It's funny that this is basically the peer-review version of harking.
I quit working with her because of that, and also because she was a total asshole. I refuse to donate to my university until she's no longer on the faculty. I don't want her benefiting from my hard-earned money.
Totally corrupt, Ive seen it when I talked to professors about getting my PhD. You prove what they want proven.
One is going to have millions of customers using it, the other is going to have a few biased professors review the data.
After-the-fact-hypothesis is constantly used to retroactively justify business decisions.
Building a product that is bad because 'X person wanted it' is bad Capitalism and will be punished.
Academia doesnt have this same customer focused delivery.
As a result, more and more, reviews will tend to be shallow and uncritical.
Turns out it won't: 2 of the 5 papers have been retracted.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.0214...
https://bmcnutr.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40795-01...
“Mr. Wansink’s fall from grace began with a 2016 blog post in which he blithely confessed to using improper research techniques known as p-hacking and HARKing. P-hacking involves running statistical analyses until they produce a statistically significant result; HARKing stands for “hypothesizing after the results are known.” The post prompted a small group of skeptics to take a hard look at Mr. Wansink’s past scholarship. Their analysis, published in January 2017, turned up an astonishing variety and quantity of errors in his statistical procedures and data.”