News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by wjnc on Friday October 05, 2018 @01:26PM (#18149956)
First guess: not being allowed to admit it due to national security reasons and it being an ongoing investigation. On the same day several Russians were exposed trying to attack OPCW. They were exposed by Dutch military intelligence. At the press briefing the UK ambassador was there. Same day US indicts several Russian spies. This to show that these are major, international events and that proper disclosure towards investors is probably on the back burner as long as operations are continuing. It must be maddening for those involved not to be allowed to discuss it, or even having to actively lie about it while government officials leak freely in the game of thrones.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ABCLAW on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:54PM (#18151662)
I think the NSL angle to the denials is bullshit - the denials themselves give you all you need.

Read the denials carefully. They don't say the attacks haven't happened. They say they haven't found a variety of things.

The apple denial in particular is interesting as it indicates that they have been corresponding with Bloomberg about this issue for a YEAR. Yet despite the magnitude of contact they refer to, they do not describe the nature of the vulnerability being discussed or refer to specific material elements they've refuted. Their statement regarding Bloomberg's most recent version of the facts isn't on material elements of the story.

Having been involved in corporate risk responses I can say I've seen more vehement denials penned with perfect factual accuracy in respect of larger allegations, where the allegations turned out to be true. Almost every statement of defense looks exactly like this, with easy-win half-truth rebuttals to facts peppered around liberally to call the competence of your opposites into question.

Edit: inserted a missing word.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by djrogers on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:01PM (#18151710)
I'm not sure where you're reading the Apple denial you're referring to, but this is *incredibly clear, detailed, and leaves no room to wiggle:

"Apple has never found malicious chips, “hardware manipulations” or vulnerabilities purposely planted in any server. Apple never had any contact with the FBI or any other agency about such an incident. We are not aware of any investigation by the FBI, nor are our contacts in law enforcement."

Also:

"If there were ever such an event as Bloomberg News has claimed, we would be forthcoming about it and we would work closely with law enforcement."

And:

"No one from Apple ever reached out to the FBI about anything like this, and we have never heard from the FBI about an investigation of this kind — much less tried to restrict it."

If you read those as not material, then I'm at a loss as to what exactly would convince you.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ABCLAW on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:27PM (#18151872)
Those aren't clear at all. They're clear to you because you don't see the weasel wording.

"Apple has never found [...]"

So what about third parties/reports/partners/contractors? Have they found anything and is Apple aware of those findings? Not disclosed here.

Are the QC processes in place sufficient to lead us to believe that Apple would/should have found this issue? etc. If not, who cares if they haven't found it.

Before you complain about the semantics, Apple specifically uses the phrasing "We are not aware of any" in respect of investigations, yet they don't use that all-encompassing language in reference to attacks.

"malicious chips, “hardware manipulations” or vulnerabilities purposely planted in any server"

What is a malicious chip - could the inserted piece be classified as non-malicious or simply not a chip? What is a hardware manipulation - are they saying they've literally never found any deviation between spec and what they've received? Why place 'purposely planted' as a qualifying requirement there?

"If there were ever such an event as Bloomberg News has claimed, we would be forthcoming about it and we would work closely with law enforcement."

They don't indicate what was claimed. They reference a volume of correspondence with a variety of claims instead of the claims. We assume, contextually, that they're referring to the specific chip insertion, but that's not borne out by their statement.

"No one from Apple ever reached out to the FBI about anything like this, and we have never heard from the FBI about an investigation of this kind — much less tried to restrict it."

This is fully plausible and means nothing. They restrict their denial of contact with the FBI to outgoing, indicate they haven't received notice of an investigation of some kind, which doesn't mean there's no investigation - collaborating with the FBI specifically on this point wouldn't involve the FBI disclosing the full scope of the investigation to them.

None of these statements actually deal with the issues claimed. They look like they do, but they don't.

Want a real statement? "Upon being notified of the potential issue by Bloomberg this past year, we have analyzed all of the SuperMicro boards referenced to determine if any unauthorized chip insertion occurred and have found none of the alleged inserted chips or any evidence of associated suspicious network activity."

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by djrogers on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:55PM (#18152861)
> So what about third parties/reports/partners/contractors? Have they found anything and is Apple aware of those findings? Not disclosed here. Are the QC processes in place sufficient to lead us to believe that Apple would/should have found this issue? etc. If not, who cares if they haven't found it.

You’re making up new assertions from whole cloth - the original story claimed Apple found the chips then alerted the FBI. Apple explicitly and clearly denies every single aspect of the BW/Bloomberg story, and your objection to their denial is that they didn’t deny actions never presented in the article?

That’s called a straw man, and it doesn’t pass muster...

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by Trombone12 on Saturday October 06, 2018 @12:58PM (#18156036)
If the chip was found by a contractor of Apple then Bloomberg has indeed asserted something that is factually wrong. But it is not a materially important error, and calling it a "new assertion from whole cloth" is severely overstating the magnitude of the error.

If someone that is talking about bash called linux for "a unix", I don't think most people would support your stance that they made completely baseless statement.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ryanlol on Saturday October 06, 2018 @06:36AM (#18154441)
Are the courts not capable of dealing with silly word games?
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ABCLAW on Sunday October 07, 2018 @04:30AM (#18159482)
If they were, you wouldn't spend millions of dollars hiring people like me to play silly word games.

Just for some perspective on how dismissive your comment is imagine the following statement being said in reference to your team: "What do you mean, you had a network breach? Aren't our ops people not capable of dealing with silly 1s and 0s??"

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by 00N8 on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @03:49AM (#18182855)
This is scarier & a lot more plausible than the Bloomberg/Supermicro story I think
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by 9db2nPZp on Saturday October 06, 2018 @09:45AM (#18155094)
Claiming ignorance is the best defense.

It almost feels like Apple tried to bait more information from Bloomberg to identify the person who spilled the beans.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by lern_too_spel on Friday October 05, 2018 @01:41PM (#18150092)
If they are under a gag order, they would simply not comment on it. Lying about it is never required and puts them at risk for shareholder lawsuits.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by stephenr on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:00PM (#18150256)
Apple specifically states that they are not under any form of gag/confidentiality order/conditions:

> Finally, in response to questions we have received from other news organisations since Businessweek published its story, we are not under any kind of gag order or other confidentiality obligations.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by bsder on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:49PM (#18151150)
Apple cannot do anything bad to China or their manufacturing stops.

Apple would have to move tens of thousands of highly specific CNC machines from China to somewhere else, set them up, and get their line moving again.

This is why I find the idea that Apple phones are "secure" to laughable on its face. China could kill years of Apple revenue if they ever did something truly offensive to the ruling party.

Apple would roll over post haste if China demanded it.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by Yoyoyou on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:17PM (#18151372)
China could cause huge harm to Apple, but the reverse is also true - how would the US government, other corporations, consumers and investors react to such a news?

The ultimate source of most Chinese factory equipment is Europe and US anyway, under extreme political/consumer pressure electronics factories can be setup in a matter of months in US.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by bsder on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:28PM (#18151452)
> China could cause huge harm to Apple, but the reverse is also true - how would the US government, other corporations, consumers and investors react to such a news?

They would react as usual: lots of whingeing, no action, and roll over for a belly scratch afterward.

> under extreme political/consumer pressure electronics factories can be setup in a matter of months in US.

It takes 9 months to make a baby no matter how many women you get pregnant ...

Many of these equipment manufacturers have entire facilities dedicated to producing equipment solely for Apple. They simply cannot replace that amount of equipment in any timely fashion.

Edit (external reference): http://www.iphonehacks.com/2016/10/next-iphone-probably-wont....

> Koenig writes. “Apple is such a huge buyer of a particular kind of mill (BT30 spindle drill-tap centers) that Fanuc, Brother and DMG Mori each have factories dedicated to building machines exclusively for Apple.”

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by teknologist on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:26PM (#18151435)
Not just the factories. Access to the market.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by frankharv on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:24PM (#18151421)
You could move every CNC machine from the manufacturing line and it would not matter.

These sneaky chips were embedded in the PCB. So this is a supplier trust issue.

Plus they probably did not implant every board, So somebody inside FoxConn had to slip in these 'special' pcb's in known Apple mobo orders..

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by frankharv on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:34PM (#18151926)
I am assuming that the PCB's are contracted out. It would be interesting to see where the PCB's came from.

One side of me feels real bad for SuperMicro. The have always been there for the small guys that like to build our own servers and for small OEM shops.

Who else are the real server mobo competitors?

Gigabyte and AsrockRack from my view and they are a very distant second and third place.

If SuperMicro goes down we all lose and IBM, HPE and Dell gains.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by Tempest1981 on Saturday October 06, 2018 @11:47AM (#18155710)
The original Bloomberg article mentions subcontractor use in this paragraph, but not names:

“As recently as 2016, according to DigiTimes, a news site specializing in supply chain research, Supermicro had three primary manufacturers constructing its motherboards, two headquartered in Taiwan and one in Shanghai. When such suppliers are choked with big orders, they sometimes parcel out work to subcontractors. In order to get further down the trail, U.S. spy agencies drew on the prodigious tools at their disposal. They sifted through communications intercepts, tapped informants in Taiwan and China, even tracked key individuals through their phones, according to the person briefed on evidence gathered during the probe. Eventually, that person says, they traced the malicious chips to four subcontracting factories that had been building Supermicro motherboards for at least two years.”

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by teknologist on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:23PM (#18151415)
Right, it's worth remembering that Apple deals with lawsuits all the time. All costs and benefits considered, it's probably the best option for them to lie about this for now, and plausible deniability is always a possibility ("at the time of writing, Apple PR were not aware of x, y and z"). The cost of losing access to the gigantic China market and its manufacturing operations would be much too great.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ryanmarsh on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:38PM (#18151547)
Could they say if they were?
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by eridius on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:13PM (#18151795)
No. But gag orders do not require the recipient to lie about it. Someone who is under a gag order simply doesn't comment one way or the other about it.

FWIW this is the principle behind warrant canaries. A warrant canary is the practice of putting a statement such as "we have not received any NSLs" in a regular report, and then omitting it once you have received an NSL. Because you've conditioned people to expect its presence, its absence then serves as a signal that you likely have received one (though not proof, as there are other reasons you may have removed it, such as being advised by your lawyer that it's a bad idea as the courts may not look favorably on the idea that, no, you weren't actually violating your gag order, you were technically saying nothing, given that you set up the conditions yourself such that saying nothing is in fact saying something).

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by derefr on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:30PM (#18152790)
What happens when you're legally obligated to comment? Like, if you receive an NSL about something, and then later are subpoenaed/compelled to testify before a grand jury or judicial inquest about that same thing?

Neither grand juries nor coroners "outrank" the Executive (unlike Congress, who I would assume can just throw out the NSL to get testimony, since they have similar powers, like throwing out a document's top-secret classified status to get it read into the public record.) But in both situations, you can still be found in contempt of court if you just say "no comment."

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by kpil on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:33PM (#18152272)
I'm pretty sure that this strategy won't hold up in court.

If you have a sign that indicates that a secret event have not happened, the intent of removing the sign is to indicate that the secret event did happen.

The intent is particularly obvious to the originator of the secret event, so you won't be able to argue in the court that it was entirely coincidental.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by astrange on Saturday October 06, 2018 @07:46AM (#18154641)
Warrant canaries have reasonable precedent in the US because of the First Amendment. See New York Times Co. v. United States.

This isn't true and they probably don't work in any other country in the world. They're explicitly illegal in Australia, apparently.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by joesb on Sunday October 07, 2018 @11:51PM (#18164011)
On the other hand, if I actually have a sign indicates that some secret event have not happened, how can I remove that sign if I truely believe I don't wanna keep telling the world that it have not happened?

If I remove the sign just because I no longer want to keep the sign up and someone takes it to mean that the secret event did happen, when it really didn't happen, do they have ground to sue me for fraud or lying?

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by iambateman on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:48PM (#18153215)
I agree.

Could you have a canary community that calls companies once/quarter and specifically asks the NSL question? Seems safer for the companies themselves.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by astrange on Saturday October 06, 2018 @07:47AM (#18154645)
The legal system doesn't appreciate cleverness and you get negative points for trying. Either everything would work or nothing will.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by stephenr on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:49PM (#18151623)
If they were, and couldn't say so, it's unlikely they would specifically say they aren't, they would say nothing about it.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by amoshi on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:25PM (#18151002)
And if they were, you think they would admit it?
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by avip on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:39PM (#18151085)
They would not have blatantly lied about it in an official statement. That could not have passed legal.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ABCLAW on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:27PM (#18152244)
You don't need to blatantly lie to author a rebuttal that doesn't actual rebut the claims against you.

You accuse me of selling pink and purple unicorns to gangsters. I reply that "I have no knowledge of any contracts or agreements relating to the sale of unicorns, horses or horse-related animals from my firm, regardless of the colour, breed or condition of the animals. I categorically also deny having any business dealings with any entity which has been charged on racketeering or any other gang related offenses.

The reality being that I 'rent' pink and purple unicorns to Don Corleone for absurd amounts, then don't revendicate when payments stop.

My rebuttal looks sweeping. I put in language to make it look like the scope of my denial is wide ranging and complete. In fact, I intentionally disclaim things you didn't claim to make it look like the moat of propriety surrounding me is vast.

But it isn't. I did what was claimed. And I didn't lie in my rebuttal.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by CamperBob2 on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:49PM (#18153410)
The problem with your arguments throughout this thread is simple: if a rebuttal is clearly engineered to be deceptive, the courts will not regard it as a valid defense in any subsequent lawsuits from shareholders and customers. That's why rebuttals and denials are normally so vague.

Courts have surprisingly little tolerance for companies who think they're being more clever than their customers, their shareholders, or, for that matter, the judge.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ABCLAW on Sunday October 07, 2018 @04:27AM (#18159472)
I'd love if that were the reality, but it isn't. A judge will scrutinize a party they believe is acting in bad faith (this is a term of art, but I'm using it in the lay sense here), but you won't show that a party is acting in bad faith because they were linguistically precise during a statement of defense.

You'll show they're acting in bad faith if documentary evidence shows they're baddies.

The theory behind our court system is one thing. The reality is another.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by CamperBob2 on Sunday October 07, 2018 @06:50PM (#18163056)

     "No one from Apple ever reached out to the FBI about 
     anything like this," Apple writes. "We have never heard 
     from the FBI about an investigation of this kind."
With language like this, it's the very definition of bad faith if they're lying. These are specific assurances that directly contradict the Bloomberg reporters in specific ways, and the companies know that people are likely to rely on them to their detriment.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by zanmat0 on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:49PM (#18151151)
Aren't they required to do so in the context of a NSL?
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by djrogers on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:04PM (#18151738)
No, they are not required to provide materially false information in direct violation of SarbOx, the SEC, and several other federal agencies and statutes - not to mention the various EU laws surrounding such activity.

If they were under an NSL they would simply not comment on this at all. That would be pretty normal for Apple, so people would probably take it in stride.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ocschwar on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:26PM (#18151863)
No. THere's plenty of case law establishing that you cannot be compelled to outright lie.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by Arbitrary4657 on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:52PM (#18151644)
Most of Apple's "creative image" is one gigantic lie. Why would they suddenly have scruples now?
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by lozaning on Friday October 05, 2018 @01:52PM (#18150178)
I wonder if there isn't some level of national security super mega secret scenario situation where the government requires companies to do something and the government indemnifies them against all risks associated with the required action.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by rrix2 on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:00PM (#18150253)
How does the USG indemnify these companies for the massive breach of trust if that's indeed the case? You can't pay for trust.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ryanmarsh on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:39PM (#18151553)
I would be highly surprised if this wasn’t the case.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by trhway on Friday October 05, 2018 @01:58PM (#18150238)
hasn't it been the case with NSA and carriers all along?

http://articles.latimes.com/2012/oct/09/business/la-fi-court...

"Congress granted retroactive immunity to people or companies aiding U.S. intelligence agents."

In this case i'd not be surprised if Google/FB/AMZN/Apple/MS/Supermicro were even part of the CIA/NSA counter-sting - feeding of the false info back to Chinese intelligence through the detected 'mistery' chips.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by lern_too_spel on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:01PM (#18150262)
The carriers never lied about it. They were provided immunity from criminal lawsuits, not civil lawsuits.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by rossdavidh on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:27PM (#18151014)
Are you sure about that? I recall reading, in reference to canary clauses (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary) that the government can and has required lying. If there's an ongoing national security concern, I would expect that they would.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by gowld on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:46PM (#18151131)
The article you linked is primarily a disproof of your claim.

It cites some hearsay speculation that Warrant Canaries are illegal, and cites several court cases that say Warrant Canaries are protected and compelled lies are illegal: "West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette and Wooley v. Maynard rule the Free Speech Clause prohibits compelling someone to speak against one's wishes; this can easily be extended to prevent someone from being compelled to lie."

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by cjarrett on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:51PM (#18151633)
--no. That's not how this works.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by walshemj on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:55PM (#18150755)
In all cases? possibly not if it is covered by national security.
Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by matt4077 on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:43PM (#18152825)
The press release specifically said that they are not under any sort of order preventing any disclosure.

And while it is indeed possible for the government to make you stay quiet, forcing you to lie is considered compelled speech, which is a fundamental aspect of current thinking on the 1st Amendment, and not something that is likely to change. No, not even when a three-letter agency wants it.

Also nobody at the either the NSA nor Apple cares about the sort of everyday world news you're mentioning. Maybe lay of the Tom Clancy for a while?

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ryanmarsh on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:38PM (#18151544)
not being allowed to admit it due to national security reasons

Came here to say this. When I read Amazon’s rebuttal my gut said “what if these folks had to respond but weren’t allowed to tell the truth?”. If the allegations went unanswered it could be damaging to Amazon and tip the hand of the spooks. If they answered and said they did find the devices the story could run away from them, the internet mob is good at writing articles with “problematic” in the title.

Still I think this was a calculated leak. Why? Probably to put pressure on China in negotiations.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by ocschwar on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:29PM (#18151890)
Amazon Web Services is the one branch of AMZN that is actually profitable.

And the make or break for AWS is the assurance that when you're runnign stuff on one Amazon pizza box, your data are safe even from other users on that same box.

You HAVE to get your assurance from Amazon if you're a corporate customer, for due diligence reasons. If that assurance is established to be a lie, every single corporate customer they have would be obliged to migrate to MSFT/RHAT/GOOG or elsewhere. AWS would be dead.

I would say it's a calculated leak that happens to be materially false, meant to pressure CHina and kicj Bezos in the shin.

Re:Making sense of the alleged Supermicro motherboard attack by WillPostForFood on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:28PM (#18151877)
Bloomberg specifically says some of their sources are senior national security officials from the Obama administration, and the conversations date back to the Obama administration. It doesn't make sense they would have been planning this leak for years in anticipation of Trump winning and a trade war with China.