News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by digitalzombie on Monday September 10, 2018 @05:23AM (#17950475)
We, the USA, is not going to have any friends left... Seems like Trump is pissing off Canada, Mexico, NATO, and EU.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by googlryas on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:08AM (#17950656)
What realistically has changed with the relationships? Renegotiate a few trade deals, chastise countries for (probably) not meeting guidelines they agreed to, slap countries on the wrist when they try to side-step international trade norms...these aren't earth-shattering things, and have all happened in the past. The only difference was that there was not the hysterical air in the media surrounding POTUS.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by hef19898 on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:36AM (#17950755)
I think it's two-fold. One thing is the message, regardless of your personel point of view any government has the right to adress any topiuc they wish with other countries. And then there is the communication part. There are long established diplomatic standards which are ignored and even violated on a constant basis.

The last part is in itself a serious problem, flawed reasoning behind the messages are a compounding factor.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by addicted on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:22AM (#17950928)
A lot has changed. People simply don’t see the US as a reliable ally anymore.

And this isn’t just the same as before. Past Presidents don’t claim that NATO partners owe the US money based on a misunderstanding of how NATO works (they have complained about NATO partners not pulling their weight which is why all of them have set concrete targets for increasing involvement which are set to take place over a few more years, for which of course Trump will try to take credit ignoring that these were negotiated by Bush/Obama).

They also didn’t pull out of treaties such as the Iran deal or the Paris climate accord the way Trump did, or constantly threaten countries about pulling out of treaties that the US pushed for and drive such as NAFTA or TPP.

They also didn’t try to wreck other countries’ economies based on the fact that they need to placate their base such as with NATO ally Turkey.

They also didn’t spread lies and misinformation about partner countries based on the latest Fox News conspiracy without first checking with the largest intelligence operations in the world which is available to them like he did with falsehood about London and the U.K. before visiting.

They also didn’t have allied intelligence agencies basically stop sharing sensitive information with their US intelligence counterparts because they leaked (inadvertently or deliberately) it to Putin.

There is a lot more than just “media hysterics” that make things different.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by acct1771 on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:47AM (#17952607)
What conspiracy was Fox News part of, in your sentence?

Or did you mean conspiracy theory?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:28AM (#17952022)
> Past Presidents don’t claim that NATO partners owe the US money based on a misunderstanding of how NATO works (they have complained about NATO partners not pulling their weight which is why all of them have set concrete targets for increasing involvement which are set to take place over a few more years, for which of course Trump will try to take credit ignoring that these were negotiated by Bush/Obama).

Can you explain your differentiation to me on how past presidents complaints about NATO members not meeting obligations is based on a proper understanding of how NATO works, but the current president's same complaints are based on a misunderstanding of how NATO works?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by danmaz74 on Monday September 10, 2018 @05:28AM (#17950498)
I (a EU citizen) still hope that Trump - and his peers over here - isn't going to last long enough as a president to do permanent damage.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by abricot on Monday September 10, 2018 @05:53AM (#17950596)
I'm getting more and more worried that it doesn't help just waiting for the world to get back to its senses. US is not the only country where leading politicians have seemingly lost their minds - and there I'm not as naive to think that it will be over when the current politicians leave office.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by wyldfire on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:08AM (#17951514)
I fear he already has done permanent damage. We in the US will need to work hard to repair the damage done.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by vetinari on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:16AM (#17950688)
It wasn't Trumps administration that openly spied on Merkel... and she didn't do anything.

Five Eyes will be never a friend of continental Europe, no matter what administration.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by fetbaffe on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:48AM (#17950803)
And Merkel...Oh

"Between 1999 and 2006, Germany’s federal intelligence service BND spied on around 2,000 targets at political institutions, international organizations, banks, companies and weapons producers in Austria, said daily Der Standard and weekly Profil."

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-austria-germany-spying/au...

"A number of US businesses and government entities were being monitored by the German foreign intelligence agency, according to documents received by the German newspaper Der Spiegel.

Between 1998 and 2006, several White House emails, phone, and fax numbers were reportedly tracked using a set of 4,000 keywords."

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

Rule of thumb - never trust spy agencies.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by lexs on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:57AM (#17951806)
Schröder was chancellor during that time. But still - never trust spy agencies.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by fetbaffe on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @04:02AM (#17957918)
Correct, he was chancellor until 2005, Merkel was responsible for one year only.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by yardie on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:49AM (#17950809)
I’m not sure what she could do, openly. Demand an apology? Or work silently so that it wouldn’t happen again. I feel the later is the more likely action taken.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by vetinari on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:12AM (#17950887)
From Willy Wimmer interview in 2014 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=faL4zRUdQTA, segment from 1:03:28, very loose translation):

---

Ken: Mr. Wimmer, can you imagine headlines "Vladimir Putin has listened to cellphone of the German chancellor for ten years"?

Wimmer: That would lead to revolutionary situation in Germany.

Ken: And if they would say "China runs a flat spy operation in Germany"?

Wimmer: They are accused of that anyway.

Ken: But why nothing happened after NSA affair? At first they said "we don't do such thing", then "we do it a will do it further".

Wimmer: That's a question of national dignity.

Ken: Do we still have it?

Wimmer: You already answered that.

Ken: Did I?

Wimmer: By asking the question. If it happened anywhere else, we would definitely cut the contact. But the reality is, as you just described. Business as usual.

---

Based on information from interviews like this, I think that nothing has happened, and no action was taken. US (correctly) assessed, that Germany can do nothing, and did what they wanted/needed/whatever. Germany can't do anything from it's position of weakness.

If Germany wants to change that, the steps necessary do not take into account the past, current or future US administration. Only German interests.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by Udo_Schmitz on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:10AM (#17951531)
Ken Jebsen is an anti-American, right wing conspiracy theorist

Both he and Willy Wimmer toe the Kremlin line

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KenFM

https://www.tagesspiegel.de/medien/juergen-elsaesser-und-sei...

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:34AM (#17952088)
That may be, but what matters is whether the above conversation is a reasonably accurate representation of what has actually transpired. Is what they say true or false, generally speaking?
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by Udo_Schmitz on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:53AM (#17952646)
Like I just wrote in another comment: the quoted part of the interview is low on facts and consists mainly of opinion. Yes, the U.S. tapped Merkel's phone. Russia and China spy on Germany as well, though I don't know how good their phone tap capabilities are. That headlines like “Vladimir Putin has listened to cellphone of the German chancellor for ten years” “would lead to revolutionary circumstances in Germany” is total nonsense in my opinion.

I assume Jebsen and Wimmer try to suggest that Germany is not a sovereign state. Points like that are often made in their circles and link to the “Reichsbürgerbewegung”.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichsbürgerbewegung

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by vetinari on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:09AM (#17951890)
Tagesspiel is a part of the Lügenpresse network.

See how easy is to label someone? Address the points, do not ad-hominem the messenger.

Wimmer spent decades in CDU, with results to show. He "toes the Kremlin line" because he disagreed with the wars in Yugoslavia, Iraq and Afghanistan, and we cannot have that.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by Udo_Schmitz on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:39AM (#17952552)
My comment is by definition not ad hominem. The part of the interview you quoted is low on facts and consists mainly of opinion. I would like to help the non-German audience on Hacker News to be able to classify the positions of the persons involved. That is why I also provided links with sources. Ken Jebsen and Willy Wimmer are part of what we call in Germany the “Querfront”: that literally translates to “cross-front” and in the historical sense is the term used for anti-democratic strategies to combine the opposing ideologies of nationalism and socialism in order to assume political power in the Weimar Republic. Internationally the modern iteration is known as “Third Position”. Today you can find those positions in every political party. They have in common that their positions are anti-American, anti-NATO and pro-Putin. So Mr. Wimmers CDU membership doesn't come in to play.

My translation from the introduction of “Rechte Hetze im Netz - eine unterschätzte Gefahr” by Patrick Gensing: “This heated atmosphere is fired by pro-Russian strategists who propagate a close alliance with Putins Russia. The result is a cross-front that wants to impose an authoritarian-nationalist system.”

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Querfront#Rechtspopulismus

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Position

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by simonh on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:41AM (#17950781)
Western countries have always spied on each other, jostling for position and influence. That is nothing new. Openly declaring hostile intent against an ally - that's new. I'm not sure if people in the US really understand how horrified everyone, of every political stripe are about Trump's behaviour towards us and the elected Republican leadership's complicity in it.

It's not just about Trump anymore. He could be kicked out of office at the next election, sure. But the elected republican leadership, who have their own democratic mandate, are just rolling over and letting all this happen. If they can't be relied on now, they can't be relied on after Trump either. As a conservative Brit, that grew up politically during the titanic partnership between Reagan and Maggie, this is all bewilderingly horrible.

I still remember the Falkland war and the way that, while it took the US a while to realise what was happening, in the end here was never any real question over here that we would be able to rely on the US in the end. I don't think that would have been substantially different under any subsequent US president even right up to Obama. But now? I don't think there is any such confidence. Can you imagine a British Prime Minister worrying about what Trump might tweet after we sank the Belgrano?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by fetbaffe on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:55AM (#17950826)
EU is not really the same as the UK, especially if UK is leaving the EU.

Trumps criticism is against the EU, Trump is a nationalist, something he is scolded for by the left, but everyone wants to forget his nationalism when it fits the argument that he is anti-UK (or any other European country)

And not to mention, Trumps "foe" comment was in regard to trading with EU, not a military conflict.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by simonh on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:30AM (#17952046)
I'm perfectly aware he's a nationalist, why do you think I'm forgetting it? I'm concerned principally with what he's doing because of it.

Trump's trade actions against the EU, including Britain, and other allies were on national security grounds. He's publicly sided with Putin against his own national security agencies. None of this is encouraging from a European perspective.

Nobody is anticipating military conflict between the EU and US, but hostile acts via security agencies? Especially targeting trade and economic activities? Operations on that front that would have been inconceivable just a few years ago cannot be discounted.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:41AM (#17952138)
> I'm not sure if people in the US really understand how horrified everyone, of every political stripe are about Trump's behaviour towards us and the elected Republican leadership's complicity in it.

Is this a factual statement? What is the source?

And I don't mean this in a snarky way, I mean it in a literal, epistemological sense.

I regularly read, both in forums and in the headlines, that "everyone" believes certain "things", but whenever I did just a little into the details I almost inevitably find that in reality, there is an extremely wide variety of opinions. After all, life is extremely complicated. So, likewise, I am interested interested in reading a bit deeper into this particular fact so I can be a more informed voter.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by simonh on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:18PM (#17952850)
Fair enough, loose terminology. Trump does have support over here, that's a fact, but bear in mind those quarters tend to be the nationalist end of the spectrum. Where in their priority list do Britain First people put Trump or the US? Not in first place, that's for sure. They're no happier with steel tariffs, cosying up to Putin, etc than anyone else. The best they can say is that he doesn't really mean it. But he's doing it, so that argument is really wearing pretty thin.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:53PM (#17953134)
And to all of this, I will once again ask the very same question:

Are these statements factual? What are your sources? In a literal, epistemological sense, by what means did you obtain the information you have written in your comment?

EDIT: And it appears I have once again deviated from the acceptable narrative and had my commenting privileges suspended for the day. This is how perceptions are managed.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by simonh on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @05:04AM (#17958156)
I didn't down vote you or censure you, and I'm not trying to score points with this post. I suspect our fellow commenters are reacting negatively to what is perceived as pedantry. Every post here is implicitly representing the opinions and perceptions of the poster. My post was based on my immersion in British and European political culture and meida, and the opinions I read and hear through many different channels - newspaper and web news articles and opinion pieces, TV news and interviews, radio, etc.

We are having a conversation, not posting peer reviewed fact checked academic papers. If you doubt or disagree with a post then it's much more effective and useful to others to provide reasons for your disagreement or counter-arguments and evidence. Again, I'm not trying to be argumentative, this thread is off the home screen and effectively dead. We're just communicating with each other at this point, so I'm just trying to explain how the commenting culture works, as I understand it. Best regards.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @07:42PM (#17964394)
Agreed. Perhaps this will shed some light on where I'm coming from (see my last reply, particularly the part about motivation): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17952440
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by josefresco on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:23AM (#17951255)
Sorry to break it to you, but with control of the Supreme Court, the GOP has done real, significant damage to the United States long term, even if they're (the politicians) all voted out in Nov 2018 or 2020.

Trump isn't the problem, he's just the populist enabler that is allowing the GOP to undermine American institutions. Even if Trump and his cronies are thrown in jail (wishful thinking), remaining in power will be the republicans who have actually done the most damage and will continue to do so as long as American's stay silent.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by fit2rule on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:54AM (#17950822)
It was happening way before Trump. He's just giving you guys cause to think about it, finally.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rezeroed on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:28AM (#17950729)
Ebb and flow. I'm elsewhere in the world, but I imagine whoever is next in the position will fix what Trump got wrong, and there will be some things which prove to be better, even if by luck. I think of it as a bit of tree shaking, pen testing, chaos engineering, maybe anti-fragility. Considering the term is only four years I've not understood all the fuss, an awful lot of which seems to have been aimless hysteria, achieving nothing, distracting people from getting on with things.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by simonh on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:33AM (#17950742)
Ok so the next president fixes up relations, but what about the president after that? The US just demonstrated that they can become a declared hostile power in the scale of a couple of years, and does not have the popular, political or institutional will to stop that happening. Who is going to trust their security infrastructure to US interests in a world where that has already happened?
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rezeroed on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:47AM (#17951051)
Well that was part of what I was referring to with chaos engineering. But I think your "declared hostile power" is part of the hysteria I was referring to.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mikeash on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:46AM (#17951373)
"I think the European Union is a foe, what they do to us in trade. Now you wouldn't think of the European Union but they're a foe.”

Is it hysteria to believe his words?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by adventured on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:08AM (#17951517)
Since it's Trump we're talking about, yes, it is hysteria.

Next week/month/year he'll declare the EU are our best friends, likely timed with a trade deal. See: how he behaved with Macron, or how he snap pivoted with Mexico and was lauding them.

He blatantly isn't representative of much of anything, even in his own administration. We're seeing that demonstrated on a daily basis.

You have to understand that Trump operates by an obnoxiously simplistic - often antagonistic - method in every single thing he does. It starts with lambasting and overreach, which he uses as a tool to stake a far out position/demand that isn't expected to be realized. In his approach, that is used to get something closer to what he really would like out of a negotiation. Every action and word Trump says on these fronts is part of a negotiation as far as he's concerned. One may plainly find his negotiating tactics poor or disagreeable, of course.

So to explain the EU statement by his approach: why call the EU a foe? He wants the EU to recoil and respond that they are in fact not a foe. He's trying out that statement to see if that pushes them to give ground. The idea is likely that they would find that terrifying, to have the US as an actual foe, or to consider that the US may now view the EU as a foe. Give me a great trade deal or we're not going to be friends any longer.... Don't push us any further, or else. There are few proclamations off the table as far as this process goes for Trump. He'll keep it up all the way to burning the house down. In that negotiating strategy, as far as Trump is concerned, the worst thing you can do is give ground. Outrageous statements are preferable in his approach, than to soften and give ground.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rswail on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:17AM (#17951956)
It is not "hysteria" to take the actions of the US head of state seriously. The man has the power of the world's largest military and nuclear force at his disposal.

He has the power of the US dollar and the US banking system to force other countries to his will.

He has abandoned allies of 70+ years standing, has abandoned positions regarding the US influence in Asia, the Pacific and Europe.

He does not appear constrained by diplomacy and is engaging in a zero-sum game of bullying.

Any nation that doesn't take this seriously is in danger.

I agree with your assessment of his approach, but it's not up to us to "understand" how Trump operates. It should be up to your Congress to rein him in and enforce checks and balances on his behavior. They have abdicated that responsibility completely.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mikeash on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:26AM (#17952478)
“He'll keep it up all the way to burning the house down.“

But taking him seriously is hysteria!?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by blarg1 on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:52AM (#17951772)
I think you are right, but people think Trump is insane and can't tell if he is bluffing or not.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by simonh on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @05:21AM (#17958222)
This is off the main page so just for conversation if you pick this up.

I really don't think he's insane. I think he's a narcissistic man child and an idiot. I'll expand on that. Just look at his behaviour on The Apprentice. He would routinely favour ineffective sycophants over effective, successful independent minded candidates, and that's what he does in office.

Being an idiot doesn't mean you're completely useless. There are some things he's very good at, his father prepared him well for success in the real estate world. However he has a very simplistic view of the world and doesn't have the intellectual skills to change that. This leads him to actions that seem insane to anyone who understands their context and implications, but he doesn't understand those so from his perspective his actions are rational. Combine that with his instinctual preference for the appearance of success over actual success, and you've got a recipe for real trouble.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mulletbum on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:34AM (#17951311)
If a country isn't with you, they are against you. So if the U.S. doesn't want to stay on good terms with the EU, the EU should assume they are going to be on good terms with their enemies. Russia is destabilizing democracy, that is a fact that the EU already knows. Now they see that the US isn't willing to stand with them. Thus they are a hostile power.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rswail on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:13AM (#17951918)
Trump called the EU a "foe". He may have meant only in a trade sense, but he didn't say that.

Trump introduced tariffs against Canada under the rubric of "national security". He may not have meant that Canada was a security threat, but he didn't do that.

Diplomacy is a requirement of any nation-state. Trump has hollowed out the State department and has issued proclamations that overturn 70 years of US policy on international norms of relations with allies in NATO, regard for WTO rules, and opposition to autocrats and criminal nation-states.

It's not "hysteria", it's a practical reaction by nations to the perceived and actual changes in US foreign policy.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by Spooky23 on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:19AM (#17951584)
My guess would be the the next president will take a very hard-line against Russia, which will prevent a repeat of 2016.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by acdha on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:32AM (#17951657)
The GOP lead that hard line against Russia (remember when that was a common criticism about Obama’s?) until Trump reversed that at the convention and it wasn’t much later before someone was printing those “better Russian than a Democrat” t-shirts.

This is going to be a big deal for many years: until now U.S. foreign policy was based on the assumption that we took agreements seriously. The casual attacks on long-time allies are going to take generations to undo.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by Spooky23 on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:09AM (#17951896)
It's more complex than that.

Many of the wackier conservatives felt that Obama had done a terrible wrong to Russia in the 2010/2011 timeframe after Putin's election. I recall hearing a similar message for a period of time on radio shows. They felt that the US/NATO had benefited from Russia's gracious offer to use Russian controlled railways to supply Afghanistan instead of the expensive and problematic road routes through Pakistan.

It sounded really strange at the time; in retrospect it was probably the early phases of the Russian influence campaign that peaked in 2016.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by malvosenior on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:25AM (#17951271)
Trump just signed a new NAFTA deal with Mexico and has improved relations with N. Korea more than any other president in history. His domestic policies might be a wreck but he's actually doing pretty good with his handling of foreign policy.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by jaegerpicker on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:10AM (#17951530)
2 small ineffective wins, that basically mean nothing weighed against a Trade War with China, almost entirely destroying relations with the EU and Nato, deeply damaging relations with the 5 eyes countries - who are the US's closest allies. Worsening relations with Iran. And of course a FAR too familiar relationship with Russia. How is that doing ok?
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by malvosenior on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:15AM (#17951553)
I wouldn't call N. Korea a "small ineffective win", I'd also put improved relations with Russia high on the list of good things but I know how unpopular that sentiment is with the left.

Putting pressure on our allies? Good. No relationship should be above examining and reevaluating. The EU has been imposing its will on the entire internet, I'm glad the US president is not in lock step with them.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by hef19898 on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:21AM (#17951597)
You're right, it was a big win. For the Koreans, finally having gotten the international recognition they wanted for three generations.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by malvosenior on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:26AM (#17951612)
And they got that recognition not through threats or displays of might but by opening up diplomacy and talking to the US and China. North and South Korea are actually talking about a united country and all of the neighboring countries see this as a positive step.

It may not mean much to westerners (although it should, nuclear non-proliferation is a big deal), but large portions of the world see this as a good thing.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by dashundchen on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:41AM (#17951710)
Doesn't seem like non-proliferation actually happened here:

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/news/cheery-trump-tweets-stark...

> U.S. intelligence reportedly estimates that the North Koreans are on track to create five to eight new weapons this year, figures apace with the average of six weapons a year that they were constructing before the Trump-Kim summit.

> Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, already deeply doubtful that inroads could be made with the North Koreans, has become disillusioned with the process when faced with the evidence, per NBC.

> President Donald Trump, on the other hand, continues to tweet messages like “we will get it done together!” and “we will prove everyone wrong!” displaying his affection for North Korean leader Kim Jong Un and his desire to keep foreign policy messaging positive before the midterms.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by hef19898 on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:32AM (#17951656)
Ok, the North-Koreans shot ICBMs how often across Japan? On trjectories that showed to everyone that they can reach the US mainland? With nukes? Ok, by that regard the whole cold war, including the Cuban Missile Crisis was profound Display of pacifism by everyone involved.

Not saying that easing tensions isn't a good Thing. But Trump doesn't deserve any credit for it besides giving away a lot in Exchange for a poor PR stunt.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by jaegerpicker on Monday September 10, 2018 @04:10PM (#17954780)
The most favorable possible view is that the North Korea talks was a small ineffective win. They were recognized, the president of the United States went to them on their terms, and it's done absolutely zero to slow the building/testing of nuclear bombs. It's more honestly a epic disaster in the making. Also the five eyes have almost nothing to do with the EU and have been the closest most important allies and partners the US has. Harming those relations is good? In what world? Sure ever relationship should be evaluated but there is a huge difference between that and publicly shaming a close friend over minor bullshit reasons.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by malvosenior on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:24PM (#17955702)
> It's more honestly a epic disaster in the making.

I don’t see how you can say this. What’s disastrous about a more open and unified Korea? Tensions have been steadily decreasing since the Trump meeting and if you follow Asian news, you’d see he is getting credit for helping the situation.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rswail on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:03AM (#17951848)
Improved relations with Russia should not involve a) defying your own intelligence organizations conclusions regarding election interference, b) not wanting to impose sanctions on oligarchs and high government officials that have engaged in obvious criminal behavior (money laundering etc), c) not condemning face-to-face, the Russian governments actions of assassinations on an ally's soil (UK), or its disgusting actions to stop democratic involvement in Russia, or the suspicious deaths of opposition political leaders, or the oppression of LGBT people, etc.

Russia is a two-bit crime organization that happens to hold land. Its GDP is less than Italy and its controlled by a dictator that has consolidated power using patronage.

There is no need for "improved relations" with that nation until it has reformed.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by dang on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:34PM (#17953942)
Russia is a two-bit crime organization that happens to hold land

Posting like that is a bannable offense on HN. It's not ok to slur another country—any country—regardless of how you feel about geopolitics.

More generally, HN is no place for nationalistic flamewar, so please avoid nationalistic flamebait when posting here. It may be upticking on the rest of the internet, but that makes it more important to avoid here.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by dragonwriter on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:16AM (#17951563)
> Trump just signed a new NAFTA deal with Mexico

No he didn't. He reached agreement in principle with Mexico on NAFTA reforms that Mexico decribes as requiring Canadian agreement to even turn into an actionable concrete deal.

> and has improved relations with N. Korea more than any other president in history.

Granting more visibility and prestige to NK for no concrete results than any other President since NK existed isn't a win, it's getting played.

> His domestic policies might be a wreck

They are.

> but he's actually doing pretty good with his handling of foreign policy.

No, that's a wreck, too, and the second thing you try to cite as a win is a big example.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by malvosenior on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:19AM (#17951581)
N. Korea just held a military parade where they didn't display nuclear weapons for the first time in years. The reality is Trump and Kim are taking steps to bring N. Korea into the modern world. It won't happen overnight, but real progress has been made and Trump does deserve credit for that.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rswail on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:54AM (#17951783)
The reality is that NK has played Trump by fluffing his ego. By making non-committal "desires" and by a few publicity stunts (eg exchanging family visits, done previously), NK has managed to a) defuse the tensions raised by their nuclear developments, b) continue to develop and hold their now nuclear-nation position, c) put the US administration in the position of having to "lose face" when negotiations fail, and d) now have "equal nation" status with the US in negotiations, completely defanging the 6 nation approach that has been the US policy for containment of NK.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rswail on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:58AM (#17951811)
No he hasn't signed a new NAFTA deal with Mexico. He signed an MoU with an outgoing Mexican President. Canada has also continued to refuse to engage with the US on further NAFTA negotiations, given the offensive tariffs for "national security" that Trump has imposed.

The agreement was about tariffs between the US and Mexico (not Canada) regarding automobile parts and assembly and relative wages.

https://www.vox.com/world/2018/8/27/17786020/usa-mexico-naft...

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by hef19898 on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:19AM (#17951582)
Help me out, how exactly did the US - North Korea relations improve? I must have missed the de-nuclearization deal they signed...
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by malvosenior on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:20AM (#17951591)
It's not an instant change but there's been continuous improvement since they met. This just happened for instance:

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/09/north-korea-leaves-missiles-...

Not giving him credit for improving this relationship is dishonest.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by jimjimjim on Monday September 10, 2018 @05:50AM (#17950586)
trump is shaping the country towards his view of the world. A view where there are no such things as friends. Either people are there to inflate your ego while trying to get power or people are there to be used and have their power subjugated. For countries, regardless of how brash and abrasive international relations go, weaker countries will try to win favor by showing support and powerful countries (that were friends) are now being pummeled and face the decision to ride out the crassness or break ties.

you can live a life with that world view but what a hollow hollow inhuman life. and those people will desert you the moment you cease to have power.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by krapp on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:13AM (#17950892)
I think it's slightly more subtle than that ... he's playing to a feeling amongst certain demographics that their share of America's political, cultural and economic "birthright" has been stolen from them by "globalists" and their foreign allies, and that this need to be pushed back against to return the US to some (apocryphal and mythical) golden age.

He's not trying to negotiate as an equal but assert his dominance. He's turning over the tables of the moneychangers and running at the world with a sourge... or at least in his head and the hearts of some of his supporters, he is.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:22AM (#17952440)
I find this sort of comment very frustrating. Indeed there is some truth in it, but my frustration stems from a complete lack of any indication of the degree to which it is true, or the degree to which Trump supporters believe these things. There is no really good way of knowing what individual people are thinking in their minds, yet an alien reading forum comments might conclude we've mastered mind-reading technology.

> he's playing to a feeling

Implying any difference of political opinion is based on emotion, rather than logic or a simple difference of opinion. Sometime in the last 10 years or so did we decide The One True Proper Way To Run The World, but it wasn't reported in newspapers?

> that their share of America's political, cultural and economic "birthright"

They think certain things are a "birthright", as opposed to thinking (correctly or incorrectly) that it is something they have earned?

> has been stolen from them by "globalists" and their foreign allies

Why is globalists in quotes? In objective reality, is there not a fairly clear distinction between those who are more nationalist in their preferred approach to managing the world's affairs, and those who are more collective/globalist?

> and that this need to be pushed back against to return the US to some (apocryphal and mythical) golden age.

Must the motivation be returning to a "golden age"? I see the debate over nationalism vs globalism as little different than capitalism vs socialism. The US tends to be somewhat more towards the capitalist end of the spectrum, which yields some good results and some bad, I don't agree with the notion that any of that necessarily "belongs" or must necessarily be shared with the overall world. Demanding "charity" is extremely offensive to me. To be clear, I believe charity is very important and by my morality I essentially consider it a near obligation if things have worked out very well for you in life, but I simultaneously believe that it should be absolutely voluntary.

> He's not trying to negotiate as an equal but assert his dominance

This sounds lovely at first glance, until you put a little thought into it. Isn't this precisely how one should negotiate? Would you have us believe it is an accepted and widely practiced norm to negotiate in a manner that does not accentuate your strengths, in order to best achieve an agreement most beneficial to your goals?

> or at least in his head and the hearts of some of his supporters, he is.

Speculation on my part, but this seems fairly inline with the popular notion that Trump lacks or has lost his mental faculties, and his supporters are all motivated purely by uninformed emotions. Again, is an informed, logical, difference of opinion impossible?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by krapp on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:36PM (#17956032)
>Implying any difference of political opinion is based on emotion, rather than logic or a simple difference of opinion.

No, it's implying that Trump's rhetoric has been primarily based on emotion rather than logic. If you can provide an argument that Trump's behavior has been primarily based on logic, I would like to read it. I have read his tweets and listened to his speeches though, and found plenty of evidence to the contrary.

>Why is globalists in quotes? In objective reality, is there not a fairly clear distinction between those who are more nationalist in their preferred approach to managing the world's affairs, and those who are more collective/globalist?

Because I find the term "globalist" to be invoked more often as a specter or bogeyman than to explicitly describe a particular and definite set of political principles - like "leftist" or "feminist", its use seems to have become so diluted and diffuse as to have lost any practical meaning.

>Must the motivation be returning to a "golden age"?

That is the primary motivation behind populism like Trump's, and what is "Make America Great Again" if not a hearkening back to some point in the past when America was "great", to which it must return? Otherwise, it would be "Make America Great," or "Make America Greater" or "Keep America Great."

>Isn't this precisely how one should negotiate?

I was being imprecise. He's arrogant, narcissistic and belligerent, insulting his allies and goading his enemies, and he works against his own purposes because the dominance he's trying to assert is one that doesn't exist. The world is not scared of him, nor does it appear to be intimidated by him.

>Again, is an informed, logical, difference of opinion impossible?

I did say some. You're talking about one camp, and I'm talking about another.

I would have loved for this last election to have been an intellectual debate about capitalism vs. collectivism, and the benefits and costs of progressivism and globalism. Unfortunately, it wasn't. We got "Crooked Hillary" and "Crazy Bernie" and "Build the Wall" and lots and lots of heat but very little light.

I can only assume that people who voted for Trump on some intellectual or rational political basis can only have done so because he was the only option afforded to them... but I do assert that the reason that became the case was his appeal to emotion, almost in spite of intellect. Those people should be more disappointed in him than anyone.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by mistermann on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @07:40PM (#17964384)
Hmmm, on one hand what you've written seems perfectly reasonable, but on the other hand I remain triggered. Perhaps breaking up your sentences into constituent parts was not as illustrative as I thought.

Let's see if I can figure out why I'm still triggered. For productivity, I will try to steelman your words.

- "No, it's implying that Trump's rhetoric has been primarily based on emotion rather than logic." - Agreed.

- "Because I find the term "globalist" to be invoked more often as a specter or bogeyman than to explicitly describe a particular and definite set of political principles - like "leftist" or "feminist"" - I see the point, yet at the same time, I wonder if you sincerely acknowledge that there is a genuine spectrum between nationalist and globalist preference. To me it seems obvious and no less controversial than capitalist vs socialist.

- "That is the primary motivation behind populism like Trump's, and what is "Make America Great Again" if not a hearkening back to some point in the past when America was "great", to which it must return? Otherwise, it would be "Make America Great," or "Make America Greater" or "Keep America Great."" - Here I disagree. Now, there's no doubt this statement, and the schtick around it is deliberately vague in order to nicely fit into a wide variety of world views (some racist I imagine). But where I (seem to) disagree with you is I don't detect a belief that it could be anything but a return to ~the good ole slave owning days. America, and the whole world, has changed drastically in the last few decades, there are all sorts of completely unoffensive things that it would be beneficial to return to. I wonder if this is psychologically similar to the "racist dog whistle" some people hear everywhere.

- "I was being imprecise. He's arrogant, narcissistic and belligerent, insulting his allies and goading his enemies, and he works against his own purposes because the dominance he's trying to assert is one that doesn't exist. The world is not scared of him, nor does it appear to be intimidated by him." - here I mostly disagree (other than the belligerent & insulting part), but I suspect this one would be irreconcilable.

If you're wondering why I go through the effort to write the above nonsense, it's because I agree with your next statement:

> I would have loved for this last election to have been an intellectual debate about capitalism vs. collectivism, and the benefits and costs of progressivism and globalism. Unfortunately, it wasn't. We got "Crooked Hillary" and "Crazy Bernie" and "Build the Wall" and lots and lots of heat but very little light.

I have a feeling if we don't identify what the root causes (ie: your words, which I suspect seem perfectly appropriate and accurate to you, "trigger" me in a psychological manner that isn't a simple disagreement, and undoubtedly this occurs on the other side of the spectrum) of the incredible political polarization, this problem is going to get MUCH worse before it gets better. A Trump can likely only get elected in this type of environment (see: https://www.epsilontheory.com/things-fall-apart-pt-1/), and if the same environment exists two years from now, it vastly improves his chances for reelection.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by rswail on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:09AM (#17951888)
That's his populist position that gets him the cheering crowds, but his trade position is based on his complete misunderstanding of how international trade works, how tariffs are a tax on US consumption, and his misconception that trade is a zero sum game, that for every "winner" there is a "loser".

Ford isn't going to import the Focus from China, because of Trump's misguided policies. They will sell the production elsewhere. The US is deprived of an efficient small car, but it hasn't gained any employment, production or anything else.

Harley Davison will move production of motorcycles to be sold in the EU to the EU and elsewhere. This deprives the US of manufacturing and the associated jobs. It doesn't deprive the EU of Harley Davisons.

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by sheepmullet on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:05AM (#17951482)
> America's political, cultural and economic "birthright" has been stolen from them

Hasn’t it? Imagine if the trillion+ spent in Iraq+Afghanistan had instead been invested in infrastructure in the US.

> He's not trying to negotiate as an equal

What makes you think that?

Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by fit2rule on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:55AM (#17950830)
The USA has been callously dropping bombs on innocent people for decades. Don't kid yourself that this is all Trumps' fault - he's just the latest rung in a very long ladder into oblivion...
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by jimjimjim on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:59AM (#17950841)
Many have always been annoyed but there was still a united front against the "opposition" parts of the world, whether militarily, economically or culturally. That united front is being actively dismantled.
Re:Macron Push to Drop CIA Code Quickens as Trump Calls EU Foe by vixen99 on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:03AM (#17950641)
You should write for the NYT.