News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by elitistphoenix on Monday September 24, 2018 @08:27PM (#18062638)
This is the problem with non-technical lawyers making technical laws. It's like when the Attorney General was pushing for metadata retention but couldn't even explain what metadata was.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by rbg246 on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:10PM (#18062802)
I have a feeling it was not explained deliberately so that the general public wouldn't know what it was and that what the legal definition of what meta data was could be expanded when required.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by lugg on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @12:35AM (#18063630)
The point still stands.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by rbg246 on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @08:48AM (#18065850)
Agreed
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by threeseed on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:45PM (#18062930)
This isn't how it works at all.

Technical laws are advised by people from technical backgrounds. And in the case of laws like this it is coming directly from technical experts at ASIO/ASIS.

Likewise it is irrelevant whether the Attorney General knows the technical definition of metadata since he isn't personally writing the law.

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by cyberferret on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:02PM (#18063009)
No, I would counter argue that those in charge of bringing in laws should at least understand the basic principles of what those laws contain.

Much as they shouldn't ban a chemical additive to our foods without first understanding the nature and effects of that chemical (based on scientific research and evidence), then they shouldn't enact laws around privacy and data without understanding what that data itself contains. (He doesn't have to make the chemicals in a lab, he just needs to understand what it is/does).

The fact that the AG has no clear definition of what 'meta data' is, or cannot explain that to a reporter or the public really shakes my confidence that his limited understanding of 'meta data' includes elements that can personally identify someone (e.g. Does he think a phone number is 'meta data' or straight up 'personal data'? Because a phone number can be owned by more than one person, or is transferrable, does he think that is 'meta'?).

The AG should at least be able to give a broad definition of the scope of the laws that he is going to be responsible for upholding.

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by threeseed on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:11PM (#18063048)
What are you proposing is unworkable.

AG and Ministers set the strategic direction for the public sector. They operate at a sufficiently high level such that they will never be the experts and will never be across the subtleties of the policies. That's the job of the public servants.

Also the distinction between data and metadata is quite subtle and as someone who deals with this daily I make mistakes with it. So I don't expert the AG or really anyone to have the right answer every time.

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by cam_l on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:34PM (#18063129)
I broadly agree with you in principle, but in this specific case i think the issue of the law is the subtlety of the definition. The thing that the AG was studiously avoiding to answer was that both he and the people that drafted the law understood that metadata is data. He was trying to obfuscate the fact that the government was massively shifting the imaginary line between them.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by ag71668 on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:45PM (#18063193)
>This is the way it is and it's gotta be the way it is because that's the way it is.

Everyone generally agrees about how it is. The discussion is about how it should be.

We're talking about the kind of people who seriously say that the laws of mathematics don't hold weight in their jurisdiction. You can't defend that level of ignorance by just claiming it's not workable to have competent lawmakers.

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by spangry on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:17PM (#18063070)
Honestly it's probably more like ASIO/ASIS asking the Attorney-General's department for these laws, then the public servant lawyers at AGs start pushing for them. You end up with the same problem: a bunch of non-technical lawyers formulating policy on issues they don't understand. I can assure you, being a public servant myself, that technical policies often do not have sufficiently technically skilled people working on them.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by ezoe on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:10PM (#18062805)
It doesn't require rocket science to understand how bad this is. It's like permission to arrest and jail anyone for no reason BECAUSE he may commit crime in the future.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by mantas on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @01:54AM (#18063924)
This reminds me an old joke..

Police raids dude's house, finds torrent client installed and says he'll be arrested for piracy. Since he has tools for piracy. Dude says they should arrest him for rape as well. Why? Well, he has tools for that as well..

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by krylon on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @07:53AM (#18065484)
Police Officer: You just don't know when to shut up, do you? [Goes and arrests the dude for piracy and rape]
[dead]
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by dang on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:18AM (#18082421)
Please don't post flamebait, and especially not nationalistic flamebait, to Hacker News.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by mb_72 on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:20PM (#18063076)
Putting aside immigrants, this is ignorant of the indigenous inhabitants of Australia who have been here for some 10s of thousands of years.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by thewizardofaus on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:27PM (#18063099)
South Australia was founded by settlers that chose to move to Australia, not convicts.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by fphhotchips on Monday September 24, 2018 @11:03PM (#18063269)
And were promptly greeted by food shortages requiring them to eat the breast meat of crows. Hence the nickname for the denizens of the state: Crow-eaters.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by mb_72 on Monday September 24, 2018 @11:27PM (#18063352)
South Australian here - I was unaware of the origin of the term, so thanks for that. I have an interest in such history as my distant relative, one "Johann Heinrich Both" arrived on the Bengalee back in 1838: http://www.theshipslist.com/ships/australia/bengalee1838.sht... ... and was most definitely not a criminal.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by toomanybeersies on Monday September 24, 2018 @11:51PM (#18063443)
And the Australian Football team from the state capital, Adelaide, are called the Crows.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by lostlogin on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @03:37AM (#18064309)
Are you referring to the aboriginal population or the Europeans who followed thousands of years later, or both? The thread that you’ve started seems to have assumed you refer to the European settlers.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by lsh on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:45PM (#18063192)
represent
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by toomanybeersies on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:06PM (#18063034)
Honestly, that joke's getting a bit old now. Most Australians are recent immigrants, only 20% of Australians are descended from a convict.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by lozaning on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @01:33AM (#18063842)
Any truth to what I've been told that it's a point of pride for those who can trace their family lines back to those that were criminals? I've heard it's kinda similar to the The Daughters of the American Revolution in the US.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by fineline on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @02:05AM (#18063971)
Apparently it used to be considered something you would try and hide, back in the days of the cultural cringe[0], whereas now it can be seen as a bit of a badge of honour. My wife's family descends from a convict bloke whose free wife came out too and got her husband assigned to her. Convicts were assigned as essentially unpaid labour (other than food and a rough bed) to land owners at the time. Given that many were very petty criminals back in Britain (e.g. stealing a loaf of bread) some interpret the arrangement as not much better than slavery, as a means to provide free labour to grow the fledgling colony. Some of the tales of the worst penal institutions (think Tasmania) are truly horrifying. But many convict labourers were granted their freedom over time too. It also had an interesting effect on the labour market, with free settlers finding it hard to get decent pay as farm labour etc. One of the great statesmen, Henry Parkes, was in exactly that position when he first arrived in Aus as a poor settler, and got involved in the protest which eventually turned back the last convict ship ever to anchor in Sydney Harbour. He went on to be elected multiple times as premier of NSW, achieving lots of progress in the state (trained nursing, universal education etc.) before getting the heads of all the colonial states around the table to drive the process of joining to become the nation of Australia. If only we had statesmen / women of that calibre today ... but sadly not.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_cringe

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by Jedi72 on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @05:01AM (#18064632)
I saw a very large bumper sticker that said "Convict stock" in the stereotypical tattoo-script style font in a particularly bogan part of Perth about 10 years ago.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by caf on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @02:14AM (#18064008)
Even the convicts were in many cases victims of the social and economic upheavals in Britain at the time, wrought by the industrial revolution.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by threeseed on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:42PM (#18062914)
About 1/3 of Australia are immigrants.

So no. Most of us aren't criminals or descended from criminals.

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by BigJono on Monday September 24, 2018 @08:32PM (#18062654)
The laws of mathematics don't apply in Australia.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by andrewflnr on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:37PM (#18063142)
Australia needs a referendum to repeal the laws of gravity.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by ggm on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @12:42AM (#18063657)
We will decide which laws of physics come to Australia and on what terms.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by iliketosleep on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:37PM (#18062905)
The Attorney General may not understand it well, but the people advising him may. The metadata collection is an "always on" type of surveillance, and under such conditions all it takes is one slip up in OPSEC to be caught out.

Some of these politicians may look like clowns at times, but don't underestimate the level of intelligence (and agendas) of those working for them behind the scenes.

Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones by walrus01 on Monday September 24, 2018 @11:32PM (#18063374)
As a network engineer for several medium sized ASes, I have a real problem with political jackasses who've never typed "enable" on a router one day in their life making regulations about the Internet.