News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by nhebb on Saturday October 23, 2010 @05:32AM (#1823078)
Studying for an engineering dynamics final, the old "when in doubt, pick C" saying popped into my head, so I decided make a frequency plot of answers for the 4 quizzes we had that term. The prof had B as the correct answer ~50% of the time. At the end of the 2 hour final I had only finished 13 of the 20 problems, so I quickly marked B for the 7 remaining. I got the 2nd highest grade in the class, bumping my grade from a B to an A.

----

My last year of college I was low on funds, so at the beginning of each term I would go to the school library and see if they stocked any of the textbooks. I could usually find 1 or 2. I'd check them out and keep them the whole term, paying only a $5 late fee - vs. the $100 textbook cost. (In case you think this is inethical, based on the past checkout records, nobody ever checked these books out)

----

Hack I wish I'd thought of: A college buddy spent the first day of summer vacation going into all the bars in downtown Portland and getting info about their happy hours. He had every day of the week mapped out and got dinner and a beer for $1/night.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by araneae on Saturday October 23, 2010 @09:47AM (#1823463)
What kind of college did you go to? In the two I went to, the late fees were something like several dollars a day, and you couldn't graduate unless it was paid off. (At best you could negotiate to pay the retail cost of the book.)

Additionally, both colleges would put any textbook that was for a class on "reserve" so you could only have access to it for several hours at a time, and students DEFINITELY used it. I don't believe that no other student in the class wanted your textbook.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by ctdonath on Saturday October 23, 2010 @09:39AM (#1823453)
My chemistry prof would tell of a student who needed to get just one question right on the multiple-choice final to pass the course. He walked in, picked 'C' for all questions, and walked out.

No correct answers were 'C'.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by gjm11 on Saturday October 23, 2010 @10:22AM (#1823522)
And this, boys and girls, is why we have randomized algorithms.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by Eliezer on Saturday October 23, 2010 @01:02PM (#1823875)
Are you under the impression that a random key fits a random lock?
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by gjm11 on Saturday October 23, 2010 @03:15PM (#1824158)
No, of course not.

I am, however, under the impression that if what you want to do (as here) is to minimize the probability that you get completely shafted by having had the test-setter choose answers complementary to yours, you should choose yours in a way that makes that probability low. Random choices are a very effective way of achieving that. [EDITED to add: not because "a random key fits a random lock" but rather the reverse: with non-negligible probability[1] the test-setter is not choosing at random but in some relatively low-Kolmogorov-complexity way, and you want to keep away from those parts of the outcome space.] Of course, having a really good model of the test-setter's decision process would be even better, but if you had that you'd just use it to ace the test.

[1] I initially missed out the word "probability". I edited it in. Sorry.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by Eliezer on Saturday October 23, 2010 @03:53PM (#1824236)
Okay, you're right.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by gjm11 on Saturday October 23, 2010 @08:22PM (#1824757)
To whoever's downvoting Eliezer's comment above (I know at least two people have):

If you think he was stupidly wrong to issue the original challenge, downvote that. If you think he was right to issue the original challenge and stupidly wrong to back down when I argued, downvote me since presumably I'm even wronger. But what the hell sense does it make to downvote someone for being prepared to change his mind in the face of disagreement?

Incidentally #1: For an exposition of Eliezer's slightly-unconventional (but, for the avoidance of doubt, neither insane nor desperately ignorant) views on randomized algorithms, and some interesting discussion, see http://lesswrong.com/lw/vp/worse_than_random/ and http://lesswrong.com/lw/vq/the_weighted_majority_algorithm/ .

Incidentally #2: For the multiple-choice test, even better than choosing random answers is to choose random answers and them check them for low Kolmogorov complexity (in so far as that's possible; there are some theorems restricting it) and generate new random answers if the results are bad. You could turn this into a not-at-all-random algorithm that performs even better, given sufficient (vast) computing power: enumerate, and execute, all "cheap enough" computations that produce sets of answers; use this to put some suitable probability distribution on answer-sets (so that answers generated by cheaper computations are more probable, and then (deterministically) choose your answers to minimize the probability of failure. This is the kind of thing Eliezer has in mind when he claims that every randomized algorithm can be beaten by a derandomized one.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by jrp on Saturday October 23, 2010 @01:53PM (#1823961)
If I only need to get one question right it doesn't take many questions before (3/4)^n is smaller than the chance the professor, for whatever reason, avoided C.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by sesqu on Saturday October 23, 2010 @07:27PM (#1824643)
I disagree. I'd put that probability at 0 after n=7.

In fact, according to the recent reddit thread, some test designers are encouraged to enforce equal proportions of each option. While stupid, it lowers the threshold to n=3 or so.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by wallflower on Saturday October 23, 2010 @02:51PM (#1824094)
Reminds me of the famous "What is courage?" test answer urban legend:

http://www.snopes.com/college/exam/oneword.asp

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by dstorrs on Saturday October 23, 2010 @05:43PM (#1824434)
Here's a variant on this that is actually true: I took Professor DiCenzo's "History of Japan" course at Oberlin College, in we he assigned several 5-page papers. There were a variety of topics to choose from (or make up your own); one of those topics was "Zen". Professor DiCenzo was famous for saying "The first student who chose the 'Zen' topic and turned in five blank pages got an 'A'. You will get an 'F' -- please try to use words."
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by pavel_lishin on Monday October 25, 2010 @01:47PM (#1830764)
> "when in doubt, pick C"

I spent like five minutes trying to figure out what a programming language had to do with engineering dynamics.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by eli on Saturday October 23, 2010 @11:48AM (#1823713)
There's an ancient Excel spreadsheet that lists and categorizes every happy hour here in DC. It gets emailed around like crazy at the start of every intern season.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by koenigdavidmj on Saturday October 23, 2010 @12:31PM (#1823821)
My university, for a while, had a mailing list to which everyone forwarded events that happened to serve food. If you worked it right, and were a sufficiently desperate postgrad, you could eat for free for most of the quarter.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by bmelton on Saturday October 23, 2010 @11:57PM (#1825158)
If you ever run into a copy of it, I'd love to get hands on it.

barry.melton@google's mail service.com

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by eli on Sunday October 24, 2010 @12:18AM (#1825188)
I'll see what I can do... but it was kinda outdated when I first saw it in 2004. Though since it was an Excel file anyone could edit, I wouldn't be surprised if it kept evolving and branching new version.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by hamilcarbarca on Saturday October 23, 2010 @04:49PM (#1824343)
To anyone living in the Philly area, enjoy.

http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=rLdNJ2i7qtM_KyzyrJ2eu...

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by listic on Saturday October 23, 2010 @07:17AM (#1823241)
Does every bar have happy hours? I thought it's rare thing for bars to have.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by hansef on Saturday October 23, 2010 @09:03AM (#1823382)
In Portland, yes, nearly every bar. Although you probably can't pull off a beer and dinner for $1 anymore most places.
Re:Tell us your naughty stories by fragmede on Saturday October 23, 2010 @01:00PM (#1823870)
Depends on where you are (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_hour#Backlash)

Happy hour has been illegal in Massachusetts since 1984.

Re:Tell us your naughty stories by bmelton on Saturday October 23, 2010 @10:11AM (#1823504)
Most bars do. The markup on alcohol is absurd. As an individual, I can buy a keg of a very good beer for a cost of approximately 38 cents a pint. That same beer at a bar costs more like 4 or 5 bucks.

Cutting the margin down still covers costs considerably, but happy hours are a 'loss leader' to get you in to a bar that would otherwise be less occupied, and perhaps as a signal for those driving by looking for a 'happening' bar, which is usually done toward the end of happy hour.

There might also be motivation to get you somewhat drunk so that you'll stay after happy hour and not realize that you're paying full price for beers.