News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by sonnyblarney on Thursday August 02, 2018 @06:15AM (#17670378)
Because of the power of mind share, Google has the power to control borders.

The border between Israel and the West Bank is an odd one.

'Both sides' have their view of it.

But if 7 Billion people on planet earth grow up seeing one version of the border, it's what they will come to believe as 'true' and effectively support - particularly those in modern nations that might have influence.

China is aware of this and they control any maps their citizens will ever see.

"Of course all that ocean between Philippines and Vietnam belongs to China!" is what most Chinese citizens will assume, after all, they saw it on their maps growing up. While the rest of us will have seen a different map.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by jakecopp on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:41AM (#17670984)
This is why the world needs OpenStreetMap.org

My understanding is that it shows multiple boarders labelled as disputed. Here's the wiki page about it: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Disputes

They also provide this guide to diplomats/officials where they essentially tell them to back off:

http://www.osmfoundation.org/w/images/d/d8/DisputedTerritori...

" However, to remain neutral and to provide a practically useful service to a global community, we cannot delete base data to suit a particular legal jurisdiction. "

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by Piskvorrr on Thursday August 02, 2018 @06:23AM (#17670406)
Disputed territories are shown differently to each side: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/shortcuts/2016/aug/10...
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by wwhitlow on Thursday August 02, 2018 @06:38AM (#17670459)
Yes, but what I think OP is more so referring to is the idea that if an international organization tried to solve the dispute most would be in favor of what they have seen for the longest time. Which brings the question of how does Google decide which map it will show the rest of the world?
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by sonnyblarney on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:05AM (#17670564)
Actually, I think people at the international level have probably a better grasp.

Mostly the issue is populism. It doesn't matter what leaders think if their entire population thinks otherwise.

And politicians will use said populism to their favour as well.

And I also think there is room for objectivity and reason here.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by wwhitlow on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:35AM (#17670953)
Thanks for the clarification I can see that is indeed the problem that can occur. I was speculating around the idea that none of these disputes are solved until those who have grown up scanning the world on Google maps are in power. In which case it would be both populism and to some degree world view.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by SuoDuanDao on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:10AM (#17670581)
If past behavior is any indication, it will show two versions depending on the local consensus.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by tomrod on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:09AM (#17670818)
Having seen much less impactful situations in large institutions: coin flips or even avarice.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by deanCommie on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:21AM (#17670886)
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by stevehawk on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:45AM (#17671294)
MS also hit this issue with Pakistan and India regarding Kashmir.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:27AM (#17670914)
It can be helpful to look at a map of the world with no borders drawn on it and remember that (apart from natural boundaries such as oceans) border lines are entirely arbitrary with no inherent meaning.

And also to look at past maps of the world when the borders looked quite different.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by sonnyblarney on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:52AM (#17671350)
"border lines are entirely arbitrary with no inherent meaning."

The have plenty of meaning.

Nations are not plots of geography - they are groups of people.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by DanAndersen on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:37AM (#17671256)
With that mindset, what makes oceans "natural boundaries" with any meaning? It's all just collections of atoms that humans socially assign meaning to.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by mijamo on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:53AM (#17671359)
"meaning" is always socially assigned (or god's design for those you believe it).

But there is a huge difference between natural boundaries and human boundaries: one can be measured and objectively represented. You can measure heights and make a map of the earth with different colors for mountains, oceans etc. It could all be done by a machine without any human intervention, and represents useful physical differences on Earth.

On the other hand nobody could draw a map of countries' borders without talking with human societies, and no map can be objective or exact. In addition, those borders often are not even visible on the field, and in most border you can just cross and not even realize you are in another country (on roads you have border control, but most borders are just rivers, forests, fields, mountains, deserts without any remarkable feature).

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by sonnyblarney on Thursday August 02, 2018 @01:47PM (#17673628)
Man-made boundaries can be objective, factual, reasonable.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by toomanybeersies on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:05AM (#17671086)
This isn't unique to China, or to Israel and Palestine.

There's also Ukraine and Russia, Armenia and Azerbaijan, Cambodia and Thailand, India and Pakistan, and a whole swathe of territorial claims in other places. Borders, especially when not naturally delineated by something like a river, are messy things.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by paleotrope on Thursday August 02, 2018 @01:17PM (#17673325)
Even rivers can change, making the borders delineated that way less unchanging then they would seem.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by Cthulhu_ on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:00AM (#17670782)
At the very least Google should show it as "disputed" for anyone not involved in the conflict. Which is another can of worms of course, e.g. for Israel supporters viewing it from the US.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by paidleaf on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:37AM (#17670964)
> China is aware of this and they control any maps their citizens will ever see.

Everyone is aware of it. Maps have always been political. Maps and borders are political creations. Why is it that whenever a controversial topic comes up, people always bring up china? Every HN thread that has a controversial topic, someone always sneaks in a reference to china?

> "Of course all that ocean between Philippines and Vietnam belongs to China!" is what most Chinese citizens will assume, after all, they saw it on their maps growing up. While the rest of us will have seen a different map.

You act like there are two maps. One china is pushing and another everyone else agrees to. China, Vietnam, Philippines, Indonesia and every nation in ASEAN have their own maps.

The issue with maps has always existed. Whether it is current - crimea (russia/ukraine), sea of japan/east sea ( japan/korea ) or historical - hawaiians/inuit/nativesc vs european colonizers. Or the remnants of colonization like india/pakistan or artificial nations created by european colonizers in africa and the middle east which has created ethnic border issues.

Pretty much every nation today has map issues. Even within a nation there are map issues ( like the renaming of mount denali ).

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by ryandrake on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:51AM (#17671335)
It's not just borders. When you produce a map for the China market, you need to make certain islands prominent, and physically larger than they actually are, because South China Sea Politics. I can't find a link to cite, but this is well known among people in the mapping business.

Even their GPS coordinate system is different than the rest of the world. Most of the world has settled on WGS-84, but when you display GPS points on a map of China, you need to convert them to their own somewhat randomly-obfuscated coordinate system [1], and display all map data in that datum as well.

Because of these kind of special-snowflake rules, when you're making any kind of geographic software, you usually have to make two versions: One for China and one for everyone else. Not unlike dealing with the USA's insistence on using imperial measurement systems while most of the rest of the world has standardized on metric.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restrictions_on_geographic_dat...

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by teh_klev on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:23AM (#17671186)
> The issue with maps has always existed.

As an amusing aside, and whilst not wishing to introduce flammable politics into this discussion, there's a funny thing that goes on whenever the topic of the Scottish Independence debate arises in the media or on social media. It usually concerns the Scottish border between Scotland and England and usually heads along the lines of "rebuilding Hadrian's Wall" to keep us pesky Scots out of the rUK (or whatever the reason de-jour is) and is often repeated by unionists (and journalists) far south of the border who've likely never set foot in Scotland.

Little do they realise (or they do and are playing along with the usual lazy stereotypes and tropes about Scotland) that Hadrian's Wall doesn't track along the Scottish border and is in fact up to 70 miles south of the border (at the eastern end). So they unwittingly in their minds donated a decent chunk of the north east of England to Scotland come independence day. Well, thank you :)

So yes, people's ideas about maps and where borders lie are issues everywhere, not just in China.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by monadgonad on Thursday August 02, 2018 @11:45AM (#17672328)
> Little do they realise (or they do and are playing along with the usual lazy stereotypes and tropes about Scotland)

Why is it either of those? I think you're willfully taking "rebuild Hadrian's Wall" to have an extremely literal meaning that isn't intended by anyone saying it. Clearly they mean "build a wall between Scotland and rUK", not "follow the exact line of a 2000-year-old wall".

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by teh_klev on Thursday August 02, 2018 @12:45PM (#17672940)
Trust me, if you've followed the Scottish Independence debate at all, there really are people who should know better that do actually think this way. They really do think Hadrian's Wall is the Scottish border.
Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by lobotryas on Thursday August 02, 2018 @12:20PM (#17672684)
>people always bring up China

Because China's often top of mind due to being in the news. Also, because China does many things (some good, many horrible) that suit them and not the West or Western principles. I'm curious to see why this bothers you and I hope you avoid falling into the "whattaboutism" trap.

Regarding parent comment: China's aggressive military base push in SCS and other waters is very worrying.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by dredmorbius on Thursday August 02, 2018 @11:16PM (#17677073)
I encountered a gentleman on G+ who argued most stridently that "the British Isles" was an absolutely unacceptible term for the large archipelago lying to the northeast of mainland Europe.

He is, it happens, Irish.

(His view is also poorly supported, and worse argued.)

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by toss1 on Thursday August 02, 2018 @12:59PM (#17673119)
NO.

China is NOT merely acting like anyone else in regards to international territories.

China very aggressively uses every social, political and military means to change the maps in their favor and extend their political control. This ranges from building military bases by expanding islands in international waters and putting air bases on it and threatening others, to denying that they invaded Tibet, to getting foreigners fired for liking a tweet that might hint that Taiwan is independent.

The US regularly needs to put naval vessels & aircraft in harm's way to frequently reassert Freedom Of Navigation in international waters -- the potential harm is from China's false assertion that these are Chinese territorial waters. This needs to be done ONLY against China in this region -- no other players try to pull the same nonsense.

Please stop trying to act as if China is not an outlier in this regard. Their egregious and even bellicose behavior needs to be called out and halted before it gets more violent. This only serves to normalize and encourage China's egregious behavior.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by dang on Thursday August 02, 2018 @01:14PM (#17673300)
Please don't take HN discussions into nationalistic flamewar. As the guidelines say, "Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."

(They also ask you not to use allcaps for emphasis, since that's basically yelling.)

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by knockingat3am on Thursday August 02, 2018 @10:52AM (#17671884)
And like clockwork, China isn't even singled out, isn't mentioned first, but instantly it's pointed out how there's really nothing particularly bad going on there, for over half a century. Even bending so far to pretend this is a "controversial subject", and as if most controversial subjects didn't mention China at all. The latter is an easily demonstrable falsehood, uttered in the interest of discussion hygiene. You can't make that shit up -- but I'm sure someone could crawl and visualize it one day. Though I guess one could simply read archives from the 1930s and get the same in more better language.

Other nations may have map issues, but China, in addition to concentration camps, really has map issues.

https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/2128124/marr...

> As for the Marriott employee who “liked” the Twitter post by Friends of Tibet, Smith said disciplinary proceedings had been started. “Due to the mistake of an individual employee, our official [Twitter] account wrongly ‘liked’ the tweet supporting Tibet independence and misled the public. [We] have now suspended this employee and dismissal proceedings are under way,” he was quoted as saying.

Well, except that's not what happened. I couldn't find the one that was originally posted on HN, that article was much better, but this one has the tweet in question:

http://www.hoteliermiddleeast.com/33151-marriott-employee-fi...

He didn't make an "error" even. He liked a positive tweet that thanked them for something he didn't understand and had no instructions about. Off with his head, and everybody do the pre-emptive obedience dance, go! When something like this walks the planet, when something like this feeds, then it's not the worst idea to mention it or things related in spirit to it at every occasion, especially whenever you meet new people or new crowds, as a litmus test.

Just like you might have a dinner party in the early 1930s and, then you mention Nazi violence, and a guest mentions that people have just different ideas about how to best go about internal politics. You smile, thank them for their comment, and never invite them again. You don't "leave politics out" when concerned with serious things, unless you're either putting all your stakes on the Nazis winning and erasing all records, like they would have done in Eastern Europe had they not lost the war, or simply aren't thinking that far. As I said, many historical archives are testament to that kinda being the norm, but culture of the present and last half century, uncountable movies and speeches, kind of seem to suggest it's not the norm we end up thinking fondly of in hindsight. They're not the people we wish we had the courage to be. They're the ones we're ashamed of and euphemize, instead of just mentioning their name and some kind of glow filling our hearts. Oh well.

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by dang on Thursday August 02, 2018 @01:17PM (#17673326)
We've banned this account for using HN primarily for political battle.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:As Google Maps Renames Neighborhoods, Residents Fume by reaperducer on Thursday August 02, 2018 @11:23AM (#17672126)
And there's also this:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-07-25/us-airlines-give-in-to...

China insisting that non-Chinese companies remove "Taiwan" as a nation from their web sites.

Some complied fully. Others, like Apple, geolocate the censorship:

http://fortune.com/2018/07/11/apple-taiwan-iphone-bug/