News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by bussierem on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @11:57AM (#18177012)
I'm gonna step in and defend the Bose headphones that he seems to have had some seriously bad luck with.

I had a pair of wired QC25's as my first pair, and they had some really good noise cancelling. I could still distantly hear people talk, but when I had music on them (albeit probably louder than him) I could hear almost nothing. Regarding Quality: Those QC25s were used when I got them (couldn't justify full price at the time), and they lasted for about 2.5 years beyond, being used literally every day for 5+ hours per day (Programming with music is my thing)

When those broke, I had absolutely no problem justifying what seems to be an exorbitant price for the newer bluetooth QC35 set. These are far beyond what the other set were. Nowadays I keep my music much quieter - listening to soft electronica at maybe 1/4 of the volume I used to, and when I do that, I can't even hear myself type on my mechanical keyboard, let alone any people talking. People can come up to my desk and talk directly to me and I won't realize it unless I see their mouth moving.

I'm not sure why his experience with Bose has been so bad, but I'm more likely to suspect he got a lemon for his headphones. I have had my QC35's now for....2 years, with I would average at 6-8h of use every day at work. They don't have a single iota of visible wear on them, and the battery life is still 24-32 hours on a single charge. I imagine that, barring any accidents with them, they will probably last another 2+ years for me.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by e40 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:17PM (#18177830)
I have had my QC35's now for....2 years, with I would average at 6-8h of use every day at work. They don't have a single iota of visible wear on them, and the battery life is still 24-32 hours on a single charge. I imagine that, barring any accidents with them, they will probably last another 2+ years for me.

Same here, but I use them walking 1+ hour a day. With all that sweat over the years, still look and perform like new.

Yes, they were expensive, but I consider them the best value of any purchase in the last few years.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by chris11 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:45PM (#18178141)
I've had a little less luck with wear on my QC25s, but repair was easy. I've just had to replace the earpads and the cord, both were easy and inexpensive repairs. And I'm happy with the noise cancellation.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by lathiat on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @05:18AM (#18183246)
The OP talks about the QC20 - which are "Acoustic" noise cancelling in-ears. That is, there is no active noise cancelling, it's just "plugging" the holes around the earcups.

What he really needed was the QC25, which is an in-ear with active noise cancelling much like the QC35 has.

EDIT: The author said QC20 but then he talks about ear-muffs - so seems he misquoted the model number I guess.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by loco5niner on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:21PM (#18186992)
Sorry, but you're wrong about the QC20s. They do, in fact, have "active" noise cancelling. I have been using a pair for at least a year, and they are great.

I actually prefer the QC20 noise cancelling to that of the over-ear versions I tried (which were either QC25 or QC35, I don't remember).

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by lathiat on Thursday October 11, 2018 @10:04AM (#18193612)
You are right. Terms are so confusing.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by loco5niner on Thursday October 11, 2018 @02:11PM (#18195757)
Agreed!
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by amag on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:50PM (#18179264)
I've had my QC35's for a bit over a year. Initially I was amazed by them but after a while I started to hear sharp noise when in complete silence (and not using the QC's), e.g. when going to sleep. So while I still use them I don't use the noise cancellation, which kind of defeats the purpose of having them...
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by vitorbaptistaa on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @06:03PM (#18180198)
Sharp noises? You mean you have developed tinnitus after using the Bose headphone and you think it was related?

Do you know if other people experienced the same?

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by amag on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @04:36PM (#18188612)
I'm not sure I would go so far as to say that I developed tinnitus after using them. I occasionally experienced it from time to time even before I started using my QC35's. But it has definitely made it worse and more frequent.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by loco5niner on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:24PM (#18187024)
I developed tinnitus during a time when I was using noise-cancelling Audio-Technica ATH-ANC7b over-ears for 5+ hours a day. I did have other things going on though, so can't specifically say that was the cause.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by realityloop on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @04:42AM (#18183088)
This the same reason I stopped using my QC25’s i’ve often wondered if any other people may have had the same result.

My logic was that they are creating opposing frequencies at the same level of sound pressure as the ambient you are trying to override meaning it’s still loud, just not in a perceptible way. So especially on airplanes, I now use earplugs instead.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by sean1524 on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @05:57AM (#18183401)
Active noise cancelling does mean that the headphones create a sound wave which has the same frequency but is out of phase by a single wave length. This causes destructive interference which causes the total energy of the waves to equal zero. You are partially correct but active noise cancelling has the same effect as putting earplugs in due to wave mechanics.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave_interference

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by loco5niner on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:31PM (#18187089)
I believe that should read "has the same frequency but is out of phase by HALF A wave length".

> active noise cancelling has the same effect as putting earplugs in due to wave mechanics.

Simply from experience, I would disagree with this. Every time I have ever enabled active noise cancelling, I have experienced an increase in eardrum-pressure, volume, or both (both with and without music playing).

I understand that wave mechanics would theoretically work as you state, but in practice, does not.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by coaxial on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @10:16PM (#18190578)
Same here, have tried QC25s and didn't keep them because it made me feel like I had a cold, gave me headaches, and felt like my ears were not equalized pressure wise.

I use concert earplugs now, they are invisible unless someone really looks in my ears, and they attenuate all frequencies equally. This way I can also use them at concerts and they won't ruin the music, just make it much quieter across every frequency.

The open office can't die soon enough, what an absurd fad this is.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by realityloop on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @04:19PM (#18188475)
I have to report the same experience, and I used to turn the volume right down when using noise cancelling too
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by 8ytecoder on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:51PM (#18179270)
I discovered the Bose QC15 6 years ago. What was then borrowing my boss's headphones then led to me buying one for my travels. After my passport, it's the bose headphones that I make it a point to never forget. Air travel is so much better for me because of them. At least for me, the sound quality is absolutely great. Noise cancellation is top notch. I got them for my then girlfriend who has ADHD and it changed her life as well.

(I have tried a variety of headphones and earphones for the past 12 years or so and have decided I'm not buying anything else. Also, I'm 100% not the type to go by a brand name or pay an exorbitant amount for products that are not necessary)

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by steve19 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @05:53PM (#18180135)
My experience also. They seemed like a crazy large expense for a set of headphones I only use a dozen times a year. But I can't travel without them.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by Yizahi on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @02:57PM (#18178816)
My QC25 bought new for 120$ are damn awesome. Half of my office tried them over last year and the conclusion was unanimous - they are great. Office noise is cut completely including most of the normal talking. Airplane noise is cut especially effectively, it seems they are optimized for it. Old subway and old trams are very high frequency and are cut only partially but still noticeably. As for build, soft materials look flimsy but neither band nor earpads are torn or degraded after 1 year of usage (office and rare travel), cord is good too. And wires in the moving part of headset looks very well implemented.

I think up to 200$ ANC headphones are a very good buy, 350$ is debatable.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by tachion on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:07PM (#18177110)
I've tried many and I must agree with the OP - Bose headphones are terrible in terms of build quality and materials, bad in terms of sound quality, average when it comes to noise cancelation, poor in terms of features and absolutely bad at this price tag. I've settled for Sennheiser's Momementum and can't recommend them more - made of metal and leather, build to last, superb sound quality, very good noise cancelation and nice features and amazing support. I'm really surprised they're not discovered by people spending such amount of money on headphones.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by theptip on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @02:02PM (#18178303)
Some empirical results seem to contradict your claim "average when it comes to noise cancelling":

https://www.rtings.com/headphones/tests/isolation/noise-isol...

This gives Bose QuietComfort 35 overall attenuation -27.08 dB, which is only beaten by the Sony wh-1000xm3, and some Etymotic in-ear buds.

Notably that number is more than 2x the attenuation of the Momentum, at -12.35 dB.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by web007 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:46PM (#18179229)
That's more like 30x better, since dB is log scale. Each +/- 3dB is about double/half as loud.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by Acen on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @06:11PM (#18180255)
It's important to differentiate between power and perceived volume.

Usually a person won't notice an increase in volume unless it has a 3-5dB (3dB = double in power) increase. And won't perceive a double in volume without a 10dB (10dB = 10x increase in power) increase and even then it depends on the specific frequency.

Some things to check out would be: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stevens%27s_power_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weber%E2%80%93Fechner_law (and thus Just Noticable Difference [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference])

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by jjrh on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:44PM (#18179217)
Those Sennheiser are not active noise cancelling which is the defining feature of Bose QC headphones - and why people are paying the money. Closed back headphones do work great for blocking noise, but are usually heavier and less comfortable.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by fossuser on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @04:14PM (#18179446)
That's been my experience with people who go on about how terrible the Bose headphones are. You can get passive noise cancelling with Shure in ear phones (basically ear plugs) that is pretty good, but Bose is by far the best for active noise cancelling.

Their build quality and sound is also pretty good. I have a decent music background and also have Sennheiser HD650s which the audiophile crowd loves, but I think their build quality is cheap plastic (they're also open, require an amp, and cost $400).

I think the Bose hate is mostly tribal nonsense - it's cool to signal audiophile virtue by hating a dominant brand that lay people like.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by jjrh on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @03:53PM (#18188289)
> I think the Bose hate is mostly tribal nonsense - it's cool to signal audiophile virtue by hating a dominant brand that lay people like.

I think most of the Bose hate comes from their speakers which cost quite a bit for the sound quality. Much of that might be historical.

These days though I don't think anyone buys Bose products solely for their sound quality, they buy them for specific use cases like noise cancelling, or filling a room with a very small speaker (those Bose sound docks were pretty incredible when they came out). Bose has done a good job at doing something unique while offering sound quality that is mostly good enough.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by wilsonnb3 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @06:51PM (#18180506)
For the record, many people think that Sony’s new WH-1000XM3 have better ANC than Bose. Bose hasn’t been the clear leader in at least a few years.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by snovv_crash on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @02:56AM (#18182586)
I have Momentums with ANC. They were rebranded as HD1, and now the Momentum is just closed back. But as far as I am aware Sennheiser makes the only headphones with both ANC _and_ premium materials, built to last.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by djrogers on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @06:09PM (#18180244)
Sennheiser did sell an ANC Momentum for short while, before rebranding the ANC version as the HD1, so I assume that's what GP is talking about.

I happen to have a pair of those, which I chose over the QC35s, however I would disagree with GP that their ANC is superior in any way - at best it's almost as good as the QC35s.

I bought them because they were more comfortable on me, the ANC was good enough for my occasional use, and I liked the way they look.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by morsch on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @06:58PM (#18180546)
The Momentum Wireless with ANC is still being sold under that name at least over here: https://en-de.sennheiser.com/momentum-wireless-headphones-wi...

But there's half a dozen other Momentum headphones, some with, some without ANC. Sennheiser's naming schemes are aggressively unhelpful. Just look at this small subset of their overall headphone selection (hit Show all): https://en-de.sennheiser.com/music-headphones-portable

Naturally, they don't call it ANC, it's NoiseGard™ [sic].

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by tachion on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @06:19AM (#18183499)
Sennheiser Momentum Wireless are absolutely with active noise canceling, and that's the model I was talking about when comparing to Bose of course. I wouldn't compare non-anc headphones with anc ones, even though I own non-anc Momentum's too and they're so great that they've even survived being sucked into airport x-ray machine rolls, something I couldn't say about Bose or Sony, that are falling apart on their own.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by pathartl on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:52PM (#18177582)
I'm going to go against you and agree with the person your commenting on. I really only bought my QC35's because I was backed into a corner with my iPhone 7. I wanted bluetooth over-the-ear headphones that could also do wired, had good battery life, and sounded okay. After plonking down the $350 I was pleasantly surprised by the build quality, 20+ hr battery life, and the comfort. The noise reduction is pretty incredible and I've heard things in songs that I've never heard before.

They are not the 100% best sounding headphones. However, the clarity and imaging they provide is pretty astounding and I think they compete with any similarly priced competitor. I'm the kind of guy that will take speakers over headphones any day, and I find myself using the QC35's more than my speakers these days.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by runevault on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @02:51PM (#18178764)
Are there ANY noise cancelling headphones that could be said to have REALLY high quality sound? I didn't full appreciate the difference until I got HD280Pros for at home (I don't need noise cancelling in my house) and realized how much better they sound then my QC 25s I use at work.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @04:46PM (#18179686)
Have you tried using your HD280Pros at work? They are closed back recording studio headphones, explicitly designed to not let a lot of sound out, so that backing track isn't picked up by vocal mic etc. So passive noise isolation should be O(20dB), which should be sufficient unless your workplace is very noisy.

I have a pair of AKG K271 mk2 at work (same category as your HD280), as well as the Bose QC35s. The AKGs give a bit less isolation, but for extended use (6-10h) wearing comfort as well as audio quality, they blow the Bose right out of the water. The QC35s have been relegated to travelling only.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by CrazedGeek on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:51PM (#18179275)
Depending on where your cutoff for "REALLY high quality sound" is, the Bowers & Wilkins PX are pretty solid, and people on /r/headphones seem to like the Sony WH1000XM line.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by cjmoran on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @06:09PM (#18180242)
I can also recommend the Sony WH-1000XM line. I have the XM2, though the model 3 is out now. Some of the only headphones out there that beat Bose in active noise-cancelling. The sound quality is top notch; the one complaint people tend to have when I show them off is that the earcups are on the small side and they touch some people's ears. Doesn't really bother me though.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by tracker1 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @05:03PM (#18179792)
I think it's a balancing act... for the most part the differences in sound will come down to preference. There are also variances in price, comfort, etc. I think the Bose QCs strike a really good balance. I find them to physically be the most comfortable for around-ear headphones on my head. They don't weigh too much, they don't squeeze my head like a vice...

It just depends.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by fhood on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:04PM (#18177710)
Huh, weird how much opinions differ. My current main headphones are HD650s but my work headphones are qc25s, and I have no complaints about the Bose build quality, noise canceling, or comfort. Sure they could sound better, but music at work is a background thing, not a foreground thing.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by Spooky23 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:49PM (#18178174)
I've had similar conversations with people about headphones. My theory is that there are alot of fakes in the channel.

Barring subjective things like sound quality that I'm really not comfortable weighing in on, I just haven't found the Bose products to be fundamentally flawed in terms of build quality or noise cancellation.

It may vary based on your office -- I don't have some crazy person simulating machine guns on a mechanical keyboard 3 feet away or a super loud, pure open office space with warehouse ceilings either.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by yarrel on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:52PM (#18177581)
I sometimes wonder if my QC25s are on, or whether the weirdly oval silicon earbuds are actually in my ears. They don't cut out music or conversation. When I take them off I realise they've cut out a lot of white noise/background noise. But they just focus distractions, really.

With music on, yes, they work much better. But whenever there are gaps between the music the distractions come right back.

I need earbuds rather than headphones for portability, and I was prepared to be realistic about what this meant for noise reduction. But if there was anything better than the QC25s in a similar form factor I would switch in a heartbeat.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by LandR on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:42PM (#18178105)
I have BOSE QC for years now too, but they haven't been reliable at all.

I've been lucky that BOSE keep replacing / fixing them... There was a period where they were needing replaced every 8 months or so and I like to think I take good care of my stuff. I'm not rough with them. The current set has at least been good for a few years now. All I have to do is replace the ear muff bits but that's expected and I had to replace the cable about 9 months ago.

Can't fault the sound quality though and the noise cancellation is great.

Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by mgkimsal on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @04:14PM (#18179440)
similar - went through a pair of QC20 - replaced 5 times in 3 years. rarely do we get extended warranties - my wife had read a few places saying to get it, and we did. she got a pair - no problems, but she uses them at most a few hours a week. mine, I'm wearing probably 8-10 hours per day, 7 days a week. I slept with them in, initially, but I'm sure that contributed to the first breakage, so I quit doing that.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by mplewis on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:27PM (#18177317)
I still have not used a pair of NC headphones that muffles noise as well as my QC35. It's like stepping into a bubble.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by damontal on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:25PM (#18179051)
don't they make your ears hot? i can wear my 25's but have to take them off at least each hour just to cool off.
Re:Poor Man’s Bose – Open Office and on the Go Noise Control by another-cuppa on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @02:33AM (#18182487)
When I put music on my shitty earbuds I can't hear anything else either.