News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Thursday August 09, 2018 @05:29PM (#17728669)
I used to fix cars for a living. Sometimes it involved “cracking” alarm & immobiliser systems.

My clients all claimed they broke/lost their keys to their car - most of the time they were believable (car stuck in front of their driveway, etc). Sometimes less so, but I’d do it anyway because I needed the money and I had no proof of the contrary (innocent until proven guilty right?), although given the sad conditions of the cars I really doubt anyone would bother stealing them.

Car security is based on obscurity. There is very little cryptography involved (if any), and where there is, the car’s “computers” would happily install new, untrusted firmware through the diagnostics (OBD) port, which means you can do pretty much anything - program new keys, disable the immobiliser or alarm completely (by installing patched firmware) or even rewind the odometer.

I’m frankly surprised it took this long for “high tech” car theft to appear, unless it’s been going on for a while but executed perfectly so nobody would find a trace.

Happy to answer any questions if anyone’s curious.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by vbezhenar on Thursday August 09, 2018 @07:48PM (#17729549)
In Russia and, I guess, similar countries, it's quite rare to encounter a car which isn't protected by an external protection system (not sure how it's called in English, in Russian it's usually called "Сигнализация") which includes shock sensors, alarm system, remote control and car block which protects some vital engine circuits. There are systems with dialog protocol between remote control and car with actual encryption inside, so it might be not so trivial to break it. In practice such cars are either stolen inside trucks or an entire system is by-passed by a separate automobile computer connected directly to necessary engine sensors, ignition coils, etc. Quite clever technique, you don't need to bypass protected electronics if you can bring and connect your own electronics.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Yizahi on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:42AM (#17731398)
In Russia and ex-USSR in general cars are very often stolen disregarding any car alarm installed and whatever GPS trackers are inside, even rental cars with multiple trackers and a live feed to someone monitoring them. The reason - they only need a few hours to get to their base of operations where car is dismantled in to parts and then sold separately, often under protection by local law enforcement. And people can't do much - yes, you can see sudden appearance of your car parts on the used parts market, same color, same tuning etc. but you can't prove anything, and all part numbers would be destroyed during dismantle.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by GFischer on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:00PM (#17735915)
I used to work for an insurance company and I got an entertaining presentation from a 3rd party that showed how ingenious thieves went around car block, special keys, etc, by bringing in the entire front panel of the car (thieves had one for each common model they wanted to steal).

"Casual" thieves are finding it harder though, it's more organized mafia in concert with dismantlers (as mentioned on a sibling comment).

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by taneq on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:20AM (#17732037)
> not sure how it's called in English

"Immobiliser", usually. :)

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:22AM (#17732317)
"Сигнализация" would be more akin to alarm.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by bri3d on Thursday August 09, 2018 @06:00PM (#17728942)
Even more modern cars with "protection" (usually against tuning, not theft) use obvious, simple-to-reverse algorithms. For example, the Simos18 ECUs used in modern VWs use flash files encrypted with AES128. Except, they share the same key and IV across all ECUs on the platform, and the key and IV are stored in plaintext in the "upgrade" routines in the flash ROM. So once you've dumped one ECU's flash memory, you own them all.

This wouldn't be that hard for car manufacturers to defeat if they really cared. It's the exact same trusted-boot problem as any mobile phone faces, except (so far) with much more limited attack resources. It's devilishly hard to get perfect (as every iPhone jailbreak proves) but it's easy to get started.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by zormino on Friday August 10, 2018 @12:46AM (#17730742)
There is actually a big security push in automotive that's sort of been slowly coming to the fore over the last few years. It's not the OEMs that are driving it really either, they are to some degree, but it's the suppliers starting to make security hardware and system protection available, as it really hasn't been for very long. It's still not really entirely there. Basic things like the microcontrollers and CAN hardware / protocol never had security designed in. No one was willing to invest significant engineering time or do expensive security in software when hardware cost is king, or even invest in the engineering cost of bringing in security from suppliers (seriously, there's like 20+ independent computers in your car and it's going to be 50+ on average soon if it isn't already and out of those you'd probably have to harden 10 or so, or introduce entire new ECUs) There's a number of solutions but none of them are cheap. As hardware support becomes widely available, development time for higher tier suppliers drops and they can economically offer secure solutions, and with scares like the Jeep remote control hack in 2015 and with cars getting more connected, OEMs are starting to see the business case for security.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Thursday August 09, 2018 @06:15PM (#17729037)
Seems like an easy problem to solve - every ECU generates its own encryption/signing key at first boot and dumps it over the serial port, which then gets recorded somewhere. This is eventually passed down to the car’s owner in the documentation, and the key needs to be presented before any firmware upgrade or configuration change.

This isn’t bulletproof either, but surely more than “hey I’m legit, here’s your new firmware, could you install and run it please?”.

Also I’m surprised they’d go after tuners, considering those are usually the most loyal customers you could dream of.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by bri3d on Thursday August 09, 2018 @08:44PM (#17729820)
Yes, like I alluded to it's trivial drawing from any other trusted boot chain implementation.

The even better and less user-intensive way to do it would be with asymmetric encryption - the ECU only trusts flashes signed with the vendor public key and to make things even more secure, you could encrypt each flash file server side with a keypair derived each boot on the ECU and sent over the Internet (many manufacturers require online flashing anyway).

Manufacturers dislike tuners because they make warranty claims for tune damaged parts like blown turbos. VW especially are very, very aggressive about detection and enforcement around this. Long term I think giving a few dishonest tuned customers free turbos is probably fine but they seem to disagree and I assume they have access to the metrics driving this decision (which I don't).

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by disiplus on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:11AM (#17730841)
they also dont like tuners because cars engines are often made the same for multiple "trims" so the car with 110 and 160 hp have the same engine but different "map" in the ecu. and only with ecu reflash you can get more power that would cost you x amount of money.

imagine a CPU where 6 and 8 core variants are the same but the 6 core is locked in bios and you can unlock it with some tuning software, its like that.

and manufacturers dont like that

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Cthulhu_ on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:45AM (#17731410)
Except that CPU manufacturers DO like that, and will give out special unlocked versions of their CPUs and even sponsor overclockers, to see what people can do with their hardware.

This also happens with car manufacturers, in racing and such. Tuners are more under the radar so they don't like that, as well as the warranty claims that were mentioned.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by disiplus on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:32AM (#17731607)
no, there is no software that i know of where you can as a consumer make your i3 an i5 with just a software unlock, that you can get for like 10 eur.

the difference on the base model mercedes c class between getting a less powerful engine and the one that is one level up is like 3.5-4k eur.

that is a lot of money. if i could unlock the bigger engine with just 400 eur i would buy the base model.

manufacturers don't want that, and is one part of blocking the touching of the ecu. the other is also that the navigation and a lot of other things is just disabled in ecu, and could be easily unlocked with software.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by thedrbrian on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:11AM (#17731770)
It’s not just more power though. My car has two version 130hp and 155. For the 2 grand I got 25 more horsepower and bigger brakes ,bigger clutch , bigger wheels with wider tyres and an LSD. The only time I can recall where the engine has been exactly the same inside was the mini one and Mini Cooper where the ecu only allowed for 86% throttle on the lower powered version. Every other engine has had a mechanical difference internally to support more power.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by koffiezet on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:56AM (#17731945)
I'm looking into buying an Alfa Romeo Giulia, and engine-wise the difference between the 200bhp and 280bhp version is 100% software.

There are some other differences, the 280bhp is AWS vs RWD for the 200bhp version, and you can get the 200 with smaller wheels. However when going for larger wheels on the 200bhp, you also get the exact same larger brakes...

It's a cool €6000 difference, for a similarly equipped car. I actually don't want AWD and the chassis can clearly handle this much power on the rear-wheels alone, the top-of-the-line 510bhp version is also RWD - so going for the 200bhp version and giving a reputable tuner €700 is a tempting proposition...

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by rciorba on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:13AM (#17732900)
Mazda's 2.0 Gasoline Skyactiv is sold as both 120 and 165 HP. Same engine, same brakes, same clutch, different ecu mapping. The only mechanical difference is the gear box's final drive ratio (the 120's has longer gears for better fuel economy). Why would they do this? I assume economy of scale makes it cheaper.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by disiplus on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:29AM (#17732348)
f30 bmw 316d and 318d are exactly the same, 2011 325d and 330d also, 2013 114i and 118i of what i can rembember right now, i dont keep the exact list.

and if i would guess you are talking about mx-5 nd, those are natural aspired engines, where something like this is not really viable.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by TeMPOraL on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:17AM (#17731109)
> imagine a CPU where 6 and 8 core variants are the same but the 6 core is locked in bios and you can unlock it with some tuning software, its like that.

But isn't this already the case (except locking might be in CPU firmware)? AFAIR this is the case with GPUs.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by jdietrich on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:47AM (#17731421)
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by TeMPOraL on Friday August 10, 2018 @09:18AM (#17732931)
The line between product binning and market segmentation is sometimes blurry.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by tikkabhuna on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:18AM (#17731799)
Can't think of an example with CPUs, but you could unlock an AMD 6950 to a 6970[1]. Some brands would actually add features to help do this.

[1] https://www.techpowerup.com/articles/overclocking/vidcard/15...

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by jinzo on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:19AM (#17730871)
Actually, from my personal experience in the field - they only care for X. years under warranty. Then they don't care. I actually don't think they have much legal ground on their own around modifications in EU. At the end of the day you do own the car.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by dmichulke on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:05AM (#17730809)
> signed with the vendor public key

That part doesn't sound very secure to me :-)

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by bawana on Thursday August 09, 2018 @11:58PM (#17730583)
Why go after tuners? Well, if you are a giant automobile firm that has been lying about their mileage and emissions and covering it up with software that detunes the car just to pass testing- well, then you don't want people figuring out your algos for covering up lying.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by neuralRiot on Thursday August 09, 2018 @11:36PM (#17730512)
So down the line after few years and changing owners you're unable to install any firmware or to install used ECUs, most of the manufacturers are now online-only for diagnostic and flashing of course charging some premium, that destroys independend shops as you need to pay a subscription for every manufacturer, and cars and its parts still get stolen, "high tech thieves" belong to the movies, real ones load your car on a tow and it goes straight to another country.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by shawn on Thursday August 09, 2018 @09:18PM (#17729964)
I'm not so sure. The key has to be stored somewhere on the car. Why not desolder that and examine it?

(If we're going with "Theoretically possible," that is.)

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by bri3d on Thursday August 09, 2018 @09:31PM (#17730024)
The solution here is a combination of tamper-proof secure enclave and ephemeral keys, just like it is for trusted boot chains. Obviously it's not 100% secure and just like mobile phones (which, again, are the exact same problem space) it's eventually defeated, but the magnitude of difficulty can be multiplied without much effort.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:24AM (#17732327)
My solution wasn't to protect against that - if you're up for desoldering stuff you may as well just replace the ECU with your own one which is happy to start the car.

This was just an idea to thwart installation of compromised firmware by thieves via the diagnostics port. It's just a little layer of security, not designed to be bulletproof, merely to slow down thieves by forcing them to actually swap the hardware.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by shawn on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:35AM (#17732375)
if you're up for desoldering stuff you may as well just replace the ECU with your own one which is happy to start the car.

I demand a source that teaches me how to do this. :)

Orrr if you're in Chicago let's go figure it out ourselves!

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by GFischer on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:43PM (#17736208)
CESVI in Argentina. Not very close to Chicago though :P , but I'm sure there's an US equivalent.

https://www.cesvi.com.ar/index2.html

I remember reading about the people that dismantled cars to find where manufacturers source the parts:

https://jalopnik.com/the-fascinating-company-that-tears-cars...

Those guys can probably switch you the ECU :)

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by shawn on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:27PM (#17736498)
This is awesome. Thank you!
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by tomaskafka on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @10:56AM (#17758491)
In Europe: https://ecu.de/
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by barrkel on Thursday August 09, 2018 @07:00PM (#17729283)
Witness Intel's unlocked CPUs: people who want access to the low-level stuff get charged a premium.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by outworlder on Thursday August 09, 2018 @07:36PM (#17729493)
> program new keys

Yeah. We bought an old Elantra which only came with a single key and no FOB. I bought a cheap gizmo on Amazon that you plug to the OBD port and allows you to program other FOBs.

Modern-ish cars are computers. Once you have physical access, all bets are off.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by jinzo on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:22AM (#17730883)
On the other side, MY2015 Audi A3 8V needs online access for remote re-sync (sometimes the RF part of the key looses sync with the car). So yes, generally older cars are easy to modify, newer not (at least yet). Also the cheap gismo was cheap because it was a clone, original tools are not that cheap.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by tpxl on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:21AM (#17731563)
You need to connect your car to the internet?
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by ollie87 on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:41AM (#17731895)
It's likely the car has it's own always-on cellular connection.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by tpxl on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:00AM (#17732221)
Yeah, this is what I meant, but that sounds insane to me.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:41AM (#17732409)
It is probably retrieving the "SKC" code which is necessary to program keys.

However, this is by no means secure where the car's ECU will happily dump its entire storage (including the SKC code) over the diagnostics port if you ask nicely.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by jinzo on Saturday August 11, 2018 @10:00AM (#17739685)
No, not programming keys per se. But re-sync RF part of the already coded key, so you can unlock it with a push of a button.

Also, I have quite a problem with dumping entire storage (EEPROM parts for example, that contain SKC/PIN). Also, my experiance is that getting that info from modern ECUs is not that straightforward/there aren't many (in some cases any) tools to get it.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Saturday August 11, 2018 @09:37PM (#17742503)
Look up “VAG Tacho”: http://maltchev.com/kiti/

This tool successfully recovers SKC codes from pretty much any VAG Group’s (Volkswagen, Audi, Seat, Skoda) cars. It can also do other things like edit the odometer and probably more. It’s simply using “undocumented” (although is anything there documented?) commands of the diagnostics protocol to get raw access to the persistent storage.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by jplayer01 on Friday August 10, 2018 @11:57AM (#17734478)
All bets are off because that's how they were designed. Just look at a modern iPhone, which is designed with security in mind. It's far harder to get the same kind of access.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by donkeyd on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:52AM (#17731446)
> unless it’s been going on for a while but executed perfectly so nobody would find a trace

My boss's car was stolen in broad daylight in front of a client's warehouse. This isn't a busy area, but it isn't extremely quiet either. The car had GPS tracking, but it disappeared without a trace.

The police guessed that it was driven into the back of a closed truck and straight away transported to Eastern Europe.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by gitgud on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:01AM (#17731488)
Incredible, was there ctv footage?

Reading things like this makes me realise how easy it is to steal things still. Much like the old days when people could exchange fake cheques at banks for cash... Most of the world is still built on trust.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by donkeyd on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:11AM (#17731523)
I asked about it at a later time, but after a certain time, the car ownership officially gets transferred to the insurance company, so any updates from the police would go to them unfortunately. From what I heard, however, police wasn't planning on spending too much time on this, because these types of cases never really result in much. Unless this becomes part of a major investigation into similar cases, it'll be dead in the water.

> makes me realise how easy it is to steal things still

So yeah, you're right about this. Statistics actually seem to show that low impact, organized crime pays in the Netherlands [1], since police is too busy with high impact cases. High impact often being being defined as burglaries, robberies, rape, etc. that have long-term impact on the victims well-being.

[1](Dutch) https://www.bndestem.nl/overig/cbs-misdaad-loont-in-nederlan...

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by donkeyd on Saturday August 11, 2018 @07:53AM (#17739331)
> makes me realise how easy it is to steal things still

I just found this through Reddit and had to think of your comment:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colton_Harris_Moore

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by tomaskafka on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @11:00AM (#17758529)
Heard a similar story except the owner chased the truck while calling police. When they stopped the truck after two hours (not so easy getting police to actually stop a truck on a highway), they found only car parts inside, with destroyed part numbers.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by smsm42 on Friday August 10, 2018 @06:02PM (#17737043)
Years ago, I had a car with a sophisticated ignition lock system (not my choice, but not relevant to the story). It was somewhat finicky, and creating a new key was not easy. And of course no chance of starting it without proper key!

That car ended up stolen right from under my nose (I was within 100 feet of it, indoors but would hear if the alarm turned on) and the only thing I found in there when I came back for it was the sophisticated security system. The thieves just ripped it out in no time and with no sound, and drove away.

Since then I'm somewhat skeptical about how much protection such systems really provide.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by kccqzy on Thursday August 09, 2018 @05:40PM (#17728767)
Have you taken a look at a Tesla car yet? From PR materials I'm led to believe that they treat their car software seriously. I doubt one can install untrusted firmware on a Tesla car; is that so?
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Thursday August 09, 2018 @05:49PM (#17728843)
I’ve never worked on a Tesla. I’ve left the trade long ago finding my way in software engineering instead.

Tesla is probably the only one I’d trust though. While I don’t expect them to be bulletproof either (at least not at first), I expect them to quickly catch on should this kind of theft appear, and make the necessary fixes. In any case I doubt they’d be stupid enough to accept arbitrary code over a diagnostics port (if they have one even). I mean, even if we forget security, why would they? Teslas update remotely via the Internet.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by StudentStuff on Thursday August 09, 2018 @10:12PM (#17730189)
Teslas have been stolen in Europe, their high value for parts makes them well worth stealing. This is primarily Tesla's fault, as they refuse to sell parts to cars that have been in accidents.

Your Tesla is essentially scrap after a non-minor accident, which is why most US insurers refuse to cover vehicles made by Tesla. Its as bad as rolling coal IMO, Tesla has created a massive eWaste problem. Meanwhile, rebuilding any other manufacturers car is doable, even other EVs.

Source: https://electrek.co/2018/07/31/tesla-theft-tips-help-prevent...

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by todd8 on Friday August 10, 2018 @12:44AM (#17730736)
Relay attacks like those mentioned that Teslas are vulnerable to can also affect most other keyless entry cars. On new Mercedes one can turn off the keyless entry system by double klicking the lock button on the key when locking the car. The car key then will have to have its unlock button physically pushed to unlock the car, and in that state relay attacks won’t work.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by bjelkeman-again on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:39AM (#17730965)
One can turn it off on a Tesla Model S/X the same way. On the Model 3 it is a different system so not sure how that works.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by FredFS456 on Thursday August 09, 2018 @08:39PM (#17729794)
I believe Telsas have a minimal OBD-II port (where mandated by law) but mostly use an Ethernet port for debugging/service.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by acct1771 on Thursday August 09, 2018 @07:44PM (#17729531)
Stripping or modding a Tesla would be the only way I'd get one...and I'd really like to. Very interested in what happens in this thread.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by voidmain0001 on Thursday August 09, 2018 @10:21PM (#17730224)
A Motherboard article appeared on HN about a rogue Tesla mechanic. Here is his channel to help you get started: https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCfV0_wbjG8KJADuZT2ct4SA#
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by DenTheRed on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:54AM (#17732784)
That Tesla powered Audi RS5 is an amazing hack! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOYY_AlRWQA
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by acct1771 on Saturday August 11, 2018 @01:31AM (#17738517)
Thanks very much!
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by King-Aaron on Thursday August 09, 2018 @11:06PM (#17730399)
I just unclip my steering wheel, and pull out my main relay (dash mounted, race car spec). I don't think the car is going very far without those.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Zhenya on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:59AM (#17731241)
It'll go damn far - on a flatbed.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by aetherspawn on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:03AM (#17731732)
How do they move it onto the flatbed if the hand brake is on?
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Scoundreller on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:57AM (#17732479)
Who needs a flat bed? Every tow truck has dollies that they can put braked/geared wheels on.

How else would a tow truck tow away a vehicle in gear or with the parking brake on?

Through there are stories of tow trucks towing away vehicles in 1st gear, things seem fine, and then the transmission causes a fire from overheating...

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by dsfyu404ed on Friday August 10, 2018 @07:03AM (#17732241)
How do they load wrecked cars, small shipping containers, machinery on skids, etc?

The 8-18k winch on a rollback will have no problem dragging your car.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by King-Aaron on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:17AM (#17731794)
It can be done, you just skull-drag it onto the back of the truck. Not great for the car, of course.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by acct1771 on Saturday August 11, 2018 @01:39AM (#17738543)
Plastic skates. 14 seconds added to the job.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by King-Aaron on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:14AM (#17731292)
haha! Yeah, but by the time you're involving a flatbed in your thieving, I don't know if any car security is going to be much good :P
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Cthulhu_ on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:57AM (#17731470)
I like to think high tech cars can detect when they're being towed and will activate their tracking system and ping the emergency call center.

Of course, all bets are off when it's loaded into an RF shielded truck. It could have an onboard camera to record the number plate of the truck, but that could be shielded.

Long story short, you're probably better off parking it in a firmly locked / secured garage, and have a wheel clamp or chain attached to something solid.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by King-Aaron on Friday August 10, 2018 @05:21AM (#17731809)
> I like to think high tech cars can detect when they're being towed and will activate their tracking system and ping the emergency call center.

My GPS tracker does do this in my daily car, but it only sets it off if the rest of the alarm is triggered (i.e. if the door sensor registers it opening while the alarm is set).

With the race car, it generally gets locked up. Although if I'm out in the town or something with it someone could possibly take off with it if they short-circuit the relay, and use something to clamp on the steering column (when the wheel is detached). But honestly, if someone stole the car like that they'd probably be found a few hundred yards up the road wrapped around a tree and on fire, after hitting boost with no steering wheel.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by inferiorhuman on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:12AM (#17732569)
> There is very little cryptography involved

Wha? That may have been true about twenty years ago, but not now. BMW was using 256-bit RSA keys to validate ECU firmware and authenticate privileged access in the early 2000s (they're up to 1024-bit keys now) and write-once memory in their instrument clusters for about as long. Other (Euro) car makers using the same vendors offer similar features.

Once you have physical access all bets are off though. That's why the thieves cut the alarm sensors.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Tobba_ on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:33AM (#17732677)
Why the hell does RSA ever get used anymore, esp. in smartcards etc? It's been obsolete for like 10 years thanks to ECC, and ECC is way easier to implement (esp. 127-bit and 521-bit).
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by rocqua on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:45AM (#17732741)
RSA has value in encryption which ECC can't do.

Beyond that, RSA is so much easier to understand and implement. Because computing powers of numbers is easier than computing multiples of points on a curve.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by j88439h84 on Thursday August 09, 2018 @05:44PM (#17728807)
Seems like that's all you can ask for if the attacker has physical access to the machine. Would be happy to be corrected though.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Thursday August 09, 2018 @05:52PM (#17728865)
Not sure I agree.

It’s one thing if you get physical access, replace the engine control module by a crooked one that will send the proper signals to the ignition and all the other actuators and start the car.

It’s another thing if you talk to the real engine control module (which should already be on alert because the car was broken into) and tell it “trust me, I’m legit, here’s your new firmware” and the computer just runs your code no questions asked.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by jinzo on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:27AM (#17730904)
But on the other hand, on modern cars that is not nearly enough to get the car started. As OP pointed out, Simos18 was quite conveniently hacked, but that's far from the only ecu family. And usually they aren't hacked as easly/quickly. For example, all that Simos18 "easy" hacking can be done once you have IGN ON, if you have IGN ON it's probably easier to just code a new set of keys, than it is to flash new FW on all related and needed computers.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by blattimwind on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:05AM (#17732525)
> I’m frankly surprised it took this long for “high tech” car theft to appear, unless it’s been going on for a while

New, expensive cars are stolen or broken into quite often. When broken into, they'll often rip out the infotainment, with high end cars this can be a five-figure repair.

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by tlrobinson on Thursday August 09, 2018 @06:25PM (#17729088)
"Sometimes less so, but I’d do it anyway because I needed the money and I had no proof of the contrary (innocent until proven guilty right?)."

Huh, is it legal to "crack" alarms/immobilizers without proof of ownership, especially if you suspect it might be stolen?

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by mygo on Thursday August 09, 2018 @06:33PM (#17729141)
anyone can call a mobile locksmith and ask them to help them get into their locked car stuck in the KFC parking lot with their keys inside. It’s usually up to the locksmith to obtain proof of ownership. otherwise they’re running the risk of committing a break-in. they usually have you sign something beforehand that tries to mitigate their liability. however I’ve used some shady locksmiths who just pulled up in the passenger seat of their friend’s ride and did it without a contract and took cash. at least they didn’t scratch my car.
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Thursday August 09, 2018 @06:40PM (#17729183)
In my case they always had the keys, it was purely the electronics side that was failing. In fact I explicitly remember one idiot who manually broke the transponder chip inside the key in half (no idea what they were attempting to do - replace the battery?). I can’t tell for sure that all the clients were legit, but those ones were so stupid they had to be legit!

I took cash as well, because I was under 18 and couldn’t legally run a business at that time (but still needed to eat and buy drinks every weekend, and family couldn’t afford it).

Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt by Rjevski on Thursday August 09, 2018 @06:37PM (#17729164)
Not sure, but given the shitty cars I’ve worked on, I wouldn’t care even if they were stolen - nobody would call the police for such things - if anything they’d be glad someone took them away for free!

I would probably feel differently if I got called to work on a supercar but that didn’t happen.