A few hundred or thousand people angrily tweet about something -- who cares, right? Wrong. Cable media cares. They pick up a few of the most inflamitory examples from Twitter (it's easier to find quotes on Twitter than it is to go outside and report) and they present these tweets as if they represent a mainstream movement involving millions.
And these angry (but tiny) mobs are having an enormous impact on private companies and public policy. The tail is wagging the dog.
That's quite literally a small army (for reference, it appears the number of active duty US marines is around 200k).
Without commenting on the causes this (or any other) army of followers believes in, it's staggering to imagine what kind of impact monetary incentives, dispersed, for example, by way of an autonomous smart contract that is funded by anonymous donors via 'x' cryptocurrency that relies on some simple proof of action for payout, could have on the frequency and magnitude of actions such groups carry out.
We really are at the beginning of a new chapter in the history of humanity.
Who gets to decide on who goes on that list? This is a very dangerous predicament that could shut out legitimate voices and dissenters. The list itself would likely be against first amendment rights.
A second big difference is facebook decides to de-platform groups on facebook for what they do on facebook, they aren't banning people on a shared bad people list. That would be a kind of cartel/collusion which breaches other restraints on a company's behaviour.
> In a blog post on Twitch’s community board, the company said that if a streamer uses other mediums to send targeted harassment or hate toward another streamer, it will consider those actions a violation of Twitch’s policies — even though the activity didn’t happen directly on the platform.
https://www.polygon.com/2018/2/8/16988424/twitch-rules-haras...
Yet, Apple imperiously employs a EULA to prevent me from using iTunes to make nuclear, biological, or chemical weapons
In Germany it isn't an explicit right, but some judges ruled that your existential minimum to live includes heat and power.
> Stealing small amounts of food to stave off hunger is not a crime, Italy's highest court of appeal has ruled.
Unless we want to start considering platforms like Facebook public spaces subject to all generalised government regulations for those spaces.
That is, until they find themselves on said list.
Don't think this is satire that can't happen.
Any thoughts on the MacBook vs a MacBook with automated engraving offered by the company?
Where do cake decorators fit into this? Is the situation different if the decorating process is automated?
But no, I doubt it would matter.
A company can refuse to put your initials as "KKK" on the product they sell you, regardless of the method by which they do it.
But isn't the problem with the social media actors in the first place...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalin%27s_execution_list_of_J...
Shall we get started? First: anyone that seriously advocates we the people build a list of dissenters among our own citizenry. Second: anyone that wants to gut core provisions of the Bill of Rights and US Constitution.
That's about it. We don't really need to go any further. So, ready to sign yourself up for that list? I think it is such a fantastic idea that you really can't allow this opportunity to go to waste, and well, you know, you'll go down in history! That's even better than 15 minutes of fame on TV!
I know being barred from the networks that most people use will be an inconvenience for you, but it's for the good of society that people like yourself aren't able to easily disseminate these sorts of ideas.
In fact, I know a guy with power and influence that can expedite your blacklisting, so I think I'll mention your name to him.
Please do not resist, comrade. If you behave we may remove you from the list after a suitable number of years.
We can find common ground, but I wish it were possible without restricting what people can say.
See recent supreme court rulings.
I had an ex who would go 6-9 months without paying her utility bill, simply because there was nothing the power company could do about it. She was abusing the system, but the rules are setup that way so that people who really can't afford to pay their bill don't freeze to death in the winter.
Look, power companies can cut power. Sure there are rules, but the point still stands that they can do it. But it's not even relevant because getting your power cut can affect your ability to remain alive.
Not posting on Facebook is not going to kill anyone.
If Silicon Valley keeps looking like it is coordinating its censorship, then I would expect those laws to be extended to ISPs & social networks.
You can just get yourself a generator, right.
And of course, Apple is under no obligation to sell you a MacBook. After all, being a hateful person is not a protected class.
I think it's about time we build a "bad people" list, which companies can consult before providing service. And if any company doesn't respect it, we can social media mob them into compliance.