Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt
by Tobba_ on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:33AM
(#17732677)
Why the hell does RSA ever get used anymore, esp. in smartcards etc? It's been obsolete for like 10 years thanks to ECC, and ECC is way easier to implement (esp. 127-bit and 521-bit).
Re:A Dutch first: Ingenious BMW theft attempt
by rocqua on Friday August 10, 2018 @08:45AM
(#17732741)
RSA has value in encryption which ECC can't do.
Beyond that, RSA is so much easier to understand and implement. Because computing powers of numbers is easier than computing multiples of points on a curve.
Wha? That may have been true about twenty years ago, but not now. BMW was using 256-bit RSA keys to validate ECU firmware and authenticate privileged access in the early 2000s (they're up to 1024-bit keys now) and write-once memory in their instrument clusters for about as long. Other (Euro) car makers using the same vendors offer similar features.
Once you have physical access all bets are off though. That's why the thieves cut the alarm sensors.