Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones
by cam_l on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:34PM
(#18063129)
I broadly agree with you in principle, but in this specific case i think the issue of the law is the subtlety of the definition. The thing that the AG was studiously avoiding to answer was that both he and the people that drafted the law understood that metadata is data. He was trying to obfuscate the fact that the government was massively shifting the imaginary line between them.
Re:Australia pushes for spyware on phones
by ag71668 on Monday September 24, 2018 @10:45PM
(#18063193)
>This is the way it is and it's gotta be the way it is because that's the way it is.
Everyone generally agrees about how it is. The discussion is about how it should be.
We're talking about the kind of people who seriously say that the laws of mathematics don't hold weight in their jurisdiction. You can't defend that level of ignorance by just claiming it's not workable to have competent lawmakers.
AG and Ministers set the strategic direction for the public sector. They operate at a sufficiently high level such that they will never be the experts and will never be across the subtleties of the policies. That's the job of the public servants.
Also the distinction between data and metadata is quite subtle and as someone who deals with this daily I make mistakes with it. So I don't expert the AG or really anyone to have the right answer every time.