News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by dbcurtis on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @08:14PM (#17964574)
The "deal breakers" checklist skirts the true issue.

I have been married longer than most HN members have been alive, which is no accident. So I'll temporarily be arrogant enough say my peace on the theory that someone might find it useful, and then duck and cover.

There really is only one thing that matters: You and your partner must share the same value system, or at least if not identical, then there must not be core values in conflict.

Why? If you agree on core values, then any disagreements (and there will be many) will be about implementation, not about the desired end state. Those are healthy discussions, even if stressful. It is possible to both be "on the same side of the problem" -- it is the two of you against the problem, and the disagreement is about how to get from point A to point B.

On the other hand, when a core value is in conflict, the only way one person can be happy is if the other person gives up a part of themselves. That is at the very least the seed of resentment, and can't help but be a wound that will not heal.

So.. Step 1: Clarify in your own mind your own values. Until you have done that, you have nothing to go on. Step 2: Get to know your potential partner well enough that you both understand each other's core values. Make sure they are compatible.

I wish I could say I did this, but in all honesty I had been married for 20 years before I understood it. I just happened to get lucky -- growing up under similar circumstances as my bride has given us common touchstones.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by 01100011 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @08:33PM (#17964651)
The problem is people often change in fundamental ways. It is difficult to choose a partner in your early 20s who will retain the same value system throughout their life. Both myself and my ex are very different people from what we were in our 20s.

There are many factors that contribute to a successful marriage. I'd say commitment is one - you have to want the marriage to work. You have to accept that the other person is an individual and accept that they aren't your twin and also that they are free to grow. You may disagree, for instance politically, yet you have to respect them and allow the differences. It's tough to run a 3 legged race for 30-40 years.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by dsajames on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @02:02AM (#17965896)
I find that people who marry young grow together. The post about core values hits it right on the head in my years of experience.

Nothing has come close to ruining my marriage as much as that.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by Diederich on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @08:25PM (#17964622)
I've been married about 19 years, and I think I'm clear on what you're saying. But I haven't heard it put quite this way.

Can you cite some concrete examples of these values, and, perhaps, common ways that an otherwise seemingly compatible couple might not share them? Thanks.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by umvi on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @08:51PM (#17964738)
Person A is religious and values spiritual growth. Person A wants their kids to believe in God and develop spiritually. Person B is atheist and thinks religion is a crock. Person B wants their kids to reject religion and flush spirituality down the toilet. Person B is willing to let A go to church on Sundays to make the relationship work since B is attracted to A.

But there will probably be big problems with this over time, especially if kids come into the picture.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by rayiner on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:39PM (#17964959)
> Can you cite some concrete examples of these values, and, perhaps, common ways that an otherwise seemingly compatible couple might not share them? Thanks.

A friend of mine's wife once said to him, about planning some extended vacation despite his busy schedule: "if you loved me you'd make time!" Between my wife and I, this is a punchline. But for many perfectly reasonable people it would be a sincere request worthy of fulfillment. A couple having different reactions to this statement could mean a lot of resentment built-up over time.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by thrownaway1337 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:15PM (#17964832)
Why should we get married in the first place?

And how do you clarify your values? Can you give some examples of what your values are?

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by jd75 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:18PM (#17964845)
Everyone's goals vary, but I got married because I wanted kids and I wanted help raising them from someone with a vested interest in doing so.
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by thrownaway1337 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:27PM (#17964898)
Why did you want kids?

I always felt like I should want to get married and that I should want kids, but I just... don't. The desire just isn't there. I'm 29 and have been with my partner for long enough that marriage and likely kids are now the next stops on the what you're supposed to do in life train.

And I guess it's not that I actively don't want it. I just don't feel an inclination toward or away from it. There's just kind of an absent feeling about it... There's not anything internal making me want it (there is external pressure from my partner though who does want to get married and from society who expects us to get married).

Does this feeling change? Or am I just weird? Or should I just do it anyway?

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by poulsbohemian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:17AM (#17965519)
Getting married and having kids is not for everyone. Rather, I'd say we should do more as a society to encourage people to think very hard about these decisions rather than continue to treat them as standard operating procedure.

I had a crappy homelife as a kid and I believe that caused me to really want to create a contented adulthood, which included children. Actually, from the time I was just a little kid I was called upon as a mentor to other children, by the time I got to high school I was a camp counselor, was teaching in an evening pre-school program for abused children, etc. So from an early age I found myself in a parent-like role. My kids are my world, but I don't believe for a minute that everyone would find the experience as rewarding.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by captain_perl on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:06PM (#17965059)
Most women in a relationship will emphatically tell you when they want to get engaged, married or have kids.

They also have a biological clock to have kids before they're 35, and most listen to that clock.

Men don't have that clock, so there's different types and levels of motivation.

In my case, I wasn't interested in having kids until my late 40s, when the circumstances were convincing (responsible partner, as late in life as reasonably possible.)

Although I prefer being around adults, I understand that kids are doing their job when they require attention. I find my "clone" to be a plus overall, though expensive.

Career-wise, I vaguely thought having kids would be an advantage somehow, but I was incorrect. In the USA, companies don't care about employees ("at will employment"), and the same is true about your family.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by derekp7 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:30PM (#17965152)
That last part depends on the type of employer. In my case, as a male, I started to see a huge improvement in promotions and pay increases once I became a "family man" (although in my case, I'm not married to my partner, and she came with kids -- but it was always treated as a family unit).
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by captain_perl on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:53PM (#17965259)
> I started to see a huge improvement

I'd appreciate if you can expand on that a little more. How do co-workers know? How is it acknowledged?

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by jd75 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:23PM (#17965120)
I didn't want kids until I was 14 and my mom had an oopsie-baby. The intense love I felt for my baby sister changed my mind. And I wasn't wrong -- despite many, many, many drawbacks to having children, I love them just the way I'd hoped.

But I think people are so different that I definitely would not try to up-sell kids. At least so far, it's like having a 24/7 job, while I have a full-time job.

(Or as the rest of the comments say, women all want all the kids and all your money that's just science...)

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by dzhiurgis on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:11PM (#17965080)
Why do you need to get married to have kids?
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by mcphage on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:03PM (#17974294)
You don’t need to get married to have kids. When you get down to it, the number of things you need to have kids is pretty small—healthy gametes is sufficent.

But what you should have is commitment to your relationship. Being willing to demonstrate that commitment is helpful, but it’s not required.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by jd75 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:30PM (#17965154)
it was probably mostly because "everyone's doing it", but i'm glad we did. a little harder to bail when the going gets tough when the in-laws' friends have given you a cuisinart. ;)
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by poulsbohemian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:08AM (#17965486)
I was married for 17 years, for about the last ten unhappily, and together with that person for about twenty. You absolutely nailed it - if the values are in sync, it works. Unfortunately sometimes values shift as life goes on.
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by jd75 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:15PM (#17964833)
I'm not sure I could identify my "core values" in a crowd -- where I feel lucky is in the "healthy discussions". My husband and I don't hit each other with too many of the Four Horsemen: https://www.gottman.com/blog/the-four-horsemen-recognizing-c...
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by dsajames on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:59AM (#17965881)
Wow. Very well said. I have had years of unsettled conflicts because I didn't do this when I married.