Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Animats on Sunday September 30, 2018 @03:49AM
(#18105086)
The trouble is this thing: "BaoFeng BF-F8HP (UV-5R 3rd Gen) 8-Watt Dual Band Two-Way Radio (136-174Mhz VHF & 400-520Mhz UHF) Includes Full Kit"[1] This cheap radio is sold as a "ham radio", and requires a ham license. Large numbers of non-hams are using it in the GMRS service at higher power levels than allowed. It's popular with "preppers", even though it's not very rugged, is complicated to use, tends not to put out as much power as claimed, and the battery tends to come loose.[2] The FCC's concern is that it allows 8 watt blithering over a wide range of frequencies by people with no clue how to use it properly. There are GMRS radios made for hunters which are much more suitable for wilderness use - waterproof and easy to use.[3]
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Stratoscope on Sunday September 30, 2018 @04:39AM
(#18105205)
Don't single out the BF-F8HP as if it were the radio the FCC is talking about. There are many similar radios made by Baofeng, AnyTone, TYT, Wouxun, and other manufacturers.
By "similar" I mean "capable of transmitting outside the amateur bands." The radios are all different, but this is the point they have in common. (FWIW, the BF-F8HP is one of the nicer Baofengs, not just for the extra power but because it comes with a much better antenna than the cheapest models.)
The current point of confusion is that the FCC seems to be saying that amateur operators can no longer legally use a radio within the ham bands if that radio is even capable of transmitting on another frequency, unless the radio is type certified for whatever other frequency that might be.
This of course is ridiculous. It goes completely against the way the FCC has always regulated amateur radio. Hams have always been allowed to build their own equipment and to repurpose military or commercial radios to use in the ham bands.
It's fairly shocking that the FCC would change their views on this so suddenly. If true, it means that radios hams have bought and used legally are suddenly illegal. I have to believe that there is some misunderstanding at the bottom of all this.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Lucky225 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @05:58PM
(#18108665)
100% the point of my post thank you. I'd also add to your sentence "it means that radios hams have bought and used legally" is a misnomer under this interpretation, in the FCC's eyes they've been using them illegally since the inception of the Communications Act.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by lightlyused on Sunday September 30, 2018 @07:06AM
(#18105663)
I really don't think the wide transmit range is a problem, the real issue is that the transmitters are dirty, they have unacceptable spurious emissions: https://imgur.com/a/up2ne.
I hope and suspect the truth is "this radio cannot be legally used by a ham operator without further cleaning it up because it is so dirty" and that this got morphed into "this radio cannot be legally used by a ham operator because it isn't certified."
The whole idea of ham certification is to prove that you can take responsibility for your own radio waves so as to relax the otherwise enormous regulatory burden on people trying to experiment and innovate on their own. If the FCC has actually reversed course on this, they are going against not only a century+ of tradition but the very spirit of the program itself.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Lucky225 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @06:00PM
(#18108673)
This is true, but the REASON the FCC is giving for the ban (since part 97 doesn't require certification, and such problems could in theory be brought back into compliance using bandpass filters and thus still be legal) is they are capable of wide transmit outside amateur.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by codys on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:29PM
(#18135355)
More than just "using it for GMRS service": the real issue is that most purchasers of these radios leave the channel configuration in the shipped default, which tends to overlap with a bunch of public safety and commercial frequencies.
If the default channels in these were GMRS, despite the lack of legality in their use on GMRS, I expect there would be much less activity in responding to the problem.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by gaius on Sunday September 30, 2018 @07:15AM
(#18105684)
It's popular with "preppers"
Every Airsofter I see has a Baofeng in an imitation Harris casing and freely uses it in their games. None of them have ham licenses. The spectrum is regulated for reasons, but there seems to be zero enforcement. This is in the UK.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by stefan_ on Sunday September 30, 2018 @03:59PM
(#18108057)
The ham radio spectrum is specifically regulated to require training because you will be using uncertified radio equipment that can communicate on whatever band you want, not just the ham radio ones.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by lima on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:52AM
(#18106393)
This is clearly a misunderstanding of the relevant laws on the part of the FCC. I have yet to see any HAM radio transceiver that is not capable of transmitting outside the HAM radio bands - many of them DIY devices with no certifications whatsoever, which is the whole point of being a HAM radio operator. This interpretation would outlaw 99% of all HAM radio transceivers. Of course, it's not legal to actually transmit on anything but the HAM radio bands, but a HAM radio operator is certainly allowed to operate it on the HAM radio bands.
HAM radio is a very special kind of spectrum user - other than any other radio service, there is no requirement for devices to be commercially certified, with the burden of ensuring safe operation being placed on the operators rather than the manufacturers (in the early days, most tranceivers were of the DIY variety). This is why there's a hard technical exam - you have to prove that you're capable of building and verifying your own transceiver.
At least in Europe, this is codified by law with no room for interpretation, and I would be quite surprised if it were any different in the US (HAM radio laws are pretty much the same everywhere thanks to international harmonization treaties).
That being said: These Baofeng transceivers are a nuisance and the earlier generations are rightfully banned in multiple countries for having poor output filters with strong harmonics all over the place - it would not be legal to operate one of these even on the HAM radio bands, by a HAM radio operator. At our local HAM radio club, a few members actually added extra filters to theirs to make them usable.
I'm all for cracking down on the use of these by non-licensed operators, since it's extremely easy to interfere with legitimate services like weather fax and emergency service communications, even if you're not actually using their frequency. Preventing this is exactly the FCCs job.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by soneil on Sunday September 30, 2018 @11:01PM
(#18109735)
I don't think this pertains to homebrew at all, they're covered separately under part 15.23.
The bigger worry is modified devices - devices that would have had a type-acceptance, but it's been invalidated by the operator. They'd be a grey area that becomes a much darker shade of grey under this interpretation.
It does bring to mind a specific example I'd be morbidly curious in; the Icom M802 is a marine HF/SSB set that's popular in small craft. It has a neat trick where if you hold a specific set of buttons while you power it on, it can be operated in the amateur bands (until it's powered off, then it falls back to the factory behaviour).
Under this interpretation, that'd no longer be legal? Since the operator has invalidated the part80 type-acceptance by enticing the unit to transmit outside of its intended bands, it can no longer be operated (by a ham operator) in the ham bands?
Under my current understanding you'd need both an (unrestricted) radiotelegaph or radiotelephone operator's license to be allowed to adjust a part80 transmitter in a way that'd affect it's proper operation; plus a technician (or above) amateur endorsement to actually operate it in this mode, to do this legally. Under this (new?) interpretation, that's still not enough to be trusted?
(A rather long-winded example, but one close to my heart. I believe it's one of the reasons this particular model lost its type-certification in Europe.)
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Stratoscope on Sunday September 30, 2018 @12:02PM
(#18106698)
Thank you for the excellent analysis.
Just one nitpick for the benefit of any non-hams who are reading this thread and may wonder: it's usually spelled "ham", not "HAM", as it is just an ordinary word, not an acronym.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by madengr on Sunday September 30, 2018 @12:11PM
(#18106743)
Yeah, but I think the difference is DIY is not selling the radios. I had a DJ-580T 25 years ago that I modded for out of band transmission. That is legal for personal use, but I can’t sell those.
Same with scanners that access the old AMPS band. You can modify it, but you can’t buy a modded radio.
Ah, the good old days of getting radio mods via BBS.
Now if it’s “test equipment” it’s the Wild West. All my SDRs can transmit to 6 GHz, but it’s not something for consumer use. Hope it stays that way.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by lima on Sunday September 30, 2018 @04:37PM
(#18108264)
Not sure why you got downvoted?
IMO, it would be reasonable to ban these mass-market ham radio transceivers like the ones mentioned in the article (Switzerland banned most of them). 99% of the people buying them aren't ham radio operators, and their output filters are so bad that you need to mod them to make them acceptable.
> Now if it’s “test equipment” it’s the Wild West. All my SDRs can transmit to 6 GHz, but it’s not something for consumer use. Hope it stays that way.
That's how it was with model airplanes, before the big drone hype happened - there was a small community of experienced people who would play by the rules and police themselves.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by franga2000 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @08:52AM
(#18105961)
I could maybe understand not allowing non-hams to own such radios - you really can't trust any random person not to do dumb shit like transmit garbage on emergency frequencies, but the whole reason ham licenses exist is to prove to the government that you know how to properly, safely and legally operate a radio. The FCC has gone too far on this one (they seem to do that a lot...).
I just hope this doesn't get picked up by some moron from the EU. They've already fucked up our Internet. Please, don't take away my garbage ebay radio too.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by femto on Sunday September 30, 2018 @05:35AM
(#18105401)
It hinges on the interpretation of the word "capable"?
That the hardware can do it doesn't always mean the radio as a system is "capable" of it. For example, the firmware may contain a list of banned frequencies or bands. From a commercial perspective, my understanding is that the FCC is okay with radio hardware being widely tuneable, as long as the end user never sees the widely tuneable characteristics and has no way to use the device outside the defined frequencies.
I'm guessing the FCC has yet to grok what "capable" means when it is a non-proprietary system where there is no manufacturer to act as gatekeeper? My guess is that the FCC would consider a radio not to be capable if it required a firmware reflash, or some other major action on a workbench, to transmit in a band, meaning it is impossible to accidentally change bands or to do so in the field. Even if the FCC disagreed that firmware can render a radio non-capable, a bandpass filter, counted as being an integral part of the radio would do so?
From my listening of the conversation and reading the article, the above is consistent with what the FCC said, if you use the above defintion of "capable".
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by im3w1l on Saturday September 29, 2018 @05:03AM
(#18099410)
My common sense tells me that it probably depends on ease of doing it. Consider these scenarios:
It will transmit on non-amateur bands if you...
plug it in.
push a particular button.
type in a particular password.
flash the firmware.
short two pins.
physically remove a limiter component.
physically add a limit-override component.
take a hammer to it and rebuild it from scratch.
Somewhere along that scale it will decided to be compliant.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by VLM on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:19AM
(#18106254)
Maybe 40 years ago toward the end of the CB fad (CB was kinda the boomer generations version of the current social media fad) vacuum tube medium to high power external amps were (and still are) a thing for ham radio use and toward the higher end of the HF frequency range they struggled to achieve 10 dB of gain, at least with simpler designs and cheaper tubes, so stick a simple low pass filter in the input that rolls off to 10 dB of loss by 11 meters and you've ruined the amp for illegal CB use while all a technically knowledgeable ham has to do to operate legally on the ham 10 meter band is short the low pass filter out with a piece of wire. It depends a bit on your filter topology, blocking the input can be shorted as per above, whereas filter elements shorting to ground you'd have to snip one wire. Usually the advertisements in the magazines would mention obtusely "snip one wire for full legal coverage" or "solder one wire for reversible full legal coverage".
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Lucky225 on Monday October 01, 2018 @02:00AM
(#18110339)
Regarding Software and specifically SDR, it would seem that the radio would need to be certificated AS an SDR, AND only software that has been approved would be allowed to be loaded on to the radio:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/47/2.1
Software defined radio. A radio that includes a transmitter in which the operating parameters of frequency range, modulation type or maximum output power (either radiated or conducted), or the circumstances under which the transmitter operates in accordance with Commission rules, can be altered by making a change in software without making any changes to hardware components that affect the radio frequency emissions. In accordance with § 2.944 of this part, only radios in which the software is designed or expected to be modified by a party other than the manufacturer and would affect the above-listed operating parameters or circumstances under which the radio transmits must be certified as software defined radios.
(a) Manufacturers must take steps to ensure that only software that has been approved with a software defined radio can be loaded into the radio. The software must not allow the user to operate the transmitter with operating frequencies, output power, modulation types or other radio frequency parameters outside those that were approved.
(b) Any radio in which the software is designed or expected to be modified by a party other than the manufacturer and would affect the operating parameters of frequency range, modulation type or maximum output power (either radiated or conducted), or the circumstances under which the transmitter operates in accordance with Commission rules, must comply with the requirements in paragraph (a) of this section and must be certified as a software defined radio.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by comboy on Sunday September 30, 2018 @07:31AM
(#18105716)
How about, instead of more regulation, try to enforce existing one? Sure, there's some man-hours cost but with cheap SDRs it should be pretty simple especially in places where it's actually causing a problem. Otherwise nothing will change except for most hardware being imported from less known brands from China instead of being sold in the US.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Mountain_Skies on Sunday September 30, 2018 @04:27PM
(#18108203)
Does anyone think that the current entry level amateur test might be too easy? When I was in elementary school I loved the idea of being a ham radio operator. I checked out books from the county library but found the content beyond my abilities at that time, especially as they were my one and only source of help. In my college days I took another look as the tests were simplified but at the time every license still required a Morse Code test. With lots of other things going on I dropped the idea.
Recently I looked into it again and took sample tests online. I passed every one on the first try. My university degree isn't EE but it's in a related field that required taking a good number of EE courses. Even with that, I couldn't design a radio to save my life. I might be able to figure it out relatively quickly with available material online but it strikes me as being a bit of a mismatch that I likely can easily pass the Technician test while my practical knowledge of equipment used by amateur operators in that of a black box.
If nothing else, perhaps the bank of questions should be larger. I'm not good at rote memorization but others are.
Perhaps there is no real problem here but I can't help thinking that maybe there are a lot of people getting licenses without a real understanding of how much in the ham world actually operates. I understand the desire to make it more accessible, especially given the pressure to reassign amateur band to other uses but is there a risk of becoming CB Radio 2.0?
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by 8bitsrule on Sunday September 30, 2018 @04:33AM
(#18105196)
For several generations, ham gear has never had to 'certified' so long as it is known to obey the rules ... power, modulation type, non-interference, etc.... for the band it's being operated in.
OTOH, if a particular amateur does not have the knowledge to know (from observations) that the gear does not violate the regs, s/he could, of course, be in violation.
I'd guess that the ARRL will have something to say about this by Monday.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by escherplex on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:08AM
(#18106213)
The world has changed. On the one hand you still have FCC 97.315 (on the extra exam) which permits sale of non-certified HF (sub 2M) amplifiers from amateur operators to amateur operators, which serves as a convenient loophole for 'homebrews' exchange by individuals with technical competence and presumably a sense of responsibility. On the other you have Amazon placing no restrictions on the purchase of BaoFeng UV5R-s at US$ 23 which have wide VHF Tx capacity. Among other things this supplies individuals, nefarious or otherwise, with the capacity to jam or transmit false weather reports on NOAA 162 MHz maritime band (for the hell of it, verified Tx capacity there using a 136-174 MHz Wouxun KG-689 run into a dummy load). With today's pervasive laissez faire mindset, measured tighter restrictions may be a necessary evil.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by VLM on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:31AM
(#18106306)
Since the mid 90s when SAME codes rolled out for NOAA weather radio system, there's been a constant low level nation wide problem with people transmitting "funny" SAME codes like hurricane warnings in north dakota and so forth.
It was pretty obvious security issue when the system was released, and the fake alerts usually make it into the news as "news of the weird" rather than "OMG someone has hacked the system" type of story. There is no way to "patch" or fix the system by the nature of its design, all receivers have to trust that any transmission is genuine.
Obviously cheap radios (SDR?) are just going to make the problem worse until NOAA alerts are essentially useless. Of course now there's cellphones and their broadcast emergency messages, so I would not be surprised to see the NOAA alert system discontinued in a couple years.
Although SAME sounds like a horrible idea, it was well intentioned in that the radio transmissions can carry 30 to 50 miles so people would ignore all warnings given that statistically most of the warnings wouldn't apply to them (sort of like Amber Alert fatigue), so they added all this digital stuff to specify the exact problem (why?) and exact zip codes (good idea).
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by paulie_a on Sunday September 30, 2018 @11:14AM
(#18106500)
I grew up in a small town, in the 90's it would have cost a couple hundred dollars to set off the tornado warning system with a 4 digit DTMF code. It probably hasn't changed since then.
Why not just stop and think about things for a while, as opposed to running around making these executive decisions and annoying people like homebrew operators? Holy smokes. And why not go through back channels, drop some truth bombs on whoever the really big offenders are, rather than scooping up all possible babies to throw out with the bathwater?
(Still, I heard from a Russian today that he'd be arrested for taking an HT to the park even just to listen to whatever's on the air. So it's all in perspective, but homebrew is huge for innovation.)
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by themodelplumber on Sunday September 30, 2018 @01:48AM
(#18104661)
The major part of it is about controlling what happens on the bands. Which to a degree is a useful function, because the FCC is useful as a sort of arbiter between various users of those bands. Commercial, public sector, amateur, etc.
However, the recent explosion in popularity of "transmit on whatever band you please, right out of the box" radios has created a lot of opportunities for idiots to cause limited havoc on one end, and for the FCC to apparently extrapolate that to "omg unlimited havoc" on the other.
We'll see how it goes, but there is clearly a lot of B&W (i.e. uneducated or just non-analytical) thinking on the matter currently.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by VLM on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:46AM
(#18106371)
"legitimate homebrew"
There's no agreement on what that means in the sense that there's at least one (very old) cultural group that sees it as buying a small pile of generic components and soldering them together by hand on a workbench into a working system of ones own custom design, and a somewhat more recent interpretation that it means buying a commercial product marketed for one group, then because its technologically possible sometimes, using that commercial product for a different marketing group without the support of the manufacturer. Needless to say both sides can't communicate, not even having common terms to discuss. And throw in the FCC which has extensive regulatory support only for the first definition for many decades and has generally opposed the latter definition, its absolute chaos.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate...
by Lucky225 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @06:35PM
(#18108816)
Couldn't have said it better, but even taking this into account the FCC still would say the former definition would be illegal if the radio is 'capable' of transmitting outside the ham bands. Even a crystal based radio is capable of transmitting outside the ham bands by simply swapping the crystal.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00MAULSOK
[2] https://offgridsurvival.com/baofenguv5rv2review/
[3] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004PGM9PO/
By "similar" I mean "capable of transmitting outside the amateur bands." The radios are all different, but this is the point they have in common. (FWIW, the BF-F8HP is one of the nicer Baofengs, not just for the extra power but because it comes with a much better antenna than the cheapest models.)
The current point of confusion is that the FCC seems to be saying that amateur operators can no longer legally use a radio within the ham bands if that radio is even capable of transmitting on another frequency, unless the radio is type certified for whatever other frequency that might be.
This of course is ridiculous. It goes completely against the way the FCC has always regulated amateur radio. Hams have always been allowed to build their own equipment and to repurpose military or commercial radios to use in the ham bands.
It's fairly shocking that the FCC would change their views on this so suddenly. If true, it means that radios hams have bought and used legally are suddenly illegal. I have to believe that there is some misunderstanding at the bottom of all this.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Act_of_1934
https://photos.app.goo.gl/VbB1L4xJ8eSi88WU7 (30dB power attenuator)
I hope and suspect the truth is "this radio cannot be legally used by a ham operator without further cleaning it up because it is so dirty" and that this got morphed into "this radio cannot be legally used by a ham operator because it isn't certified."
The whole idea of ham certification is to prove that you can take responsibility for your own radio waves so as to relax the otherwise enormous regulatory burden on people trying to experiment and innovate on their own. If the FCC has actually reversed course on this, they are going against not only a century+ of tradition but the very spirit of the program itself.
If the default channels in these were GMRS, despite the lack of legality in their use on GMRS, I expect there would be much less activity in responding to the problem.
Every Airsofter I see has a Baofeng in an imitation Harris casing and freely uses it in their games. None of them have ham licenses. The spectrum is regulated for reasons, but there seems to be zero enforcement. This is in the UK.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISM_band
HAM radio is a very special kind of spectrum user - other than any other radio service, there is no requirement for devices to be commercially certified, with the burden of ensuring safe operation being placed on the operators rather than the manufacturers (in the early days, most tranceivers were of the DIY variety). This is why there's a hard technical exam - you have to prove that you're capable of building and verifying your own transceiver.
At least in Europe, this is codified by law with no room for interpretation, and I would be quite surprised if it were any different in the US (HAM radio laws are pretty much the same everywhere thanks to international harmonization treaties).
That being said: These Baofeng transceivers are a nuisance and the earlier generations are rightfully banned in multiple countries for having poor output filters with strong harmonics all over the place - it would not be legal to operate one of these even on the HAM radio bands, by a HAM radio operator. At our local HAM radio club, a few members actually added extra filters to theirs to make them usable.
I'm all for cracking down on the use of these by non-licensed operators, since it's extremely easy to interfere with legitimate services like weather fax and emergency service communications, even if you're not actually using their frequency. Preventing this is exactly the FCCs job.
Source: licensed HAM radio operator
The bigger worry is modified devices - devices that would have had a type-acceptance, but it's been invalidated by the operator. They'd be a grey area that becomes a much darker shade of grey under this interpretation.
It does bring to mind a specific example I'd be morbidly curious in; the Icom M802 is a marine HF/SSB set that's popular in small craft. It has a neat trick where if you hold a specific set of buttons while you power it on, it can be operated in the amateur bands (until it's powered off, then it falls back to the factory behaviour).
Under this interpretation, that'd no longer be legal? Since the operator has invalidated the part80 type-acceptance by enticing the unit to transmit outside of its intended bands, it can no longer be operated (by a ham operator) in the ham bands?
Under my current understanding you'd need both an (unrestricted) radiotelegaph or radiotelephone operator's license to be allowed to adjust a part80 transmitter in a way that'd affect it's proper operation; plus a technician (or above) amateur endorsement to actually operate it in this mode, to do this legally. Under this (new?) interpretation, that's still not enough to be trusted?
(A rather long-winded example, but one close to my heart. I believe it's one of the reasons this particular model lost its type-certification in Europe.)
Just one nitpick for the benefit of any non-hams who are reading this thread and may wonder: it's usually spelled "ham", not "HAM", as it is just an ordinary word, not an acronym.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etymology_of_ham_radio
Same with scanners that access the old AMPS band. You can modify it, but you can’t buy a modded radio.
Ah, the good old days of getting radio mods via BBS.
Now if it’s “test equipment” it’s the Wild West. All my SDRs can transmit to 6 GHz, but it’s not something for consumer use. Hope it stays that way.
IMO, it would be reasonable to ban these mass-market ham radio transceivers like the ones mentioned in the article (Switzerland banned most of them). 99% of the people buying them aren't ham radio operators, and their output filters are so bad that you need to mod them to make them acceptable.
> Now if it’s “test equipment” it’s the Wild West. All my SDRs can transmit to 6 GHz, but it’s not something for consumer use. Hope it stays that way.
That's how it was with model airplanes, before the big drone hype happened - there was a small community of experienced people who would play by the rules and police themselves.
That the hardware can do it doesn't always mean the radio as a system is "capable" of it. For example, the firmware may contain a list of banned frequencies or bands. From a commercial perspective, my understanding is that the FCC is okay with radio hardware being widely tuneable, as long as the end user never sees the widely tuneable characteristics and has no way to use the device outside the defined frequencies.
I'm guessing the FCC has yet to grok what "capable" means when it is a non-proprietary system where there is no manufacturer to act as gatekeeper? My guess is that the FCC would consider a radio not to be capable if it required a firmware reflash, or some other major action on a workbench, to transmit in a band, meaning it is impossible to accidentally change bands or to do so in the field. Even if the FCC disagreed that firmware can render a radio non-capable, a bandpass filter, counted as being an integral part of the radio would do so?
From my listening of the conversation and reading the article, the above is consistent with what the FCC said, if you use the above defintion of "capable".
It will transmit on non-amateur bands if you...
Somewhere along that scale it will decided to be compliant.Is this possible at all?
> take a hammer to it and rebuild it from scratch.
That does not count as an adaptation.
Idk if that's a thing for radios.
Software defined radio. A radio that includes a transmitter in which the operating parameters of frequency range, modulation type or maximum output power (either radiated or conducted), or the circumstances under which the transmitter operates in accordance with Commission rules, can be altered by making a change in software without making any changes to hardware components that affect the radio frequency emissions. In accordance with § 2.944 of this part, only radios in which the software is designed or expected to be modified by a party other than the manufacturer and would affect the above-listed operating parameters or circumstances under which the radio transmits must be certified as software defined radios.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/47/2.944
(a) Manufacturers must take steps to ensure that only software that has been approved with a software defined radio can be loaded into the radio. The software must not allow the user to operate the transmitter with operating frequencies, output power, modulation types or other radio frequency parameters outside those that were approved.
(b) Any radio in which the software is designed or expected to be modified by a party other than the manufacturer and would affect the operating parameters of frequency range, modulation type or maximum output power (either radiated or conducted), or the circumstances under which the transmitter operates in accordance with Commission rules, must comply with the requirements in paragraph (a) of this section and must be certified as a software defined radio.
Recently I looked into it again and took sample tests online. I passed every one on the first try. My university degree isn't EE but it's in a related field that required taking a good number of EE courses. Even with that, I couldn't design a radio to save my life. I might be able to figure it out relatively quickly with available material online but it strikes me as being a bit of a mismatch that I likely can easily pass the Technician test while my practical knowledge of equipment used by amateur operators in that of a black box. If nothing else, perhaps the bank of questions should be larger. I'm not good at rote memorization but others are.
Perhaps there is no real problem here but I can't help thinking that maybe there are a lot of people getting licenses without a real understanding of how much in the ham world actually operates. I understand the desire to make it more accessible, especially given the pressure to reassign amateur band to other uses but is there a risk of becoming CB Radio 2.0?
OTOH, if a particular amateur does not have the knowledge to know (from observations) that the gear does not violate the regs, s/he could, of course, be in violation.
I'd guess that the ARRL will have something to say about this by Monday.
It was pretty obvious security issue when the system was released, and the fake alerts usually make it into the news as "news of the weird" rather than "OMG someone has hacked the system" type of story. There is no way to "patch" or fix the system by the nature of its design, all receivers have to trust that any transmission is genuine.
Obviously cheap radios (SDR?) are just going to make the problem worse until NOAA alerts are essentially useless. Of course now there's cellphones and their broadcast emergency messages, so I would not be surprised to see the NOAA alert system discontinued in a couple years.
Although SAME sounds like a horrible idea, it was well intentioned in that the radio transmissions can carry 30 to 50 miles so people would ignore all warnings given that statistically most of the warnings wouldn't apply to them (sort of like Amber Alert fatigue), so they added all this digital stuff to specify the exact problem (why?) and exact zip codes (good idea).
It used to be a problem back when illegal CB radio amplifiers and pirate broadcast radio were still a thing :-)
Most equipment uses Selcall: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selcall
My... uhh... friend doesn't understand what you meant by that. Would you mind elaborating?
http://www.arrl.org/news/arrl-fcc-discussing-issue-of-uncert...
https://medium.com/@lucky225/fcc-back-peddles-all-transceive...
Why not just stop and think about things for a while, as opposed to running around making these executive decisions and annoying people like homebrew operators? Holy smokes. And why not go through back channels, drop some truth bombs on whoever the really big offenders are, rather than scooping up all possible babies to throw out with the bathwater?
(Still, I heard from a Russian today that he'd be arrested for taking an HT to the park even just to listen to whatever's on the air. So it's all in perspective, but homebrew is huge for innovation.)
However, the recent explosion in popularity of "transmit on whatever band you please, right out of the box" radios has created a lot of opportunities for idiots to cause limited havoc on one end, and for the FCC to apparently extrapolate that to "omg unlimited havoc" on the other.
We'll see how it goes, but there is clearly a lot of B&W (i.e. uneducated or just non-analytical) thinking on the matter currently.
There's no agreement on what that means in the sense that there's at least one (very old) cultural group that sees it as buying a small pile of generic components and soldering them together by hand on a workbench into a working system of ones own custom design, and a somewhat more recent interpretation that it means buying a commercial product marketed for one group, then because its technologically possible sometimes, using that commercial product for a different marketing group without the support of the manufacturer. Needless to say both sides can't communicate, not even having common terms to discuss. And throw in the FCC which has extensive regulatory support only for the first definition for many decades and has generally opposed the latter definition, its absolute chaos.