentioned a few problems everyone knows about nuclear (NIMBY, financing, licensing, etc), but one of the unintuitive problems was the lack of institutional memory for construction. Westinghouse et.al. will design the core of the plant, but each plant is constructed by a series of contractors and subcontractors who many times, have never constructed anything this precise before. Jessica Lovering compared it to constructing cathedrals (in that each one was bespoke). This makes each one effectively as expensive as the last.
This is one of the many problems companies like TerraPower are trying to solve: Not just dropping up front cost (finance) or making it more stable (NIMBY), but also trying to build a living knowledge of how to build reactors repeatably.
Total tangent: My pet theory is that if it gets really bad, we'll just start building floating nuclear reactors and park them within transmission distance from cities. Ironically we have a ton of experience with floating nuclear reactors from maintaining a large nuclear-powered navy.
[1] https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/can-we-make-nuc...