News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:36AM (#18291841)
Apple sells a walled garden that controls what software you can use, forces upgrades by forbidding repairs and slowing down old phones with software updates, and sells more dongles by eliminating features and changing ports in every generation of their products.

I admit they are better than Google on the privacy issue, but should we be grateful for having an alternative that abuses us in different ways?

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by robocat on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:43AM (#18291884)
Each of your complaints is because of a well-designed compromise (app quality/safety; preventing abrupt phone shutdown; removing a common failure point). You may disagree with the compromises, sure.

PS: I own zero Apple devices (partly because of the reasons you have, not for the way you are misrepresenting those reasons).

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:46AM (#18291907)
Apple's App Store policies are about far more than app quality or safety. Apple has banned many apps for political or financial reasons.

Slowing down old phones without notice or permission wasn't the best response to aging batteries. Even Apple didn't deny it was wrong. They apologized, once they were caught.

And the MagSafe connector was not a common failure point.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by robocat on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:31AM (#18292206)
My problem with your first comment is that you misrepresent the issues. Your second reply is worse because you introduce other different issues, without addressing the point (that Apple chooses compromises that you might disagree with).

> Slowing down old phones without notice or permission wasn't the best response to aging batteries.

Sure, it wasn't handled well, but you said that they did it to force upgrades... That is patently incorrect in my opinion. Apple are far superior at keeping old devices updated than most actors in the Android world (as a comparison point).

> And the MagSafe connector was not a common failure point.

And your original post complained that "and sells more dongles by eliminating features and changing ports". What does replacing a proprietary magsafe connector with USB C have to do with Apple selling more dongles? There are now plenty of compatible third party options available in more than one category.

Regards app store policies: see sibling reply.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:46AM (#18292352)
My second post addressed your claim that these issues are "well-designed compromises" by disproving it with counterexamples.

MagSafe was at once an example of a port changed (MagSafe 1 to 2) and a feature removed (replaced with USB) that didn't fit your explanation "removing a common failure point". Even Apple didn't try to claim that slowing down old phones was a well-designed compromise; instead, they apologized. And there are many examples of Apple removing apps for reasons other than "app quality/safety", for one such example, see my response to sibling reply.

These are not "other different issues", these are counterexamples. They may not be the issues you thought of when you read my first post but they were some of the issues I was thinking of.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by harywilke on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:49AM (#18293444)
"About a year ago in iOS 10.2.1, we delivered a software update that improves power management during peak workloads to avoid unexpected shutdowns on iPhone 6, iPhone 6 Plus, iPhone 6s, iPhone 6s Plus, and iPhone SE. With the update, iOS dynamically manages the maximum performance of some system components when needed to prevent a shutdown. While these changes may go unnoticed, in some cases users may experience longer launch times for apps and other reductions in performance." https://www.apple.com/iphone-battery-and-performance/

Unexpected shutdowns vs. longer app launch times and other reductions in performance. a compromise.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by FireBeyond on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:06PM (#18296886)
That's a ... highly rose-colored ... definition of what the issue was.

And if it was such a good, but misunderstood feature, why wasn't it touted as such in the first place, but denied initially, and then only acknowledged apologetically with the removal of such?

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:36PM (#18294590)
Quote the whole phrase: a "well-designed compromise". What's well-designed about secret behavior that angers users?

But it's hard to trust that statement anyway. I'd be more likely to trust them if they'd reported that on their own, instead of hiding it for a year then issuing a PR statement when users proved it was happening.

And if that statement wasn't contradicted by their behavior in shutting down phones after the screen was replaced.

"First and foremost, we have never — and would never — do anything to intentionally shorten the life of any Apple product, or degrade the user experience to drive customer upgrades."

...

They forgot to mention the "unless the user tries to repair it" exception.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by mcintyre1994 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:17AM (#18292100)
> Apple bans competing apps regardless of app quality or safety.

I don't know what criteria they actually use, but this is at best incredibly inconsistent. There's heaps of competing mail apps, calendars, camera apps, photo apps, weather apps, notes apps, reminders app, messaging apps on iOS, including a Google one in most of those categories.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:41AM (#18292299)
I know that once upon a time they banned competing apps, including Google Voice. I don't know if that behavior continues but I think it's a bit too soon to forget.

https://techcrunch.com/2009/07/27/apple-is-growing-rotten-to...

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by danaris on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:00AM (#18292983)
This is from nine years ago, when the iOS App Store (then just the iPhone App Store, as the iPad didn't even exist yet!) was less than 2 years old.

Calling that "a bit too soon to forget" seems...problematic on several levels.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:52PM (#18294721)
Why? They continue to use their control of the app store for financial gain. The clock on forgiveness doesn't start until the abuse stops.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by danaris on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:40PM (#18295669)
When you're replying to a comment pointing out that there are, in fact, lots of competing apps, and your comment claiming that they're still evil points to an article from nine years ago, you don't demonstrate much credibility to your claims.

I think your clocks are just broken.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:47PM (#18295726)
I didn't say Apple bans all competing apps. They're selectively "evil". And they've faced so much outrage about the app store, and still do (for example, there's a Supreme Court case pending and a recent lawsuit from Spotify) that they are slightly restrained at the moment.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by drivingmenuts on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:57AM (#18291969)
Personally, I think the MagSafe connector was bloody brilliant and I'm not giving up my mid-2015 MBP until it absolutely won't function any more, because of that feature (it's saved my MBP several times when I was a bit clumsy or forgetful).

Another reason: the multiplicity of ports and bunches of things that all use USB-A.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by reaperducer on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:17PM (#18297857)
I believe there's a product, or at least a Kickstarter, to add a MagSafe-style dongle to a USB-C port.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by raarts on Thursday October 25, 2018 @02:34AM (#18298938)
I tried several MagSafe-like USB-C cables and found them lacking reliability, ending up having to re-seat the connectors multiple times to get them to connect properly. Don't think USB-C and MagSafe are a good marriage.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by jamamp on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:50PM (#18296754)
The reason Apple moved to the USB-C charging on the MacBook is because it no longer served the purpose it was originally for. Older MacBooks and MacBook pros were a bit bulky and heavy. Tripping on a MagSafe charger cord connected to one of these would disconnect because the friction of the laptop on its its surface was stronger than that of the magnetic pull of the MagSafe connector.

With the new Macook, however, I believe it was much lighter to the point that it would have pulled the laptop down with it upon someone tripping on the cord. It wasn't doing anything to benefit the user at that point. Because of this, they probably opted for a slimmer charging port (USB-C), and it went well with the growing use of USB-C in the industry.

I do wish they included more USB-C ports, however.

I do not know exactly the reason they opted for USB-C in the new MacBook Pro, however. I believe it would still be heavy enough for MagSafe to be effective. However at this point, USB-C is saturating the market and consolidation in their products may be a more important issue for Apple at this point.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by briandear on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:36AM (#18293303)
They didn’t apologize for doing it; they apologized for not explaining it.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by leereeves on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:30PM (#18295087)
Keeping it secret was part of the design. Who knows what other hidden "compromises" are waiting to be discovered?
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by maxxxxx on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:14AM (#18293115)
" Each of your complaints is because of a well-designed compromise (app quality/safety; preventing abrupt phone shutdown; removing a common failure point). You may disagree with the compromises, sure."

You should add "making more money" to the factors that went into this "well designed" approach. For example I don't see how not adding a MicroSD slot is nothing other than a method of forcing people into buying phones with larger internal storage (and making more money for Apple).

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by bitcurious on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:15PM (#18294930)
A microSD slot would have slower read/write access, would take up much more room per GB, and would compromise waterproofing.

Your point about money would be better made if you just complained about the cost of larger internal storage, except then it would be obvious - Apple is profit motivated.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by robocat on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:22PM (#18294999)
Supporting MicroSD is most definitely a compromise. 1. I've lost photos on an Android because I used one (I bought the most reliable brand of card I could, from my most trusted store, with quite a low capacity). 2. Also the UX is crap - I know the Android universe well, and managing the options, the files, and the apps is not something I would recommend to my mum. 3. Finally any hardware interface is a point of failure (e.g. recently I had to reseat a SIM in my friend's iPhone that couldn't connect to it).

I can see your argument re profit in the past, but it is becoming less valid as the minimum flash memory size is increasing. I have just bought an ZTE with 32GB because that is all I need (32GB is the minimum you can get in a new iPhone.)

All these arguments that Apple is trying to "nickel and dime" their users is just tiring. Sure, they charge a lot, and they love profits, but that doesn't mean they are shitting on their users (like say cellular network providers do!) Edit: ironically it is probably because they charge so much for the device and it is so profitable that they don't need to chase every cent they could e.g. they don't provide payday loans to buy their phones!

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by strictnein on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:40AM (#18292789)
Apple was never a player in the ad market, so which of these "well-designed compromises" went against their bottom line?
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by Mononokay on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:47AM (#18292861)
Worth noting that they do have an ad platform, actually, and that all apps on the App Store are mandated to use it if wanting to monetize.
Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by eric_h on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:02PM (#18294243)
> they do have an ad platform, actually, and that all apps on the App Store are mandated to use it if wanting to monetize.

What? This is not true at all. Source: I released an iOS app that used a non-apple third party to serve ads.

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by kapad on Thursday October 25, 2018 @07:34PM (#18305555)
Then use open source. if there's a hardware manufacturer that you trust, then that's all you need. you can install a version of android i.e. open source and without play services (eg. LineageOS) and then download apps from a store like f-droid. (all these apps as well as the f-droid app are all open source).

Your functionality though, will be severely compromised. So the choices are:

1. Apple - hurts your wallet and your choice of apps (only the walled garden and nothing else). 2. Google - you're the product. not the phone. 3. Something else like the open source solution. You'll spend a lot of time here and will be restricted to the limited choice of apps on the the f-droid store.

So take your pic. I'm mostly in #2, with a billion or so others. I'm fully aware that me and my data are the product here, and whenever I start feeling that I made a deal with the devil, I simply tell myself that they can't know what's happening in my head. I then quickly shift focus and start thinking about something else. :P

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by bootlooped on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:56AM (#18292944)
Being in a walled garden is not a concern of most users, and it often works to their benefit. If dear old grandma can barely tell the difference between the internet browser and Facebook, I don't think I care if she doesn't have root access to her phone.

To roughly quote another HN user who I don't recall, "Not everybody wants to sysadmin their phone".

Re:Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial ... by kayaknutrient on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:39AM (#18292772)
Yes. There are different degrees of bad. I'll take the hardware walled garden and data protection over the other bads.