News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by Retric on Sunday September 23, 2018 @04:06PM (#18052883)
Social Security hands money to literal billionaires while excluding many of the elderly poor. Now, we can argue if it’s good use of money, but these programs are intentionally set up this way.
Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by toast0 on Sunday September 23, 2018 @07:58PM (#18054058)
Social security is a mostly old age and disability insurance program with eligibility requirements and weird rules, and maybe some solvency issues. My understanding is there is some coverage for disabled children that's not based on previous earnings, but I'm not familiar with the details.

Everything else is based on eligible earnings, so I wouldn't consider it a safety net -- if you didn't earn enough or long enough, you may not get anything out of it.

I think you're going to get a lot more resistance from high income/ high net worth individuals if you take away their social security payments than if you raise the pay in caps, and set the payout percentages to be even lower at the top end. Or scrap the whole thing and build an honest steal from the rich and give to the poor guaranteed minimum income tax scheme.

Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by Retric on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:09PM (#18054539)
I completely agree, but when you don’t include the majority of Social Security then the magnitude of spending on the ‘safety net’ is vastly smaller.

America for example lowers the tax rate for low income people, just not as low as dividends are taxed.

Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by smileysteve on Monday September 24, 2018 @12:59PM (#18059286)
> just not as low as dividends are taxed.

Citation needed;

Bush tax cuts maximizes dividends and long term capital gains tax rate at 15%;

While, our first two progressive income taxes are $9525 at 10% and $38700 at 12%; (and if head of household these are $13600 and $51,800.) And that's without counting any deductions, like $12k standardized deduction!

So, dividend tax rates are only lower than low income people if you're counting the top 10% as low income.

Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by Retric on Monday September 24, 2018 @04:25PM (#18061099)
I said tax not “income tax alone”.

Social Security and Medicare are 12.4% + 1.45% and have no ‘deductions’ on earned income below ~125k adding up to: 13.85%. People paying more than 1.25% on earned income are rather common.

Many very low income earners are blocked from reviving any benefits from social security, but they still paid.

Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by smileysteve on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @03:31PM (#18069699)
This is a good point; sorry, was not accounting for payroll tax.
Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by madengr on Sunday September 23, 2018 @04:46PM (#18053082)
There aren’t many billionaires, and SS taxable income is capped; $128k this year. So a billionaire receiving SS is rightly entitled to receive what he contributed.

You can strip SS from the 1% and it will make no difference. You can do the same for the 10% and it will make little difference. The 10% payed FAR more in than they will receive.

Re:A real estate company's simple way to offer the homeless ... by Retric on Sunday September 23, 2018 @06:05PM (#18053538)
So, you agree SS is not a safty net?

PS: Social Security is hardly fair. That cap is by far the largest benifit for billionaires from social security’s design. People in the 10% pay a vastly higher percentage of their income to support others.

A fair system would be something like X% up to a cap that you get back and y% that you don’t with everyone paying their share of the y%. But that starts to look like a safty net.

On top of that married couples get a larger benifit with a single large income vs two incomes of half that size.