It doesn't work that way for knowledge workers and creative types. Some people are rare talents, some people are just okay. Some people fill wear 5 different hats and cover responsibilities outside their title. One artist may be the visionary behind your greatest success, another just follows orders, but both are on the same team and at the same level of the hierarchy.
If you force a system where everyone makes the same salary based on how long they've worked there, the best people will leave. But if people negotiate for themselves, it isn't collective bargaining anymore, and you don't have a union.
Want to prevent burnout? The union negotiates for rigid 9 to 5 hours. Many creative people will hate it. Or you let people come in when the want, but they have to fill out a timesheet, can't work overtime without the approval of both a manager and a union rep, and have to adhere to rigid guidelines.
Unions can't work without bureaucracy, but creative people and creative organizations don't work well with bureaucracy.
I can only suppose that people with perspectives like yours have convinced themselves and others the possible is in fact impossible for no discernible reason.
And the actual, real life results for most unions today... is not great. I am not even talking about industrial era stuff. I am talking about existing examples of unions.
If this innovation and disruption of the union industry was so easy, then someone would be doing it. But they aren't.
And I have no reason to believe that techies would be any better at solving the inherent problems of unions, better than all the other people who have tried. IMO, it would inevitable run into exact the same problems as the ones you see today in existing unions.
How else should we judge things, than based on their results?
IE, the existing electric cars in 2004, were better than the electric cars made in 2003. And the same for 2005 cars, compared to 2004 cars.
This happened, until eventually they became good enough that people started using them, but there was still noticable progress along the way.
The same is not true for unions.
The unions in 2000, were not noticably better than the unions in 1990. There is no steady and obvious progress, or linear regression that can be extrapolated into the future.
IE, for these other technologies, they were clearly getting better by X% every year, using a measureable, objective metric. Battery life, or screen resolution or whatever.
You do not see an x% increase in an obvious objective metric for unions.
SAG WGA DGA
Last I checked all the best people in those fields were members.
Knowledge workers are largely cogs. No game project can be held hostage by one or a several critical employees. A majority of game jobs have already left California, with drop in replacements in Shanghai or Montreal or Austin.
Do you have a good example of engineering unions? The only one I know of is the SPEEA, and I know of it because one of my friends quit a job to escape the union defined hierarchy and the associated culture.
There is no reason, philosophical or technical, why a software dev union would need to have rigid 9 to 5 hours or wages based on length of time on the job.
Unions lets workers assert some meaningful control over the operation of the company, instead of simply relying on management to give them conditions they like. A union of creative folks could absolutely reflect the working conditions creative folks like.
The union would prevent burnout by making a company hire 5 people to do those 5 jobs, instead of overworking 1 person.
Maybe this would cause the company to fail - but needing employees to work so much unpaid overtime is just another unrealized failure mode.
It actually works quite well for Hollywood, and for scientists and researchers...even though these industries are heavily talent-based.
Unions negotiate based on the needs of their members. Some unions, like the Hollywood unions, negotiate job protections, benefits, and salary minimums. Members are free to negotiate better deals.
To the extent that unions improve worker conditions, they do so in part by restricting entry and thus influencing the supply side. In general unions tend to benefit people already in the industry at the expense of people outside who'd like to join, among other groups. Whether that's a desirable outcome depends on large part to which group you either belong or care about the most.
Yes. There are too many people in the industry pursuing their passion product, as opposed to doing something because it will be successful.
If you act like an artist, expect to be treated like one. And artists are treated.... poorly by society.
Not that I don't support the general idea of working on things that you like. I have a couple side project myself, that I am doing for fun. But I have absolutely zero expectation of success, and have a day job (that I like) to pay the bills. I am not going to pretend like my side projects could support me.
What would anti-union libertarians say about the labor conditions there? Workers should just avoid the game industry until more tolerable and better-paying workplaces arise? How is organizing workers not a valid solution to the problems there? Do they think that unions will somehow make the situation worse?