News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by Animats on Sunday September 30, 2018 @03:49AM (#18105086)
The trouble is this thing: "BaoFeng BF-F8HP (UV-5R 3rd Gen) 8-Watt Dual Band Two-Way Radio (136-174Mhz VHF & 400-520Mhz UHF) Includes Full Kit"[1] This cheap radio is sold as a "ham radio", and requires a ham license. Large numbers of non-hams are using it in the GMRS service at higher power levels than allowed. It's popular with "preppers", even though it's not very rugged, is complicated to use, tends not to put out as much power as claimed, and the battery tends to come loose.[2] The FCC's concern is that it allows 8 watt blithering over a wide range of frequencies by people with no clue how to use it properly. There are GMRS radios made for hunters which are much more suitable for wilderness use - waterproof and easy to use.[3]

[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00MAULSOK

[2] https://offgridsurvival.com/baofenguv5rv2review/

[3] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004PGM9PO/

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by Stratoscope on Sunday September 30, 2018 @04:39AM (#18105205)
Don't single out the BF-F8HP as if it were the radio the FCC is talking about. There are many similar radios made by Baofeng, AnyTone, TYT, Wouxun, and other manufacturers.

By "similar" I mean "capable of transmitting outside the amateur bands." The radios are all different, but this is the point they have in common. (FWIW, the BF-F8HP is one of the nicer Baofengs, not just for the extra power but because it comes with a much better antenna than the cheapest models.)

The current point of confusion is that the FCC seems to be saying that amateur operators can no longer legally use a radio within the ham bands if that radio is even capable of transmitting on another frequency, unless the radio is type certified for whatever other frequency that might be.

This of course is ridiculous. It goes completely against the way the FCC has always regulated amateur radio. Hams have always been allowed to build their own equipment and to repurpose military or commercial radios to use in the ham bands.

It's fairly shocking that the FCC would change their views on this so suddenly. If true, it means that radios hams have bought and used legally are suddenly illegal. I have to believe that there is some misunderstanding at the bottom of all this.

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by Lucky225 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @05:58PM (#18108665)
100% the point of my post thank you. I'd also add to your sentence "it means that radios hams have bought and used legally" is a misnomer under this interpretation, in the FCC's eyes they've been using them illegally since the inception of the Communications Act.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by Stratoscope on Sunday September 30, 2018 @06:04PM (#18108683)
Hams: "Illegal" for 84 years and proud of it!

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Act_of_1934

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by lightlyused on Sunday September 30, 2018 @07:06AM (#18105663)
I really don't think the wide transmit range is a problem, the real issue is that the transmitters are dirty, they have unacceptable spurious emissions: https://imgur.com/a/up2ne.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by jjoonathan on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:43AM (#18106353)
Yep, the harmonics are bad, and the start-up transients are pretty spectacular too:

https://photos.app.goo.gl/VbB1L4xJ8eSi88WU7 (30dB power attenuator)

I hope and suspect the truth is "this radio cannot be legally used by a ham operator without further cleaning it up because it is so dirty" and that this got morphed into "this radio cannot be legally used by a ham operator because it isn't certified."

The whole idea of ham certification is to prove that you can take responsibility for your own radio waves so as to relax the otherwise enormous regulatory burden on people trying to experiment and innovate on their own. If the FCC has actually reversed course on this, they are going against not only a century+ of tradition but the very spirit of the program itself.

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by lima on Sunday September 30, 2018 @02:21PM (#18107490)
Switzerland has banned them for that exact reason: https://www.bakom.admin.ch/bakom/en/homepage/equipments-and-...
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by Lucky225 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @06:00PM (#18108673)
This is true, but the REASON the FCC is giving for the ban (since part 97 doesn't require certification, and such problems could in theory be brought back into compliance using bandpass filters and thus still be legal) is they are capable of wide transmit outside amateur.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by codys on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:29PM (#18135355)
More than just "using it for GMRS service": the real issue is that most purchasers of these radios leave the channel configuration in the shipped default, which tends to overlap with a bunch of public safety and commercial frequencies.

If the default channels in these were GMRS, despite the lack of legality in their use on GMRS, I expect there would be much less activity in responding to the problem.

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by gaius on Sunday September 30, 2018 @07:15AM (#18105684)
It's popular with "preppers"

Every Airsofter I see has a Baofeng in an imitation Harris casing and freely uses it in their games. None of them have ham licenses. The spectrum is regulated for reasons, but there seems to be zero enforcement. This is in the UK.

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by stefan_ on Sunday September 30, 2018 @08:44AM (#18105933)
The spectrum is regulated because you can use uncertified radio equipment, if these are banned anyway, the regulation makes no sense anymore.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by lima on Sunday September 30, 2018 @02:33PM (#18107585)
The only bands you can use uncertified radio equipment on are ISM[1] (with strict limits) and ham radio bands.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISM_band

Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by gaius on Sunday September 30, 2018 @12:14PM (#18106765)
Umm the entire spectrum is regulated. This is only about one small slice of it.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by stefan_ on Sunday September 30, 2018 @03:59PM (#18108057)
The ham radio spectrum is specifically regulated to require training because you will be using uncertified radio equipment that can communicate on whatever band you want, not just the ham radio ones.
Re:FCC bans radios that haven't been certified for non-amate... by lima on Sunday September 30, 2018 @02:31PM (#18107566)
Many people (mistakenly) believe that these are PMR446/LPD radios. Some countries like Switzerland banned their sale altogether.