News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by lotusleaf1987 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @02:42PM (#1792061)
Why don't we just abolish patents? The fashion and food industries seem to get by without them. I can see the argument to justify patents--rewarding people who innovate, but so often they are abused by the likes of Nathan Myhrvold and Intellectual Ventures. Without patents, everything would essentially be a meritocracy. Either way, this is another example of how badly the patent system needs reform of some kind.

Here is an article that makes a better argument than I have the time or capacity for: http://mises.org/Community/wikis/economics/a-world-without-i...

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jemfinch on Thursday October 14, 2010 @02:54PM (#1792100)
> Why don't we just abolish patents? The fashion and food industries seem to get by without them.

There are several things wrong with your proposition.

First, the food and beverage industries get by without patents because they leverage trade secrets, which is the exact sort of privatized knowledge that patents have long sought to prevent.

Second, fashion survives without patents because names matter. People will buy Louis Vuitton whether it's good or not, simply because it has his name on it. Louis Vuitton has no need for patents because it's not the bag design, but his name that matters.

The problem with abolishing patents is that while it might make it easier for companies, it would make it absolutely impossible for small-time, independent inventors to advance human knowledge. What incentive is there for a couple guys to build a time machine in their garage when, as soon as they try to mass produce their invention, any number of larger companies better equipped to manufacture things at scale will just make their invention and sell it for less?

The problem with patents in this article isn't the patent itself, but the fact that it covers software, which is 50% math and 50% business process and shouldn't ever have been patentable in the first place.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jerf on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:36PM (#1792265)
"Second, fashion survives without patents because names matter. People will buy Louis Vuitton whether it's good or not, simply because it has his name on it. Louis Vuitton has no need for patents because it's not the bag design, but his name that matters."

How do you know this is cause and not effect? The adaptation of the system to not having government monopolies may have been to go to a name-based reputation system.

It certainly seems to me this would work for software, probably even better than it does for fashion. Arguably it already does.

" What incentive is there for a couple guys to build a time machine in their garage when, as soon as they try to mass produce their invention, any number of larger companies better equipped to manufacture things at scale will just make their invention and sell it for less?"

Yes, this is the standard argument. Do you have any evidence that it actually works that way? I don't see a lot of small companies making it big on a patented product where they get a lot of protection that works; I do see a lot of companies of all sizes being stomped on.

Goals aren't results. You've stated the goals of the system, but really, who cares what the goals are? What matters are the effects. The effects in reality do not seem to be a net positive for the "little guys", who can't afford the patent process in the first place, especially now that turnaround time is measured in years. In fact the horrible outcome you describe in a world without patents seems rather similar to what actually happens in this one.... the little guys won't be able to afford the lawyers, and everybody in the system knows it.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jemfinch on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:04PM (#1792371)
> It certainly seems to me this would work for software, probably even better than it does for fashion. Arguably it already does.

Yes, it would work better for software! I'm unsure why you and my other interlocutor considered this an interesting point to make: my post is clear that I believe software patents should be abolished, but not all patents.

> Yes, this is the standard argument. Do you have any evidence that it actually works that way?

Yes. The fact that innovation has marched on and that small-time inventors have invented new and relevant products is evidence for my claim.

> I don't see a lot of small companies making it big on a patented product where they get a lot of protection that works;

Sure you do. Segway is one. Many of the products by Dyson would be others.

> I do see a lot of companies of all sizes being stomped on.

Please, by all means, provide examples.

> The effects in reality do not seem to be a net positive for the "little guys", who can't afford the patent process in the first place

Tell that to James Dyson or Dean Kamen.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by cousin_it on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:01PM (#1792575)
Isn't Segway protected by its uselessness rather than a patent?

Edit: if you believe that Segway's lack of success meant nothing, and that many companies want to build and sell self-balancing scooters but the patent system is stopping them, you should argue that point and downvote, not just downvote. I'm annoyed.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jacquesm on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:32PM (#1792716)
> I'm annoyed.

Rightfully so.

Downvotes aside, it seems the segway has it's dedicated fans.

I think the biggest thing that's wrong with it was the way it was launched, not the article per se.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by thaumaturgy on Thursday October 14, 2010 @10:24PM (#1793446)
DEKA is a strange duck. They have some genuinely brilliant people there, working on some genuinely revolutionary inventions -- but they just can't seem to actually bring them to market. Or, they're not interested in bringing them to market.

I've never seen one of their wheelchairs; I've seen some Segways, but they remain more a curiosity and spectacle than a common device; I've yet to hear of the Stirling engine / water purifier being deployed anywhere; and their cybernetics for amputees don't seem to be getting beyond experimental.

I really don't "get" them. The best I can figure is that everyone (influential) there is happy just to be working on these puzzles, and they don't really care if anyone uses them or not.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jemfinch on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:46PM (#1792978)
Honestly, I think you deserved your downvotes. The segway is clearly not useless; the market has shown that. Just because something isn't a runaway success doesn't mean it wasn't a success.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by hxa7241 on Friday October 15, 2010 @09:26AM (#1794436)
> The fact that innovation has marched on and that small-time inventors have invented new and relevant products is evidence for my claim.

The logic of that is not right.

The presence of both patents and innovations does not prove that innovation depends on patents. It only proves the sort-of negative: if both patents and innovation exists, then patents do not imply the absence of innovation -- i.e. patents do not completely destroy innovation.

Various other things help innovation happen. And I expect more detailed evidence shows them to be the important factors -- that is the gist of Boldrin and Levine's work, so that is probably a good source to pursue on the matter.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by notahacker on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:34PM (#1792727)
Louis Vutton's name _is_ a government monopoly, and they've sued everyone from Britney Spears to Darfur charities to protect it; they even boast about how aggressively they protect their IP on their website. http://www.louisvuitton.com/info/fake/index.html

Problem is that people buy Louis Vutton bags as a sign of conspicuous consumption whereas ACME's expensive and ingenious widget is a commodity, so government protection on the name alone would be insufficient.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by ajscherer on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:36PM (#1792264)
I can think of a ton of ways to make money with a time machine that don't involve selling it.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by shasta on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:24PM (#1792675)
Sure, you go back and file a bunch of patents
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by mechanical_fish on Friday October 15, 2010 @08:09AM (#1794293)
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by viraptor on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:28PM (#1792919)
> Second, fashion survives without patents because names matter.

Have you heard "nobody got fired for buying from IBM"?

> What incentive is there for a couple guys to build a time machine in their garage when, as soon as they try to mass produce their invention, any number of larger companies better equipped to manufacture things at scale will just make their invention and sell it for less?

How does it change with patents? They produce and patent a prototype. "a large company" starts making their own copy. If the guys sue from their garage, the "large company" sends in their own lobbyists and 1k$/h lawyers - the garage guys lose.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by meric on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:31AM (#1793974)
"Van man 1, Microsoft 0"

  The Australian inventor whose company, Uniloc, 
  was awarded $US388 million 
http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/van-man-1-m...
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by nene on Friday October 15, 2010 @06:26AM (#1794153)
Oh... so this guy basically patented the evil method of associating registration code with specific hardware configuration. But he should have used it for good and sayd: "No Microsoft, I will not allow you to use this technology at all."

IMHO it would be a good idea to patent all evil business practices and then disallow companies to use them :)

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by viraptor on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:02PM (#1795530)
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by tbrownaw on Thursday October 14, 2010 @08:09PM (#1793175)
The problem with abolishing patents is that while it might make it easier for companies, it would make it absolutely impossible for small-time, independent inventors to advance human knowledge.

It would make it easier for them, since there's no legally-privileged cartel locking them out.

What incentive is there for a couple guys to build a time machine in their garage when, as soon as they try to mass produce their invention, any number of larger companies better equipped to manufacture things at scale will just make their invention and sell it for less?

Because building things is fun, and because they get to use whatever they build. And because it takes time for the larger companies to copy them.

The problem with patents in this article isn't the patent itself, but the fact that it covers software, which is 50% math and 50% business process and shouldn't ever have been patentable in the first place.

Everything in life eventually boils down to math and/or thinking. What makes math special is how very clearly the fact of "standing on the shoulders of giants" is recognized, but this pattern applies just as well to everything else. What makes business process special is how clearly unjust it would be to tell people they can't use their own thoughts, but of course all other inventions are just as much people's thoughts.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by kiba on Thursday October 14, 2010 @10:44PM (#1793495)
The problem with abolishing patents is that while it might make it easier for companies, it would make it absolutely impossible for small-time, independent inventors to advance human knowledge. What incentive is there for a couple guys to build a time machine in their garage when, as soon as they try to mass produce their invention, any number of larger companies better equipped to manufacture things at scale will just make their invention and sell it for less?

It's much, much more complicated than that.

Some large companies are bureaucracy with poor incentive structures. So innovative tech passes by them. Their size also slow them down a lot even when they want to adopt the new tech. They cannot focus as intensively as a small corporation can.

Beside, not everybody will necessary see the usefulness of inventions. That where entrepreneurs come in. They risk their money, invent better marketing techniques, make it cheap and efficient, and so on. Inventors do important jobs, sure. But who will market the inventions and risk capitals and so on?

Makerbot Inc is making lot of money with open hardware while also doing some R&D to improve their products. They're making it big without patents. Arguably, patents would actually impedes the growth of small hacker enterprise like Makerbot Inc.

The problem with patents in this article isn't the patent itself, but the fact that it covers software, which is 50% math and 50% business process and shouldn't ever have been patentable in the first place.

Have you ever look at the history of patents and their economic consequences? Patents doesn't disclose secrets or whatever consequences you imagine. It shift technological research from secretive inventions to easily reverse engineered inventions, but doesn't increase them. They are more deadweight costs rather than incentive.

Patents are the problem. However, nobody ever brother to look into the history of patents, much less question their assumption.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by phr on Friday October 15, 2010 @01:08AM (#1793738)
If I had built a working time machine in my garage, I'm pretty sure mass production would not be my next step.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by lotusleaf1987 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:48PM (#1792310)
>Second, fashion survives without patents because names matter.

How does this not apply? How about AutoDesk, Apple, HP, Dell, Sony Vaio? All those names create a different and unique mental image and perception. The name matters just as much in software as in fashion. And are you actually referring to the movie Primer as evidence?

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jemfinch on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:54PM (#1792332)
> How does this not apply? How about AutoDesk, Apple, HP, Dell, Sony Vaio? All those names create a different and unique mental image and perception. The name matters just as much in software as in fashion.

And in the world I propose where software patents don't exist, it would matter even more. But the GGP didn't talk about banning software patents, he talked about banning all patents. If you must respond, please try to respond to the actual thrust of my argument.

> And are you actually referring to the movie Primer as evidence?

I made an allusion to it in a fictional example to illustrate a point. You sound like you're itching to argue for some reason.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by CamperBob on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:54PM (#1792801)
The problem with abolishing patents is that while it might make it easier for companies, it would make it absolutely impossible for small-time, independent inventors to advance human knowledge.

Pull the other one. It has a bell attached!

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by potatolicious on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:07PM (#1792600)
Take off the blinders for a second and keep in mind that your view of patent abuses is very much limited to that of the software realm.

Patents remain relevant and valuable in fields beyond software, where product development and basic R&D costs a hell of a lot more than it does in our little field.

I was trained as a mechanical engineer, and have some experience in that field - and I can say with great certainty that bringing even a simple mechanical contraption (or electrical, for that matter) to market is a lot more expensive than what we do. In fact, for the vast majority of software, the only substantial cost is salaries, and maaaaybe hosting. We don't deal with regulatory fees, testing so extensive as to cost tens of millions of dollars (if not more), and prototyping costs more substantial than a bunch of bits on a platter.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jacquesm on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:34PM (#1792729)
Innovators will innovate as much as artists will paint.

Innovation won't stop because of a lack of patents, you will just have to shift to increased secrecy during the development phase which will lead to the competition having to play catch-up.

I can see a world without patents move faster, not slower in terms of innovation.

edit: @binspace, that's pretty close :)

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by rwmj on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:56PM (#1792805)
Patents were (sort of) good in the days when reverse engineering was hard, but those days are long gone. Today if you release just about any product, software or hardware, your competitors can tear it apart and easily see what it does. So patents are not necessary any more to prevent secrecy.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jacquesm on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:18PM (#1792877)
Patents never were about secrecy. Patents are published.

Trade secrets are about secrecy (hence the name ;) ), and with patents gone trade secrets would go up in value as a means of protecting business interests.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by 0x44 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:42PM (#1793117)
I believe your grandparent was suggesting that reverse-engineering was hard, therefore patents served a valuable purpose to the commons by providing a limited monopoly in exchange for publication.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by imasr on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:36PM (#1792945)
So you say because costs are high they should get protection?
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by potatolicious on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:56PM (#1793142)
It's not a matter of "shoulds" - but rather one of cause and effect, incentives, and careful balance. The original concept of patents was borne out of traditional engineering fields, where the costs of bringing something to market is very high, but the costs of simply copying someone else's innovation is substantially lower.

This disincentivizes inventors and gives a large amount of market advantage to copycats, and when this balance reaches a point where inventors cannot reasonably expect to profit off of their inventions, innovation stops.

The problem here is that we've taken this concept and applied it willy-nilly to software without modification. Software is a field where experimentation, innovation, and even product production is fundamentally dirt cheap, perhaps hundreds, if not thousands of times cheaper than traditional engineering fields.

In this case, applying the system as-is has resulted in a gigantic power shift towards the patent-holder/inventor, where they can hold the market hostage, and the fact that you can iterate so quickly and cheaply means that, under current rules anyways, a solid day's work is probably patentable somehow. This is obviously bull, and needs to be fixed - but I'm not convinced removing patents globally (i.e., from all fields, not just software) is a good idea.

IMHO the concept of IP must exist, even for software, but we must also account for the fact that software is intrinsically insanely cheap to produce (compared to just about everything else in life), and that the amount of exclusivity, protection, or just plain definition of what is sufficiently innovative to be protected, must change.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by imasr on Friday October 15, 2010 @10:30PM (#1797162)
Yes, that's the exact explanation patent trolls give, though in fact there's no real evidence on that being true.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by binspace on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:32PM (#1792718)
> Patents remain relevant and valuable in fields beyond software, where product development and basic R&D costs a hell of a lot more than it does in our little field.

There's evidence that innovation increases without patents.

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20100421/1451179133.shtml http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/study_says_patents_hind... http://blog.mises.org/10217/yet-another-study-finds-patents-...

Patents are rent seeking agreements and have long since been outdated, if they ever made sense.

Basically, I think of patents in the same light as special interest groups. They promote the welfare of the few at the expense of the rest.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by thwarted on Thursday October 14, 2010 @02:49PM (#1792091)
I can see the argument to justify patents--rewarding people who innovate...

It would be easier to see this argument if that is what actually occurred. I mean, I understand that argument, but it's been a bogus argument for a long time because it's not practiced and the people who say we need patents for that reason are not looking to actually execute on that.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by lotusleaf1987 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @02:54PM (#1792102)
That's why the next word is "but".
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by thwarted on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:41PM (#1792497)
I know. I was attempting to add more specifics to why I think that argument is questionable, not to challenge your observations.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by davidw on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:27PM (#1792234)
> Why don't we just abolish patents?

"Intellectual property" is one way of increasing the provisioning of "public goods":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good

Which, in theory, are under-provisioned in a system where they can be easily copied once someone has invested the effort to produce them, leaving the creator under-compensated for their time and effort.

IP is inherently a compromise between producers and consumers. In the case of software patents, the balance has tipped too far towards the "producers", I think.

However, in the case of something like innovative pharmaceuticals, maybe the compromise isn't that bad right now. It takes years of work, and millions of dollars to bring a drug to market, and once it's on the market, you have to say exactly what's in it! No trade secrets, no obfuscated binaries, but the exact substance, which makes it relatively easy to go copy. You could make a case that there would be less invested in finding new drugs if they could immediately be copied the moment they were released.

In any case, there are no absolutes - it's a compromise, and one that needs to be carefully considered for different fields of endeavor, rather than apply blanket solutions like "eliminate patents".

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by josephcooney on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:52PM (#1792994)
A friend of mine is a patent lawyer. From what he told me the food industry is rife with patents.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by brc on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:29PM (#1793089)
No patents, no PARC. No PARC, well, would we have come up with the GUI, the laser printer, ethernet? Maybe so, but it's hard to argue against the merits of PARC, which existed solely because of the photocopying patent held by Xerox.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by eli on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:28PM (#1793086)
The fashion industry disagrees that they are getting along fine without them http://www.counterfeitchic.com/