When a vote is for 'status quo' or 'not status quo' then there'll be a lot of people voting for 'not status quo' that want radically different and incompatible things.
Realistically they should have planned more, but planning is limited when you're going into negotiations with an unpredictable third party. If other countries had voted to leave the EU, or the German or French elections had been different then the negotiation would be very different. Even the UK election after the vote could have wildly changed our brexit policy.
Presumably Norway isn't in the ECHR, which would be significant. Neither is it obligated to join the Eurozone. It's more complicated than you're painting it.
The ECHR is a separate institution to the EU anyway so I'm not sure why it would be relevant. Leaving the EU does not leave the ECHR, and there has been no referendum to suggest that the UK should do that.
None of this means that the recent referendum gave any mandate for leaving the ECHR.
Personally, I'm against referendums of any kind.
For this kind of referendum it also might be worth considering changing the "one person, one vote" rule.
By "this kind" I mean referendums that (1) have a much bigger long term impact on some large groups than they do on other large groups, and (2) there is good reason to believe that within some reasonable time frame that those groups who are the most impacted will be able to win a referendum to try to reverse this referendum, and (3) it will be very difficult and take a long time implement such a reversal.
It just doesn't seem fair that, say, someone who is 95 years old and who has a very good chance of being dead before Brexit can be implemented and a 25 year old whose entire life has been built around a world where Britain is part of the EU have an equal say in this.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_devolution_referendum...
Since Proposition 13 passed in 1978 (by a simple majority), California has required 2/3 majority votes in the legislature to increase taxes, and 2/3 majority votes for local elections to increase taxes.
I lived in San Francisco for a while, and I don't remember the numbers and I know you can look this up, but it felt like I was voting No on up to dozen different bond proposals every two years. Doesn't matter, they always pass. (To clarify, I also don't remember if these were always up to a majority vote, but they almost always pass unless it's for something Californians don't like for whatever reason.)
It more than feels like it; most people don't know that.
As with other things, we can blame the total lack of financial education in our education system.
A referendum should be held on major political stuff (like leaving the EU or Scotland leaving the UK) if national polls have pinged the opinion at least 60%, and then it should also require a higher majority (like 60%) to change. This ensures a big major change happens if it's really wanted, but for very divisive issues it will take time.
So yes we should keep having a Brexit referendum if the national polls start getting 60% support, until then it's not worth it. And it should require more than 60% otherwise if you go 50% like now, you have half the country hating the other half. If we kept the status quo, then the brexit people would have had to keep up and slowly change peoples opinion so the majority of the country agree.
Rather, I think it is absolutely important to inform the electorate and to make sure that propaganda is effectively prevented. I have literally no idea how to do any of that.
If “the people” cannot be convinced of your arguments, then the arguments suck — and one thing I’ve been amazed at since the referendum is how severely all of the talking heads in the UK, Remain and Leave both, have persistently failed to connect with any issue of importance to the other side.
Personally, I think the problem is that social media means that too much of the conversation is in echo chambers, and echo chambers are terrible at fairly considering the other side's view.
I love Palin's delivery of this:
"Listen, strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony. You can't expect to wield supreme executive power just because some watery tart threw a sword at you. If I went round saying I was an emperor just because some moistened bint had lobbed a scimitar at me, they'd put me away" :D
2005 Referendum was 57.7% Yes, 61% turnout, required 60% to pass.
2009 Referendum was 39% Yes, 55% turnout, required 60% to pass.
This year, we get to vote on both Yes/No, as well as rank three possible systems - current polls are 32% no, 33% yes, 33% undecided, and MMP with 49% support. To pass, we require only 50% Yes votes, but there's a clause that will have us do a followup in 8 years (2 election cycles) as to whether to keep the PR system or go back to FPTP.
I'm very happy with the "50% but built-in allowance for takebacks" setup this time around.
BC held a referendum in 2005 which was on Single Transferrable Vote. 57% voted in favour, but the threshold was set at 60%, with a majority needed in at least 60% of the electoral districts.
BC held a second referendum in 2009, and the vote swung in the other direction. Only 39% voted in favour of STV.
So a majority vote for Brexit that fell short of a prescribed threshold would create huge problems for future EU treaties.
Again, not attacking, genuinely curious.
What I said was that I was not in favor of direct democracy. In context, what that means is "rule by referendum". I'm against it, and so were the authors of the Constitution. And they had good historical reasons - they saw what happened to democracy in ancient Greece. That position is not directly related to the electoral [not electorate] college. I could be against the electoral college without that invalidating my position on referendums.
As it happens, I am in favor of the electoral college, but on different grounds - limiting the ability of the large states to run over the small ones. It's the same reason we have a Senate, not just a House of Representatives.
However in the case of things like brexit vote, it really does seem like it’s the elites versus the common folk battling out what their vision for what the country should look like.
I wouldn't be surprised if that were the case, but information from someone who knows more would be nice...
A better informed electorate would have prevented Brexit. We don't allow foreign countries to air political ads. It's time social media policies caught up.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_20...
[2] https://www.euronews.com/2018/02/12/new-report-concludes-rus...
Yes, foreign interference was a problem, and we need to do better to prevent it. And simple majority rule on referendums leads to hotheaded spur-of-the-moment decisions, even without foreign interference.
I did not used to think this. In 2007 British Columbia had a referendum on switching to proportional representation from FPTP. The result was like 52% in favour, but the government had set a minimum of 55%,so it did not pass. I thought it was a a terrible idea at the time (the people had spoken! Democracy!), but I don't think so anymore. Another example is the 1995 Quebec independence referendum, which "stay" narrowly won, but afterwards the federal government passed an act making it much harder to pass a referendum.
Basically, the bigger the question, the longer and larger implications it has, the more it has to be thought through, the more consensus there should be. The US constitution has features like this when it requires large majorities to pass amendments etc.
As an engineering metaphor, having a fast-response system without any dampening can lead to out of control oscillations, which ultimately destroy your system.