News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by tomcam on Sunday September 02, 2018 @02:43PM (#17898049)
I had to visit the Shakespeare festival in Ashland, OR many times as a kid. My parents didn’t push attendance on me, but nor did my dad explain why Shakespeare is so great. “It’s classic literature.” “How? What makes it better than Isaac Asimov or the Hardy Boys?” “It’s just great literature.” I found this frustrating and started telling people that Shakespeare should be taught as a second language (a joke one of my college professor friends likes to repeat even now).

Fast forward 35 years. I have come to enjoy reading Shakespeare on my own.

(Why is it great literature? Incredible prose, insane plot lines, and way way underrated comedy. Some of the best comedy I have ever encountered is in Shakespeare’s so-called tragedies, a situation that very much matches my own tragedy-marred life. Reread “Hamlet”, “Richard III”, and “MacBeth” for a barrage of hilariously inappropriate one-liners.)

Anyway, a decade and half ago wife wants to take the kids, ages 7 & 9, to the Ashland Shakespeare Festival. I tell them they don’t have to see any of it. I tell them I didn’t enjoy anything but the comedies as a kid but that the staging and costumes were always good. No pressure at all; they are welcome to hang out in the hotel room with iPads or to watch TV, a luxury they lack at home.

They go see everything, including histories and tragedies. And they totally get it. Apparently my children don’t know they’re not supposed to understand the antiquated English, because halfway through their first play (“Merchant of Venice”) I am sometimes having to ask them what’s going on, and my 7 year-old patiently and correctly gives me the 411. They attend pre-play lectures and, when asked by the lecturer, read better than most actors. We go many more times in the ensuing years and it’s now among my most cherished memories.

To this day they quote Shakespeare accurately and mumble “Exeunt” under their breath when they want to get out of a boring situation.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by brightball on Sunday September 02, 2018 @08:14PM (#17899384)
There are certain things that you can’t fully appreciate until you have experienced life enough for the material to be relateable. When I was in high school and college I hated history. I classified it as a “memorize and regurgitate” busywork subject.

Now I read history for recreation and can’t get enough, largely because now that I’m older and understand enough of how society works that I can understand the chain of events better. Reading history is almost like applied psychology.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by RajuVarghese on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:08AM (#17901415)
My experience entirely! As a science and engineering student I was drawn to the rules, laws and preciseness (precision?) of the STEM subjects. As I got into the 50's I began to take delight in European history and now I can't get enough of it. Yes, it takes a while to realize that we should exult in the 'crooked timber of humanity'.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by secfirstmd on Monday September 03, 2018 @08:20AM (#17902156)
I would add classical music and also traditional ("trad") Irish music to this. Parents would have had it on a lot when younger but not really in an annoying way. It was just there. Used to hate as a teenager but somewhere around the 20s it just all clicked and I love it. Probably listen to more of it than anything else.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by jwdunne on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:45PM (#17905075)
Oh yeah. I always liked history but it's now a favourite pastime. The best explanation I give for my growing interest is that you learn from mistakes and history is full of them. In more so, the greater the power, the bigger the mistakes and the harsher the consequences. But really I think that's just a rationalisation for a burgeoning fascination that I can approach with greater maturity.

My wife is the niece of a history professor too. It's interesting that the more I learn the less I want to talk to him about it - perhaps because I'm always learning there's a hell of a lot I don't know. Intimidating.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by stan_rogers on Sunday September 02, 2018 @04:53PM (#17898583)
If you get the chance to see Shakespeare in original pronunciation (OP), jump on it - and take the kids. The ear tunes it in amazingly quickly, and a lot of things suddenly make a lot more sense. The jokes are jokes and the puns are puns. There are still words that, alas, didn't survive the journey from the past, and false friends whose meanings have changed drastically in the interim, but the rhyme and meter of, well, antique "pirate talk" fit the material much better than a pompous theatrical version of RP.

(Be prepared to explain a lot of off-colour puns and double entendres. Shakespeare may have written much for the the equivalent of the private boxes, but he was most definitely not above a bit of Carry On/Benny Hill for the groundlings.)

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by gavinpc on Sunday September 02, 2018 @07:36PM (#17899269)
The "Living Shakespeare" recordings from the 1960's are 50-minute productions that can make the plays much more "accessible."

I hesitate to link this (because it's been parked for a while), but you and the OP might enjoy the text-audio integration at this site.

https://willshake.net/#Shakespeare

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by signal11 on Monday September 03, 2018 @12:38AM (#17900353)
As an aside, “Exeunt, followed by a bear” from The Winter’s Tale was probably one of the greatest stage directions in English literature.

One point worth mentioning is that Shakespeare was not particularly high literature for his time: these were plays written for the 17th century theatre-goers to enjoy. And they had plenty of risqué one-liners: http://mentalfloss.com/article/54442/10-shakespeares-best-di... has a list. That said, Shakespeare at his best easily outdid his peers — his tragedies particularly, although they aren’t particularly historically accurate.

I suspect some of Asimov’s and particularly Stephen King’s works will be “classics” in 500 years time.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by pvg on Monday September 03, 2018 @03:56AM (#17901134)
It's 'exit'. 'Exeunt' is a plural, not a fancy shakesperean way to say 'exit'. Similarly, you can't really mutter 'exeunt' to yourself unless you plan to leave with other people.

One point worth mentioning is that Shakespeare was not particularly high literature for his time

I don't think this bit is accurate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King%27s_Men_(playing_company)

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by signal11 on Monday September 03, 2018 @06:31PM (#17905316)
Re “exeunt”— yes, sorry, I was quoting from memory and misremembered.

The point about not being “high literature” was that the plays had a very broad audience. Shakespeare’s company were asked to perform in front of royals as well, but the plays were were seen by up to 3000 people a day with the cheapest tickets being a penny (about the price of a loaf of bread - cheap even for its time). They were effectively mass entertainment for 16th century Londoners.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by jkoschei on Sunday September 02, 2018 @03:06PM (#17898131)
This makes me happy — sounds like some top-notch parenting, and I'm heartened to hear your kids got so into it. I may steal the "exeunt" remark to exit a boring situation...
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by lordgrenville on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:27AM (#17901473)
I've tried to 'get into' Shakespeare a number of times, and have recently started another attempt. I'm going through the plays from the beginning and quite enjoying them. I actually don't agree that the comedy is that funny, and I find the plots completely over-the-top.

The thing is, I've seen enough films at this point in my life that even when I see new material, I get the sense that I've seen it before. Shakespeare's stories might be very predictable, but instead of giving much thought to the plot, you focus more on getting into the heads of the characters in the moment. They are vehicles for the universal human feelings: jealousy, love, lust, loneliness, elation, depression, mourning etc.

And then the way Shakespeare describes this is so rich. This is one way in that reading the plays is more rewarding than watching them, because in our day you need more time to parse the sentences, to look up archaic words (or those whose meaning has changed) and Classical references. But I find that putting in that work enriches my own English, and is an entertaining puzzle on its own .

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by jgtrosh on Sunday September 02, 2018 @06:12PM (#17898966)
Really off track, but I don't think iPads were a thing 15 years ago. (You can reply with “Exeunt”.)
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by tomcam on Sunday September 02, 2018 @10:48PM (#17899957)
Fudging numbers a bit for privacy reasons ;)
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by toomanybeersies on Sunday September 02, 2018 @09:04PM (#17899558)
Shakespeare is good enough that they keep ripping off his plots for movies, including my guilty favourite: 10 Things I Hate About You.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by rz2k on Monday September 03, 2018 @12:27AM (#17900315)
One of the lines I disagreed with from the otherwise excellent column:

> Schools and universities ought to help us to understand that no book that talks about a book says more than the book in question, but instead they do their level best to make us think the opposite.

Of course, a great number of Shakespeare's works were riffs on old plots that had been done many times before, and up to a few thousand years earlier.

His genius was not the plots but in what he 'said more than the plot in question'. One could easily make a distinction between analysis of a work and reinterpretation of a work, but I still think it is foolhardy to claim that analysis and critical thinking can not create its own value, and even more foolhardy to imply that that value is in competition with the value of the original work.

Anyway, I think the better modern reinterpretations of Shakespeare tend to focus on the themes that Shakespeare added to the classic plots, than they worry about the plot specifics.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by Chathamization on Sunday September 02, 2018 @09:09PM (#17899580)
Its funny. I think if you took away the context of it being an old Shakespeare play, most people would find The Taming of the Shrew (which 10 Things I Hate About You is very loosely based on) fairly abhorrent.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by toomanybeersies on Sunday September 02, 2018 @09:19PM (#17899618)
That's common with a lot of Shakespeare. A lot of his plotlines and humour are marginal at best. If Shakespeare was alive and writing these plays today, he would be pilloried.

The Merchant of Venice is blatantly anti-Semetic. The Comedy of Errors has a whole scene that's just fat shaming for no good reason. There's plenty of other examples of things that would be problematic if written in a modern context. Obviously it wasn't problematic several hundred years ago, and we shouldn't judge Shakespeare by modern standards.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by whatshisface on Monday September 03, 2018 @02:25PM (#17904117)
>The Comedy of Errors has a whole scene that's just fat shaming for no good reason.

I really don't think fat jokes are considered off-limits for present-day comedies.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by shrikant on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:42AM (#17901523)
If you like Shakespeare, you might like this television series on the BBC called "Upstart Crow", written by Ben Elton (of Blackadder fame) and starring David Mitchell (of Peep Show fame) as Shakespeare.

Personally I found it hilarious, but it was a poor experience for the SO, who isn't as au fait with the bard as I am.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by pvg on Sunday September 02, 2018 @03:23PM (#17898187)
Incredible prose

Pedantipoint: it's mostly verse.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by tomcam on Sunday September 02, 2018 @04:55PM (#17898590)
Later histories & tragedies tended to be more prose than verse. Those are my faves.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by pvg on Sunday September 02, 2018 @05:32PM (#17898788)
I think those are also mostly verse - blank verse is still verse. Although, as with all things Shakespeare, his use of prose and verse is its own subfield of study so I was able to google my way to some cold, hard numbers (in spreadsheet form, no less).

https://shakespearefactsblog.wordpress.com/2016/09/02/shakes...

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by Chathamization on Sunday September 02, 2018 @09:06PM (#17899563)
I had the opposite experience. I saw Shakespeare plays every year as a child and enjoyed them a lot. As I got older, however, I began enjoying them less and finding more issues with the plays. I think it would be worthwhile for people to explore more playwrights rather than simply focusing so much on a single one; you never know which one will resonate with you.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by jl6 on Sunday September 02, 2018 @05:02PM (#17898619)
What are some great jokes/one liners/scenes that will make me laugh?
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by scarejunba on Sunday September 02, 2018 @07:56PM (#17899319)
My personal favourite as a child was a popular one from Julius Caesar.

"It's Cinna! Tear him apart!"

"I am not Cinna the conspirator. I am Cinna the poet!"

"Tear him! Tear him for his bad verses!"

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by matt4077 on Sunday September 02, 2018 @09:03PM (#17899549)
Alcohol: It provokes the desire, yet it taketh away the performance!

(I mostly appreciate that line (from Macbeth) because it's just extremely relatable.)

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by jfoutz on Sunday September 02, 2018 @05:19PM (#17898712)
I thought “She is spherical, like a globe.” Was pretty funny.

A lot of it depends on context. A guy trying to be intimidating, but realizing they’re out of their league.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by toomanybeersies on Sunday September 02, 2018 @09:10PM (#17899583)
The entire kitchen scene in The Comedy of Errors is hilarious.

> Marry, sir, she's the kitchen wench and all grease; and I know not what use to put her to but to make a lamp of her and run from her by her own light. I warrant, her rags and the tallow in them will burn a Poland winter: if she lives till doomsday, she'll burn a week longer than the whole world.

If Shakespeare's plays were written today, there would be outrage. Political correctness was definitely not a concept in 1594.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by EliRivers on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:07AM (#17901411)
It was very politically incorrect to practice (or worse, proselytise) Roman Catholicism.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by selimthegrim on Sunday September 02, 2018 @08:15PM (#17899390)
Also punning on the Globe Theatre probably
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by wiredfool on Monday September 03, 2018 @02:13AM (#17900705)
The Pyramus and Thisbe bits from Midsummers. And basically all of Bottom with the Ass head.