The rest of your post aside, the FBI cannot do that. It wouldn't matter if it was secret. It's not even a close call, it's been explicitly and repeatedly slammed down by courts even in extreme cases like classified information being illegitimately leaked, for example with the Pentagon Papers (SCOTUS ruling [1] against prior restraint). It just came up again a few months ago when a federal judge tried to use prior restraint and depublishing against the LA Times over their publication of information about a confidential informant and bargain that was accidentally published in full on PACER. A rung bell cannot be unrung.
Now, if the FBI could find a leaker who had signed an agreement with the Federal government they could go after them in person. If a newspaper broke the law to obtain a story then that separate violation could independently be prosecutable (in public). But none of that means the publicly released information can then be taken back. And even if some random blogger might be intimidated illegally and not find the resources to fight back, that wouldn't be an issue for a major publication.
I don't take issue with your skepticism in general but it's not helpful to ascribe special powers to government that it doesn't actually have either.
-----
1: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/403/713#writin...
Control the media conglomerates, lobby as control over the internet, control the sentiment.
Like, say, the matter of secret surveillance on the mass scale? I mean, the track record here is not exactly pristine.
> Bloomberg didn't do their due diligence and were too eager
That is a distinct possibility too. But I think we are now beyond the point where we could say "major tech companies would never lie together with the US security apparatus on a matter of public importance". They would, if they think it's worth it.
This is just conspiracy theory thinking. You offer no evidence for this incredible assertion. Some companies have previously collaborated with the government, generally without explicitly lying, but we cannot jump to the conclusion that all companies would voluntarily lie in a coverup conspiracy -- which, by the way, opens them up to investor lawsuits and risks destroying their branding, for no good reason. We also do know that the government cannot legally compel companies to lie, only to remain silent.
> You offer no evidence for this incredible assertion.
The evidence to the above is publicly available and has been discussed to death. If you somehow managed to miss all of it, start with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance_in_the_Unite... and go on the links from there, it will take you some time.
> Some companies have previously collaborated with the government, generally without explicitly lying,
Yes, saying "we do not conduct this particular kind of surveillance ordered by this particular person" while knowing they conduct a slightly different kind of surveillance, ordered by different set of persons - is not explicitly lying. Just like saying "we don't have surveillance technology installed by FBI" if it's installed by NSA instead. There are many ways of lying without "explicitly lying".
> but we cannot jump to the conclusion that all companies would voluntarily lie in a coverup conspiracy
We can not and we do not. We do not know whether any specific company would lie - we just know this option is now very much on the table.
> which, by the way, opens them up to investor lawsuits and risks destroying their branding, for no good reason.
Being on good terms with somebody as powerful as US federal government is a very, very good reason. And I don't see anybody's branding being destroyed so far by the revelation of mass surveillance. We know about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemisphere_Project - has AT&T brand been destroyed? Not in the least. And the government granted them immunity from lawsuits related to this.
The PRISM denials were not vague and were perfectly true. PRISM was a system for handling subpoenas, and nobody denies getting subpoenas. If you ask e.g. Facebook they also won't deny proactively reporting child abuse to the FBI, which is another real US legal requirement.
Furthermore, the argument against this would be that (from the denials PRs) Bloomberg has been approaching the involved parties for "several years."
Why would they decide to pull the trigger now simply from haste?
There remains no evidence that any companies lied about secret surveillance on a mass scale.
Also, these companies want to continue to do business in China, and likely do not want to be on the record accusing the government of a massive criminal conspiracy.
Outright lying is financial suicide. Shareholders can and will sue the company.
"Apple never had any contact with the FBI or any other agency about such an incident." If Incident was being handled by 3d party private entity which was in contact with some gov entity this would hold true.
"We are not aware of any investigation by the FBI, nor are our contacts in law enforcement." If it was contacted by entity other than FBI this would hold true.
If it's made up, it's more realistic to believe the publication is complicit in the fabrication.
Could it be a conspiracy to deceive Bloomberg? From all the conspiracies, that seems the most likely to me.
Silence would be perceived as confirmation, and claiming to not know would be terrifying to their customers. Confirming it would risk their entire supply chain.
Sure, maybe it's not true... but the only move here is to deny it even if it were true. The corporations involved have a massive amount to lose here.
They describe a microcontroller the size of a decoupling capacitor that is installed between the main CPU and main memory (as far as I can tell from the vague description).
I assume this would have to be done without layout changes. On a part of the board that is quite sensitive to layout changes. It just doesn’t seem likely that you’d do a hack like this. You’d need a micro controller or ASIC that was running as fast as main memory. You’d need to make it cope with different kernels... and edit memory such that remote servers could reliablely be contacted.
Why not just swap out some other part? Like the IPMI controller? Or the Ethernet controller? Something that has access to main memory, that would hide the functionality even better, and that would give the attacker more space to work with?
I don’t get it.
If the chip is inserted on the serial data line between the SPI flash memory and the BMC CPU, then, as an ex-InfoSec engineer, the whole thing sounds very plausible and even easy IMHO...
You have to expect that any article about intricate tech details written for a general audience will get parts of their descriptions wrong. Like you I was raising my eyebrows when I started reading. But when they mentioned the BMC, I believed. The author did not make a vague mistake when mentioning this very specific technical term.
In fact, the BMC is the perfect target for such a hardware hack: low-speed SPI flash memory interface easy to man-in-the-middle, BMC more privileged than the OS (can virtualize storage, keyboard, etc), BMC code independent of the OS (infect both Linux and Windows at once), BMC code changes so rarely that a backdoor making assumptions about the code layout and content would still work after many years of updates, etc.
Edit: I checked Supermicro servers from the 2015 era. Most used the AST2400 BMC. It boots from SPI flash so this backdoor chip only has to intercept and modify bytes on the data out (DO) line to inject malicious code.
AST2400 has option for two spi memories, one overrides the other by default. They simply put a microscopic spi flash in place of the second "recovery" flash.
I heard before the rumors of Chinese server mobos "talking" some gibberish on ICMP, so that must be it.
It might be interesting to try and reach out to that person, they may still have the hardware.
[1] https://communities.intel.com/thread/123362
Edit: the mobo in that post is the X11SPH-nCTF, which has the AST2500 BMC
If China did this, kudos to them, in the sense that that's their job. Just like it is NSA's to do the same to them.
Apple, Google, Microsoft, Intel, FB and a few other companies can probably match China's expertise and expenditure. What about the rest?
They've also had accounting irregularities that caused their stock to be delisted from NASDAQ: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/08/22/supermicro_facing_n...
> "The delay primarily relates to the magnitude of work that the company must still perform in order to review the company's accounting judgements, estimates and records for transactions that occurred during fiscal year 2015 through 2017, as well as the assessments and conclusions on the effectiveness of its internal control over financial reporting."
It's interesting that the irregularities started in 2015.
The vigorous denials from Apple and Amazon are suspiciously against the grain in these situations.
If you compare to MSFT etc whenever there is a "global cyber incident" the story is the same and correlates with the governments etc which is business as usual.
This is not business as usual.
It's either a giant conspiracy by the FBI and multiple mega-corporations to blatantly lie, on public record, about a matter that if happened would most likely come up in the future again. Furthermore if apple and amazon were both notified for comments, there is good reason to suspect that the FBI would hear of the article and try to censor such an article for national security reasons, especially so if they made apple and amazon lie about it.
Or ... Bloomberg didn't do their due diligence and were too eager to be duped by agents who wanted to push an agenda to move manufacturing away from china or something similar.