News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by hemantv on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @08:26PM (#17614163)
This company is the drug dealer of Silicon Valley. They have consciously destroyed a generation attention span using psychological tricks.

Hoping they start losing some of the good talent + the US implement something similar to GDPR.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by sergiotapia on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:51PM (#17614528)
100%. A whole generation grown on dopamine addiction and fake relationships with people they don't know.

I hope they go down. Social networks were a net negative on the world at the end of the day.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by nostalgeek on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:28PM (#17614651)
To me that award goes to Twitter, not Facebook. Facebook is actually useful to stay in touch with friends and family in a private fashion. Twitter on the other hand is constant pettiness, aggressiveness and bickering 24/7 from people looking for validation and internet points. The worst internet mobs came out of Twitter and my statement doesn't discriminate between political sides.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by sergiotapia on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:44PM (#17614713)
Twitter is just a platform for idiots to yell at each other and marketers to sell their books/wares. However I haven't noticed people spend HOURS on twitter, like I have with facebook. Facebook is much much more insidious and poisonous.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by pbreit on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:36PM (#17614678)
Except Twitter has much higher quality content from original sources, experts, celebrities, etc.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by aylmao on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:29AM (#17615060)
> Except Twitter has much higher quality content from original sources, experts, celebrities, etc.

My comment is subjective, but yours is too, so what gives here it goes: I doubt this is the case. I think I just see people post "more" on Twitter.

If I'm looking for quality content from experts I'd go to StackExchange, indpenendet websites/blogs or just go buy Nature magazine.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by ahartmetz on Thursday July 26, 2018 @02:46AM (#17615515)
Private communication with friends? Signal if you can, WhatsApp if you have to.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by SmellyGeekBoy on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:42AM (#17615984)
WhatsApp might not be your best choice if you're trying to avoid Facebook.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by Grangar on Thursday July 26, 2018 @06:53AM (#17616442)
At least messages are still E2E encrypted. If you avoid all other facebook systems and restrict the apps permissions I think the damage can be contained to a decent level.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by hemantv on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:53PM (#17614536)
I think they add some positive value being able to be in touch with distant friends and relative.

But their business models depend upon getting people hooked up like a drug addict.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by Tloewald on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @08:33PM (#17614209)
You should look into the career of B.J. Fogg.

https://www.bjfogg.com/

He literally teaches his students how to make psychologically addictive products and is proud of it (and rich). His disciples are the priests of "engagement".

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by giantsloth on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:17PM (#17614624)
Reading his website makes him seem less like a master of anything serious and more a master at self aggrandizing douche baggery.

B=MAP reads much like any self helpy gimmick, something so obvious and so useless you somehow feel smart for having had your obvious thoughts on a topic reworded and handed back to you in corny new configuration you can share with your vapid fake friend group.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by SmellyGeekBoy on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:43AM (#17615989)
> Reading his website makes him seem less like a master of anything serious and more a master at self aggrandizing douche baggery.

Sounds like 90% of the "business" books I've read

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mrep on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:18PM (#17614395)
Drug dealer is way too much of an exageration in my opinion. Nicotine vaping is a better analogy I think.

While there have been some studies on the negatives of social media like nicotine vaping, it is not that bad as what we currently give people the choice to consume and I think we should swing even further towards more freedom of choice even if it negatively effects people long term.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by ikeyany on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:58PM (#17614556)
They have people who's sole job is to make sure Facebook users are on the platform for as long as humanly possible. The company goes out of its way to subvert your desires to make it hard to leave (such as changing sorting by most recent so that you have no idea what content you've seen before). That's as close as you can get to being a pusher.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by thx4allthestuff on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:24PM (#17614640)
That sounds like a job that you would find at pretty much any mobile gaming company with a free-to-play model. Don’t get me wrong, Facebook has had some pretty gross practices over the years, but it doesn’t exactly rot your teeth and make you steal from your mother.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by tonypace on Thursday July 26, 2018 @03:40AM (#17615754)
Facebook and mobile gaming companies are both taking their playbook from gambling companies. Casino addiction doesn't root your teeth, but it certainly does convince a lot of people to steal from their mother. It's a very unethical business model.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mrep on Friday July 27, 2018 @12:17AM (#17623397)
Eh, I think psychology is the root subject here but gambling companies tend to be the best at it. What do you propose though since you seem to find business models that play to psychology unethical?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by aylmao on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:24AM (#17615039)
And it's a job that has existed way before Facebook too-- Disneyland is designed to be lovable and make you spend money. TV shows are designed to keep you hooked and on the edge for the next episode. Movie theatres are designed to make you crave soda and popcorn. Candy and soft drinks are designed to be sugary so people keep wanting more.

I think all this is terrible-- the world ends up becoming landmine after landmine of companies trying to pull you in and get your money-- but lets keep in mind it's nothing new or unique. Just standard business in an free market economy.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by jquast on Thursday July 26, 2018 @08:25AM (#17616851)
Facebook can take a hard ethical stance against allowing teens on the platform. Or, they could add a simple "if" statement on age, and not allow teens to be targeted for advertising.

Instead, they chose to implement the minimum legal requirements of the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), which prevents companies from collecting certain information from kids under 13, and kids who are under 13 just lie about their age. Facebook has really good data, collected for advertising, to know that kids are signing in, and do not make an effort to stop it, beyond a stern "Don't lie to us" phrasing in their TOS.

I think the point made here, especially with Disneyland, Candy, and Television is that children are targeted and manipulated for profiteering. And that's surprisingly legal.

But it is not ethical. Each company has a choice. I hope public opinion will see FB as unethical and unforgivable in the future.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by aylmao on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:14PM (#17619068)
CocaCola can take a hard ethical stance against diabetes. It is one of the deadliest diseases in the world. They could add a disclaimer to their bottles the way tobacco companies are obliged to warn about the effects of long-term smoking.

Instead, they chose to implement the minimum legal requirements set by the FDA with a tiny number on tucked-away table. CocaCola has really good data on how much sugar their drinks have and they do not make an effort to really surface it to people assuming they are acting in their own interest, will read the label, and that will be enough to deter them from drinking a third can.

And the same can be said about pretty much any other company. They all implement "the bare minimum" required by law if it potentially affects their numbers.

> I think the point made here, especially with Disneyland, Candy, and Television is that children are targeted and manipulated for profiteering. And that's surprisingly legal.

Yes, but is it that surprising? We can't expect companies to regulate themselves.

> But it is not ethical. Each company has a choice. I hope public opinion will see FB as unethical and unforgivable in the future.

I agree, though I also think Facebook is a much lesser concern than other companies out there. That's not to say it should be put to the side or nothing can be done before something is done about big Tobacco, big Pharma or even big Sugar. I just think comparing it to a drug company is disingenuous, and lessens the urgency of dealing with companies dealing with proven, dangerous physical addiction.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mrep on Friday July 27, 2018 @12:19AM (#17623407)
So how do you propose to fix it then/What do you think is better?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mrep on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:00PM (#17614564)
Source?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by ikeyany on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:08AM (#17615001)
For which part? Do you have a Facebook account? It's not exactly a secret.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mrep on Friday July 27, 2018 @12:21AM (#17623414)
Any sources for any part will do.

Although, the whole "They have people who's sole job is to make sure Facebook users are on the platform for as long as humanly possible" part makes me the most skeptical.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by ikeyany on Friday July 27, 2018 @07:17PM (#17630266)
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by earloflexus on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:21AM (#17615026)
If Facebook is making a better product, one that people want to use more, with the intention of keeping users on the platform, how can we fault them?

Do we blame TV makers for wanting to sell additional techniques?

Facebook seems to conduct its business in a relatively ethical way, it certainly doesn't seem to go out of its way to make it addictive, they're preocupied with making it more functional - they're adding features constantly.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by zjaffee on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:31PM (#17614665)
To say that we should leave everything to simple choice is ignoring the realities of what groupthink has on a broader society. I.e. everyone smokes so it's fine and I should do it too.

I'm not saying we should make these sorts of things illegal, but to require the industry to display proper warnings, to actively give money to organizations that work against them (such as how tobacco companies must pay for anti smoking commercials), seems like a logical step forward.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mancerayder on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @08:51PM (#17614280)
But surely they're not the only villains. It began with pop-up ads in the old days, evolving to that interstitial nightmare. Mobile notifications of almost anything, combined with a snaring in of people's attention using human weaknesses: need for attention and validation, frailty with regards to gossip, need to find a way to procrastinate during difficult times (work) and much more that I'm missing. It's time for some serious scholarship in the psychological arena in this direction.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by hemantv on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:18PM (#17614392)
There is difference between passively consuming media for everyone.

Or I can create a special dose for you based upon your data that get you most high.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mancerayder on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:46PM (#17614502)
I agree but Google has this with its news, and perhaps (I'm guessing because it's hard to imagine otherwise) Instagram. What makes Facebook vile is the news feed.

But everyone is selling customer data. And my words are coming from the very unusual coincidence that I'm in a bar in Brooklyn and two data scientists are discussing 10 years of customer data needing to be parsed (and I heard the word verticalization). I'm not making this up (it's live).

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:08PM (#17614349)
Weren't people saying the same thing about MTV a generation ago?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by byebyetech on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:16PM (#17614385)
MTV was not watching you interactively. There was no data "dance" between your usage pattern and what shows MTV showed you. There was no Feedback Loop. This is much more sinister than passive consumption of media.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by aylmao on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:14AM (#17615013)
I think it's crazy how the same narrative changes so much.

I remember the internet and social media used to be so much better than TV. TV was controlled by big corporations who wanted to brainwash everyone. 1/3 of the time was ads that only stupefied you, and the rest were shows that did the same. They would do anything for ratings-- CNN was a bastion of treachery dividing the country by presenting politics as sports for the sake of viewership. People were glad Crossfire got canceled (now all of CNN is essentially Crossfire).

But social media? What a tool for free speech and change! It was the breath of fresh air that fought away big corporations, that gave us the Arab Spring, that let anyone with something to say become famous and have a voice and an audience, for free! It provided a platform for critical thinking instead of passive consumption! This data "dance" was the 8th wonder of the world and news articles were being written about how clever Obama's campaign had been to use analytics and "research" to get the edge on the campaign.

I'm not saying any one view is right and the other wrong but something I've noticed about Americans is that they are a very scared people and are very quick at painting things black or white (: The world is not so scary, and most things lie somewhere on a grayscale.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:15AM (#17615214)
>something I've noticed about Americans is that they are a very scared people and are very quick at painting things black or white

This can be seen a lot and it seems quite like the Christian narrative has deep roots in some parts of the world even among non-believers. The idea that everybody is looking at the world through a good-vs-evil lens explains a lot. Mythology is a powerful force, it can't just be dumped, it needs updating.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by brazzledazzle on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:46PM (#17614500)
There was a dance but it was broad, clumsy and tailored towards demographics that were themselves broadly and clumsily lumped together. And the feedback loop was glacial. But comparing that to what they do today is like comparing cavemen banging stones together to an industrial laser cutter.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:32AM (#17615264)
There absolutely was. You think MTV didn't use focus groups and Neilson ratings and all manner of data to target and 'optimize' for maximum effect on their desired audience? It doesn't have to be 'you' specifically, you're not that unique. Things that are effective on your population are effective on you. If you were in a different population you had to change the channel, but it is not really all that different. Maybe marginally more efficient now.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by nashashmi on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:40PM (#17614483)
MTV did its damage on the youth who are now all adults and totally different from the generation that preceded them. There is no telling in what ways minds have changed. If only someone were to do a research study on this.

But without it, it is difficult to say that damage did or didn't happen.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:17PM (#17614626)
My point has been the "X is ruining the children's attention" is a constant across history for several new X each generation for as long as there has been civilization.

You could certainly do a study of some metric and X's effect on it and find a few that were affected negatively, call that 'damage', and write blog posts about it. X would continue to thrive, adults would continue to complain about it, and the next generation would find a new X to use, abuse, and irritate their parents.

Philosophically, 'damage' is more like 'change' and there are a lot of people who like complaining about it because they have forgotten or misremembered what it was like to be young and have limited capacity to empathize with a different generation. If there are things about the change which are right and wrong, they probably aren't the ones being discussed or even understood until enough time has passed to see the change with the perspective of time and by then whatever problems have likely resolved themselves anyway.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by jessaustin on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:33PM (#17614671)
This argument proves too much. If some new actually-bad youth trend were to arise, e.g. the youths were to be convinced that lithium batteries are a better source of nutrients than real food, this logic would still ignore the problem, since "the old folks never understand". It's more illuminating to seriously consider the unforeseen effects of new things.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:51PM (#17614745)
Some day that will probably happen. Somebody will figure out how to make some cybernetic implant that will plug in and provide an alternative to eating. "old folks" will go about complaining about wholesome food and techies will ignore them.

Over time I have grown increasingly irritated by the talk about things being "bad for you". At this point if you don't have a decades long history of studies holding up to meta-analysis backed up by a philosophy of life and what is good and bad for it, I really think what is being said is nonsense. I'll believe hyper-specific cause-and-effect data, but I just don't care about the latest opinion about if something is bad for me.

Until you can show me a study proving that listening to that sort of constant what-I-call-nonsense leads to quantifiable improvements I can be convinced to care about, I'd rather people spend their energy doing something other than complaining about change and/or the status quo. It holds the same status, in me, as celebrity gossip.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by jessaustin on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:22PM (#17614850)
OK well I admire your commitment to the philosophical position... even so, please don't eat batteries.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:30PM (#17614878)
All the other kids are doing it, must be a good time
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by bogomipz on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:36PM (#17614682)
No, people were not saying the same thing about MTV a generation ago.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by colechristensen on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:23AM (#17615235)
27 years ago...

>"The MTV Generation," Lazin said, directly addresses the pros and cons of MTV, which has been criticized for everything from placing too much emphasis on image to promoting short attention spans and the need for constant entertainment in its audience.

http://articles.latimes.com/1991-11-10/news/tv-1845_1_mtv-ge...

That sounds EXACTLY like a criticism you'd hear about facebook. s/MTV/Facebook/ and you couldn't tell if that was written in 1991 or 2018.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by trophycase on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:37AM (#17615967)
Why can't they both be right. They placed too much emphasis on image and FB/IG are even worse. There is certainly no shortage of people claiming that our society is vapid and shallow.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by bogomipz on Thursday July 26, 2018 @10:20AM (#17617713)
Perhaps you should re-read the OPs comment:

>"They have consciously destroyed a generation attention span using psychological tricks"

MTV at the height of music videos in 1980s and 1990s was never accused of using "psychological tricks."

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by _cs2017_ on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:05PM (#17614579)
Judgmental much? Who are you to speak on behalf of everyone, a whole generation? I personally have enjoyed using FB and Instagram. If you don't like it, don't use it. And don't tell me and other users that we are stupid or drug addicts.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by jnwatson on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:17PM (#17614623)
Just like the opioid crisis, there is a point at which individual choices collectively impact society. I'm personally fine with someone shooting up in the privacy of their own home, but clearly something must be done when entire communities are affected.

Facebook has shown a willingness to provide my country's adversaries a powerful tool to subvert the foundations of its society. Fomenting racial strife and spreading pernicious rumors is just the start of it.

The country and the world would be a better place without Facebook.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by existencebox on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:48PM (#17614731)
Honest question; Why is _facebook_ the powerful tool, and not our populations inability to recognize the threat (misdirection, targeted messages, biased sources, etc) within it/think critically about it? To dismiss the nonsense like most people used to dismiss tabloids. Facebook obviously scales this up, but that is the nature of a modern connected world, whether we like it or not, and I'd rather give people the tools to navigate that than try to build a padded room, since there will _always_ be another Facebook. (And to fully undermine my own point, I _don't know if it's possible_ to give enough people these skills, but from a philosophy of personal empowerment and freedoms, the alternatives seem far less preferable)

It sounds a lot like the drug war. The approach that DRUGS are the problem, as opposed to situations that lead users to abuse them in destructive ways, has lead to a very demonstrable half-century of ineffectual policy and violent/sad outcomes.

I have not so entirely given up on ones ability to tread a path through this insanity, and am more worried of an escalating trend to put that responsibility in the hands of some gatekeeper as opposed to ones own agency as a sentient human. I don't even disagree with your final statement; I'd just want to see it come from rejection by the individual than mandate from on high.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by beagle3 on Thursday July 26, 2018 @06:29AM (#17616360)
> Honest question; Why is _facebook_ the powerful tool, and not our populations inability to recognize the threat (misdirection, targeted messages, biased sources, etc) within it/think critically about it?

> It sounds a lot like the drug war. The approach that DRUGS are the problem,

"facebook" is not the drug; "http://facebook.com" is the drug, and that's not he problem. "Facebook Inc" is the problem, much like purdue pharma is a significant cause of the current heroin epidemic. And not, purdue has not been addressed either. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/29/health/purdue-opioids-oxy...

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by _cs2017_ on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:06PM (#17614799)
That's fair, there is some line beyond which personal choices affects the entire society so much that being judgmental is reasonable. (That said, not everyone in the world agrees that personal drug use is past that line - but that's besides the point.)

But you draw your line way too aggressively. If merely using an online community like FB is something that you should decide for other people, there's very little personal choice left. I, for one, certainly wouldn't want to live in a society so judgmental over individual choice.

I don't even mention the fact that FB is far less damaging, in any sense, then bad diet, lack of exercise, getting news from tabloids, trusting politicians, and arguably watching most the TV programs in this country.

Now, if you told me you only discourage your own family or close friends from using FB, I'd think you're very reasonable -- just like you can discourage them from eating junk food and spending weekends on the couch. But by imposing your judgment on billions of people, you present a greater evil, IMHO, than the worst of the FB misdeeds.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by SmellyGeekBoy on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:45AM (#17616001)
> Fomenting racial strife and spreading pernicious rumors is just the start of it.

Not trying to justify Facebook's behaviour here but are you familiar with the tabloid press? Facebook certainly didn't invent this concept.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:14PM (#17614616)
This is not being judgemental, this is factual based on scientific research (Facebook has even admitted as much).

You could Google “Facebook harmful effects research” for several pages of citations.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:52PM (#17614753)
Trouble is, every moral panic since the days of Aristotle has been accompanied by mountains of "harmful effects research." Video gaming, comic books, novels, TV, movies, any number of musical genres and trends... how much of this "research" ever pans out in the long run?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by tdb7893 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:25PM (#17614643)
I think the issue with the "don't like it, don't use it" is that it's specifically designed to be addicting. It's hard to say they aren't complicit in the harm when they designed it to be harmful (being addicted to Facebook isn't the worst thing to be addicted to but it's still harmful).
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by sergiotapia on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:47PM (#17614728)
Here's a comment reply for your dopamine hit.

You are an addict, you just don't realize it.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by kowdermeister on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:51AM (#17616021)
My attention span was already weak before social networks. Could it be that they helped me train it to resist cheap tricks?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by marcrosoft on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:03PM (#17614570)
I value privacy but GDPR is an overreaching government hand with consequences that you and I can't even imagine.

Edit: We'll pass a law that protects your privacy while we ourselves don't abide by it.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by omeid2 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:29PM (#17614659)
Please stop this fear mongering. The essence of GDPR is transparency and accountability. Is there anything else there that you're afraid of?
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by jessaustin on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:48PM (#17614732)
Rather than "afraid", I'm mildly annoyed by the regular posting to HN of various error messages that Europeans get when visiting various sites that DGAFAGDPR. Why don't they send those errors to the European regulators instead? Those people seem better-placed to do something about the errors.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by mrep on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:54PM (#17614758)
From what I have read here on HN is that companies are forced to have users opt in to targeted advertising business models which will make almost all advertising business models unprofitable.

Unsurprisingly, companies are deciding that EU users are not profitable customers without targeted advertising and thus not worth serving these users causing them to block all EU users even if some EU users would accept the previously agreed upon terms of targeted advertising in exchange for the content they wish to receive.

This is a terrible precedence of anti-choice in my opinion since the EU has forced upon all EU people the inability to accept a business model of targeted advertising in exchange for content and thus causing many companies to leave the EU altogether.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by kruczek on Thursday July 26, 2018 @02:51AM (#17615537)
> companies are forced to have users opt in to targeted advertising

Well, that sounds good to me. If user wants targeted advertising, he should show that desire, i.e. opt in. It's privacy by default.

> EU users are not profitable customers without targeted advertising

So, they can't find profitable business model without stealing users' data? Well, then let them fall. And yes, I do mean stealing, if it is done without users' explicit consent.

> the EU has forced upon all EU people the inability to accept a business model of targeted advertising

It's not the EU that forced this, but rather companies which don't care even enough to provide basics of privacy.

Btw, I also don't think companies blocked EU users, because the targeted advertising model became unprofitable; rather it's because they don't want to spend time and resources to figure out what they would need to change.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by curun1r on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:26AM (#17615045)
The part of GDPR that I find unreasonable is the requirement to appoint an EU representative. It makes small companies with no presence in the EU Hire someone in the EU if they want to comply, which could be necessary if they sell to companies that do have an EU presence. Granted, a single person can act as a representative for a few companies, but the estimate is still around 20,000 Europeans that need to be hired for this strictly unnecessary position. It's wasteful and stupid.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by omeid2 on Thursday July 26, 2018 @02:47AM (#17615519)
> It makes small companies with no presence in the EU Hire someone in the EU if they want to comply, which could be necessary if they sell to companies that do have an EU presence.

It simply does not.

Paragraph one of the Article 27 which states the requirement for a representative is followed by

Paragraph 2: The obligation laid down in paragraph 1 of this Article shall not apply to:

a) processing which is occasional, does not include, on a large scale, processing of special categories of data as referred to in Article 9(1).

If you're wondering what is "special categories of data", they're reasonably sensitive data,

Art 27. 1: Processing of personal data revealing racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, or trade union membership, and the processing of genetic data, biometric data for the purpose of uniquely identifying a natural person, data concerning health or data concerning a natural person’s sex life or sexual orientation shall be prohibited.

Which is again, exempt, under Paragraph 2 of the same Article, which states:

2. a) Paragraph 1 shall not apply if one of the following applies:

    the data subject has given explicit consent to the processing of those personal data for one or more specified purposes.

So basically, responsibility and transparency.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by curun1r on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:33PM (#17618736)
It's not at all that simple [0]. In particular, it's not at all clear what occasional means, since GDPR doesn't define it clearly and a simple dictionary definition would mean that something as simple as an Apache log would not qualify as occasional and would require an EU representative.

[0] https://www.dpr.eu.com/do-gdpr-art-27-apply

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by nugget on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:53AM (#17615144)
Every incorporated entity in the US is required to have a registered agent physically located within the entity's state of incorporation as well. It's a pretty low bar to meet.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by marcrosoft on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:41PM (#17614697)
How about huge non compliance fines for reasons that need to be debated in court.

Oh, did you interpret the law wrong? We'll take the greater of 20 million or 4% revenue kthanksbye.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by omeid2 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:55PM (#17614949)
Regulation without teeth is child-talk.
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by dominotw on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:49PM (#17614517)
If not Facebook they will go to Reddit, Twitter or watch reality TV .
Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by qubax on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:06PM (#17614343)
> They have consciously destroyed a generation attention span using psychological tricks.

They did the same thing CNN, MTV and all media does. They do the same thing movies, music, tv, news, etc does. They do the same thing Google does, Twitter does, reddit does, snapchat does, like everyone does. What's with the organized and targeted hate towards facebook?

I'll make a bet with anyone here. Once FB gives in to the mob like google did, like twitter did or reddit did, I guarantee you the outrage will magically disappear like it did for google, twitter and reddit.

> the US implement something similar to GDPR.

You want free speech curtailed in the US? You want more regulation of the internet? That's last thing you'd expect in a "hacker" news site. But like most social media, it's less tech people on tech forums and more political people with an axe to grind it seems.

Re:Facebook stock drops more than 20% after revenue forecast... by hluska on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:56PM (#17614553)
How does GDPR curtail free speech? Please give me citations from the text.