News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by vasco on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:09PM (#18231103)
You don't own the term open source mate.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by FooBarWidget on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:11PM (#18231124)
Your opinion isn't the only one out there. I recognize the OSI as the authority on the term open source.

On a more practical level: who do you consider be the authority? If the answer is 'nobody' (except yourself) then that makes the term essentially meaningless because there is no standardization, which means that one should stop using that term.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sangnoir on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:15PM (#18231153)
MongoDB recognizes OSI as an authority as well, which is why they submitted their license to OSI for approval. Which led us to this moment, where OSI has not (/yet) granted that approval, and that apparently raised gp's hackles for some reason.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by twblalock on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:09PM (#18231667)
MongoDB recognizes that OSI approval is a nice thing to have as a selling point. I very much doubt that they accept the OSI as an authority that can make binding rules and regulations about who gets to call their software "open source".
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by tyingq on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:17PM (#18231179)
OSI seems to recognize they don't own the term. https://opensource.org/pressreleases/certified-open-source.p...
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by gwbas1c on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:41PM (#18232517)
Strongly disagree. "Open Source" is not a trademark, no one entity can claim ownership over what defines open source.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by module0000 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:15PM (#18231733)
>> who do you consider be the authority?

That would be Richard Matthew Stallman, the proverbial OG in this entire field.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sangnoir on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:31PM (#18231911)
You will find that RMS detests "Open Source"[1]. He's more of a Free software guy, the distinction on user's freedom is important.

1.https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by AsyncAwait on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:48PM (#18232062)
I think OP meant in the spiritual sense, free software is the original "open-source". A better one, I'd argue, but that's a different discussion.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sangnoir on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:56PM (#18232131)
I was addressing OP's suggestion that RMS is the authority on "Open Source" (which was the question further up the thread). He'd rather have you use/contribute (to) Free software instead.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by AsyncAwait on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:05PM (#18232193)
Yes, I understood that, I assume the OP meant that he is an authority on "open-source" in that "free software" was the original "open-source" and thus "open-source" has RMS a lot to thank for. Otherwise I agree.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:09PM (#18232231)
It might be the original "open source" but it ISN'T open source, per the definition. Open Source was coined for software LONG AFTER the FSF had declared what free software meant.

Going back and saying "Well, RMS might have MEANT open source, so it's actually the original open source" is very subjective and not historically accurate.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by AsyncAwait on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:22PM (#18232363)
> Open Source was coined for software LONG AFTER the FSF had declared what free software meant

I know, you COMPLETELY misunderstood my comment.

> Going back and saying "Well, RMS might have MEANT open source, so it's actually the original open source"

I don't think he meant open-source and I am not saying he did, as free software defines greater freedoms. I am not a big fan of open-source myself, much prefer free software.

What I am actually trying to say, is that "free-software" was the original way to share code and work on it collaboratively for the commons, ie the thing open-source got inspired by.

What I am saying, is that in certain sense, you could say that Ken Thompson has a grandfatherly hand in Linux, despite him technically not. It's a spiritual hand, if you will.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:07PM (#18232213)
RMS has an ideal: All software should be free and open.

This doesn't work for businesses that need to profit from what they do. Keeping things proprietary, while benefiting from source-available software is impossible if a company has to release their source. Competition goes out the window.

So while RMS has a nice ideal, it doesn't generally apply.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sangnoir on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:32PM (#18232979)
> " Keeping things proprietary, while benefiting from source-available software is impossible"

That's a tragedy of the commons, not something any company is entitled to (BSD-style licenses excepted). Enjoying the benefits of an ecosystem while not contributing to it is not a thing to laud.

> So while RMS has a nice ideal, it doesn't generally apply.

...and here we are, with a MongoDB pulling a bait-and-switch on licensing because they want to have their cake and eat it. You shouldn't expect to only get the kudos (and higher adoption rate) that result from your open-source license and not run the risk of someone (possibly a competitor) forking your code. That is the price of admission into the open-source world.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by icebraining on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:33PM (#18234220)
Sure it does. I've worked in multiple growing for-profit companies that released all their software as (A/L)GPL.

It might not work with certain business models, but that's alright, others would fill their place.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by nailer on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:21PM (#18231803)
ESR and O Reilly are the OGs for OSS, though they certainly owe a debt to RMS
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by gonzo on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @06:52PM (#18233980)
Neither invented the term, they just marketed it, because it directly benefitted them.

Christine Peterson of the Foresight Institute is the "OG" for the term "open source" as applied to software.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by jpambrun on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:21PM (#18231219)
The authority on word definitions is a dictionary, so that we don't have to argue like that.

This definition seems suitable: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/open-source

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by themoonbus on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:41PM (#18231414)
Dictionaries reflect common usage and shared understanding, they're not some infallible source. If the technology community started using the term "open source" in a different way, the dictionary would have to be updated to reflect the new meaning.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by parent5446 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:39PM (#18231406)
Strange, my dictionary has a different definition: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/open-source
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:12PM (#18232258)
The definitions in a dictionary are for general purposes and not used, necessarily, in legal battles. There are legal definitions for things like Intellectual Property, Copyrights, Patents, and Trademarks. These definitions are what will be used when it comes to determining, legally, what open source is - not some wordsmith.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by pdkl95 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @06:21PM (#18233800)
Noah Webster did use a strongly prescriptive approach when he wrote his dictionary. His decision to use alternate or simplified spellings of some words is still seen today as the differences between American English and British English. Linguistic prescription - the idea that there is a single "correct" language and other uses of language are somehow inferior or improper - was used to intentionally to give American English it's own identity.

Fortunately, most modern dictionaries recognize that languages evolve, using a descriptive approach, updating definitions when needed to reflect how words are actually used.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictionary#Prescriptive_vs._de...

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by vasco on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:16PM (#18231165)
So by me saying that the term might be interpreted differently by different people - since it can't be owned by anyone now that it's in wide use (and hence implying there's different opinions out there) you assume that I fail to see there's a multitude of different opinions on the matter? That's exactly the point I was making.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sangnoir on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:20PM (#18231207)
Only if you're completely ignoring the context, which is MongoDB asked OSI to approve their license as "Open Source" - OSI isn't in a position to do so immediately, and so in OSI's estimation, MongoDB isn't "Open Source"
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by jfk13 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:38PM (#18231394)
As OSI hasn't yet reviewed the license, perhaps it would have been better for the OSI VP to explain that "MongoDB may not meet the OSI definition of Open Source" than to announce (in CAPITALS, no less) that "MongoDB...IS NOT OPEN SOURCE".
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sangnoir on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:55PM (#18231525)
> "MongoDB may not meet the OSI definition of Open Source"

That's just euphemism for "MongoDB is not (certified) Open source". It either is, or isn't; and presently it isn't, for reasons that were entirely under MongoDB's control.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:14PM (#18232282)
If it doesn't fit the OSD (https://opensource.org/osd) it IS NOT OPEN SOURCE. The license has not been reviewed by the OSI, and there isn't any "Approved until shown otherwise" clause to refer to. So, in the OSI's eyes (and really anyone who knows what open source actually is) it's NOT OPEN SOURCE anymore.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by jfk13 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:42PM (#18232521)
> If it doesn't fit the OSD (https://opensource.org/osd) it IS NOT OPEN SOURCE.

Well, that presupposes that the OSD is the One True Definition of the term "Open Source"; although the OSD is widely accepted and respected, that's a rather bold claim over an English phrase.

> it's NOT OPEN SOURCE anymore

That claim doesn't seem justified at this point. It would be more accurate to say that it is not currently CERTIFIED BY THE OSI as being Open Source -- because the OSI has not yet reviewed the new license. Maybe it will turn out that it is Open Source (as per the OSD), maybe not. Until the license is properly reviewed, we simply don't know.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by Sir_Cmpwn on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:23PM (#18231234)
The only people who interpret the term open source differently from the OSI definition are either wrong or deliberately trying to sow discontent in the open source community.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:15PM (#18232298)
Kudos for recognizing this. We have the OSD: https://opensource.org/osd

THAT is the definition of the term "Open Source" for all intents and purposes. Anyone else's is just a subjective opinion.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by FooBarWidget on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:21PM (#18231214)
No, that is not what I said.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:13PM (#18232268)
Please, just read this:

https://opensource.org/osd

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by mithr on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:08PM (#18232224)
In a funny way, I actually don't think ownership of the term, or even who gets to decide that, is what really matters. Mongo can release their software under a license they term "open source", or "special mongo license", or "license X" -- they're under no obligation to use any commonly-accepted licenses or terms. They are certainly free to call themselves "open source" under any new license, and make their arguments as to why they believe that term applies.

However, what really matters here is whether, if they choose to do that, developers would still be willing to freely contribute to Mongo's code base, and whether companies who use open source software will continue to use their product. Because _that's_ the reason Mongo cares about being "open source". If most developers and organizations recognize the OSI, with their license approval process, as the arbiters of what constitutes an open source license, then that's the reason the OSI's opinion here really counts. Not because they have some divine right to that term, but simply because if they say "after review, we don't consider this project to be open source by our definition of open source", developers and organizations may hesitate to contribute to, or use, this project.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by jesseb on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:18PM (#18231189)
They're referring specifically to The Open Source Definition[1] outlined by the Open Source Initiative.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Open_Source_Definition

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:51PM (#18232099)
The OSI owns the definition, yes. You are incorrect.

See https://opensource.org/osd which is what DEFINES open source. The term has been around for 20 years. Your lack of understanding the history doesn't make you any kind of an expert.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by zzzcpan on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:14PM (#18232278)
> The OSI owns the definition

No, OSI doesn't own the definition and doesn't get to define open source. Some people agree with that definition, some don't. Nobody has to though. You can't really own what other people think, you can only try to agree on some definition during interaction. No need to pretend there is some universal truth that they just don't know about. It's an agreement, not truth.

And OSI might become irrelevant anyway if it doesn't change in light of recently emerged licenses with more restrictions and doesn't certify them in some way. People will just stick to a handful of popular known licenses and call them open source.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:18PM (#18232333)
Yes, they do! They are the ones that put together the OSD (https://opensource.org/osd) which they derived from the DGSL. No one else has defined open source, not even Richard M. Stallman. His definition is for "Free Software", not "Open Source".

So when it comes to who owns the definition, the definitive answer is the OSI. Anything else is just subjective opinions.

You must not work. Because businesses that do REAL BUSINESS and use Open Source are happy that there is the OSD and approved OSI licenses. That way, we can make real, LEGAL decisions. For individual developers, they might have a different idea of what the definition is, but the actual reference to what defines it is at: https://opensource.org/osd

Reading that will clarify what open source is and isn't. Anything else is just "free software" and should hunt down the FSF for licenses and such. RMS has a very different opinion on software that DOES NOT WORK for large corporations.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by jazzyjackson on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @06:46PM (#18233950)
I think what I'm seeing over and over in this thread is people talking past each other because the grandparent shouldn't have assumed we were all working in the same context.

I agree, in the legal context of business decisions, OSI has a very specific claim to the term 'open source' and declaring that mongoDB "IS NOT OPEN SOURCE" is a warning directed towards people making business judgements around legal risk.

To everyone else, we use the term 'open source' because we heard someone else say it, and when we write software we say 'oh it will be open source' without getting into the nitty gritty of what license it will use and whether that's OSI approved.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by zzzcpan on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @08:20AM (#18238231)
> in the legal context of business decisions, OSI has a very specific claim

But it doesn't. In the legal context of business decisions conformance to an OSI definition of "Open Source" means exactly nothing and OSI-certified "Open Source" even less than nothing. It doesn't help you with anything and doesn't protect you from anything.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by zzzcpan on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:34PM (#18232451)
OSD is said subjective opinion, not a universally agreed upon definition.