News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by rubicon33 on Sunday September 23, 2018 @02:26AM (#18049679)
"Third job was not a startup, but it was a fairly small company, and I've made nearly two million in tax deferred accounts"

I would love to know how. Am I just stupid? How am I missing these opportunities? Someone above posted that 4 years at FAANG would net you $1,000,000 savings. And you're saying that a "fairly small" company netted you $2,000,000 savings?

I am failing at life, apparently.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by faangthrowaway on Sunday September 23, 2018 @11:00PM (#18054731)
Just to add some concrete FAANG numbers for comparison...

I started at BigCo four years ago as a SWE, after my phd in a not-cs hard science. My starting salary was $130k, with about $30k for signing bonus and moving fees. At my first full year, I received an additional $60k in vesting equity, for about $200k total.

Last year I made Senior SWE, which gave a bump to $165k base pay. Meanwhile, stock equity trickle has continued to grow, and looks like ~$100k this year. And an additional $40k from bonuses for performance, recruiting and general 'company has too much money' put the projected total for the year at about $300k pre-tax (and not including health or other benefits).

I live afaict unusually frugally. I don't drive, live in a shared house, and don't have short humans to worry about. But I occasionally travel to interesting places and give ~$8-$10k a year to stuff I care about. After four years at BigCo, I've got about $450k in the bank+investments. So, not a million, but probably way better than I would have done with the startup scene... and it sounds like the one recruitment bonus I've gotten so far is better than most people ever see from a startup exit.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by rosser on Sunday September 23, 2018 @02:50AM (#18049759)
> I am failing at life, apparently.

Insofar as you seem to be "keeping score" against anyone but yourself, maybe a little. Otherwise, not really.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by civility on Sunday September 23, 2018 @02:48AM (#18049755)
I've never worked for a "big" company, much less one of FAANG. Although, I knew a kid who went to Apple, and he did well. I also had a friend from Intel, and he did well too.

My situation was much more than 4 years, but it was steady (exponential) growth at a nice rate, and I'm exiting in my mid 40s. Maybe I could've done better, but to the point of this topic, my one stable job did much better than the three startups I was exposed to.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by mikekchar on Sunday September 23, 2018 @08:17AM (#18050739)
People win the lottery. You don't ask "Am I doing something wrong. I bought a ticket too and didn't win anything".

These huge bonuses, etc are handed out to people who either have really scarce skills or get lucky.

Wikipedia[1] says there are nearly 4 million software developers in the US. If each were to receive a million dollars, then it would total up to 4 trillion USD (using US ways of naming large numbers). The GDP of the US in 2016 (same time the software developers demographics was reported) was about 18.6 trillion USD.

The idea that a million USD is reasonable for a developer is absolutely laughable.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_engineering_demograph...

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by pm90 on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:31AM (#18051231)
Nobody makes a million dollars a year. Read the comment... it’s over their entire tenure at the company.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by nojvek on Sunday September 23, 2018 @07:53PM (#18054033)
Even 4 years at FANG with million in savings is laughable. You gotta be pretty high up the ladder. It is definitely not the average.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by pm90 on Monday September 24, 2018 @01:17AM (#18055197)
Actually an initial grant of 600K in RSU's in a FAANG would probably net that much with 4 years of rapid growth in stock price. And don't forget the cash component isn't peanuts either.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by nojvek on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @08:49AM (#18065861)
Is 600K RSUs a normal thing? I’m guessing it’s only for senior+ engineers only.

That’s a ridiculous amount of money. Microsoft feels very stingy if this is the normal.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by pm90 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:19AM (#18083744)
The old guard (MS, IBM etc.) seem stingy indeed when it comes to comp (except for executives, who seem to be compensated somewhat similarly across the board).

The newer software firms are much much better at adequately compensating software engineers, and especially senior software engineers. If you are a senior software engineer you should seriously consider trying getting compensated along those lines.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by antaviana on Sunday September 23, 2018 @04:18AM (#18050031)
99% of times success or failure is just a state of mind, so it’s pretty much your choice to decide.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by cyphunk on Sunday September 23, 2018 @07:45AM (#18050629)
classic :)
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by SZJX on Monday September 24, 2018 @06:01AM (#18056347)
He never specified how many years he worked there, and he's apparently already retiring? Maybe that's over a very long period of time so I don't see how you're "failing". Maybe you're actually doing much better.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by tinkerteller on Monday September 24, 2018 @02:08AM (#18055391)
You are also failing in life against someone who won lottery last week. You should have lot of regret about not going to that same store and not choosing those same numbers that lottery winner chose.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by dyeje on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:28AM (#18051209)
I wouldn't believe everything you read on the internet. I often see absurb compensation packages posted on HN and have never seen anything close to them in real life.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by deanmoriarty on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:39AM (#18051261)
The fact that you are doubting the information I wrote in the previous comment, suggesting the parent poster to not necessarily believe them, is disturbing.

I can only say I truly got those packages and I’m an average engineer.

I suggest you ask to the close friends you have working at FAANG if those are true.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by dyeje on Sunday September 23, 2018 @11:58AM (#18051636)
First of all, I didn't read your previous comment and you are not the parent post of the comment I replied to.

I am sorry you are 'disturbed' by my skepticism of random people on the internet, but I don't have friends working at FAANG so all I have to go off is my own experience and publicly available info. Based on those, I find it hard to believe how many people here post that they make 500k+.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by patio11 on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:24AM (#18057425)
Hiya Dyeje. My name is Patrick. I was previously the CEO of a recruiting startup, have many friends who work at AppAmaGooBookSoft, and am broadly considered credible on HN. I do not work at AppAmaGooBookSoft and my financial exposure to them is denominated in probably tens of dollars; to the extent I am biased here, my incentives are to convince people to not take their offers.

AppAmaGooBookSoft do, indeed, pay deep into the six figures. Each of them has an engineering ladder, where promotions start off like promotions in grade school. If you're not fired, you make it to level X. (They don't fire many people.) The offer at X is, depending on negotiation skill, phases of the moon, perceived competition (particularly on the initial offer stage), and slight variations in performance, about $450k.

There are promotions available after X. People get them, approximately daily.

There are many people for whom it is not in their interest to tell you this, because it will make their offers or proposed life plans less attractive by comparison. There are many HNers who prefer ignoring reality on this issue, sometimes out of jealousy, sometimes out of pride, or sometimes out of believing that they can reason from first principles what Google should pay a Senior Software Engineer and therefore ignore what Google does pay a Senior Software Engineer.

These people are wrong. The market prints the deals where the market prints the deals.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by mailshanx on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @01:44AM (#18063887)
Do you know if there are any other markets other than the USA where a competent (but not necessarily celebrity-famous) dev can make 300-400k a year?

For many good devs, immigrating to the USA is close to impossible in these times. Would be nice to know if these kinds of salaries are attainable outside the states.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by jasonkester on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @02:07AM (#18063979)
Plenty of those American companies hire remote developers. I spent several years working for them here in France and the UK, for market compensation as measured at the Bay Area companies being discussed here.

Some places will try to pay you less based on your location. You can't blame them for trying, but you don't have to accept their first offer, either. The market is really good now.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by deanmoriarty on Sunday September 23, 2018 @01:20PM (#18052066)
I suggest then you download the blind app. It’s an anonymous app where people share offers they get (especially from FAANG), mostly to ask for negotiation advice. That’s where I posted my offers back then, as a sounding board to make sure I wasn’t taken for a ride.

You’ll quickly discover that either those compensations are real and very common considering how many posters are there, or the app is literally full of trolls pretending to have those offers and ask tips to other trolls, for whatever reason (except that they need to have a valid FAANG email account to post, so go figure why they would lie).

And there are many other resources to vet those numbers, such as http://levels.fyi or advice from “trusted” folks in the software community like patio11: https://mobile.twitter.com/patio11/status/100632191192687001...

As to why I am disturbed: people who don’t believe average software engineers can make that much are the reason why many employers don’t pay that much, so they drive down the overall compensation in the industry. If all software engineers were more aware of their market value, there would be less discrepancy in compensation, such as in other mature fields (e.g. doctors, lawyers). So, the fact you don’t believe me it’s disturbing because it’s directly affecting the job market I’m in.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by dyeje on Sunday September 23, 2018 @02:52PM (#18052520)
The sample size for levels.fyi is small and in Jeff Atwood's reply to patio11 only 7% of responders said they make over 400k+. I don't doubt that there are people out there (or even you) making that much, I just don't believe every rando on HN that chimes in to a salary thread saying they do. Sorry ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.

That said, would love if someone made a site dedicated to collecting these offer letters. Would certainly help next time I'm job hunting.

Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by sjg007 on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:48AM (#18051293)
The 450k includes money for health insurance right and in lieu of stock? I heard that Netflix would allow you to select compensation based on how much risk you are willing to take.
Re:Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your ... by deanmoriarty on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:53AM (#18051313)
Mostly correct, though I’m sure there were some employer subsidy for the health plan, and the ability to get some more advantage from the stock growth via something similar to ESPP.

I didn’t dig too deep into that because I recklessly opted for the startup instead of FAANG :), but the best deal was FB: everything was paid for and they were also offering a fat sign on bonus of 100k