I see research, especially fundamental research, like a lottery in which we don't know what we will win. State invests X billions of dollars, and a breakthrough will likely happen, but maybe not in the expected problem (principle of serendipity). More X billions means a higher chance of breakthrough, and hopefully on the desired problem. Surely experts and thinkers looked at efficiency in research, but by definition researching is about looking at the unknown, and when there is uncertainty, a lottery model is probably a better way of thinking about it.
Here's a typical unit:
Yow. I thought I had a pretty hardcore home lab with my Faxitron cabinet machine.
In trying to find the costs of a synchotron I came upon this article [1] that mentions the construction of an entire campus surronding a synchrotron, experimental facilities, and so on. The entire construction project and synchotron cost £263 million. That's at government level efficiency, which is to say significantly overpriced, and of course is also just a one-time expense. Even this one time inefficient cost however is only about 10% of our annual spend. The ongoing spend related to maintenance of the facility would of course be a small fraction of that upfront cost.
I just don't understand how one can argue that a 3x increase in funding can be expected to yield massive exponential gains in output.
[1] - https://www.theage.com.au/national/synchrotron-will-cost-tax...
I don't understand that kind of argument. You have to choose the right level of scale for what you are looking at. I would not trust an architect (of buildings) who is a particle physicist, or a forest(-system) manager whose specialization is the cell. Some things need to be looked at the the higher (compound) level to get any useful results.
EDIT (for the reply below, to which I cannot reply?):
> I find it important / useful for myself to put it into context.
Well, my point is that you don't.
For me the takeaway is that I went and calculated how many times richer than the average and therefore what my share of $0.5 per person would be. It still wasn’t a lot. And probably more affordable to me than the person at the middle of the income scale even then.
But yes! I see the “what about all the other things” element too.
Future generations are going to look back at us like we are psychopathic barbarians.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_by_duratio...
This seems to challenge belief. There are almost always rapidly diminishing returns on increasing allocation of resources once you reach a certain baseline. And almost is a weasel word there -- I can't think of anything where this is not true. Just like 50 programmers won't work 50 times faster than 1 programmer on a given task, 50 times the amount of money dedicated to a task will often provide far less than 50x the return. And the article's premise is suggesting not only a linear return on investment, but a largely exponential one.
Of course this all goes out the window when you're desperately understaffed or underfunded, but if $3 billion a year is anything remotely close to 'desperately underfunded' then it makes one wonder if that may be a product of waste and inefficiency than a lack of funding.