News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by Yetanfou on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:50AM (#18228538)
It is an odd thing that a company can on the one hand become known as the one firing an engineer who tried to open an honest discussion on a hot subject like 'gender discrimination' because that engineer was deemed to lack a moral compass, while on the other hand bending over backwards to assist an oppressive - but lucrative - dictatorship in implementing a real-life version of Oceania's Ingsoc [1] [2]. As if these people are so blind-sided by their own ideology that they do not recognise their own moral compasses twirling as if they're in the Bermuda triangle and the 'no' being struck from their previous motto of 'do no evil'.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingsoc

[2] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-09-18/china-social-credit-a...

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by grey-area on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:34AM (#18228807)
firing an engineer who tried to open an honest discussion on a hot subject like 'gender discrimination'

That's not an accurate summary of Damore's motives, or the reasons for firing him.

on the other hand bending over backwards to assist an oppressive - but lucrative - dictatorship in implementing a real-life version of Oceania's Ingsoc

Corporations are amoral by design. So I don't find this odd at all, but is an incredibly dangerous development.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by drakenot on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:05AM (#18228991)
That's not an accurate summary of Damore's motives, or the reasons for firing him.

What is then?

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by soundwave106 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:08AM (#18229482)
IMHO the Damore memo got way too heavy into the political angles at the end (straying away from the science and citing non-analytical political opinion pieces and even an anti-feminist Wordpress blog of all things), so I'm not sure I'd call it "100% honest". That being said, my personal impression is that such was more driven by naivety than malice; firing was an over-reaction.

For the capitulation to China, though, the scale seems different. I would agree with the parent that this seems to contradict core philosophy -- much of the words espoused in their "Owner's Manual for Google Shareholders" in their IPO (https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/000119312504...) now seem hollow (for reasons more than just this). Do they still believe strongly in the "long term" as they claim? How does submitting to one of the world's most repressive places (information wise) "make the world a better place"? You certainly can't claim "unbiased and objective" search results when there is a government telling you certain things you can't include. Companies may be amoral by design (as another poster said) but Google at least in their manifesto certainly seemed to strive to be different. Not anymore, apparently.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by nindalf on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:08AM (#18229484)
The Economist wrote a rebuttal of Damore's memo here. I'm a little disappointed that Google didn't write their own rebuttal of the memo. Just firing Damore fed into the victim complex that some of these people suffer from.

The e-mail Larry Page should have written to James Damore - https://www.economist.com/international/2017/08/19/the-e-mai...

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by roenxi on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @11:01AM (#18229916)
This would have been a really good piece of work if an editor had trimmed out everything before "let’s examine its argument". Putting words into Larry Page's mouth is in lousy taste. It isn't satire and isn't a form that adds anything honest to the article.

But past that it was a pretty reasonable argument. Pruning out the par-for-the-course of accusations that Damore really meant something other than what he actually wrote it made for an interesting and constructive read.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by tynpeddler on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:11PM (#18231702)
That article is pretty lacking. For its length, it employs a lot of fuzzy logic, lacks proper context and doesn't support its own points. I'll go through the more well supported points. I'm going to have to do a bit of reorganizing because the article is basically a gish gallop and poorly structured:

1. "Then you make a giant leap from group differences between men and women on such measures as interest in people rather than things, or systematising versus empathising, to differences in men’s and women’s ability to code"

The author seems to think that ability to code is some inborn talent that must be evenly distributed between men and women. Coding ability (like math, knitting, doctoring and literally every other human skill) is a confluence of natural talent, interest, coaching, and raw time spent. People can have equal talent for a skill, but ultimately have radically different ability due to their chosen paths in life. If Damore's hypothesis is correct and men do have a greater natural interest in coding, then we could expect men to have a greater ability to code, on average, even if men as a whole had less aptitude for coding. Damore didn't clarify because he probably didn't expect anyone to interpret his words with such malice.

2. "You ignore many other gender differences, basing your argument only on a few that you think support your conclusion."

These differences should be cited and used to build a counter argument.

3. "You’re ignoring everything else that could explain the gender gap."

Damore's memo does not take place in a vacuum. It's an alternate view offered in contrast to the popular mainstream view.

4. "The gender differences you cite differ between countries and over time."

Not an argument, or even a rebuttal. More of a confounding factor.

5. "They (gender differences) don’t even support your argument, because you don’t seem to understand what makes a great software engineer...Software engineering requires a broad mix of skills ... Teamwork, in particular... Senior engineers must manage teams—and by your own reasoning that should mean that women, with their greater empathy and interest in people, should be over-represented at that level."

Being a low level software engineer is a prerequisite to being a high level software engineer. If women are underrepresented at the bottom, it's expected they will be underrepresented at the top. You might expect an "enrichment" effect of women in management, but there may be other factors (that I'll talk about later) that result in women leaving the software profession before that point. All of this assumes that high empathy and interest in people are even required to be a good manager. Steve Jobs was often considered a good leader but it doesn't seem like he gave a crap about the people under him.

6. "You clearly don’t understand our company, and so fail to understand what we are trying to do when we hire"

Not an argument.

7. "Even if you are right that more men than women are well-suited to the job of software engineer at Google, you are wrong that taking steps to recruit more women is inherently unfair to men."

Not an argument.

8. "There is plenty of evidence that women in Silicon Valley suffer sexism and discrimination. Read Susan Fowler’s description of the harassment she experienced at Uber before leaving the firm in December. Look at the responses to “Elephant in the Valley”, a recent survey of senior women in tech: among its findings was that two-thirds had been excluded from networking opportunities because of their sex. And beyond our industry, women are less likely than men to be given plum assignments, are given less useful feedback, are seen as pushy when they ask for pay rises (men are seen as ambitious) and, in leadership roles, may be seen as either competent or likeable, but rarely both. “We need to stop assuming that gender gaps imply sexism,” you write. But we know there is sexism! We don’t need to infer it from the existence of gender gaps."

An argument! All of this is certainly true and should be addressed by internal and legal processes. In addition, all of these are potential explanations of the gender gap in software development. However, these points alone are not sufficient to make that argument. What we need here is context. Does the rate of discrimination differ between fields that are lopsided, like computer science, and fields that are more even, like law and medicine?

9. "Finally, let’s look at your contention that by trying to recruit more women Google is discriminating against men. You seem to think that if we stopped paying any attention to applicants’ gender when deciding who to hire, we would naturally converge on the “right” share of men and women, that is, the share that matches the distribution of talent in the recruitment pool. I don’t believe that. Unless we make special efforts, some women will be put off applying by the heavily male culture; those doing the hiring will be influenced in their assessments of candidates’ ability by the stereotypes they’ve formed in that male environment. We should “treat people as individuals, not as just another member of their group,” you write. That is what we are doing."

This is so much feeble it hard to figure out where to start. First, no one really cares about talent in the recruitment pool, even if they use the word "talent". What they really care about is ability (see my above definition of ability). If you have solid math skills but can't tell a for-loop from an if-statement, google probably isn't trying to recruit you for a programming job. "Special Efforts" is the problem, not the solution. Harvard makes "special efforts" not to recruit asians. Fifty years ago, companies made "special efforts" to hire white men. "Special Efforts" are discrimination, full stop. Reverse sexism is still sexism.

In this article's quest for "context", they missed all of it. There are a couple of major data points that they glossed over.

1. The paradox of gender ratios in STEM fields by country. Gender ratios in STEM fields are most extreme in countries that are most gender equitable (like the nordic countries) and least extreme in countries known for sexism (software developers in Zimbabwe are 50% women and india has a much higher percentage of women in programming). One explanation is that Software development in these countries is composed of more westernized individuals who have more progressive views than other people in their country. The other explanation is that talented women are basically "funneled" into computer science in those countries because it's even harder for them to enter other professions.

2. The prevalence of women in law and medicine. The stigmas against women entering these was pretty extreme, yet women smashed these barriers to the point where most people entering the medical profession are now women. There are still areas in medicine that are male dominated, but there are also areas that are female dominated.

There's also a philosophical question that needs to be addressed. Is the existence of a gender gap proof of sexism? If yes the forensic science and veteranarian science have a lot to answer for. Those professions are more lopsided in favor of women then computer science is in favor of men.

Obviously the issue is complicated, but it's not clear that the discrimination that women face in computer science is greater than they face in other fields where representation is more equitable. My biggest takeaway from Damore's memo was that Google was 110% committed to the idea that the gender imbalance is due to sexism. And since it can't find particular instances of sexism to punish or stop, everyone must be so guilty that they can't see it. Google's response to the Damore memo says quite a lot.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by jbob2000 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:26AM (#18229137)
I really think he was just a naive, young guy who perhaps was motivated by "being correct" and "logical" over more pragmatic ways of living and socializing. He was fired because a bunch of right wing nut jobs started attaching themselves to him (and by proxy, google) and the last thing Google wants is their name attached to these people, so they threw the baby out with the bath water.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by nugga on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:54AM (#18229354)
There is a narrative being pushed aggressively by people who identify as left wing, liberal, 'equality above all else' types etc that seems to deny biological facts and human nature while championing for equality of outcome (bad, because that's not how human potential works) and affirmative action (favouritism to minorities and women) and usually place the white western man as the evil in the world.

These people will brand fascist those who urge for calm conversation supported by facts and reason. They will deplatform and protest and even violently attack those who speak up about there being more to this stuff than discrimination, namely individual motivation, and whatever the gender influenced magical secret sauce is that forms human motivations and personality especially when you look at population averages.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by nugga on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @12:07PM (#18230492)
James Damore, as far as I can tell, argued that people gravitate towards things that interest them and gender plays a role in this and that is why women are not 50% of the engineers and programmers.

Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson for example agree and talk about these things, the cultural phenomenon of 'group identity', 'social justice warriors' and 'equality of outcome vs. equality of opportunity' and are generally opposed to this radical movement that tries to tell us that you are defined by what you (must) identify as or what group you belong to, eg. white heterosexual male.

Bret Weinstein, professor of biology, gets attacked and has to resign: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evergreen_State_College#2017_p...

Jordan Peterson gets protested a lot and labeled a right winge extremist despite being left wing liberal (but an advocate for 'fixing your shit' so you can 'step up your game'): https://www.queensjournal.ca/story/2018-03-06/news/jordan-pe...

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by n4r9 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @12:32PM (#18230731)
> James Damore, as far as I can tell, argued that people gravitate towards things that interest them and gender plays a role in this and that is why women are not 50% of the engineers and programmers.

imo you've overstated his point, I think he would argue that some of the difference can be explained by biological differences. But if that was the full extent of his assertions I don't think he would have got into so much hot water. As I've argued elsewhere on HN, Damore made several further claims, such as:

1) Hiring practices and funding which aim to counter the gender gap are wrong...

2) ... and Google cannot see this because of its inherent left-wing bias.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by afuchs on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:19AM (#18229557)
People have measurable and quantifiable biases that have an effect on how they perceive others.

While there are actual differences between individuals, what is presented as an objective biological fact is often a false projection of someone's subjective biases (i.e. sexism and racism).

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by djschnei on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:34AM (#18229197)
Who are the rightwing nutjobs? Joe Rogan and Dave Rubin?
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by jbob2000 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:41AM (#18229726)
The first people that approached him were the guys from Project Veritas, veritably right wing nut jobs. Joe Rogan has a libertarian slant, and while not a right wing nut job himself, he does have a large right wing following who definitely appreciated hearing from Damore.

And here's your boy Dave Rubin:

"In an interview in March 2018, Rubin said he would vote for Donald Trump in the 2020 U.S. presidential election if a progressive like Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, or Gavin Newsom is running against him.[29] Rubin also characterized President Trump as a political moderate, saying "he's a Democrat in a lot of ways", and spoke favorably of Trump's cuts in government regulations.[30]". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Rubin

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by Fins on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @12:27PM (#18230669)
What Rubin says makes sense, viz. Sanders. Not that this is any kind of choice one would want to make.

Also, it is not at all surprising that it would be right-wing nut jobs who would approach Damore -- as we can see even here, no one else wants to discuss it, no matter what the merits of the argument, such as they were, might be.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by stevenwoo on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:51AM (#18229828)
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/nov/16/james-dam... Jordan Peterson, Milo Yiannopoulos, Peter Duke then a succession of other right wing trolls on Youtube.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @12:59PM (#18231007)
Jordan Peterson isn't a "rightwing nutjob" though. He's just controversial.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by djschnei on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:26PM (#18232390)
I think it's because he's not a leftwing nutjob ;)
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:07PM (#18232782)
Yeah... Pretty much
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by stevenwoo on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:26PM (#18232388)
Jordan Peterson is pretty much the definition of right wing nutjob by anyone who is not a men's right activist, cherry picking studies on invertebrate species to justify his philosophy. Just for that one topic we could bring in an actual expert on marine invertebrates to refute Jordan Peterson's foundations. https://twitter.com/baileys/status/997646354414522368
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by djschnei on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:22PM (#18232897)
"Oh I absolutely did not read the book and have no intention to do so. I find hate-reading to be a waste of my time." - your Expert

So, she is drastically misrepresenting and misunderstanding ONE point he made in ONE chapter of his book (hardly a foundation of his philosophy), and she openly admits to having never read his book, and that's the example you want to give? Interesting...

Can someone mansplain "hate-reading" to a layman?

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:40PM (#18233043)
Hate-reading, noun:

The act of reading a piece of writing by someone you dislike for political reasons and mentally discrediting them by refuting their arguments with specious or fallacious reasoning. Primarily undertaken in the conscious pursuit of confirmation bias.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:04PM (#18232748)
If you really think Jordan Peterson is a right wing nut job then I just don't know what to say to that. And the fact that there are other reproductive behaviours besides the lobster one doesn't really disprove the point. You can observe the same behaviours (that of a male hierarchy of competition) all across nature. I find it interesting that the thread you quoted didn't actually deny the lobster thing either. Nor really show that the alternative mating/sex behaviours of other animals disprove the hierarchy thing. I mean, I'm skeptical of some of the things he says, but just claiming he is wrong doesn't make him so without something to back the claim up.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by topmonk on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:55AM (#18228565)
It's not about a moral compass, it's about attracting top talent. The universities push this ideology, so if you want to get the alumni from the universities to work for you, you have to abide by the tenets.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by nradov on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:22AM (#18229108)
Except that the notion of "top talent" appears to be a myth.

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2002/07/22/the-talent-myt...

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by vertline3 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @11:07AM (#18229976)
Interesting link, I just skimmed it but I don't think it quite showed top talent is a myth, but rather that our ways of measuring that talent is flawed, this syncs up with ideas from Moneyball as well. We know that pitching is a talent, but we struggle to project who will be the future star due to our preconcieved biases.

So in the story they found a stronger correlation between tacit knowledge than simply IQ for instance.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by claydavisss on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:05AM (#18228639)
You mean, you have to pretend you abide by the tenets...
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by agumonkey on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:06AM (#18228643)
The limit of profit based entities. Capitalism today but probably as old as humans.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by oconnor663 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @12:05PM (#18230475)
> who tried to open an honest discussion

I mean, that's precisely what people disagreed on. One side thinks his way is the best and most obvious way of getting to the truth, and the other side thinks he's a deliberate provocateur who's loose with his facts. There's nothing wrong with being on a side, but at the same time we shouldn't paper over that it is A Side.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by repolfx on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @01:58AM (#18236459)
Damore clearly wanted an open and honest discussion, which is why he wrote so politely and provided citations for all his arguments.

The resulting meltdown and repetitive lying about his memo just goes to show how right he is. Nobody has successfully defeated his arguments which aren't even complicated, they're obvious and common sense. Instead they just try to shoot the messenger.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by oconnor663 on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @04:02PM (#18243180)
> which is why he wrote so politely

This is kicking the can down the road on noticing the disagreement. Some people think he wrote in a perfectly reasonable, rational way. Other people think he wrote in a deliberately provocative way, to cause a stir. It's certainly possible to use polite-sounding language in deliberately provocative ways.

Just to go with the most extreme possible example, if I wrote an article about any conceivable version of "was the Holocaust really as bad as people say?", it wouldn't be enough to just word the whole thing politely. I'd have to be extremely considerate of my audience audience to write something like that, and of the real world context in which my audience was going to read the article, and what it would mean in light of their experiences. My motivations for choosing that topic would be under intense scrutiny, since everyone has heard heard similar-sounding things before from horrible people. If I'm not extraordinarily considerate about those things, I'm either an idiot, or I'm deliberately causing trouble. Anyone can see that, right?

Some people feel that way about Damore's arguments. They feel the content is inherently hurtful, such that starting an "even-keeled, rational-sounding debate" about it is inherently rude, at least without doing a lot of work to acknowledge the feelings context. And then obviously lots of other people feel differently. That's a big disagreement, and you don't have to be an insane person to be on either side of it.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by LiterallyDoge on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:00AM (#18229413)
Aren't these consistent? They're both just a large corporation censoring things it doesn't like.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by nova22033 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:58AM (#18228592)
>because that engineer was deemed to lack a moral compass

Did Google say he was fired because he lacked a moral compass?

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by moduspol on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:02AM (#18228622)
Did they actually fire him for the reason they said?
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by late2part on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:34AM (#18228810)
So far, legally, yes.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by pimmen on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:28AM (#18228785)
The cost of firing the dev was whatever he could claim in a wrongful termination suit. Which is, what, millions of dollars? The benefit of firing him is that you appease the devs of the future who demand that their company take a stand on divisive issues.

The opportunity cost of not getting in on the Chinese market by being complicit in human rights abuses is in the billions, and possibly some direct costs if you generate badwill (so, let's add the cost of keeping up a farce for the employees just to be thorough, which is probably in the millions). As long as you keep everyone in the dark about what you're doing you can reap the benefits.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by creaghpatr on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:32AM (#18228803)
Opp cost could be even higher. If a Chinese company builds the next great (censored) search engine, they could turn around and launch an uncensored version in the US, challenging Google's monopoly on de-listing 'hate speech' in search. Would be ironic, but only as ironic as Google launching a search engine in China.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by brandmeyer on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:23AM (#18229115)
> they could turn around and launch an uncensored version in the US

It is far more likely for such a competitor to turn around and launch a censored version in the US, just changing the censorship criteria. Can you imagine the impact of a partnership between the Murdoch empire and a search engine with ideological censorship built-in?

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by plasticchris on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:52AM (#18229343)
It's poor justification for evil that someone else might do it.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by repolfx on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @02:03AM (#18236486)
The cost of firing Damore was much, much higher than that.

It sent a message to the entire world that Google is staffed by extremists who systematically cannot be trusted to provide unbiased services or search results for anything involving women or feminism. It caught the attention of conservative politicians. It killed dead the idea that Google is run by logical, data driven people (as Damore's memo was basically a big pile of data and studies), and judging from what my friends who still work there think, it created huge cynicism in the developer workforce too. It very much did not "appease the devs" unless you are naive enough to believe that Damore is some outlier in disliking diversity programmes in tech firms.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by nashashmi on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @12:05PM (#18230480)
If the denominator you are looking at is morality, then those actions are at odds.

But as others have said, the common denominators are profit, social credits, employee demands (only a few people resigned b/c of the china initiative), suppression of individual opinions and elevation of collective opinions, corporate leadership, corporate power, innovation and culture that leads to innovation, etc.

Anyone else care to identify other parallels between these two actions?

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by paraditedc on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:57AM (#18228580)
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by UncleMeat on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:41AM (#18229261)
Damore's memo had asides about cultural marxism and claimed that the expected opposition to his post would prove that he was right about political correctness. Although he cited research, he made conclusions based on that research that were not derived from the evidence.

Damore might have considered it an "honest" discussion from his perspective, but there was no chance that it was actually an even handed analysis. The memo was poisoned by his words from the start.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by skgoa on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:32AM (#18229653)
I completely agree with that criticism, but that's still not grounds for just firing him and for certain parts of the media branding him a misogynist.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by repolfx on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @02:06AM (#18236491)
Which conclusions, exactly?

He claimed that writing the memo would put his career at risk because left wing opponents would attempt to purge him. In fact the memo wasn't even primarily about gender, it was about anti-conservative bias at Google. This claim was proven entirely correct by what happened next.

The reason he used the phrase "cultural Marxists" is because Marxists have historically relied heavily on purging institutions or ideological opponents, suppression of speech, insistence on conformity and relentless lying about people they dislike. Given that all these things have happened to Damore it appears to be an apt analogy.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by clubm8 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:45AM (#18229769)
They're neoliberals. It makes perfect sense. They're liberal on social issues, conservative on econ/foreign policy issues. Examining their actions through this lens makes everything clear.

To give an example outside technology, think of prisons - largely staffed by and filled with men.

A democratic socialist or a libertarian would want to close prisons.

A neoliberal wants the prison to hire more female guards.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by n4r9 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:49AM (#18229805)
Isn't the simpler explanation that they want to make as much money as possible? Firing Damore saves their reputation and having a good reputation is key to making money. Expanding into China opens up huge opportunities for making money.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by clubm8 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @11:40AM (#18230236)
>Isn't the simpler explanation that they want to make as much money as possible?

Yes, as I said, they're neoliberals ;)

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by hnbroseph on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:46PM (#18231458)
the 'liberal' in neoliberal is not the same 'liberal' used in typical current US parlance. that is to say, it's more right-libertarian vs 'progressive'. neoliberal isn't a label that says all that much about social issues, generally.

> A neoliberal wants the prison to hire more female guards.

afaik, a neoliberal wants the prison to be able to hire whoever it wants without meddling regulations causing inefficiency and putting more strain on the hiring process.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:05PM (#18231071)
I want to agree with this, but social progressivism isn't associated with neoliberalism in my mind. I thought neoliberals were socially classical liberals (freedom of spsech/markets/association/etc)? I always thought of the predominant startup politics to be a crony capitalism/social progressivism mashup.

Either way, I laughed.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by clubm8 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:27PM (#18231264)
>I want to agree with this, but social progressivism isn't associated with neoliberalism in my mind. I thought neoliberals were socially classical liberals (freedom of spsech/markets/association/etc)?

I think it depends how you define social progressivism. They buy into basic tenets - for example, gay marriage. Basically, progressive when displayed alongside a far right party.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:07PM (#18232777)
By social progressivism I meant the affirmative action reference you made. As far as I was aware gay marriage is pretty centrist these days.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by digitalzombie on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:34AM (#18229199)
> It is an odd thing that a company can on the one hand become known as the one firing an engineer who tried to open an honest discussion on a hot subject like 'gender discrimination' because that engineer was deemed to lack a moral compass

It wasn't an open honest discussion.

He wrote some memo and it was pass around the Google until some people found out and got offended.

If he wanted an honest discussion he shouldn't be passing notes around like it's highschool. The memo apparently ended up being pass by more and more people. That's not how you approach this or many topics that are sensitive. I think his lack of common sense and clarity screwed him over really.

This is my understanding base on this article:

https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/kzbm4a/employees-...

Gizmodo have the full letter:

https://gizmodo.com/exclusive-heres-the-full-10-page-anti-di...

This is before we even approach this sensitive topic, regardless how anybody feel about it, he have already messed it up from the get go.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by dx87 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:51AM (#18229332)
He didn't pass around a memo like a highschool student, he posted it on an internal message board that was created as a place for employees to write about controversial topics.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by digitalzombie on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @06:22PM (#18233808)
Do you have a source for that?

Because I've sourced my stuffs and showed how I base my discussion and form my thoughts on my subject with those sources. If I am wrong I would like to learn from it. Otherwise just posting this means I have to take your word for it without any evidence and I don't do that.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by explainplease on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:47PM (#18234288)
You read one article about it, and now you're demanding that he feed you links? You're on the Internet. Google is the topic of discussion. If you cared about the truth as much as you claim, you would do your own homework and seek out your own sources. I guess you really are a digital zombie.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by honestlyidk on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:41AM (#18229732)
>If he wanted an honest discussion he shouldn't be passing notes around like it's highschool. The memo apparently ended up being pass by more and more people. That's not how you approach this or many topics that are sensitive.

You are making the perfect the enemy of the good here. Your idea of "honest discussion" and claim that how not to approach topics that are sensitive is completely subjective. You are trying to silence his voice (just like google is silencing many chinese voices). You dont make the rules about how someone gets to speak.

I dont think he was productive in his desires but I do believe that he was candid , genuine and I would never tell someone they dont get to epxress their honest thoughts.

Think of the past decades with gay rights , trans rights and you want to tell someone they cant express their thoughts and need to keep their ideas in the closet. Is bigotry from the LGBTQ crowd allowed but we cant be bigoted against them? This double standard keeps us all back from making a truly free society. It seems google and and from your argument that this freedom is subjected and carefully tailored from elite that designate what voices should be heard and silenced.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by digitalzombie on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @05:52PM (#18233618)
> You dont make the rules about how someone gets to speak.

I don't have to make any rules. I'm saying how he did it got him fired. If you think how he did it is correct go ahead and do it in all of those tech companies. You think you won't be risking getting fire doing the way he did it?

Whether you like it or not. Just like his memo trying to be slapping hard truth down. I'll give this unpopular opinion down. There is always rules on how to sell your idea and say things especially sensitive matter. If you're going to go blunt about it, don't get mad if you're going to get fire. Actions have consequences. He could have gone about it many ways and if you think his ways is the best go ahead and do it at your company with his memo. I wouldn't be surprise you get fire.

Rules? Ha. I just have to point to what happened to him. He got fire cause his way got him fire. Rules? You think this idealist thought of yours work with people? Try managing people with many different ideas and being blunt all the time.

You're the same as the people that didn't like his memo. You can't handle the blunt truth and got angry.

Also here's a thought experiment. Why don't you use your real name instead of a username handler and post the same thoughts online.

I'd like to see if you act the same way with your real name as a username.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by explainplease on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:49PM (#18234305)
"Also here's a thought experiment. Why don't you use your real name instead of a username handler and post the same thoughts online." --digitalzombie, Hacker News, 2018

This is some top-tier trolling, right here. Thanks for the laugh.

Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by Rotdhizon on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:45AM (#18229763)
How else is he supposed to discuss it? Every single time that topic gets brought up in any medium, it gets immediately shut down and disregarded. It's always "This isn't the place to discuss this" or "This isn't the time to discuss this". The exact same thing that happened to the CERN scientist a few weeks ago. He brings up some valid points on gender but since he dared to speak his mind, he was ousted because some people were offended by it. I don't blame him one bit for doing it how he did, it certainly had a drastic effect once people got their hands on it.
Re:Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China... by digitalzombie on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:00PM (#18234021)
> How else is he supposed to discuss it?

Most Google employee that didn't like the China or Pentagon collab protest by leaving.

His memo from the get go divided people into groups. Is that really how to sell an idea? So the people reading this either going to like it or not. It made it so easy for the reader to fall into a group because it did it for them. Is being blunt a good thing at all? The things he said about women, whether or not I agree with it, being blunt about it is such a bad way of presenting his idea. Bringing up negative stuff over and over instead of positive is not a good way about trying to convince people to your side. You can just focus on whatever strength/positive your solution on your side and address little to none of the other side negative. There are books out there for persuasion; it's not some evil technique, it teaches you how not to come across as a social lunatic when talking about sensitive subject.

If you don't agree with it's fine because for me, it's not a mole hill worth dying for.