News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by rayvy on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @04:59PM (#18287429)
As someone who works monitoring ad network traffic at a large ad-tech company (not FAANG, but just below), let me just say: everyone does fraud.

Some don't need as much of it (e.g., Google), but quite literally saying "there's fraud in my online traffic" is like saying "there's tomato sauce in my spaghetti". It's quite literally such a normal thing that I've become immune to even getting roused by it (and remember, again, I work to find ad-fraud daily).

Does this make it right? No, absolutely not. But is this ever going to change, absolutely not. Too many people are making too much money from this. Just you try to tell an L2 that they can't hit their Q4 Revenue OKR because "we're doing something really immoral by allowing fraud".

Don't make me laugh XD

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by milesskorpen on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @05:57PM (#18287878)
Beyond this, ad spend ASSUMES some level of fraud. It's baked into your ROI numbers, at least for performance advertising.

Probably the main people getting stiffed are the publishers who are offering real traffic, and getting a smaller share of dollars relative to the incremental value they deliver.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by cf498 on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @07:13PM (#18288322)
Can you point me towards credible work determining ROI for online advertisement? Whats the current state of the art?

edit: I should rephrase, this sounds hostile. I know there is wide work in influencing people to buy stuff when influenced in person. The interpersonal dynamics are widely studied. I also know, that chumming content and goating works to gather more views, but that can only be turned into a ROI by people paying for ads to serve those viewers. There is also the segment of ads, which offer a discount, but what about all the rest? Does banner or clip advertisement actually provide a measurable return of investment? Does online advertisement offer brand recognition, and does it provide a ROI? Are the adverse effects studied, so that people actively despise brands for offensive ads? What are the going rates for views and reactions to online advertisement vs traditional marketing?

In short, what is the state of the art of research into online advertisement?

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by downandout on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:05PM (#18289120)
There are two distinct areas of online advertising: performance marketing, and brand advertising. I'm a performance marketer. I make a profit only when ads result in conversions - usually sales or signups for trial offers, but in some cases we do lead generation campaigns for clients as well. We spend high 5/low 6 figures per month, mostly on Facebook ads, with a monthly ROAS (return on ad spend) that beats Berkshire Hathaway's annual returns. The idea that online advertising cannot work is absurd.

The schemes mentioned in articles like this are almost exclusively targeted at brand marketers. My guess is the problem lies in the way that large brands incentivize the people running their campaigns, because the technology exists to knock out the vast majority of this type of fraud. Companies like Coke hire ad firms that send them reports about impressions, and they are thus incentivized to not pay attention to traffic quality, and just maximize impressions. That has to be the problem, because just my internal traffic quality tools that I have written would have shutdown ad delivery on the sites sending such obviously bad traffic within a few clicks from each referrer - and I don't claim to have written the most sophisticated filter out there. There are many ways to do reality checks on traffic, on a per-referrer basis, and cut out much of this stuff. Webview traffic (the kind being taken advantage of here) is among the easiest to detect.

As to your question about measuring ROAS it's simple for performance marketers. Take your ad spend and compare it to revenue. I'm not sure that brand marketers have a reasonable way of determining ROAS, either online or in the physical world. I suppose they could take brand recognition surveys and compare before/after a given campaign, but that is hardly an exact science.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by DeGi on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:21AM (#18290119)
And without doing experimental setup (RCTs), how do you know you are not just paying for organic conversions?

I had this presentation a few months ago: https://www.slideshare.net/mobile/gregak/if-youre-not-measur... I would be interested to know what you think.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by downandout on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @04:11AM (#18290523)
Very interesting presentation. The question your research is attempting to answer is certainly a valid one for major sites, where people might be on the site anyway without having clicked on a given ad. In my specific case, most of the sites/offers we market through Facebook ads wouldn't have attracted many organic visitors, let alone conversions, on their own, so it's not a question I need to answer. These sites rely almost entirely on paid traffic, and if they don't get it they are out of business.

The importance of being able to figure out what actually led to conversions is not lost on me though. One unique technology I created allows us to do something that I have never seen anyone else in the online marketing world do: track conversions back to the initial click and ad campaign, even if someone just texts, emails, or uses an instant messenger to send the URL to a friend. So let's say someone visits the site, sees that the offer isn't for them but texts it to a friend. A month later, that friend finally gets around to looking at it, but decides it isn't for them either but knows someone else who might be interested, and they email it to someone else, who ultimately converts. We can track that conversion and all the steps in between back to the initial click and attribute it to the initial ad campaign, which gives us a much better sense of what each ad campaign is actually producing. The technology also lets us create custom Facebook audiences of anyone that has shared a link from the site - regardless of how they shared - text, email, Facebook - doesn't matter. We can then customize campaigns to encourage those people to share again.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by DeGi on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:51PM (#18297767)
If close to 0 of your traffic is organic, then you don’t have to care too much about the whole correlation vs. causality problem, yes.

What you describe is certainly interesting. I guess you are building a graph of unique IDs, with each shared URL containing the ID of the parent as a query param or something like that?

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by downandout on Thursday October 25, 2018 @04:22AM (#18299355)
Something like that, yes. When you visit any URL on the site, we use javascript to rewrite the URL in the location bar with a shortened, unique, trackable URL. So we know both what URL you came in through, and the new URL that we then assigned to you. With this we can track every click all the way back up through the tree to the initial click, even if you just copy/paste the URL or hit the button on your phone to text the page to a given contact. Where possible, we also track any link preview engines that visit the URL, so we can usually tell not just that you shared, but how you shared (skype, telegram, iMessage, gmail, facebook, twitter, etc.).

I initially wrote this system so that I could retarget through Facebook ads people that had previously shared viral news articles, but now we have found great applications for it in ecommerce and lead gen as well.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by DeGi on Thursday October 25, 2018 @04:34PM (#18304355)
You wouldn’t know who shared until someone doesn’t actually visit the shared link, right? Unless I’m misunderstanding something. Also I don’t see how you would build a custom audience on FB for the people who shared, e.g. by copy-pasting the URL from the location bar. I see how you would do it on some javascript event (e.g. page load, click on share button, etc.), but that’s not the same.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by downandout on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:05AM (#18306713)
Correct, we don't know who shared until someone visits the link. But, we can build a custom audience after the fact because the Facebook retargeting pixel lets you pass an arbitrary ID of your choosing with each pixel load (the variable name is "extern_id" [1]). So when a click comes in on a given URL that we know had to have been shared, we know what extern_id we gave to Facebook for the original user that shared the link on the pixel fire back when they first visited the site. We can then build a custom audience using a list of those extern_id's for only people that have shared, after the fact.

https://developers.facebook.com/docs/marketing-api/audiences... - see "External Identifiers"

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by cf498 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:27PM (#18297366)
Thank you very much for you answer
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by milesskorpen on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:15AM (#18289692)
https://www.statista.com/statistics/225474/booking-holdings-...

Booking Holdings, for example, spent $4.1 billion dollars in 2017 on performance advertising. This would generally mean they had an ROI target (e.g., each dollar of spend should return $1.2 in revenue). The method of measuring this would generally come from an agreement between the marketing team and the finance team — it might require some assumptions on things like LTV or the value of certain actions, but the finance team would be major participants in determining this value.

There's no way Booking or similar massive advertisers are spending billions of dollars without a very very clear POV on the return they're receiving.

I think a lot of the "state of the art" that you're asking for won't be shared with the public by these companies.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:39AM (#18289766)
As pointed out elsewhere in this thread, however, there is a big difference between performance marketing, where it's relatively easy to track conversion, vs brand marketing.

In fact, a huge reason Booking is so successful is because their sites convert at a higher rate than their competitors (which they themselves attribute to an early and maniacal focus on A/B testing), and thus they are able to bid more for travel-related search terms on Google as each click is worth more to them. It's pretty easy for them to track what percentage of Google AdWords click-throughs result in a completed booking.

Brand advertising, though, has much fuzzier metrics, and the incentives for brand advertisers is to show that they have a larger impact than they actually do.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by simtam on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:15PM (#18289167)
Shall I point you towards some keywords: ghost ads, conversion lift, brand lift studies.

But what does it have to do with the ad fraud?

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by cf498 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:07PM (#18297567)
I dont think its surprising, that people are involved in scams when it comes to advertisement.

We know possible targets try to scam the system, this article shows so. We know, that certain parts of advertisements are trying to sell stuff to people they dont need. As naive as it sounds, most advertisement isnt there to inform us of stuff we dont know of and would want to buy if we knew. And if you pay people to make other people act against their own interests, it is not unreasonable, that they would do the same to the people hiring them. And not just the same, but alot more. I think its only reasonable to assume, that professional scammers would not just try to scam the people, they are payed to scam, but also the people who pay them in the first place, who offer a much larger payout.

Why wouldnt advertising agencies not put alot more effort in convincing potential customers of their own, that they need their advertisement, then trying to influence the potential customers of their customers on the abstract level of brand awareness.

If brand awareness is not a matter of ROI but bullshit and just a matter of triggering interpersonal marketing mechanisms. "Your competition is spending this amount on" brand awareness and all the other true and tested mechanisms. Marketing your advertisement services to companies for brand awareness sounds like just another sales gig. And one where the methods are true and tested. Be it selling used cars or selling you your appearal as your image or selling the concept of creating a brand throguh digital ads.

Lobbying works for a reason in politics. My question was, if there is a reason to not assume the same for online banner marketing for brand awareness.

Thank you for your keywords, i will look them up.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by cwkoss on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @08:39PM (#18288742)
Also interested. I suspect the lack of noise is a result of lack of impressive results.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by rayvy on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @07:41PM (#18288467)
> Probably the main people getting stiffed are the publishers who are offering real traffic

Unless you're a large premium publisher like say a NYT, a Techcrunch, or even a Forbes, more of your traffic probably wont be real, and you have little to no control over that. The online ad/traffic buying game is so mind-blowingly convoluted, you can be a small publisher (foo.com), having your site spammed, and what little revenue you've made via your supply completely wiped out (i.e., clawed back by your upstream partner - even large publishers don't operate by themselves), and your reputation takes a hit.

The main people getting stiffed are the web users, and the advertisers. But it doesn't seem like either of them care enough about it to do something that can have a lasting effect

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by milesskorpen on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:17AM (#18289699)
I guess I don't think the advertisers are getting stiffed — yes, they pay a CPM for 1000 impressions where some meaningful percentage are fake, but that should be baked into their models. The effective CPM for whatever the real number of impressions is is still ROI positive.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by Twisell on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:53AM (#18290451)
I would love to hear John Gruber opinion about that. His advertised funding model is sponsorship without agressive ad and without passive tracking. https://daringfireball.net

So yes I totally think that current bonus for add fraudster is not helping a "new John Gruber" to emerge.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by Tsubasachan on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:28PM (#18295055)
Marketing budgets are payed for by consumers. The money for ads doesn't magically appear.

Its why I don't feel bad using ad blockers: I subsidise your shitty commercials anyway.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by ASalazarMX on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:34AM (#18293289)
This month we got two unrelated emails (one from Bangladesh, the other from Turkey) with the same scam: "We have hacked your email account, we're emailing you from it, your password is xyz deposit $800 USD in bitcoin or else".

These guys just send a bunch of emails using known leaked accounts, and a few of these people are going to be scared because they reuse the same password. Since they ask for bitcoin, anyone can see the transactions of their wallets: roughly $6-12,000 USD each attempt.

The risk-reward ratio is ridiculously low, I guess that's the same with ad fraud. Companies would fight a company-sized rat, but not thousands of rat-sized companies.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by da02 on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @05:13PM (#18287539)
What kind of fraud does Google do?
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by janesvilleseo on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @05:47PM (#18287814)
It’s not that they do it. It’s that they allow it. Not outright, but they don’t go out of their way to suppress/stop it anymore more than anybody else.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by Donzo on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:42AM (#18289773)
I'm a small to medium sized publisher and I've had to travel through Google's compliance funnels more than I would have liked.

I've never had any compliance issues with any other advertising network.

Google works hard to keep the ecosystem healthy because it's good for their long-term interests. But of course, their systems are not perfect.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by doodliego on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:23AM (#18289918)
If you're removing 700,000 apps a year from your store for violating your own policies, it's fair to say your system is not only not perfect, it's horribly broken.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by ariwilson on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:41AM (#18289982)
Completely disagree. Could also mean they're doing a great job finding problematic apps.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by doodliego on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:48PM (#18298259)
They have "only" 2.6 million apps (as of March 2018):

https://www.statista.com/statistics/266210/number-of-availab...

37% fraud-rules breaking rate is pathetic. Maybe they should spend time vetting these things before allowing malware-infested spyware out into the "ecosystem."

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by chillfox on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:05PM (#18297557)
Another way to look at it is their submission process fails to catch problematic apps. Making it necessary to pull them from the store after they have been published.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by canadapups on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @05:55PM (#18287870)
When it comes to email spam or fake email accounts, Google not only allows it, they enable it. One scammer can setup thousands of gmail accounts and google doesn't blink an eye. Gmail also allows "[email protected]" and "scammer+2@gmail" to be the same account. I've reported obvious gmail abuse to Google through their channels, but nothing. Same scammer keeps coming back with new email accounts.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by chipperyman573 on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @06:51PM (#18288197)
>Gmail also allows "[email protected]" and "scammer+2@gmail" to be the same account.

This is a well-documented feature that has many legitimate uses. If you're trying to stop fraud, clip any gmail addresses after the +. For example, I believe Facebook does this.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by canadapups on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @08:55PM (#18288814)
I do clip it. I have to do many other things too (spending time and money) to counteract scammers usage of google's services. Given google's ability to track people, they'd could do more against fraud, instead of letting scammers use their services freely (hence my comment of them enabling scammers).
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by lucasmullens on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @06:49PM (#18288188)
Can't spam detection check if it's the same email with a +1? Seems pretty straightforward.

There's no scarcity in available email addresses. If your security depends on people not being able to register new emails, you've already lost.

Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by jlarocco on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:13PM (#18289157)
Tagging email with + has been a feature of email forever, and has nothing to do with Google. Their service would be broken if they didn't support it.
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by Eridrus on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @11:30PM (#18289492)
So, you've basically outsourced your spam detection to Google, and you're here complaining that you have to do a few small things on your end?
Re:How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to... by canadapups on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:44AM (#18289784)
No, my point is Google allows and/or enables fraud and they could be doing more to fight it. Source: the article we are discussing, "How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to Steal Millions". And my experience with scammers using Gmail.