Caesarian's costs the NHS around £1,700 a time compared with £750, for a normal childbirth and women also stay in hospital for twice as long on average. There is a general presumption in the UK that avoiding what is an invasive operation is preferable for both baby and mother alike, in the absence of other factors.
I would argue that clearly How a baby is delivered is other people's business since other people are involved. However the ultimate choice should be the mother's.
However, we do have a process whereby use of my wage income is not entirely elective, it's called taxation and in part is used to improve outcomes for other people's children.
In your opinion should infants have no advocacy, should mothers (parents presumably) have complete determinency over the medical needs of their children without regard for medical outcomes.
Strongly disagree. The mother's freedom is not subservient to the child's wellbeing. Stable families are also associated with better outcomes for children, does that mean a man should not be allowed to divorce his spouse after they have children? What about second hand smoke or the psychological effects of parents' alcoholism on a child? I could go on (consider Vaccinations), but if a child's outcomes are the primary concern why stop at C-sections?
> Indeed surgical procedures should never be entirely elective.
Why not? What about plastic surgery, liposuction, or gastric bypass? This is a weird sort of medical puritanism.
Except they're not. It's called adoption.
> I don’t think there’s any precedent in culture or our legal system that puts freedom of parents at a higher priority over well being of children - nor should it.
I just listed several including divorce and the freedom to choose to vaccinate (or not). I never said that the freedom of the parents is paramount, but it's also not fully subservient to the child's wellbeing. It's a balance. And my larger point is that mandating that someone go through a painful and potentially physically scarring natural birth for a dubious improvement to the child's development does not make the grade by this standard.
There's fewer than 700,000 births a year. If every one was a c-section it would cost an extra £700m a year, less than 1% of the NHS budget.
NICE guidelines state that the woman should discuss the pros and cons and then it's her choice.
Well, yes, but that doesn't mean it's a choice between two roughly equivalent options. C-Sections are invasive surgeries and come with added risks. I would argue a healthcare provider's duty is to advocate against them unless there is an appropriate medical reason.
This is one major reason to oppose publicly funded health care. _Every_ decision becomes a public one.
I've lived in a country with socialized medicine. It's not perfect, but at least they don't have a huge chunk of the population walking around with easily-treatable conditions that slowly destroy them because normal people don't get decent health coverage.
My son and wife's lives were saved by a C-section three weeks ago. Watching that fetal heart rate monitor dip to zero and then slowly, unsteadily rise back up over and over again was the hardest thing I've ever done. The hospital staff pushed us to do a vaginal birth the whole time. I understand and appreciate what they did, but at the same time I hope there is a better way, because in hindsight I would have never put my wife and son through this again.
This isn't a programming language preference. If you don't know the details of clinical practices around C-section, if you're not an expert or a patient, then you really shouldn't be pushing your opinion on others. Refrain.
These campaigners have persuaded the CQC to stop pressuring trusts over rates of C-section or normal birth, and to get the NMC to stop paying normal birth so hard.
In the information age, there are so many irresponsible and incomplete bits supporting this, that or the other in as many superlatives as possible. What can a person do? I thought that VBAC was more dangerous for the mother than the newborn, for a healthy young woman, coupled with even a tiny amount of pressure this could easily lead people to make a decision they were not really comfortable with. The "sheer force of opinion surrounding ... childbirth in general" is astonishing; I agree with you here. The information age is badly curated and gives far too much weight to the inexpert opinion, imh (and non-expert) o. Mothers must give birth naturally, mothers must nurse their infants for x months, fathers must cut the umbilical cord.
All the modern medicine in the world coupled with the power of the information age can't make these decisions for us. Maybe, in the future, machine learning methods can pull relevant information out for people to counter some of the cultural pressures.
In the US, there are a couple of tiers of pressures and thought process. People make these choices from reasons varying from the medically advised, to cosmetic, to schedule based, to something else. Some people make choices for trivial reasons that are disturbing to the doctors who are placing people at risk, at their direction.
I think the medical concern is that there are more complications, the less informed people tend to correlate to folks who are less able to care for themselves afterwards in recovery and overall risk of anesthesia and other things.
* It's the doctor's concern because of the Hippocratic Oath
* It's the baby's and therefore father's concern (but not choice), since vaginal birth is correlated with better outcomes.
* If insured, it's the insurer's concern, as it's over twice the cost of vaginal delivery. (In the case of the UK, this is the government, so literally everyone.)
Try telling that to some of those here, in the US. The mantra is "do what I say, not what I do."
How a baby is delivered is none of anyone's business but the mother herself.
My wife (an epidemiologist) deliberated for months over having our second by VBAC (vaginal birth after csection) and opted to go for it, due to the overwhelming expectation from everyone around her that she should do it naturally, and despite having read an Australian study indicating higher rates of stillbirth during VBAC [citation needed]. Sadly, our daughter didn't make it through the labor.
Needless to say, the csections that safely delivered my first, and recently (yay) third children seem like a miracle of modern medicine to us both.
Even before this personal tragedy, I was astounded by the sheer force of opinion surrounding the cesarean section and childbirth in general. This is creating an environment where women are not able to make their own choices and I fear that the doctors in this article, however well meaning, by warning of an "epidemic" are only adding fuel to this fire.