News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by potatolicious on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:07PM (#1792600)
Take off the blinders for a second and keep in mind that your view of patent abuses is very much limited to that of the software realm.

Patents remain relevant and valuable in fields beyond software, where product development and basic R&D costs a hell of a lot more than it does in our little field.

I was trained as a mechanical engineer, and have some experience in that field - and I can say with great certainty that bringing even a simple mechanical contraption (or electrical, for that matter) to market is a lot more expensive than what we do. In fact, for the vast majority of software, the only substantial cost is salaries, and maaaaybe hosting. We don't deal with regulatory fees, testing so extensive as to cost tens of millions of dollars (if not more), and prototyping costs more substantial than a bunch of bits on a platter.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jacquesm on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:34PM (#1792729)
Innovators will innovate as much as artists will paint.

Innovation won't stop because of a lack of patents, you will just have to shift to increased secrecy during the development phase which will lead to the competition having to play catch-up.

I can see a world without patents move faster, not slower in terms of innovation.

edit: @binspace, that's pretty close :)

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by rwmj on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:56PM (#1792805)
Patents were (sort of) good in the days when reverse engineering was hard, but those days are long gone. Today if you release just about any product, software or hardware, your competitors can tear it apart and easily see what it does. So patents are not necessary any more to prevent secrecy.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by jacquesm on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:18PM (#1792877)
Patents never were about secrecy. Patents are published.

Trade secrets are about secrecy (hence the name ;) ), and with patents gone trade secrets would go up in value as a means of protecting business interests.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by 0x44 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:42PM (#1793117)
I believe your grandparent was suggesting that reverse-engineering was hard, therefore patents served a valuable purpose to the commons by providing a limited monopoly in exchange for publication.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by imasr on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:36PM (#1792945)
So you say because costs are high they should get protection?
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by potatolicious on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:56PM (#1793142)
It's not a matter of "shoulds" - but rather one of cause and effect, incentives, and careful balance. The original concept of patents was borne out of traditional engineering fields, where the costs of bringing something to market is very high, but the costs of simply copying someone else's innovation is substantially lower.

This disincentivizes inventors and gives a large amount of market advantage to copycats, and when this balance reaches a point where inventors cannot reasonably expect to profit off of their inventions, innovation stops.

The problem here is that we've taken this concept and applied it willy-nilly to software without modification. Software is a field where experimentation, innovation, and even product production is fundamentally dirt cheap, perhaps hundreds, if not thousands of times cheaper than traditional engineering fields.

In this case, applying the system as-is has resulted in a gigantic power shift towards the patent-holder/inventor, where they can hold the market hostage, and the fact that you can iterate so quickly and cheaply means that, under current rules anyways, a solid day's work is probably patentable somehow. This is obviously bull, and needs to be fixed - but I'm not convinced removing patents globally (i.e., from all fields, not just software) is a good idea.

IMHO the concept of IP must exist, even for software, but we must also account for the fact that software is intrinsically insanely cheap to produce (compared to just about everything else in life), and that the amount of exclusivity, protection, or just plain definition of what is sufficiently innovative to be protected, must change.

Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by imasr on Friday October 15, 2010 @10:30PM (#1797162)
Yes, that's the exact explanation patent trolls give, though in fact there's no real evidence on that being true.
Re:Rollover image on your website? That will be $80,000 (ple... by binspace on Thursday October 14, 2010 @05:32PM (#1792718)
> Patents remain relevant and valuable in fields beyond software, where product development and basic R&D costs a hell of a lot more than it does in our little field.

There's evidence that innovation increases without patents.

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20100421/1451179133.shtml http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/study_says_patents_hind... http://blog.mises.org/10217/yet-another-study-finds-patents-...

Patents are rent seeking agreements and have long since been outdated, if they ever made sense.

Basically, I think of patents in the same light as special interest groups. They promote the welfare of the few at the expense of the rest.