Yes, it would work better for software! I'm unsure why you and my other interlocutor considered this an interesting point to make: my post is clear that I believe software patents should be abolished, but not all patents.
> Yes, this is the standard argument. Do you have any evidence that it actually works that way?
Yes. The fact that innovation has marched on and that small-time inventors have invented new and relevant products is evidence for my claim.
> I don't see a lot of small companies making it big on a patented product where they get a lot of protection that works;
Sure you do. Segway is one. Many of the products by Dyson would be others.
> I do see a lot of companies of all sizes being stomped on.
Please, by all means, provide examples.
> The effects in reality do not seem to be a net positive for the "little guys", who can't afford the patent process in the first place
Tell that to James Dyson or Dean Kamen.
Edit: if you believe that Segway's lack of success meant nothing, and that many companies want to build and sell self-balancing scooters but the patent system is stopping them, you should argue that point and downvote, not just downvote. I'm annoyed.
Rightfully so.
Downvotes aside, it seems the segway has it's dedicated fans.
I think the biggest thing that's wrong with it was the way it was launched, not the article per se.
I've never seen one of their wheelchairs; I've seen some Segways, but they remain more a curiosity and spectacle than a common device; I've yet to hear of the Stirling engine / water purifier being deployed anywhere; and their cybernetics for amputees don't seem to be getting beyond experimental.
I really don't "get" them. The best I can figure is that everyone (influential) there is happy just to be working on these puzzles, and they don't really care if anyone uses them or not.
The logic of that is not right.
The presence of both patents and innovations does not prove that innovation depends on patents. It only proves the sort-of negative: if both patents and innovation exists, then patents do not imply the absence of innovation -- i.e. patents do not completely destroy innovation.
Various other things help innovation happen. And I expect more detailed evidence shows them to be the important factors -- that is the gist of Boldrin and Levine's work, so that is probably a good source to pursue on the matter.
Problem is that people buy Louis Vutton bags as a sign of conspicuous consumption whereas ACME's expensive and ingenious widget is a commodity, so government protection on the name alone would be insufficient.
How do you know this is cause and not effect? The adaptation of the system to not having government monopolies may have been to go to a name-based reputation system.
It certainly seems to me this would work for software, probably even better than it does for fashion. Arguably it already does.
" What incentive is there for a couple guys to build a time machine in their garage when, as soon as they try to mass produce their invention, any number of larger companies better equipped to manufacture things at scale will just make their invention and sell it for less?"
Yes, this is the standard argument. Do you have any evidence that it actually works that way? I don't see a lot of small companies making it big on a patented product where they get a lot of protection that works; I do see a lot of companies of all sizes being stomped on.
Goals aren't results. You've stated the goals of the system, but really, who cares what the goals are? What matters are the effects. The effects in reality do not seem to be a net positive for the "little guys", who can't afford the patent process in the first place, especially now that turnaround time is measured in years. In fact the horrible outcome you describe in a world without patents seems rather similar to what actually happens in this one.... the little guys won't be able to afford the lawyers, and everybody in the system knows it.