This is exactly the reason why I don't donate to my alma mater, neither should most people. Less "alma mater" and more "greedy mater who funnels taxpayer money into a growing bureaucracy".
http://www.washington.edu/news/2008/06/05/moving-cunningham-...
When I was in college, undergrads would have to purchase a meal plan, which could take a few forms. You could have a designated number of meals, and buy things from the cafeteria that qualified as a meal (one entree, one side, one drink), or you could have balance of food dollars which could only be spent on campus. There were also plans that involved a mix of those two types of currencies, but the better plan was to get the food dollars (which were called Declining, for whatever reason), and use that to buy food, because that gave you more flexibility. You could spend Declining at the cafeterias, at the corner store, at the Starbucks on campus, it was literally cash that you could only spend on the campus and only on food.
At the end of the academic year, though, your balance gets zeroed out, no matter how much you have left in Declining. So every year starting in April or so, people would start buying stuff in bulk from the corner store or from the Starbucks just to get something out of the money that was going to evaporate. My senior year, my girlfriend spent like two hundred dollars on coffee beans and gave them to people as presents, because what else was she going to do? I myself spent like sixty bucks on fifteen pounds of sour patch kids.
No reason to not buy that four dollar coffee every day when the money's already spent and you're not getting it back.
In standard economic teaching, Is not this what happens when there is a cartel acting?
Yeah, this is exactly a rephrasing of the point I was trying to get across.
It reminds me of when I realized that banks have an interest in balancing income from issuing more loans with default rates. Someone responded who was close enough to banking to say that they were aiming for about a 7 percent default rate as optimal. In other words, lower lending standards until you're at that rate for optimal profit. These forces are obviously financially good for the institution, but bad for the public. We need to find a way to fix that and the only thing I can think of is educating people on how they are getting screwed so they can make their own judgements on when to participate in such games.
That's the most important question. Same applies to health care. Where does the money actually go and how has that changed over the last 50 years? Everybody immediately complains about their favorite scapegoat but there is no comprehensive accounting.
https://www.air.org/system/files/downloads/report/Delta-Cost...
The table on page 11 summarizes the story. The big consistent increases in spending are on student services and academic support.
The growth in spending on student services covers a lot of things. One big chunk is explained by the trend toward organizing and professionalizing things that were historically handled in a sort of ad-hoc manner by a student's academic advisor, sometimes by the Greek system, or by nothing at all: Career counseling and networking, academic advising, mental health services, stuff like that. Another big chunk is non-academic, non-instructional activities like student clubs and athletics. I believe advertising costs also tend to get lumped in under the "student services" budget item.
Academic support is stuff that's related, but maybe not quite so directly student facing: Dean's offices, instructional material development, the IT department, stuff like that.
It is important to note that relaxation of regulation is important as well, since the direction of that easement usually favors banks and big business[1] - it's a matter of perspective. Always ask what the true purpose of a political action or movement is and follow the money; more often than not there's an ulterior motive.
"All politicians should serve two terms: one in office and one in jail." ~My Grandfather
[1] https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/economy-budget/28362...
The actual answer appears to be that it´s being squeezed into the financial sector by several positive feedback loops operating around lending, and in particular securitized lending - but that´s not the sort of answer that helps to pander to populist sentiment, and securitized lending is a trillion dollar industry - so you won´t see it discussed very much.
Money creation through debt is another topic, but still benefits primarily the same parties.
The earliest reference I see in Google is from 1992, with an Arizona anti-Semitic pamphlet.
A member of one of the administration teams at ASU (a dean or someone of similar position) told my sister, "everyone carries debt," as if to justify that 40k a year at an honors college is a valuable investment compared to virtually any alternative.
The comment was so asinine and destructive, I can only gather as a blanket statement that the members of administration there are either incompetent to help direct students, or are explicitly volatile for one's growth in the context of broader society, and are out to protect the institution's interests. It may be sensible to assume a bit of both.
I'm not defending it, but there isn't Trader Joe's or Aldi of college yet (slightly better than average generic product with low/no frills).
If you want the answer: college loans are very lucrative, so they are pushed on the consumers heavily, just like home loans were 10-15 years ago. The people that profit from that benefit from irresponsible behavior and a broken system.
Community college.
They tend to be older and more focused on their education; to have already demonstrated that they can complete 2 years of basic coursework without dropping out; and have mostly completed their general education classes, meaning they are much less of a drain on the institution. None of these reasons demonstrate 'better-than-average' quality of community college education, just the quality of the kind of students that pursue it successfully, and where they are in life when they apply somewhere else.
The very strategy of doing your first couple of years (ie - the general stuff you can teach yourself from the text book) before going somewhere else to your final degree belies the argument that the education is 'better than average'.
The second problem is that even if this was a reasonable system, people estimate the risk associated with getting the job paying X very poorly, colleges exploit this, even if only few people get a job paying X everyone pays the same costly multiple of X.
Doubtful. If that were true, you would pay differently for a English degree than a Chemical Engineering degree. And I've never seen that.
Even without the commercial angle , the cost of teaching English is not remotely the same as chemical engineering, you need lot more labs , more depts with different expertise , more courses to cover etc. why is it costed the same ? Unless both are heavily subsidized and cost is a just token amount it doesn't make sense.
We could literally print nearly free wealth, inflation free, if we just opened up land for development. It's a win win win.
Doesn't neighboring real estate value decline as you put more capacity on the market? You can't print real estate wealth anymore than you can print dollars without consequence. At the end of the day, all of this "value" is trying to get dibs on the output of labor today (housing prices are usually tied to incomes, with some distorted market exceptions).
The more interesting question is: can you provide these basic necessities at such a low cost that you can drastically reduce the labor output required to enjoy them? What if you only had to work three days a week to meet your basic needs? What if healthcare inflation wasn't consuming wage increases as rapidly as it is?
Great example! More to the point, total wealth is useless, just as GDP is useless as a measure of citizen wellness and happiness (US GDP was 18.57 trillion USD in 2016). It's the distribution that matters and where we're utterly failing. Your example is not progress when necessities inflation (housing, food, education, and healthcare) races ahead of other consumer expenses and incomes in general, unless one is expected to watch that 50" TV in a van down by the river.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/blogs/lookout/fed-official-heckle... (March 11, 2011)
> Reuters reports that New York Federal Reserve Bank President William Dudley was heckled at a speech in Queens today when he suggested that the rising cost of food is offset by how cheap iPads are. "Today you can buy an iPad 2 that costs the same as an iPad 1 that is twice as powerful," he said referring to Apple Inc's (AAPL.O) latest handheld tablet computer hitting stories on Friday. "You have to look at the prices of all things," he said. This prompted guffaws and widespread murmuring from the audience, with one audience member calling the comment "tone deaf." "I can't eat an iPad," another quipped.
Shelter and medical services have ballooned due to ever increasing regulation. That regulation may be necessary, but it unquestionably comes with a cost.
Land is also necessary on which to build said shelter, but vacant lots in rural areas can be had quite cheaply. Lots of places where an acre, which is more than plenty to build shelter on, won't fetch much of anything dollar wise. That is, where regulation allows you to actually buy a small lot in a rural area from the surrounding landowner. Regulation often makes doing that very difficult.
The problem, at least not in a huge country like the USA, isn't population. There is incredible amounts of unused space ripe for housing someone. The problem is being able to build shelters for those people without getting caught up in red tape.
Hardly anyone wants to live in rural areas where land is cheap because there are no good jobs or services nearby. In desirable areas, land acquisition costs are far higher than construction costs. Regulation has little to do with it, although in some areas zoning laws that limit density are a factor.
Desirable areas are expensive because regulation has allowed some people to make vast fortunes, allowing them to spend almost limitlessly on living in those desirable area.
Tech is the prime example of that. Without regulation like that which surrounds intellectual property, software would be quite literally worthless.
And then there are the absurdities. Where I went to school they now have all sorts of fancy places to eat on campus. I can't imagine students paying $4 a couple times a day for a Starbucks coffee when they're paying with borrowed money. This is just grossly irresponsible. I imagine the justification is "but everybody does it". The problem is nobody is teaching the general public anything about managing their money or evaluating costs of anything.
Sure, if you get a good job you can pay off your loan in X years, but that has nothing to do with the fact that you drastically overpaid for what you got (services provided).