News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by tcbawo on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:51PM (#17974663)
Is it really surprising that a multinational company would have a preferred candidate? Although, I'm sure they lobbied extensively for all major candidates. It is interesting that both major parties seem to want to have their cake and eat it too when it comes to free speech, "common carrier", and antitrust issues.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:54PM (#17974997)
No, it's not surprising at all. Every company has a preferred candidate in pretty much every election, at least the CEO and top leadership certainly does.

What is surprising is turning an all hands into a kind of mass grieving funeration for all of their 90K employees, replete with publicly weeping executives and the entire executive leadership being vocally outraged. Turning an all hands into a political event like this is both unprofessional and, frankly, creepy.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by akhilcacharya on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:43AM (#17976098)
Imho it’s creepier to have a president-elect threaten to ban your employees from entering the country or threatens to lock up his opponent ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

This bizarre external obsession with the internal cultures of basically just 2 tech companies is really weirding me out too. Reminds me of the campus reform folks handwringing about Ivy League admissions...perhaps there’s a pattern.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by skybrian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:42PM (#17975246)
To add some context: remember that Google has employees who felt personally threatened by election results (immigrants and transgender employees). Nobody knew what Trump would do.

The worst fears turned out to be overblown, but it was hard to make the case for not worrying at the time. Telling people they had nothing to worry about would have simply been offensive.

There are few election results that employees would consider to be threatening like that. It was very much a special case.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:11PM (#17975391)
There are people personally threatened in every presidential election, and most of those fears are overblown pretty much all the time. Lots of extremist views in this country and lots of people feeling threatened about pretty much everything.

Should google have held the same weeping festival in case Hillary won, and someone was personally threatened that she would start a new war in Syria or lead to war in Russia? Which could lead to a nuclear war? Of course not. That would be as ridiculous as what happened now. You don't cater to those kinds of views in the workplace.

The correct response is not to hold a company meeting about how threatened anyone feels in an election, but to talk about the new products being rolled out and what you expect from your employees in their business life. And there are lots of blogs and opportunities for Google employees to express their political views outside the company. No public weeping of executives is required.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by skybrian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:19PM (#17975425)
Oh come on, you're doing a terrible job of understanding how your political opponents think.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by dang on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:15AM (#17976663)
Please don't post unsubstantive comments to HN, and certainly not uncivil ones.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by ctlby on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:05PM (#17975364)
It was trivial to make the case, and that people didn’t see this represents a massive epistomological failure. Perhaps it would have been offensive, but adults should not be indulged when they engage in hysteria.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by skybrian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:12PM (#17975396)
Eh. Maybe you could have used platitudes like "America has survived worse" and "most people in government will follow the law, even if he doesn't." But those aren't particularly comforting.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:16PM (#17975410)
I was around when Bush won re-election. After he lied us into war. I couldn't believe it. I was absolutely stunned, depressed, and horrified that something like that could happen.

Yet not once did I expect my employer to "comfort" me. I mean, my God, that's not the job of an employer. Friends comfort you. Your employer is not your friend.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rphlx on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:28PM (#17981630)
Google appears to have a long history of infantilizing its workforce, partly - one hopes - as a sort of group-bonding in-joke, and partly - one suspects - as a darker psychological management strategy with objectives that are not always unambiguously in the infant's best interest.
[dead]
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by akhilcacharya on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:46AM (#17976105)
Considering he continues to have a severely underwater approval rating I’d wager it’s less derangement and more the majority view.

If anything the “it’s all normal, everything is fine” folks whose reactions are more interesting here. It’s certainly not the consensus view.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by monochromatic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:50AM (#17978157)
I haven’t exactly seen trans folks being rounded up and out into camps. The people who said everything was going to be all right were correct. TDS remains in effect for others.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by akhilcacharya on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:50PM (#17980129)
“Not committing genocide” is a very low bar for a presidency in the worlds sole superpower and I’m concerned that anyone would hold this or any administration to such a low standard.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by monochromatic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:01PM (#17981377)
It’s what people were getting their panties in a wad over.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by swebs on Thursday September 13, 2018 @04:56AM (#17977079)
His approval rating has been hovering around 45-50%.

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/trum...

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by akhilcacharya on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:47AM (#17978136)
That is the sole pollster that indicates this. The rest indicate low 40's to mid-high 30's. This is despite a growing economy.

https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/trump-approval-ratings/

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by monochromatic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:51AM (#17978164)
And we still trust polls in a post-2016 world?
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by akhilcacharya on Thursday September 13, 2018 @09:01AM (#17978242)
....yes
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by monochromatic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @09:44AM (#17978519)
No concerns about the “shy trump voter” phenomenon this time around?
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by akhilcacharya on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:32PM (#17979911)
Nobody believed that then either because it’s a myth.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by monochromatic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:01PM (#17981379)
How do you explain the election results then?
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by aikinai on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:09AM (#17975937)
Seems everyone's down-voting you, but considering the huge number of immigrants and international employees at Google, it'd be crazy to expect a Trump win to be treated neutrally when the foundation of his platform was antagonism of immigrants and other countries.

And it wasn't completely overblown, there were many Googlers trapped inside or outside the US immediately after Trump took power; one, for example, had no way for her parents to meet her newborn baby as they were all banned from travel. [0]

[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/one-google-employee-on-trump-or...

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by pen2l on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:17AM (#17976243)
I work in a research hospital, I went through a lot of similar meetings, and a lot of emails talking about where to get help if you're feeling down.

I remember thinking hey this is a bit over-blown... but then I talked to this Iranian guy on my floor: he was extremely shocked and depressed. He had a situation on his hands -- he wanted his wife to come to America, but was afraid that wouldn't be possible and he was entertaining the idea of just quitting and returning to Iran.

Surely at Google, where a lot of immigrants work, they went through similar experiences.

So I totally am okay with what I see in the video -- I think it was the right move by GOOG executives to take that position, if only for the employees.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by Domenic_S on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:33AM (#17976295)
What happened with your friend's wife? Did she come over?
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by theossuary on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:10AM (#17977940)
Considering Trump is still in power, and the travel ban is still in effect, I'd say that's a no.

Americans have a short memory.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by Domenic_S on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:20PM (#17980434)
The ban has exceptions for, for ex. students; there are still ways.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by ryanobjc on Thursday September 13, 2018 @02:10AM (#17976415)
Also, many people think that openly accepting immigrants is what makes both google and America great. It was pretty clear that trump was very anti immigrant. And that’s a direct attack on the success of google.

And the first thing he did policy wise literally confirmed everyone’s worst fears.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by betterunix2 on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:37AM (#17978079)
Google employees are highly educated (disproportionate numbers of PhDs work there etc.), and highly educated people in America, on both the left and right, were mourning when Trump was elected. You do not have to be left leaning to think a President who does not read books, who admires dictators, who is surrounded by criminals, and whose campaign rhetoric involved the overt demonization of ethnic and religious minorities (and plenty of dog whistles too), might be a bad thing for this country. I would have voted Republican if the Democrat candidate had encouraged division in this country the way Trump did. I have intelligent Republican friends who voted for Hillary for the same reason; even my Christian Conservative father in law, who said Bush was not conservative enough, could not bring himself to vote for Trump (he only voted for congressional candidates in 2016). People across the political spectrum recognized the danger Trump poses from the moment he started talking about Mexican rapists.

One problem with the "debate" on Trump is the effort by some to make this into just another political disagreement and to normalize Trump. It is not just politics and the all-hands meeting was not a "political event." People have every reason to be scared by what has been happening since Trump took office.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by JohnBooty on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:46PM (#17974946)
Wanting to improve their news algorithm to favor more trustworthy sources is not a violation of free speech.

"Free speech" guarantees you the right to say what you want, as long as it doesn't interfere with others' freedoms (i.e., making death threats or yelling "fire" in a crowded movie theater)

"Free speech" does not guarantee you a platform for your protected free speech. I have the right to claim blatantly false things; Google is absolutely not obligated to amplify my voice.

I am allowed to claim that Obama shot JFK. That does not mean that Google, you, or anybody else is obligated to help me spread that opinion.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by gizmo686 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:56PM (#17975016)
The first amendment does not prevent Google (or any other company) from restricting speech. That is a very low bar.

The distinction between government and private groups is not a clean as you might think. At a large enough scale, private groups can start to take on a role in society that resembles that of a government, should we not then expect them to be held to a standard that resembles that we expect of governments?

The FCC cannot revoke your spectrum license for saying Obama shot JFK. Should ISPs be able to revoke your internet license for saying that?

Google is a much harder case, because the core service they provide is filtering; and that filtering is an immensely valuable public service. But given the role that filtering plays in society, is is not an area that should be left unregulated.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by adamrezich on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:15PM (#17975406)
>The distinction between government and private groups is not a clean as you might think. At a large enough scale, private groups can start to take on a role in society that resembles that of a government, should we not then expect them to be held to a standard that resembles that we expect of governments?

I hope this view becomes more mainstream soon. Regardless of outcome, it's something that people need to consciously think about.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:13PM (#17975093)
That's a bit of a strawman, since the OP didn't talk about the first amendment but about "free speech". Free Speech is a principle coming from the enlightenment of which the first amendment is one expression, but certainly not the only expression.

The idea is that speech should be tolerated even if you disagree with it, and that societies that make room for controversial speech are better off, in the long run, than societies that do not. As a corollary, it espouses the view that individuals should be free to speak their mind and should be tolerated even if their speech is controversial. Because we cherish Free Speech, we created the first amendment. The first amendment is not the sum total of free speech, nor is free speech merely a governmental issue. For example, the California labor protections that protect employees from being fired for what they say in their private time is an example of the principle of free speech at work, and has nothing to do with the first amendment.

The principle of free speech is why there are many processes, both private and public, in which the public is invited for individuals to air their views, whether they be question and answer sessions in companies, or local government hearings. It's also the principle behind movements to build public libraries that stock controversial books. Almost every institution, whether public or private, tries to give some room for dissenting speech in its operations and tries to create a space for people to air their views. Thus the attacks on these spaces, even if they are not attacks on the first amendment, are of concern to those of us who value free speech. This includes opposition to efforts at censorship, both public and private, whether these be the circulation of blacklists of communists during the cold war, or any other kind of punishment, both public and private, merely for speech.

You may not agree with these values, but merely saying "well, the first amendment doesn't prohibit it, so it's not an attack on free speech" is a wild misunderstanding of what free speech is.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by gizmo686 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:20PM (#17975131)
I'm not sure if you are agreeing with me or not.

As far as I am aware, the US does not have any substantial free speech protection other then the first amendment, so it does not make sense to say that "free speech" guarantees us anything beyond what the first amendment does.

The arguement that my parent was making is that Google can deny you use of their platform without violating your free speech. In my view, the only way that makes sense is if you interpret free speech as narrowly defined by the first amendment. Otherwise, to be denied Google seems to be clearly denied free speech.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by amanaplanacanal on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:29PM (#17979875)
Yes but. It seems to me that forcing somebody to say what you want them to say is a much larger infringement on free speech than preventing them from speaking. Who should be telling Google, or anybody else for that matter, what they have to say? I have heard people suggest that Twitter, Facebook, or Google de-platforming people is an abrogation of free speech, but it seem to me that it would be a worse abrogation if you didn't allow them to do that. Should we pass laws to force the New York Times to print certain articles? That would seem a worse outcome for free speech than what we have now.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by 3rwww1 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:42PM (#17975541)
> The distinction between government and private groups is not a clean as you might think. At a large enough scale, private groups can start to take on a role in society that resembles that of a government, should we not then expect them to be held to a standard that resembles that we expect of governments?

Just after his Senate hearings, Mark Zuckerberg made some statements about preventing further election interference (obviously), and then went on talking about implementing new content-filtering policies within Facebook such as "community driven governance", an "appeal process" and even a "supreme court" and some sort of "due process" (Paris Vivatech 2018, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gp0BnrHn6cA around 34:40)

Zuckerberg and his peers are not elected individual, they cannot be removed from office, etc. While not disputing his intentions, using tools traditionaly used within democracies doesn't make up for a democratic process. Substituting laws by terms & conditions, courts by a privately-owned justice system, is a slippery slope to say the least.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by JohnBooty on Sunday September 16, 2018 @09:51PM (#18002579)

    The distinction between government and private groups is 
    not a clean as you might think. At a large enough scale, 
    private groups can start to take on a role in society that 
    resembles that of a government, should we not then expect 
    them to be held to a standard that resembles that we expect 
    of governments?
Absolutely agree that companies, particularly companies with large market share, can effectively wield state-level powers and that it is something we need to figure out as a country.

In this case we're talking about Google's all-hands discussion about weeding out bad-faith actors. They weren't trying to silence people who simply thought Trump was the better candidate, they were talking about something very close to spam filtering. "Silence Republicans" is something that (even as a liberal) is something I'd be absolutely opposed to; filtering out outright fraudulent news sources (from any part of the political spectrum) is something we should all support.

We've been doing something similar as a country for many years. Notice how tabloids like the National Enquirer aren't typically lumped in with "real" news sources at the newsstand.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by tinkerteller on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:06AM (#17975925)
It is surprising that those people put in charge to run business by stockholders are picking sides in front of employees who they have subordinate powers over them. This is big no no. Imagine being an employee who believes in conservatism and being forced in to group think, suppress your personal political speech and view. There is no difference in boss pitching himself as politically left vs boss pitching Christianity vs boss pitching male superiority over females. Business should never take sides in politics, race, gender or religion to make sure they are fair to all employees. Leaders needs to keep their view in these subject personal just as they keep their religious identity personal. Not doing this allows businesses to essentially hijack democracy by enforcing their political will on employees. Businesses should not be wielding their leverage of paychecks in to bending anybody’s political will and opinions.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by solipsism on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:20AM (#17975988)
Imagine being an employee who believes in conservatism and being forced in to group think

Forced? No one is forced to work for any given company.

Companies are not mindless profit making machines. Not even public ones. They're composed of people. They have values. Some are very homogeneous culturally, some very heterogeneous.

Business should never take sides in politics

You are welcome to your opinion on that point. I don't agree, nor do many other people. As an employee and as a shareholder, I like companies with strong moral character. And that can include political action.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rdtsc on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:56AM (#17976174)
> Is it really surprising that a multinational company would have a preferred candidate?

Not really. Google lobbies the government more than Verizon, Wall St. banks and defense contractors. We don't usually mind cause they lobby for the things we care about as well.

However we could also see how perhaps Eric Schmidt, ex-CEO and at that time Executive Chairman, walking about at a Hillary Clinton's event with a staff badge might make things a bit too obvious:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CxbUJoZWEAAzp04.jpg

But perhaps Google isn't partisan enough? I think it is the superficial "we are not biased and all opinions are welcome" type message clashing with their existing bias, that's bothering people. I think they should be bolder even and say, we are biased, we support these values.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:26PM (#17974844)
Corporations seem like they have a comical level of hypocrisy, until you realize that corporations are in it for the money, and will almost always take the most profitable position for them in any given debate.

For instance, you will see strong calls to regulate businesses they have to interact with, while actively fighting against regulation of themselves, even on the same issues.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:00PM (#17975334)
Yes, corporations are in it for the money, and they are hypocrites, etc. I don't think most people have a problem with that (except maybe those who think corporations are moral agents), but what's been happening recently is very concerning:

1. Corporations, always wanting to appeal to younger voters because brand loyalty is sticky, naturally try to position themselves externally as hip/woke/whatever. That means espousing whatever cool urban cause is hot right now, like Nike supporting Kaepernick to whitewash their labor and environmental record while appealing to urban trendsetters, or cosmetic companies parading around 12 year old transgender models to show how leading edge they are. That's not a big deal by itself, as Nike gonna Nike and everyone wants to position themselves as a trend-setting lifestyle brand.

2. Tech companies, in particular, needing to appeal to a tight labor market for young programmers, feel a need to make more internal concessions to the politics that young programmers have, creating a woke monoculture in many places. No, they're not gonna budge on stuff like paying taxes, but they are happy to no-platform someone who is, say, pro-life, or uses the term "illegal immigrant" instead of "undocumented american", or someone who points out the real risks of giving mastectomies to pre-teens or even medical castration of young boys suffering from gender dysphoria. OK, a bit creepy, but the republic will survive (although some of the kids are going to have a hard time).

3. The same companies are now effective monopolies in large online spaces (Facebook, twitter), online marketplaces (Amazon), and online information dissemination (Google).

Uh oh. Combine 1,2,3 and you have a real threat to Free Speech. If you say the wrong thing, you might get booted from huge public marketplaces.

If you only had 1, 2, you could always find some competing brand and there wouldn't be a monoculture.

If you only had 3, then you might expect, say Google, to skew information about H1-B visas or whatever narrow economic interests it cares about, which while bad for the public discourse, isn't an all encompassing, stifling thing.

But the combination of all 3 poses really big problems for creating space for dissenting views and having those views heard. The closest analogy I can think of would the 1950s chill, in which a few large conglomerates were working hand in glove to suppress communist/leftist views. That was the era of Chomsky and Hermann's "Manufacturing Consent", where leftist positions were thrown into the memory hole and only lived in fringe spaces, like random anarchist bookstores and tiny meetups. They were completely shut out of the public dialogue and policy making process. Blacklists circulated of who you shouldn't hire, and there was consensus on what you shouldn't report. It was a bad time, and led to some very, very bad decisions, such as the Vietnam war, war on drugs, and rollback of some important new deal protections. I'm not looking forward to the new circulation of blacklists and the cheering that is happening to the new chill in public discourse.

Now we see a similar monoculture forming that is trying to stifle what are basically traditional conservative cultural views -- views that were basically mandatory in the 50s are forbidden today -- while you still have the right wing views about economic organization in place -- and this is also going to lead to some very bad decisions.

At least no one has won a total victory, and so you see leftist business openly weeping at government election results, not because they are sad about all the tax cuts, extension of IP protections, and further erosion of anti-trust, which they knew they would get, but because it offends the cultural left who they need to cater to as their employees and young urban customers.

But if you look at a scatterplot of where people fall, the biggest group is the cultural conservative/economically liberal group. Although it's trendy to say you are an economic conservative and cultural liberal, fewer people inhabit that space.

So we are in a situation in which the maximum number of people are being excluded from the public discourse. Even if you don't agree with this group, if there is still some shred of shared loyalty for your fellows, you don't want to see the majority of the nation excluded from our new monoculture. It's a great time for tax cuts, but not a good time for free speech and we are gonna make some colossally terrible decisions as a result of this exclusion, together with radicalizing a large section of the population.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by tcbawo on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:41PM (#17975536)
Technology and information overload are driving everybody to think their viewpoint is the suppressed majority, feeding a victim mentality. We seem to be working towards more of a massively individual polyculture than monoculture. Also, we shouldn't always project everything into right and left, as there are other orthogonal dimensions for framing policy (eg. authoritarian and individualistic). That's a hidden cost of the creeping politicization of everything.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by TangoTrotFox on Thursday September 13, 2018 @10:09AM (#17978716)
There's an interesting thought experiment. Break America in half by general partisan divide - allow for free migration based on political ideology alone. How long would it take before these now wholly 'unified' halves then turn to bitter and polar divisiveness? What would be the new divisive topics?

There's probably roughly a 0% chance of success, but Calexit would be a phenomenal social experiment and perhaps something people could learn an immense amount from. On the other hand, there's already an immense amount of information and history people could learn from today. But anything that's inconvenient to 'the' ideology is irrelevant, of course.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @06:15PM (#17983153)
I don't think it would take long at all, sadly.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @05:49PM (#17982963)
I totally agree that this is not a right/left issue per se. There are many competing strains:

traditionalists are skeptical of radical social change, but may also be skeptical of turning everything over the free market

libertarians just want to be left alone and don't want anyone telling them what to do

leftists may be communitarians or anarchists or even neoliberals who want to abolish national borders

And people may have different views on different scales -- e.g. I know a lot of Nimby's who oppose new people they don't like moving into their neighborhood and think they should have a right to keep them out, but at the same time support open borders for the nation as a whole.

And to be honest, I think there is something to recommend each of these views. Nobody is entirely the enemy. What bothers me is attempts to blacklist arguments/speech or to suppress open debate between these competing views. That really bothers me. It's like you can't just disagree with someone, you have to snuff them out, try to get them fired, and expel the enemy entirely from your view. It's a recipe for disaster.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by adamrezich on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:34PM (#17975505)
This is a great analysis and I'm mainly replying in order to hopefully spur replies with actual constructive discussion instead of letting this turn into one of those [dead] comments you see that says something "controversial" yet gets zero replies before being buried; it's always a bummer when that happens.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by carapace on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:36PM (#17975779)
I think we're seeing the formation of "Morlocks" and "Eloi". Most people can't conceive of or understand the potential power of FB, Google, etc. to form, in effect, a new mode of government.

Even CA is mostly a "red state" outside of the cities.

Speaking to hypocrisy, I haven't watched the video (yet) but I'm sure the "lower classes" of Google will not be represented in the attendees. The service staff at Google are largely made up of a different proportion of races than the technical staff. Fraternizing is discouraged and, in fact, the service staff can get in trouble for it. It's the kinder, gentler racism of the well-to-do left.

Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by amanaplanacanal on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:34PM (#17979934)
Can you give us some examples of number 2 happening? Because all I've heard about is those companies removing people who are whipping up their followers to abuse somebody. It is possible that there are examples of them removing people who are merely expressing conservative values, but I haven't seen it yet.
Re:Google’s first all-hands after 2016 election [video] by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @05:55PM (#17982995)
Well, say person X thinks we should have fewer H1-B visas. Person Y thinks to themselves "Hey, this is my enemy! He is trying to expel me from the country! He's attacking me! He makes me feel unsafe"

And all of a sudden, you can claim to be firing people for being abusive, when in reality you are firing someone for expressing their policy preferences.

And if we really want to have open debate, we need to discuss these things. Imagine if you are pro raising capital gains taxes, or repealing Prop 13, and someone else depends on that for their livelihood. They will feel personally threatened. Or someone who is pro-life might make someone who is pro-choice feel personally threatened. And I haven't even gotten into foreign policy.

In this modern era where everyone is screaming about being "unsafe" whenever they hear something that they oppose, and everything is personalized, pretty much everything that you feel strongly about is going to sound abusive to you if you are on the other side.