News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by thomasfedb on Sunday September 16, 2018 @02:47AM (#17997625)
For some science, the baseline is very high. You can't do X-ray crystallography of organic compounds, for example, without a synchrotron.
Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by yborg on Sunday September 16, 2018 @03:49AM (#17997813)
DNA's structure was deduced from X-ray crystallography using a conventional X-ray tube, most laboratory protein crystallography doesn't require a synchrotron light source.

Here's a typical unit:

https://www.rigaku.com/en/products/protein/micromax007

Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by CamperBob2 on Sunday September 16, 2018 @04:56AM (#17997998)
The MicroMax™ 007 HF is the most widely used home lab X-ray source for protein crystallography and a popular source for small molecule crystallographers who need the additional flux of a rotating anode generator.

Yow. I thought I had a pretty hardcore home lab with my Faxitron cabinet machine.

Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by thomasfedb on Sunday September 16, 2018 @09:21AM (#17998777)
Sorry, I meant lipid-phase organics. In any case, it is true that some science has huge initial investment cost - synchrotrons, space telescopes, etc
Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by TangoTrotFox on Sunday September 16, 2018 @03:40AM (#17997794)
Absolutely, but I think we become desensitized to numbers. $3,000,0000,000 is alot of money.

In trying to find the costs of a synchotron I came upon this article [1] that mentions the construction of an entire campus surronding a synchrotron, experimental facilities, and so on. The entire construction project and synchotron cost £263 million. That's at government level efficiency, which is to say significantly overpriced, and of course is also just a one-time expense. Even this one time inefficient cost however is only about 10% of our annual spend. The ongoing spend related to maintenance of the facility would of course be a small fraction of that upfront cost.

I just don't understand how one can argue that a 3x increase in funding can be expected to yield massive exponential gains in output.

[1] - https://www.theage.com.au/national/synchrotron-will-cost-tax...

Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by AnthonBerg on Sunday September 16, 2018 @06:10AM (#17998190)
It’s $0.5 per person.
Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by ItsMe000001 on Sunday September 16, 2018 @07:45AM (#17998450)
That's great in a single-variable universe, but in ours unfortunately there are a million other "it's (only) $0.5 per person" things. It's like letting the public choose what students have to learn - "but this is sooo important!" (and this, and this, and this,...).

I don't understand that kind of argument. You have to choose the right level of scale for what you are looking at. I would not trust an architect (of buildings) who is a particle physicist, or a forest(-system) manager whose specialization is the cell. Some things need to be looked at the the higher (compound) level to get any useful results.

EDIT (for the reply below, to which I cannot reply?):

> I find it important / useful for myself to put it into context.

Well, my point is that you don't.

Re:Vaccines Against H.I.V., Malaria and Tuberculosis Unlikel... by AnthonBerg on Sunday September 16, 2018 @08:59AM (#17998704)
It’s both a lot of money and also much less. I find it important / useful for myself to put it into context.

For me the takeaway is that I went and calculated how many times richer than the average and therefore what my share of $0.5 per person would be. It still wasn’t a lot. And probably more affordable to me than the person at the middle of the income scale even then.

But yes! I see the “what about all the other things” element too.