News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by hliyan on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:24AM (#18291405)
> electrical signals weaken more as they flow along human dendrites, resulting in a higher degree of electrical compartmentalization, meaning that small sections of dendrites can behave independently from the rest of the neuron

Reading this, I just realized that all this time I was using the wrong computing analogy to understand the brain: neurons are not the transistors of the brain, dendrites are!

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by protonfish on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:57PM (#18294190)
Dendrites are just a specific part of a neuron (1), so you are no more correct.

More importantly, neurons are nothing like transistors. Each neuron contains significant computing power. For example, in the retina of a frog there is a neuron that accepts as inputs dendrites from an area of light-sensitive cells (rods and cones) and only fires when a small, round, moving object is in the field of view. These neurons are colloquially called "bug perceivers." (2)

1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuron

2 "What the Frog's Eye Tells the Frog's Brain" (1959)

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by teekert on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:38AM (#18291491)
To be honest, using a transistors analogy may keep you on the wrong path for a long time as well :) There is not a lot of "digital" going on in those cells...
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:40AM (#18291503)
Wait - transistors are not digital they're analog. And neurons are terribly digital, acting as rate controllers and pulse counters and dividers and so on.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by robotrout on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:47PM (#18294076)
Any digital analogy fails, since the biological signals attenuate with distance from source. A digital gate acts as a repeater, re-boosting the signal strength to original level. That is not the case with neurons/dendrites.

Perhaps a better model would be for each neuron to be modeled as a current source instead of a voltage source. The more parallel paths that current is funneled into, the smaller it gets, until it is below the threshold of detection. You can have your transistor model allowing/blocking that current, but never boosting it back up.

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by ItsMe000001 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:53PM (#18295276)
> the biological signals attenuate with distance from source

The voltage signal is propagated in axons sometimes over very long distances (a meter, e.g. from the foot to the spine). It is renewed (see "Nodes of Ranvier") along the path for as long as needed, at distances that depend on how, or if, the axon is myelinated. That's why the speed is so slow (ca. 120 m/s max., often much slower) - it's actual ion movement through lots and lots of opening and closing voltage triggered channels all along the axons, compared to a purely electrical signal like in a metal wire. This means while in a wire the electrical field is from start to end, leading to electrons exiting on the far end pretty much instantaneously, in an axon am electrical field is only local, and only strong enough to trigger anything for about 1-2 millimeters at best. Then there have to be a new set of channels triggered by the electrical field further up the axon that renew the signal by letting in ions.

Attenuation is more important in dendrites and neuron bodies, spatial distance of simultaneously incoming action potentials (via connected axons from other neurons) plays a role in determining whether a threshold is reached that would trigger firing an action potential from this neuron. Since a dendritic arbor can be quite extensive and have lots of branches location - where exactly along the branches does an incoming signal attach - matters a lot.

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by hliyan on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:44AM (#18291527)
True. However, logic gates constructed from transistors are digital. I'm wondering what the corresponding higher level neuronal structure would be...
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:45AM (#18291530)
Neurons are already logic gates. And FFT devices, and discriminators and ...
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:21AM (#18292128)
So basically neurons are ASICs, partially digital and partially analog.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by JackFr on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:18PM (#18293787)
They're basically cogs, rods and gears.

Seriously, molecular biologists devote decades of study and publish volumes figuring out how some small virus 'works'. A human neuron is orders of magnitude more complex than such a virus. To dismiss it as 'like an _____', is a (sometimes necessary) analogy of very little explanatory depth.

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:34PM (#18295624)
I'm not dismissing things. In fact, 'JoeAltmaier is correct that my analogy here was in context of the usual "neuron as signal adder" / "neuron as transistor".

And yes, I'm aware neurons are complex. But that does not mean all of that complexity is relevant to the task of thinking; all living cells have machinery related to self-replication, self-maintenance and survival in a biological system.

Or to use another analogy - a smartphone is orders of magnitude more complicated than a flashlight. Yet in context of people illuminating their way during the night, a smartphone is just a flashlight.

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:26PM (#18293854)
Metaphors help understanding. A neuron is more on the order of an entire logic subsystem, than a transistor or a gate. That's a reasonable comparison-of-complexity statement.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by davisr on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:45AM (#18291897)
Memistor/Memristor
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by Balgair on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:14PM (#18295472)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor

Many synapses behave very much like memristors, though caveats apply.

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by achileas on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:24AM (#18292644)
That's oversimplified and usually how it's taught at the undergrad level. Neurons and especially the networks they form are more analogous to analog electronics, but both analogies end up failing at some point.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by reubenswartz on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:40PM (#18295670)
IAMNANS (I am not a neuroscientist) but my very simple understanding is that to a reasonable approximation, inputs are analog (there’s a lot of nuance in if and how much signal makes it into a neuron) and outputs are digital (neuron fires or doesn’t), leading to all kinds of interesting circuitry.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by protonfish on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:02PM (#18294245)
From what I know, neurons typically click on or off, so they are digital in that way. Signal strength is implied by the frequency of those clicks, so that's analog. Transistors are analog electronics, but used to make digital switches so it's sort of the reverse.

I guess my point is that calling neurons analog or digital is not a very good analogy and should probably be avoided.

Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by nickpsecurity on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:22PM (#18294436)
It's a mixed-signal, general-purpose ASIC done in wetware. Combines both digital and analog traits. Some of most interesting research I saw in hardware CompSci does the same. Never goes mainstream since industry prefers things that are easy to automate and scale up for obvious reasons.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by kazinator on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:28PM (#18297666)
Transistors also shut on and off fully in, say, a switched mode power supply, or a class D amplifier, or any other pulse-width-modulation-like scenario. That is all considered analog.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by ItsMe000001 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:46PM (#18295209)
But whether or not the incoming signals ever lead to a new action potential depends on so many factors (spacial, temporal, chemical, biological,... and it's all dynamic on many levels) that can all be called "analog" and are quite diverse that it's hard to call anything "digital". One action potential, that thing that brings to mind the "digital" analogy, really is a very small part in that system.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by stephengillie on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:06PM (#18296879)
The brain is analogous to an analog analogue of digital computing?
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by buboard on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:57AM (#18291612)
It is and it isn't. There is a two-layer model of neuron that captures some properties like firing rates of hippocampal neurons, but there are also alternate models. E.g: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5267aed6e4b03cb52f5e0...
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by hliyan on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:53AM (#18291943)
Thanks for this! I'm not in the neuroscience field, but the title itself tells me that I've a misconception that needs correcting.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by michrassena on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:10AM (#18292543)
Does this imply that the neuron is more of a power supply, and the properties of sections of dendrites (not the whole dendrite) and their connections is what does the actual computation? If so, that adds a layer of messy complexity which is fairly typical in living things.
Re:Electrical properties of dendrites help explain our brain... by achileas on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:26AM (#18292662)
Both. Because neuroscience is hilariously complex and a big "fuck you" to neuroscientists.

Computation happens at many levels - among dendrites, among axons (some neurons have multiple axons as well!), axonal branches, within the neuron, and also among various networks that arise (behavioral and structural networks). It's all a bit much, if you ask me.