It should be no surprise that we ended up with expensive and ineffective social programs.
NY Times 2008: "The number of chronically homeless people living in the nation’s streets and shelters has dropped by about 30 percent — to 123,833 from 175,914 — between 2005 and 2007, Bush administration officials said on Tuesday."
"the officials attribute much of the decline to the “housing first” strategy that has been promoted by the Bush administration and Congress and increasingly adopted across the country."
https://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/30/us/30homelessweb.html
2013: "The Astonishing Decline of Homelessness in America"
https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/08/the-ast...
Ultimately culminating in an all-time record low rate of homelessness in the US by 2017.
The George W. Bush administration deserves the negative flak it took for its various bad policies. It also deserves credit for the positive things like its policies on homelessness or PEPFAR that were astounding successes.
It absolutely needs a redesign but it also needs funding -- and people who don't want to fund these programs have gotten very good at using the former to avoid doing the latter.
Everything else is based on eligible earnings, so I wouldn't consider it a safety net -- if you didn't earn enough or long enough, you may not get anything out of it.
I think you're going to get a lot more resistance from high income/ high net worth individuals if you take away their social security payments than if you raise the pay in caps, and set the payout percentages to be even lower at the top end. Or scrap the whole thing and build an honest steal from the rich and give to the poor guaranteed minimum income tax scheme.
America for example lowers the tax rate for low income people, just not as low as dividends are taxed.
Citation needed;
Bush tax cuts maximizes dividends and long term capital gains tax rate at 15%;
While, our first two progressive income taxes are $9525 at 10% and $38700 at 12%; (and if head of household these are $13600 and $51,800.) And that's without counting any deductions, like $12k standardized deduction!
So, dividend tax rates are only lower than low income people if you're counting the top 10% as low income.
Social Security and Medicare are 12.4% + 1.45% and have no ‘deductions’ on earned income below ~125k adding up to: 13.85%. People paying more than 1.25% on earned income are rather common.
Many very low income earners are blocked from reviving any benefits from social security, but they still paid.
You can strip SS from the 1% and it will make no difference. You can do the same for the 10% and it will make little difference. The 10% payed FAR more in than they will receive.
PS: Social Security is hardly fair. That cap is by far the largest benifit for billionaires from social security’s design. People in the 10% pay a vastly higher percentage of their income to support others.
A fair system would be something like X% up to a cap that you get back and y% that you don’t with everyone paying their share of the y%. But that starts to look like a safty net.
On top of that married couples get a larger benifit with a single large income vs two incomes of half that size.
The US child poverty rate has dropped by over 50% since the 1970s. It's at an all-time record low solely due to the expansion of the US social safety net.
US homelessness is near a record low (it hit a record low two years ago), solely due to the expansion of the US social safety net.
The overall US poverty rate is near a 40 year low.
The number of people with healthcare coverage is at record highs, primarily thanks to the expansion of Medicaid, CHIP and SS disability.
Right now we mostly get what we pay for: we pay a reduced rate and get reduced results, which in this case largely translates to more poor people suffering. We could change that, certainly we have the funds necessary, but we've collectively decided not to.