News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by edoo on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:30PM (#18393030)
Banks and the rest hate me. I use keypass to generate random alpha numeric 'passwords' I use for the answers to personal questions.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by nothrabannosir on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:27PM (#18393566)
I have personally experienced a CS rep accepting “it’s just a bunch of random characters” as an answer. Combined with the fact that you just went on the record as using that scheme, your opsec just took a dramatic hit.

Use plausible sounding, but random answers.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by panopticon on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:35PM (#18394213)
The first time I had a CS rep require me to recite my 64-character alphanumeric answer was what prompted me to switch my strategy. Now I generate a list of four arbitrary words for every answer to security questions... so much easier to answer.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by samstave on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:19PM (#18395005)
Whats the name of the first school you went to?

"School"

Whats the name of your first pet?

"Pet"

---

I use this scheme when i need to come up with these types of answers for a service that i dont deem as super critical or risky...

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by vermilingua on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:57PM (#18395247)
That’s twice in this thread that someone has revealed pretty potent details of their personal security.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by chii on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:05PM (#18395305)
it just goes to show that these questions are useless as a security barrier. Any institution still using them are doomed to have social-engineering vulnerability.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by rkho on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:39PM (#18395871)
Any company employing low cost workers is vulnerable to social engineering and bribery.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by kazinator on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:01PM (#18396023)
I think I would refine that like this: among companies that train workers against social engineering, ones that pay workers peanuts are going to still be more susceptible than the others simply because of the don't-care factor.

Other than that, anyone is susceptible to social engineering, regardless of pay. Social engineering is crafted to suit demographics.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by mattkrause on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:56PM (#18395989)
What's the absolute worst that could happen if you crack my free account on some cooking website?

Maybe you favorite a bunch of recipes with lima beans (which I hate). Instead, you discover that I was really into lentil dishes for a while, but have been more interested in dumplings this fall. Maybe this could be used in some sort of elaborate social engineering scheme that nets you more valuable information, but I'm not seeing how....

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by kazinator on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:05PM (#18396056)
> What's the absolute worst that could happen if you crack my free account on some cooking website?

The worst that could happen is that you used the same password there as for your online banking, or important e-mail account and such.

If you didn't do that, then the impact is approximately zero.

Of course, that cooking site still wants you to use a sufficiently long password with at least one digit, capital and lower case letter, and special character ...

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by YouAreGreat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:36PM (#18400680)
Wherever you can publish text or media (eg, on a cooking site) speech crimes can be committed under your account.

Fancy a prison term in one of the more enlightened European jurisdictions, or Canada?

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by mattkrause on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:59PM (#18401284)
Okay, I set myself up for this by saying "absolute worst", but this strikes me as so unlikely that it's not really worth worrying about. After all, someone could make a new account using your name (+ some numbers) /right now/!
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by 14 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:50PM (#18395953)
I disagree. I do the same for certain sites. I have a gmail that I use for weird sites that I most likely won't visit again or any time soon and answer the security questions much the same. If this account gets compromised I literally lose nothing other then make a new gmail and do it again. This shows nothing about my bank or Facebook or actual gmail account security as those I do take steps to protect.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by icedchai on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:34PM (#18396206)
Hopefully they're using unique usernames and not using the same username all over the Internet. Or, worse, a variation of their real name as a username.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by MisterTea on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:43PM (#18395902)
That's Amazing! I've got the same security answers on my luggage!
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by jgtrosh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:45PM (#18394276)
In this case a password like “to be repeated exactly: <random string>” has the same properties and can be divulged without affecting opsec particularly.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by nothrabannosir on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:05PM (#18394447)
(Un)fortunately, normal people don't think like programmers. That's why security questions exist, in the first place. Do you think they won't accept "It's to be repeated exactly, and then gschgschgsch. Ahh, youth. Those were the days."

If you think that's bad: I always enter a fake phone nr. Once, a company turned out to use them as verification for phone support. I didn't know, and had forgotten, so gave my actual number. "Oh, it says something else here. Shall I just go ahead and remove that, then?". I wanted to cry.

Don't play games.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by function_seven on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:17PM (#18395410)
Not that I condone this strategy, but what is the threat model where an impersonator knows to say, "It's to be repeated exactly, and then adso&#fjsou..."?
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by nothrabannosir on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:43PM (#18395588)
I'd go with "putting your security question strategy on a public forum", for starters.

Security through obscurity strikes again.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by function_seven on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:52PM (#18395617)
Well yeah, in this case that's the weakness. But before parent announced their strategy on this forum, what was the threat model? Hell, let's assume OP obfuscated the introductory part in their comment to avoid that leak.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by ChristianBundy on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:37PM (#18395862)
If they're willing to brag about their passwords on the internet, I'd be willing to bet that family and friends have the same information.

Assuming that wasn't true, a customer service rep for the phone company could call the customer's bank and try to impersonate the customer, assuming it's used often (like the poster stated).

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by lozaning on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:15PM (#18394533)
Im always shocked by how small the fields for some of those inputs are though. How much space for entropy do you have left after including the notice about needing an exact match?
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by Pxtl on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:28PM (#18395798)
This is where "correct horse battery staple" password generators might be good.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by lstodd on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:50PM (#18395951)
Well, hell, I got off with just saying "I don't remember it" an then following up with details of _recent_transactions_ not one time. This whole "personal question" scheme is useless.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by wtvanhest on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:04PM (#18396051)
I just reset my password for American Airlines. They ask me 3 (what I would consider public questions) about myself, then let me reset the pw in browser. No emails or any other authentication. Im still blown away.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by tvanantwerp on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:38PM (#18393684)
Got bitten by this when I had to give a 32-character alphanumeric answer over the phone. I groaned and asked, "Can I just give you the beginning and the end?" The rep laughed and accepted my compromise. Since then, I use a collection of random words (in the style of correct-horse-battery-staple) for security questions.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by RickS on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:32PM (#18393055)
What are some of the ways this blows back? Having to answer them over the phone when they're not passwords, but more like customer service gatekeepers?

I do this as well and it has yet to blow up in my face, though it does seem like an inevitability.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by telesilla on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:19PM (#18393492)
I got pretty good at memorising alpha bravo charlie[1] so I just jump straight into that, and for characters like #, * and ! I try and use the word I know is most common, e.g. in english "pound", "star" and "exclamation mark". "hash" and "bang" get me what I suppose are the equivalent of blank looks..

So I have nicely complex passwords generated by Keepass and the staff usually don't think anything of it once I mention I work in "computers".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NATO_phonetic_alphabet

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by edoo on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:36PM (#18393085)
I used to do a slightly different system where I'd have ridiculous answers, sort of a word game play on the question itself, and forgetting your secret answers with a company like Verizon can take days to figure out.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by AckSyn on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:47PM (#18393201)
I do this but instead of passwords like `NGIyNzgwMTEyNDczYTIyNjEwYWRhYWZh` I'd use `BatteryHorseStaple33` to the question: Where were you born.

I've never had it blow up in my face with any rep, and I make sure to keep the passwords in an offline (never touches any network) laptop.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by captn3m0 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:48PM (#18393212)
My bank (HDFC India) specifically states while setting up the security question that the bank will never ask for these (over phone or elsewhere), so I'm happily using random UUIDs
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by greenshackle2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:22PM (#18395771)
HDFC appears to have truly terrible security, someone managed to sign up with my email address and a really weird mailing address - like an airport warehouse or something, then proceeded to fill up the card and never paid it back. I emailed HDFC about it but they never responded.

Apparently they don't even do e-mail verification.

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by jandrese on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:57PM (#18393297)
What is the point of a security question if they never use it?
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by enitihas on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:01PM (#18393325)
Asking you to fill them online for password recovery etc?
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by captn3m0 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:05AM (#18397205)
Yes, they use it for 2FA sometimes on netbanking transactions.
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by psergeant on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:23PM (#18393530)
I get asked for single characters of mine a lot
Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by pasbesoin on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:48PM (#18394314)
I treat them as less secure passwords -- passwords that often a representative at the company has access to. (I've experienced instances of people on the phone (upon my calling the organization at a known number) soliciting their answers and checking them against what they have on their screen. Usually these days, with actual passwords, they undergo a computerized check and members of the organization have no access to their values -- or at least to their unencrypted values. (Although, don't blindly depend upon that assumption.)

Security questions introduce insecurity. I remember being mightily puzzled when they were considered a "best practice" and the organization I was at was all "het up" to implement them.

The real reason? They save head count / expense -- at least, in the short run. One less "I can't remember my password" interaction -- one that, from an optimistic perspective, at least doesn't just blindly depend upon emailing the email address of record... Only, many sites seem to implement that alongside their security questions flow, so...

Re:Operation Luigi: How I hacked my friend without her notic... by adzm on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:06PM (#18395691)
Diceware phrases work well here, too!