News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:43AM (#18137929)
Meh.

On the one hand, I'm against tracking everyone, everywhere. On the other hand, I'm totally for ALPRs dispensing indiscriminate justice on people violating speed limits. I wish we could have auditable, trustworthy ALPR boxes that only report speed violations to be immediately turned into tickets, and don't store license plate numbers of people who follow the law.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by ubernostrum on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:24AM (#18138089)
Be careful what you wish for.

Red-light cameras in the US opened up all sorts of issues nobody thought about when they were just "totally for" ticketing people who ran red lights. We got issues like local governments tinkering with timing of traffic lights in order to increase the number of violations, because violations are lucrative and who wants to defend red-light runners? People who run red lights are bad people who do dangerous things, and they should be punished!

There are also the ongoing studies into whether red-light cameras actually increase collisions, by incentivizing people to stop unsafely.

And that's without getting into the due-process issues, or the way offenses start creeping into more expensive categories (see California cities which have been "upcoding" various other offenses, like rolling turns, into full-on red-light violations in order to collect larger fines).

Speed limits have a number of notorious issues; they tend to be set for political, rather than safety, reasons, and very few US jurisdictions actually follow the general best practice of setting limits based on 85th-percentile speeds. Some smaller towns infamously derive almost all of their municipal budget from running speed traps (i.e., a 55mph highway passes by, the town annexes a tiny strip of it and sets a far lower temporary limit, then tickets as many unsuspecting drivers as possible). What you're asking for is to industrialize all of those issues.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by LitFan on Thursday October 04, 2018 @10:34AM (#18140220)
Some anecdata for this: There is one intersection on my drive into work with a red light camera. There is also one on the way home.

Without fail, whenever I approach one of those intersections on a green light where the pedestrian signal has changed to a flashing hand, at least one car slows down.

I have seen people stop at a green light where the pedestrian signal is a solid hand (meaning the light will change to yellow soon).

Acting in an unexpected way is a recipe for an accident.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by btrettel on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:41PM (#18141477)
How common are the issues you mention? I hear a lot more complaints from drivers having to pay legitimate sounding speeding tickets than I do bogus tickets. In fact, I can't think of a single instance of anyone I know who got a speeding ticket that wasn't legitimate. Corruption in the process of enforcing the law is not inevitable too.

I also am not comfortable calling the "85th percentile" rule a best practice. Seems like a moving target that has more to do with perceived safety than actual safety. Here's someone else's take: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/1/25/speed-kills-so...

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by ubernostrum on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:41PM (#18143477)
First of all, it's useful to distinguish two types of roads: those which are controlled-access exclusively for motorized vehicles, and those which are not.

Much of what you're trying to do is impose one-size-fits-all enforcement on both types. Controlled-access roads forbid pedestrians and bicycles, so arguments about protecting pedestrians and bicyclists on those roads fall flat. They should be using 85th-percentile metrics, in combination with the known design speed of the road, to set limits. But because controlled-access roads tend to have higher speeds, they're also the most tempting targets on which to run speed traps (i.e., if you can set a stretch of road to 25mph when the rest of it is 55mph, and park a hidden camera or cop right at the boundary, you can make a lot of money for your municipal budget, and precisely zero dollars of it will have been justified by increased "safety").

For the non-controlled-access roads, most of the real solutions the strongtowns/walkable/bikable/etc. movements want are going to come down to radically different infrastructure which have nothing whatsoever to do with speed limits. Speed limits are at best a non sequitur there.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by btrettel on Thursday October 04, 2018 @05:07PM (#18143683)
I don't think you are responding to what I wrote. I never suggested a one-size-fits-all approach.

I don't think the 85th percentile rule is entirely bad, just not a "best practice", which sounds to me like "one-size-fits-all". The Strong Towns post I linked to said it makes sense for highways as I recall, which seems perfectly consistent with what you wrote.

Anyway, to reiterate, I am still interested in knowing how frequently speed cameras and the like are used poorly. The only uses of speed cameras that come to mind in my experience were not on "controlled-access" roads and seem justified to me. In fact, I rode my bike several times on one road with a speed camera that many drivers whined about back when I lived on the east coast. It was not uncommon for people to drive 15 mph or more over the speed limit there, despite the pedestrians. If I recall correctly the speed camera was added before a pedestrian crossing.

Edit: What I am recalling was actually multiple cameras on multiple roads. http://www.gazette.net/stories/12092010/laurnew185647_32536....

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by mehrdadn on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:33AM (#18138127)
Links would be great here, but thank you for the eye-opening comment.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by HarryHirsch on Thursday October 04, 2018 @05:04AM (#18138252)
The town of Waldo, FL made the headlines a few years back: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/florida-town-infamous-for-speed...

You'd like to invoke Florida Man, but plenty of small jurisdictions rely on the income stream from fines. Ferguson, MO comes to mind. The police fleecing blacks and out-of-towners, it does wonders for the perception of the law.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by adrianN on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:55AM (#18137978)
I really don't understand why we don't enforce speed limits more rigorously. We have the technology to do this at basically zero cost and speeding is one of the main causes of death on the road. Especially in residential areas where pedestrians and cyclists are around even moderate speeding dramatically increases the chances of deadly accidents. Doing 30mph instead of 20mph increases the chance of death for pedestrians from 5% to 45%. [1]

[1] http://www.humantransport.org/sidewalks/SpeedKills.htm

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by saagarjha on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:06AM (#18138018)
The real issue I have is that speed limits are selectively and arbitrarily enforced. This basically means that most people just end up breaking the law anyways and it allows law enforcement a convenient excuse to find a reason to fault someone.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by sschueller on Thursday October 04, 2018 @05:19AM (#18138319)
Here in Switzerland we have a lot of speed cameras and they are ruthless. 3km/h (1.9mph) over and you get a ticket in some areas. They are fully automated and ticket is automatically sent to the owner of the vehicle by mail. There are units in the city that bring in more than a 1 million a year each. The trend in deadly accidents is downwards but it's probably not only due to the massive fines.

A lot of the city has been reduce to 30km/h (18.5 mph) zones which drivers hate but makes it a lot safer for pedestrians.

[1] https://www.watson.ch/schweiz/strasse/861871246-in-welchen-s...

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by eps on Thursday October 04, 2018 @07:03AM (#18138781)
In many cantons there's an "error" allowance of 5 km/h when issuing a speed ticket. If the speed limit is 50, you won't get a ticket unless you were at 56 or more. This is done to account for car's speedometer inaccuracy.

One principal difference is Swiss traffic controls, at least in French-speaking parts, is that they prevent intersections of traffic flows. E.g. you can't turn left on a green that allows going straight unless cars in the opposite direction are held by the red. That is, if you are following the signs and lights, you will simply not have a chance to run into another car going in some other direction.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by raverbashing on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:36AM (#18138136)
Because speed limits are mostly arbitrary, your speedometer might be not as accurate as you expect and it's very easy to set a "speed trap"

Driving 50% over the limit is dangerous, fining people for going 2mph over is just "creating revenue".

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by adrianN on Thursday October 04, 2018 @05:58AM (#18138486)
If you feel that your speedometer is not accurate you can always err on the side of safety and drive a little slower than allowed. Perhaps your brakes or your reaction time aren't as good as you think either. Besides, typical radar traps have an error of around 3km/h or 3%, whatever is larger, so it's unlikely that your speedometer is wrong enough to matter.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by dsego on Thursday October 04, 2018 @05:43AM (#18138413)
Isn't there always some error margin. I know in my country it's something like +10kph +10%. Then the 130kph limit on the motorway becomes 154kph.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by paganel on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:02AM (#18138501)
> I really don't understand why we don't enforce speed limits more rigorously.

Not sure how things are in the States but over here in Eastern Europe there are lots and lots of stupid speed limit signs, I call them "stupid" because if you were to follow them literally (instead of going with the traffic flow) then most probably you'd cause accidents for being an obstacle on the road.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by qrbLPHiKpiux on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:49AM (#18138718)
There is a highway here that is engineered for 80 mph and the speed limit is 55. It is painful to drive on it.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by mehrdadn on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:08AM (#18138028)
> Doing 30mph instead of 20mph increases the chance of death for pedestrians from 5% to 45%.

What is this metric supposed to imply though? We obviously have roads with limits above 30mph already, so clearly decisions aren't made based on merely chance-of-death-assuming-a-collision being too high.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by adrianN on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:12AM (#18138044)
This metric is supposed to imply that "it's only ten over" is not a valid excuse to speed in residential areas. Unless you assume that 20mph limits are just there for fun and not because it's an area where it's likely that a pedestrian crosses the road unexpectedly or where you share the road with cyclists.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by mehrdadn on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:18AM (#18138067)
I guess what I was trying to get at was that you need to also consider the likelihood of collision in the first place. I'd assume that's also higher in residential areas -- not sure if it's just me, but I think that would sound like a far more compelling argument than just considering the chance of death assuming a collision.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by mprev on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:11AM (#18138042)
They’re based on chance of collision with a pedistrian and, in the UK at least, on that stretch of road’s history of such incidents.

So the figure shows that if there are more pedestrians likely to get in the way of your car then you should drive more slowly if you care about not killing those people.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by NeedMoreTea on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:52AM (#18138208)
The biggest problem with UK limits is when they reduce a limit for an unrepresentative peak in accidents.

When the figures regress to mean next year or two it's taken as proof the new limit was correct. So we slowly deviate from the 85th percentile rule, and get weird stretches of dual carriageway at 30 or 40 with a speed camera in the middle.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by eecc on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:45AM (#18138164)
Often, lowering the limit is another option when dealing with road maintenance: can’t be bothered fixing one? Bump the limit down to 30km/h (car gearboxes aren’t even designed to drive at these speeds for long any more) and call it a day. If shit happens it’s someone else’s fault
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by eps on Thursday October 04, 2018 @10:12AM (#18140026)
> car gearboxes aren’t even designed to drive at these speeds for long any more

This makes no sense. Source?

Besides, 30 kmh limit is exceedingly common in European cities.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by tombrossman on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:12AM (#18138540)
Auditability is important, especially given how wildly inaccurate* some of these 'speed detection' machines are. Most of the ones I have seen are pretty close, but some are clearly malfunctioning and would basically generate speeding tickets for 100% of the vehicles passing them until they are fixed.

*https://i.imgur.com/NF6eYb9.jpg

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by Jmcdd on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:46AM (#18137942)
Don't forget stolen, untaxed, and uninsured vehicles too