Re:Are Facebook and YouTube quasi-governmental actors?
by happytoexplain on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:13PM
(#17711353)
This is a hyperbolic analogy and not useful. Sale of electricity and of general purpose computers are wildly less direct than providing a purpose-built platform for speech dissemination. Now, I don't think that banishment from those platforms for anything they define as "hate-speech" is guaranteed to be right for all definitions of "right", and it deserves real scrutiny, but your argument doesn't illuminate anything.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Are Facebook and YouTube quasi-governmental actors?
by shawn on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:23PM
(#17711420)
It was refreshingly insightful. It clearly illustrates the problem with “no platforming,” a concept that is inherently censorship.
Re:Are Facebook and YouTube quasi-governmental actors?
by happytoexplain on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @01:08AM
(#17713335)
It's a common and obvious rhetorical tactic to manufacture an analogy that scales up the points you want to make and/or scales down the points you don't agree with. It's the same spirit as a strawman. I'm genuinely sad to see that called "refreshingly insightful" on HN.
Re:Are Facebook and YouTube quasi-governmental actors?
by shawn on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @03:04AM
(#17713764)
Mm, a fair critique. This is one of the classic arguments where people feel strongly in one direction or another, and it takes very little effort to essentially set up a yay/nay vote.
We can find common ground, but I wish it were possible without restricting what people can say.
Re:Are Facebook and YouTube quasi-governmental actors?
by reader5000 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:02PM
(#17711719)
I would disagree. I think selling a person a computer/electricity which they use to make a podcast is as "wildly direct" as selling server hosting (social media platform) for the podcast.