But what was not considered was that the causality here could be incorrect, instead showing us that people with traits optimized for success in life chose to enroll in higher education to use the additional knowledge and experience as a catalyst for their success (or they just otherwise loved academia or learning).
Due to the extent of which this first hypothesis was treated as a fact, we are left with a system that attempts to reinforce it at many levels of society, ignoring the large cost that it takes.
Measuring the true returns of education is impossible, both on the individual level (we can't replay history with alternative choices) and the population level (clean randomisation on education is socially unacceptable), so all we have are approximations and methodological hacks (technical summary in linked summary paper). But such approximations typically found that "ability bias" was not all that large.
Someone ordered that every household should have books at home while failing to realize that correlation != causation…
https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/27/sat-scores-and...
And last I checked, there is a strong correlation between maternal educational achievement and child educational achievement even after controlling for various things including wealth. The correlation with paternal achievement when controlling for other factors is much lower.
How do you know this possibility has been left unconsidered?
Yes, there were students who started and ended the quarter hopelessly overwhelmed. But there were also students who through determination and hard work and lots and lots of help managed to dig themselves out of that hole. Many of those students would not have "succeeded anyways", they succeeded specifically because of the help they got.
If you mean to say that they succeed because of their willingness to ask for (and make use of) help, then sure. But your original comment makes it sound like you're tossing them into the same bucket as the students who never need to show up for help in the first place, which is absolutely unwarranted.
Yes, this is exactly what I mean. Success often requires asking for help.
Countless times I tried to help students that really didn't seem to care too much, they just wanted to get through the class. (it was required for the degree)
But I regretted splitting my time equally with people that just wanted to eek their way through, when they didn't even care, and didn't really need my help to pass, just to get a better grade.
Where as I wish I had devoted more effort/time towards students that really wanted to excel, even if their skills weren't great, or their talent was near non-existant.
The students that had a drive and need to learn, but still needed help, were the ones that succeeded.
Half the students were there for unknown reasons and would play games in class. Try and tell me how much I should care that they have run out of time to get their projects done at the last minute?
It's better for them to fail than to get shoe-horned into the next class because I helped them maintain their last minute freakout sessions. This did not help them succeed at school or life.
I think this is an example of why college isn't for everyone; and if it is for everyone, not all at the same time.
These people are literally there because they're scared (or, rather ingrained) to think about where else they should be.
I think I disagree with you there.
Debt - Schools could do better at financial assistance and in helping students better manage their finances. Relationship/mental issues - Schools could provide or increase their access to counselors/therapists. Peer mental health support is also becoming an attractive option.
All of this being said, I'm not arguing that schools should help with these issues, rather just pointing out that there are solutions out there.
That's not what I meant, I mean there are students that spend all their "loans" on video games and entertainment instead of on living expenses and school, so no matter what the school does to help, the student will screw this up.
Can't blame the school for irresponsible students.
I have had a couple of homeless kids, yes friggin homeless kids, and one turned into rockstar. The only reason he could even attend was because the school made every student have a laptop (they provided, with full software and support)
There is money available to everyone, and there's only so much you can do to help people. Sometimes letting them fail instead of propping them up is what is actually good for them.
As like many other's here, I failed at the beginning, and learned a lot from that failure.
It seems as if your opinion is that a college should have a baseline minimum for protecting students. Some think that minimum should encompass mental health, or financial education.
Psychiatry and financial education is not an emergency service that is needed immediately. That would be like offering cancer treatment at the university. If someone has cancer and they need treatment they should go to the hospital.
Over your lifetime, it will matter to the vast majority of people. For 1 semester's tuition, it's worth it just to get past HR filters.
And seriously, trying to convince a college student to drop 30k on a credit card is awful.
My entire two degrees was maybe 25k CAD. Why would anyone ever in the right mind even try to go to school if it costs that much?
Surely you meant 3k. You can't possibly get a credit limit for 30... Good God I hope not... Can you?
Not everyone is lucky enough to live in a state with a good one, however.
It's pretty easy to get $30k+ credit limits, I have two cards with over $40k limits (I do points milling/never carry a balance). If I were to max my total credit limit on all cards and pay minimum payments it would take 86 years to pay off.
For public schools the average out of state tuition is about $10k.
The absolute highest is $23k. In state is much cheaper on average.
For private schools, $30k a semester is sticker price at an expensive school.
Very few college students can get limits that high.
> If I were to max my total credit limit on all cards and pay minimum payments it would take 86 years to pay off.
Most large credit cards charge accrued interest for the month plus 1% of balance (once your balance gets above a certain amount). It wouldn't take anywhere near 86 years for the majority of credit cards.
The "prestige" of the degree. Meh
Her job is to give general advice that works for “90% of the people 90% of the time”.
It was the most logical thing for her to suggest
That's far from obvious without knowing the specifics of the case; putting $25,000 of tuition on a credit card with a 24% APR, could get mighty expensive.A student might be better advised to take a leave of absence, or finish up their degree part-time, or transfer to a less expensive or in-state school.
- most colleges don’t take transfer credits for junior/senior level classes
- even if you go part time, most schools charge fixed fees per quarter + per credit hour. That would make it more expensive.
source: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/10/bill-gates-us-college-dropou...
That was me for a long time (I even dropped out once), until I took a course from a teacher that actually inspired me in a subject I found fascinating. Next thing you know I had a Masters degree in math.
Some of my students were inspired in my classes and have good jobs in the industry. They were looking for something, and I had something to offer. I suspect your experience wasn't too different.
Unfortunately, most students don't find what you found...
Higher education most often helps poor students or students of limited means and without any family connections to land coveted jobs, which is life changing not only for them but for their family. Education (and to some degree small time entrepreneurship) is the only way for them to come out of their circumstances that were not of their choosing.
These people would not have succeeded anyways.
Isn't that the complete opposite to what teaching is about?
Have you considered that maybe this isn't a problem with the students but a problem with society and the very problem with the education institutions and teachers like you that are just basically feeding on them?
It's far easier (and economically viable in a shortsighted way) to blame students for their shortcomings than to make the effort to help them. I hope you are not thinking that you're doing society a favour by failing them instead of making the effort to figure out what their strengths are and/or if the way your teach, or what your employer preaches, may actually terrible.
Maybe you shouldn't go back to teaching the next time you get "dragged back into" it.
My state used to pay 100% of your state college tuition if you maintained a 3.0 GPA. A lot of students in my freshman dorm stayed until the 30 hour re-evaluation period and then disappeared forever. They partied, never went to class, never studied, and withdrew from most of their classes. They'd regularly fall asleep in or oversleep for 11:00 classes.
As a teacher, how do you handle these students? Many of them have not been raised to be on their own, and college is the first time they're let "off the leash". They're unprepared to be independent adults.
Additionally some students fail the same class over and over, then keep retaking the class with no improvement. They keep asking the same questions, slow down the class, and make it more difficult for everyone else to learn.
As a teacher how do you handle these students? Maybe you've already failed them twice. Maybe you've had extensive study groups, office hours, extra credit materials for these people, but they continue to do poorly. Some of them you suspect have learning disabilities or other mental problems that may always interfere with their ability to take your class.
(Later the state college system changed it to 80% tuition for 3.5 GPA, and at least my college mandated a maximum of 5 withdrawls, which cut down on the problem some.)
Many people don't believe in working hard today for having a better life tomorrow.
They think they might as well get stuck by lightening and die. Should we blame them for this kind of thinking?
This why the idea of a weflare state seems to saddle the ones who work with more work at the expense of those who are not willing to do anything.
Today, the ones who get most benefit from the social system act indifferent to the soceity's need and refuse to contribute.
Maybe best system is one where everyone is left to fend for themselves and receive no help from government or society?
Look at the Panama Papers and all of the off shore banks, the Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich, etc. As a percentage of income per individual, these are the the folks that benefit the most and contribute the least to society by several orders of magnitude. Subsidies, bailouts, elaborate tax evasion schemes, government guaranteed student loans. This is the real "welfare state". People on food stamps don't even scratch the surface in comparison.
Let's not assume there are only 2 groups, one rich/evil and other poor/victims.
There are also rich who contribute positively to the soceity at large.
I've no problem with with poor people who contribute their share.
There are also poor people who negatively contribute to the soceity.
Money is not the only way people contribute. Social interactions/behaviour/attitude also matter.
Are rich people shitting on BART escalator?
Just because a CPA can do it for $300 doesn't change that.
The ones that benefit the most from the welfare state are the ones that (theoretically) pay the most for it: the wealthy. Imagine if Gates/Jobs/Page/Bezos et al had to invest in 18 years of education and healthcare for every potential hire? They'd never get the employees they needed to strike gold.
The humanities are a day care and delayed adulthood for those who would be better suited doing anything else with their time aside from one or two students in every classroom of ~40.
For context, I left to work in the private sector with people who give a damn.
I left for CS after undergrad.
No, it's not. Higher education is not adult daycare. If I have half a class screwing off and playing video games _in class_, and the other half desperately trying to improve their lives.
I used a very strict grading policy, if you don't turn in your assignment, you get a zero, period. All it takes is 41% of not turning in your assignments and your class doesn't apply to your degree. (ie, failure by default)
Are you suggesting I commit fraud to let these students pass? I did not "fail" them, they failed themselves.
Edit: Fyi, 100% of all my students that failed did so by not turning in assignments. 100% of them.
I've always disliked the verb "teach" because it implies that it is something I can do to you, when really all I can do is nurture, facilitate or provide a framework for you to learn.
By the time I started working, it was “just a job” and 20 years later, it still is. I study and “do well”, because I am highly motivated to stay employed and stay employable at market rates.
You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink.
I taught EFL at a high school for 5 years. Being a good teacher takes a lot of experience, inspiration and hard work. It is a very, very difficult job. When I was doing it, I often thought how much easier it is to explain things to a computer compared to a person -- especially when the person is often doing everything they can to avoid listening to you ;-)
I don't want to diminish the role of a teacher because there is a huge difference between a good teacher and a bad teacher. It's just that there comes a point where you have to realise that the best you can do is to create an environment where it is possible for the students to learn. Everything else is up to the student.
The OP's point is very correct that of students who succeed, the vast majority would have succeeded even without the teacher. In those cases, the teacher may create a more pleasant environment, or may provide a convenient filtering of information. But there are very few disciplines where a good text book and a place to practice aren't enough. Where foreign languages are concerned, you don't even need the text book!
I fairly quickly realised that my "value add" in the classroom was to help those people who were borderline. There are always some people who are eager to work, but are constantly at a loss about how to start. In my experience, this is a very small percentage of the class (maybe only 10%), but you can make a big difference as a teacher to these students.
The real problem is where the teacher is placed in an environment where they are unable to concentrate on those students. For example, I often had classes of 42 students. For a language class, that's horrible. I can actually manage with 20, but if you get up over 30, it becomes impossible to spend enough time with the people who need it.
Of course, just like high school (which is filled with students who don't want to be there), undergraduate courses have massive numbers of students who are hopelessly uninterested in studying. There was a time when "university" was aimed at a very small number of very keen students. You had lectures with less than 10 other students and had tutors who helped you work your way through the ridiculously large amount of material that you had to learn. But such organisations are never going to fund a proper football programme, and what is the poor NFL going to do to train their players? ;-)
I mean your point is completely fair: society should take its share of the blame. However, consider who makes up society? The very people who think it is completely reasonable to drift from high school to university, take a bunch of random courses, and party every day. These same people whose career plans are to take their gold stamp for having sat through 4 years of boring lectures and exchange it for a "good job" (TM), which will bring them a very high salary but will have completely unspecified content.
Although, contrary to my rant, one of the things I really like about code boot camps is that it allows people to "wake up" from their delusion. After getting a general degree in "business" with specialisation in making unnecessarily complicated Excel spreadsheets, and working as a drone in the financial industry for 2 years, suddenly some people think, "OMG! Programming is amazing. What the heck have I been doing with my life?". Some of the best people I've worked with recently have come a similar route.
So it would be extremely great if we could help society get over this expectation of mediocrity and start making universities that are centres of higher learning. However, a teacher in a classroom is up to their ears wrestling with extremely unfortunate social dynamics and doesn't have very much time to change the world.
We really need to quit pushing them; they're not ready. They'll most likely fail and be in a worse position than they were going into it.
I've lots of experience in teaching mathematics to students of all age. I believe how well you can be taught exclusively depends on your genetics and the environment you are brought up in.
Not everyone can succeed, not even majority of them can succeed.
You can simply filter students at the lowest level to manipulate the propotion of students who are succeeding.
Since then I've stopped teaching and went to start my own business.
If you really want to help them, leave them to fend for themselves and let the evolution make them fit for survival.
Anything done to screw with the nature will bite you back.
But my experience is anecdotal, and maybe the industry attracts video game players (my assumption) and this makes it more difficult demographic for success. The welders in the school seem to do great and generally succeed from what I have learned from the other departments.
Maybe I was a sucky teacher? Who knows...
Rich can have unmotivated kid and poor can have motivated kids and vice-versa.
Those who can't succeed, schools can still accept fees from them and create a larger pool of resources which those who 'can do' can leverage at expense of those who can't.
Wether it's good or bad - it's for the society to decide.
I can say emphatically, the quality of the schooling only helps people who would succeed anyways. Those that won't or can't, no school can help them. There are just too many lazy, unmotivated or simple defeatist students out there. To not be too harsh, there are many students over their head in life (debts, relationship or mental issues, etc...), also which a school can do little to help with.
Nothing proved this to me more than seeing half the class not turn in the easiest assignments.