Re:How to Brexit? – Explore the (im)possibilities of the dif...
by pjc50 on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:21PM
(#18094622)
The trouble is that of the two obvious options, one is pointless ("Norway") and the other ("Canada") breaches the peace treaty in Northern Ireland.
Re:How to Brexit? – Explore the (im)possibilities of the dif...
by zimablue on Friday September 28, 2018 @01:00PM
(#18094933)
Fortunately we're something like (top of my head) ten times as important to the EU as either of those, and so even the most hardened remainer would privately admit that we should have more leverage in negotiations.
Presumably Norway isn't in the ECHR, which would be significant. Neither is it obligated to join the Eurozone. It's more complicated than you're painting it.
Re:How to Brexit? – Explore the (im)possibilities of the dif...
by kybernetikos on Friday September 28, 2018 @01:51PM
(#18095407)
Norway is part of the ECHR. In fact, just like the UK it was a founding member of the Council of Europe which agreed to create the ECHR at the Congress of Europe at which Winston Churchill was a delegate from the UK.
The ECHR is a separate institution to the EU anyway so I'm not sure why it would be relevant. Leaving the EU does not leave the ECHR, and there has been no referendum to suggest that the UK should do that.
Re:How to Brexit? – Explore the (im)possibilities of the dif...
by zimablue on Friday September 28, 2018 @02:40PM
(#18095879)
You're right on Norway being a member of the ECHR, I wasn't sure as I stated in my post, but you're vastly oversimplifying by implying there's no connection
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-3614979...
Re:How to Brexit? – Explore the (im)possibilities of the dif...
by kybernetikos on Friday September 28, 2018 @03:07PM
(#18096146)
There is no direct connection. But a respect for human rights is required to belong to the EU. Leaving the ECHR would cast the UKs commitment to human rights into question (at the very least it would be an indication that the UK has a different conception of human rights to the rest of the EU) and would mean that the EU would have to scrutinise whatever legislation took its place to ensure that the UK did still intend to retain a conception of human rights close enough to the other member states.
None of this means that the recent referendum gave any mandate for leaving the ECHR.
Realistically they should have planned more, but planning is limited when you're going into negotiations with an unpredictable third party. If other countries had voted to leave the EU, or the German or French elections had been different then the negotiation would be very different. Even the UK election after the vote could have wildly changed our brexit policy.