I don't keep large liquid in my CU, instead that is in higher yeild accounts, but that was true with Chase or BoA as well.
The reliable IT system has to be there, but you might be horrified about the beast of systems (human and computer) that make our banks/ach/transactions/etc function.
I don't worry much about loosing money in the bank due to FDIC/ NCUSIF. I can't audit their internal process so I instead depend on insurance. It kinda removes worry about their IT infra from my mind.
If you are above FDIC value, you should be banking with multiple banks and putting your money to better uses.
For me, 'good IT infrastructure' isnt for reliability (though that's important!), but got good digital products. I want an iPhone app for my bank that's made my actual humans that know how to make apps.
In my eyes, the most successful banks have realised that there's actually very little differentiation between financial products between banks, and where you can set yourself apart is with your internet banking and mobile apps.
I use Monzo in the UK and really enjoy it.
This would never happen with major banks - because they screwed the pooch with that in the 1980s and still have the same COBOL patches running today.
What I am trying to say is that the new banks will offer really good new products - but there is a risk premium.
What?
Do they tend to get some kind of private insurance against institutional failures for their entire balance? Or do they just not worry about it?
There isn't much of a gap between your average credit union and the best online banks. They all use one of a few COTS systems. Usually the only gap is that it is more difficult to setup inter-bank ACH.
For my personal bank account though I agree -- just do the job at lowest cost. A cash management account works better for me even than a credit union.
Note that this is an attitude where the banks are essentially assumed not to be at risk of bankruptcy. Maybe this means the depositor views the banks as a utility - access to the system whereby debts are settled and trade occurs.
This is completely at odds with what the banks actually do day-to-day, which is make judgments about which businesses and families have a chance to thrive. They execute this through their decisions on who to loan to, and how much.
There is an enormous tension here - the capitalist mechanism to encourage good performance of the banks day-to-day duties is losses and hence bankruptcy if they really muck up. A voting consumer who wants 'reliable IT' and 'Tech Support' isn't going to tolerate that in the design of the system.
I don't have any money in the American banking system, so I can be harsh. The world is full of threats and risk; if people can ignore what is been done with their money then the financial abstractions and safety nets are too extreme. It isn't reasonable for a depositor to be completely, purposefully ignorant of what is being done with their money. They should acknowledge and carry some (relatively small amount) of the risk, and have an actual relationship with their banker.
I miss the old-world personal relation with the banking manager that a reasonably wealthy individual could enjoy. I think it would create stronger local communities.
EDIT obviously depositors with account sizes in the <$10,000 sort of range should be able to ignore the whole financial thing, they don't really have enough money to be interesting. But serious amounts of money should feel some of the risk. Someone with, eg, a $50,000 bond should be able to ask probing questions.
When your short-term/emergency needs are fulfilled and you want a relationship, risk exposure, critical thinking about the use your money is put to, etc. you invest with a broker. Some traditional banks have associated brokerages (Chase/JPM, BofA/Merrill) and some brokerages have minor retail banks (Fidelity, Schwab) but the best-in-class services generally come from different institutions.
For most practical purposes, banking and investment are completely different things. That may not have been true historically, but these days the concept of interest on a deposit account is a vestigial curiosity. If you want returns, you go to the stock market.
Conventional wisdom says small businesses benefit from a personal relationship with local bankers who know market conditions and can sign off on loans and lines of credit that a national bank might see as too risky or too small to deal with.
But as a depositor, I don't want a personal relationship with my bank at all. I want a reliable IT system with low costs and great tech support if something goes wrong, which is something the scale of a national operation can best deliver.