News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @06:39PM (#18349805)
Hi, I'm one the makers of Levels.fyi. Happy to answer any questions and would love to hear feedback! We have a lot of features in the coming months that we think folks will love!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by ummonk on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:41PM (#18350172)
I've been using levels.fyi and really liking it. It provides much more useful data than paysa. I strongly believe the economy needs a functioning free labor market, and price discovery is crucial to any free market.

The main feature I'd like to see is information on typical refreshers. Also useful would be a way to just get a list of companies sorted by comp at a given approximate level. Additionally, information about refreshers and career trajectories at different companies would be nice too, for evaluating medium-long term prospects of working at any given company (e.g. I've read anecdotes that Apple offers more generous refreshers than most companies).

I'd also like to see data on equity aggregated across small-medium startups, perhaps as a function of valuation, employee number, employee experience and time since last valuation. AngelList has some data about listed equity but it's very broad, and I'd like for some actual data of the sort that startups privately share with each other but keep secret from employees / job-seekers.

Edit: It would also be cool if you guys can get some companies to post job ads with compensation ranges included for the posted levels. It would be useful for everyone involved; it would help candidates avoid needlessly applying to companies that can't match their desired comp, help out companies that offer competitive comp in sourcing candidates, and add more revenue for you guys as well.

Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @08:13PM (#18350381)
Thanks for the feedback! We've been currently been heads down working on adding account functionality so that folks can start reviewing companies / teams within companies. As soon as that's out (next few weeks) we're hoping to work on more granular compensation information as well!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Pfhreak on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:49PM (#18350222)
Consider adding non-binary genders to the comp reporting. Something as simple as 'other' or 'non-binary' would be nice. The challenges that non-binary folks face can sometimes be different, and it might be nice to see that reflected in the comp tool.

Edit: I wouldn't ask, except that the tool already asks for gender. If you are already asking for a gender, you should consider include options beyond male/female.

Curious about the downvotes without responses. Tech has people who are non-binary, whose salary negotiations may be impacted by that, and who may struggle to find data that represents them.

Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Thursday November 01, 2018 @11:05AM (#18354563)
Good feedback, we'll get this added shortly. We added gender recently based on feedback to highlight the gender wage gap. Agree that non-binary folks may experience another set of challenges and will be good to see the data.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Pfhreak on Thursday November 01, 2018 @11:13AM (#18354679)
Thanks, who knows if enough non-binary folks will report, but I appreciate you taking the feedback!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by malmsteen on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @09:19PM (#18350711)
There's barely enough data to make statistic over the whole population in his website i'm not sure it would make sense to isolate specific minority who would have like 1% of the already little data...

i'd be more into removing the male / female distinction overall in the website

[dead]
Re:Compare career levels across companies by andrewem on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @09:12PM (#18350674)
I've downvoted this because it seems like you're trying to be insulting to this person on the basis of an assumption about their gender. That doesn't seem worthy of HN.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by NKosmatos on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:11PM (#18349978)
Hi and thanks for the info. A couple of things if I may. Please don’t hijack the browser history, played around with some companies and levels and when I tried coming back to HN the history was full ;-) Also it would be good if you could include some extra details about each level (e.g. education, years of experience). I think I’ll give Triplebyte a try, reminds me of HackerRank.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:17PM (#18350016)
Good feedback. The browser history was a bug introduced from recent change in last few days. We're on it.

Regarding additional details on each level, although there is some correlation between years of experience and level, it actually isn't very strong. A better indication is typically responsibilities / scope of impact which we are working on defining more clearly. Thanks for the feedback!

Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Friday November 02, 2018 @10:35AM (#18363297)
Update: fixed!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by xeromal on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:06PM (#18349959)
Clicking around on the page adds to the tab's history. I had to click back 10x to go back to this thread. Seems kind of pointless to record state in this usecase?
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:18PM (#18350023)
Re Browser history hijack: this was bug introduced with a recent change. We're on it - apologies for the inconvenience!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Friday November 02, 2018 @10:35AM (#18363295)
Update: Fixed!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by phd514 on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @09:31PM (#18350778)
I added my comp at one of the listed companies a couple weeks back and it never showed up in your list. I'm not sure if there are bugs in your front end or lots of false negatives in your spam filtering or what. I'm happy to contribute to such an effort but not to the point where I have to figure out how to game your submission process.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @11:11PM (#18351190)
Apologies - this shouldn't happen. Are you sure it never made it on the site? The comp page takes ~5 minutes to refresh new submissions.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by bronxbomber92 on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @11:43PM (#18351311)
Thanks for putting this site together! Two pieces of feedback:

1. It would be valuable to ask for years at company and years in industry along with the reported compensation.

2. When reporting my compensation, how should I account for additional bonuses/RSUs due to being promoted? (E.g. climbing a level). I historically receive an additional 100k grant when I’ve been promoted, but I don’t anticipate that 100k on non-promotion years.

Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @11:53PM (#18351347)
1. We actually do ask for this - it's toward the end of the form. :) Click the '+' on the left side of the row to show it.

2. The main Total Compensation field is per-year and the simplest way is to look at your W2. For RSUs / bonus we recommend taking the average amount you receive per year

Re:Compare career levels across companies by ryandrake on Thursday November 01, 2018 @02:12AM (#18351755)
Do you believe that self-reported salary data will be biased either high or low? Do you attempt to measure bias? How do you account for the difference between the salaries reported on your site and the averages/medians published by salary.com and glassdoor.com? Is it that your site only focuses on outlier (top) companies?

Any plans to add "Project Manager" role?

Re:Compare career levels across companies by freyir on Thursday November 01, 2018 @12:56AM (#18351546)
Why don’t the numbers always add up? A Tesla P3 engineer lists his or her base as $130k, stock grant as $150k and TC is listed as as $168,000?

Does it not check whether the numbers make sense?

Re:Compare career levels across companies by shanghaiaway on Thursday November 01, 2018 @01:55AM (#18351717)
Stock grant over 4 years, TC is per year.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by null000 on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:26PM (#18350080)
Interesting site - it's nice to have such straightforward compensation numbers.

Worth mentioning, though - several tech companies intentionally and transparently attempt to pay more for some locations. My company, for instance, pays way more if you're in Silicon Valley than pretty much anywhere else.

It'd be nice aggregate, summarize, and compare companies based on a single location.

Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:58PM (#18350274)
We're working on ability to filter by location more easily. More of a UX challenge than data challenge since we have data for other regions already. Still need to think through how to present this cleanly without over cluttering the site. Thanks for the feedback!
Re:Compare career levels across companies by malvosenior on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:13PM (#18349994)
Hi, thanks for making such a helpful site! My feedback would be:

* Would love to see the salary numbers without clicking for easy comparison

* I don't like how clicking around fills my browser history and adds back button clicks

Re:Compare career levels across companies by Zaheer on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:18PM (#18350030)
We have a dedicated page for compensation information: https://www.levels.fyi/comp.html

There's also a short url: www.comp.fyi :)

Re:Compare career levels across companies by malvosenior on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @07:21PM (#18350051)
Oh, great! It's nice to see them all side by side like that.
Re:Compare career levels across companies by returnInfinity on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @10:42PM (#18351085)
Adobe is missing