News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by mychael on Saturday October 27, 2018 @10:51PM (#18318895)
I don't visit Gab, but I will definitely be closing my Joyent account.

If you're not a courageous and principled defender of free speech, you should get out of the cloud business.

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by krschultz on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:03PM (#18318941)
Gab is in the same category as The Daily Stormer. It's not courageous to hide behind free speech absolutism to protect content that invites others to violence. That's being too weak to engage in making the hard choices of what you will support with your efforts. It's the exact opposite of being principled.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by otriv on Sunday October 28, 2018 @01:59AM (#18319362)
Except that The Daily Stormer is creating their own content while Gab is just hosting others. I'm sure I could find YouTube comments equally as bad as comments on Gab.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by krschultz on Sunday October 28, 2018 @12:19PM (#18321296)
The era of tech washing their hands of being accountable for user generated content on their platform is over. YouTube works quite hard to keep their platform safe. It's still not good enough. But I'm sure they have more people working on that problem than have ever worked on Gab.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by arcseco on Monday October 29, 2018 @12:02PM (#18328581)
Do you think 4chan also be moderated in this way and users purged for using abusive language? And how do I become the moderator of language? I sure would like to be the gate keeper of acceptable speech.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by chasing on Sunday October 28, 2018 @12:35PM (#18321387)
Their original logo was a variation of the stupid pepe frog. They’re not a neutral platform. They were built as a platform for the racist alt-right.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by jakelazaroff on Sunday October 28, 2018 @02:25AM (#18319397)
Gab actively cultivates a neo-Nazi userbase; see https://twitter.com/ClenchedFisk/status/1027690034718224384?...
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by happytoexplain on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:16PM (#18318999)
I think it's unconstructive to command people to get out of a business because the line they draw on how disgusting and hateful content can be before they'll disallow it on their platform is different from the line (or lack thereof) that you'd draw. I also think it's probably purposeful disingenuous to frame that distinction as a righteous free speech decision where anybody who doesn't agree with your interpretation is not courageous.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by drivingmenuts on Sunday October 28, 2018 @12:35AM (#18319199)
Nothing prevents Gab from finding harbor with any company that will have them, but nothing legally compels any company or person to provide that harbor.

This is exactly the same as if I told you to get off my porch.

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by jrs95 on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:22PM (#18319018)
You may as well stop using the internet entirely, there simply isn't anyone in this business that is the type of defender of free speech you're talking about. And if there was, toxic elements would gather there and then they'd most likely have other companies they depend on cut them off somewhere down the line.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by mychael on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:30PM (#18319040)
Just because you can't think of any examples of businesses not cowering to censorship, doesn't mean that there are none.

Twitter has made lots of mistakes, but they've also stood on first principles many of times when it comes to free speech. Cloudflare is another great example.

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by jbarciauskas on Saturday October 27, 2018 @10:56PM (#18318909)
The US standard for what is legally free speech is absurdly low. Why should companies hold themselves to it? Why should they force themselves to support organizations that promote the wholesale elimination of other classes of people?
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by stuart78 on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:01PM (#18318932)
The ‘US Standard’ for free speech is exactly where it should be, and applies to the government’s role in censoring citizen speech. Joyent, as a business has no obligation to support anything outside of their own policies.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by lgierth on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:10PM (#18318972)
I think they were saying, if money is free speech, and racist slurs are free speech, and anti-semitic conspiracy theories are free speech, then the quality standard for something to be free speech is low, and any mildly sympathetic individual or organization would put their own standard for free speech higher.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by jbarciauskas on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:05PM (#18318950)
I think we are mostly in agreement?
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by syshum on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:09PM (#18318964)
The "US Standard" generally means the standard by which the people of the US value the concept of Free Speech, which extends beyond that of the 1st amendment. We the people of the US codified our position on speech in the 1st amendment of our governing document to ensure that our government would never infringe upon our most vital right as free humans.

This however does not in anyway mean we believe others including large corporations should have the right to infringe upon said rights simply because "its a business"

There are many avenues one could seek to hold Joynet and others like them that proclaim to be open to all in their advertisements then reject many they disagree with. First and foremost would be Truth in Advertisement laws, Fraud, and other legal regulations which if they were properly enforced these companies would be clearly violating

No the "US Standard" of Free Speech is not just about government censorship, that is ignorant and naive view of what Free Speech is as a concept. Free Speech is concept where by a person is free to express themselves with out fear of censorship from either government or society at large. Free Speech today is under massive attack not by government in the US (yet) but by society at large.

//Edit for the record. I do not have nor do I plan to sign up for a Gab account (or twitter Gab's competitor) this is not about Gab as a service, I honestly could not care less about Gab it is about the precedent this sets when it comes to cloud and other internet infrastructure

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by drivingmenuts on Sunday October 28, 2018 @12:42AM (#18319216)
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

I suggest you re-read that and point to where it says "society at large". The 1st Amendment is a restriction on the government, not on the people (except maybe the "peaceably" bit).

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by syshum on Sunday October 28, 2018 @05:24AM (#18319835)
The Constitution is a document establishing and limiting government power. It has nothing to do with what I am talking about

Freedom of speech exist beyond and outside of the 1st amendment, that fact that many people believe all free speech issues are limited only to the 1st amendment and government censorship is part of the massive problem we have in society at large

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by mychael on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:06PM (#18318956)
> Why should they force themselves to support organizations that promote the wholesale elimination of other classes of people

Straw man arguments like this really lower the quality of discussion.

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by jbarciauskas on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:10PM (#18318971)
What part is a strawman? That is literally the conversation that takes place on Gab.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by jquery on Friday November 02, 2018 @02:28PM (#18365440)
That conversation also takes place on Twitter and Facebook.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by ubernostrum on Monday October 29, 2018 @08:41PM (#18333036)
Do you believe a baker should have the right to refuse to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, if the baker has a deeply-held religious belief that same-sex relationships are sinful? If the baker turns out to have that legal right, would you argue that baker should nonetheless not exercise that right?

Asking because people in these kinds of threads often seem to get suspiciously selective about when and why they decide to argue for stripping the right of free association -- and disassociation -- from others.

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by cjhopman on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:33PM (#18319052)
Usually when people make these statements, they don't actually mean it.

If Gab were strictly a child porn site, would it be okay if Joyent stopped serving them? If yes, then your absolutist statement isn't actually what you mean and it's just a question of where to draw the line. If not (which has yet to have been the case when someone initially stated such a trivial statement), then I disagree with you and maybe there's some interesting discussion to be had.

Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by drivingmenuts on Sunday October 28, 2018 @12:54AM (#18319246)
I would argue that restrictions on child pornography are more about consent and intent and the idea that anyone under the age of majority is not considered capable of giving consent to a sexual act.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by lgleason on Sunday October 28, 2018 @02:55AM (#18319458)
Making racist statements is not against the law in the US. Child porn is. As such they would have a legal obligation to cut them off if they were hosting child porn.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by cjhopman on Thursday November 01, 2018 @05:21AM (#18352303)
Oh please. Smoking marijuana is illegal in every part of the US but every so-called "defender of free speech" that I've met would be totally up in arms about a host shutting down a site for being involved in that.
Re:Gab.com Booted from Hosting Provider Due to User Account by pvg on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:10PM (#18318973)
Being in the cloud business does not have to include being in the cloud business with Nazis.